Three major reasons why transgenerational effects of radiation are difficult to detect in humans

Testicular exposure to ionizing radiation and sperm epigenetic alterations as possible mechanisms of hereditary effects: perspectives from the viewpoint of radiation protection

PURPOSE

Since the genotoxicity of ionizing radiation was demonstrated in the 1920s, its hereditary effects have remained a serious concern for human society. The International Commission on Radiological Protection has highlighted the need for appropriate protection against hereditary effects of radiation in humans. In this paper, we review the literature on the possible multigenerational and transgenerational effects following testicular exposure to radiation, focusing on sperm epigenetic alterations as possible mechanisms.

RESULTS

This mini-review highlights that hereditary effects following testicular exposure occur via epigenetic changes of germ cells in animal models, providing implications on human radiation protection.

CONCLUSIONS

A great amount of epigenomic research data has emerged rapidly since the beginning of this century; thus, a revision of the radiological protection protocols against the hereditary effects of radiation would be no longer inevitable. The collection and analysis of evidence on these effects must be enhanced and further accelerated to formulate appropriate protection protocols in the future.

Transgenerational Effects on Lifespan and Pathology of Paternal Pre-conceptional Exposure to Continuous Low-dose-rate Gamma Rays in C57BL/6J Mice

The present work investigates the multigenerational effects of paternal pre-conceptional exposure to continuous low-dose-rate gamma rays in C56BL/6J mice. Male C57BL/6J (F0 sires) mice were exposed to low dose rates of 20, 1, and 0.05 mGy/day for 400 days, to total accumulated doses of 8,000, 400, and 20 mGy, respectively. Upon completion of the radiation exposure, the F0 male mice were immediately bred to non-irradiated 8-week-old C57BL/6J females (F0 dams) to produce the first-generation (F1) mice. Randomly selected F1 males and females were then bred to produce the second-generation (F2) mice. All the mice, except the F0 dams, were subjected to pathological examination upon natural death. Reproductive parameters, lifespan, causes of death, neoplasm incidences and non-neoplastic disease incidences were used as parameters to evaluate the biological effects of continuous pre-conceptional exposure of the sires (F0) to continuous low-dose-rate radiation. There were no significant differences in the pregnancy and weaning rates among the parent (F0) generation. Average litter size and average number of weaned pups (F1) from dams bred to males (F0) exposed to 20 mGy/day were significantly decreased compared to the non-irradiated controls. Significant lifespan shortening in the sires (F0) was observed only in the 20 mGy/day group due to early death from malignant lymphomas. Life shortening was also observed in the F1 progeny of sires (F0) exposed to 20 and 1 mGy/day, but could not be attributed to a specific cause. No significant differences in the causes of death were found between dose groups in any generation. The number of primary tumors per mouse was significantly increased only in the F0 males exposed to 20 mGy/day. Except for the increased incidence rate for Harderian gland neoplasms in sires (F0) exposed to 20 mGy/day, there was no significant difference in neoplasm incidences and tumor spectra in all 3 generations in each sex regardless of radiation exposure. No multi- or transgenerational effects in the parameters examined were observed in the F1 and F2 progeny of sires exposed to 0.05 mGy/day for 400 days.

Consideration of hereditary effects in the radiological protection system: evolution and current status

PURPOSE

The purpose of this paper is to provide an overview of the methodology used to estimate radiation genetic risks and quantify the risk of hereditary effects as outlined in the ICRP Publication 103. It aims to highlight the historical background and development of the doubling dose method for estimating radiation-related genetic risks and its continued use in radiological protection frameworks.

RESULTS

This article emphasizes the complexity associated with quantifying the risk of hereditary effects caused by radiation exposure and highlights the need for further clarification and explanation of the calculation method. As scientific knowledge in radiation sciences and human genetics continues to advance in relation to a number of factors including stability of disease frequency, selection pressures, and epigenetic changes, the characterization and quantification of genetic effects still remains a major issue for the radiological protection system of the International Commission on Radiological Protection.

CONCLUSION

Further research and advancements in this field are crucial for enhancing our understanding and addressing the complexities involved in assessing and managing the risks associated with hereditary effects of radiation.

In utero exposure to ionizing radiation and metabolic regulation: perspectives for future multi- and trans-generation effects studies

PURPOSE

The radiation protection community has been particularly attentive to the risks of delayed effects on offspring from low dose or low dose-rate exposures to ionizing radiation. Despite this, the current epidemiologic studies and scientific data are still insufficient to provide the necessary evidence for improving risk assessment guidelines. This literature review aims to inform future studies on multigenerational and transgenerational effects. It primarily focuses on animal studies involving in utero exposure and discusses crucial elements for interpreting the results. These elements include in utero exposure scenarios relative to the developmental stages of the embryo/fetus, and the primary biological mechanisms responsible for transmitting heritable or hereditary effects to future generations. The review addresses several issues within the contexts of both multigenerational and transgenerational effects, with a focus on hereditary perspectives.

CONCLUSIONS

Knowledge consolidation in the field of Developmental Origins of Health and Disease (DOHaD) has led us to propose a new study strategy. This strategy aims to address the transgenerational effects of in utero exposure to low dose and low dose-rate radiation. Within this concept, there is a possibility that disruption of epigenetic programming in embryonic and fetal cells may occur. This disruption could lead to metabolic dysfunction, which in turn may cause abnormal responses to future environmental challenges, consequently increasing disease risk. Lastly, we discuss methodological limitations in our studies. These limitations are related to cohort size, follow-up time, model radiosensitivity, and analytical techniques. We propose scientific and analytical strategies for future research in this field.