Fission-neutron-induced expression of a tumour-associated antigen in human cell hybrids (HeLa x skin fibroblasts): evidence for increased expression at low dose rate

The CGL1 (HeLa × Normal Skin Fibroblast) Human Hybrid Cell Line: A History of Ionizing Radiation Induced Effects on Neoplastic Transformation and Novel Future Directions in SNOLAB

Cellular transformation assays have been utilized for many years as powerful in vitro methods for examining neoplastic transformation potential/frequency and mechanisms of carcinogenesis for both chemical and radiological carcinogens. These mouse and human cell based assays are labor intensive but do provide quantitative information on the numbers of neoplastically transformed foci produced after carcinogenic exposure and potential molecular mechanisms involved. Several mouse and human cell systems have been generated to undertake these studies, and they vary in experimental length and endpoint assessment. The CGL1 human cell hybrid neoplastic model is a non-tumorigenic pre-neoplastic cell that was derived from the fusion of HeLa cervical cancer cells and a normal human skin fibroblast. It has been utilized for the several decades to study the carcinogenic/neoplastic transformation potential of a variety of ionizing radiation doses, dose rates and radiation types, including UV, X ray, gamma ray, neutrons, protons and alpha particles. It is unique in that the CGL1 assay has a relatively short assay time of 18-21 days, and rather than relying on morphological endpoints to detect neoplastic transformation utilizes a simple staining method that detects the tumorigenic marker alkaline phosphatase on the neoplastically transformed cells cell surface. In addition to being of human origin, the CGL1 assay is able to detect and quantify the carcinogenic potential of very low doses of ionizing radiation (in the mGy range), and utilizes a neoplastic endpoint (re-expression of alkaline phosphatase) that can be detected on both viable and paraformaldehyde fixed cells. In this article, we review the history of the CGL1 neoplastic transformation model system from its initial development through the wide variety of studies examining the effects of all types of ionizing radiation on neoplastic transformation. In addition, we discuss the potential of the CGL1 model system to investigate the effects of near zero background radiation levels available within the radiation biology lab we have established in SNOLAB.

The RBE of 3.4 MeV alpha-particles and 0.565 MeV neutrons relative to 60Co gamma-rays for neoplastic transformation of human hybrid cells and the impact of culture conditions

The neoplastic transformation of human hybrid CGL1 cells is affected by perturbations from external influences such as serum batch and concentration, the number of medium changes during the 21-day expression period and cell seeding density. Nevertheless, for doses up to 1.5 Gy, published transformation frequencies for low linear energy transfer (LET) radiations (gamma-rays, MeV electrons or photons) are in good agreement, whereas for higher doses larger variations are reported. The (60)Co gamma-ray data here for doses up to 1.5 Gy, using a low-yield serum batch and only one medium change, are in agreement with published frequencies of neoplastic transformation of human hybrid cells. For 3.4 MeV alpha-particles (LET = 124 keV/mum) and 0.565 MeV monoenergetic neutrons relative to low doses of (60)Co gamma-rays, a maximum relative biological effectiveness (RBE(M)) of 2.8 +/- 0.2 and 1.5 +/- 0.2, respectively, was calculated. Surprisingly, at higher doses of (60)Co gamma-rays lower frequencies of neoplastic transformation were observed. This non-monotonic dose relationship for neoplastic transformation by (60)Co gamma-rays is likely due to the lack of a G2/M arrest observed at low doses resulting in higher transformation frequencies per dose, whereas the lower frequencies per dose observed for higher doses are likely related to the induction of a G2/M arrest.

Commentary 2 to Cox and Little: radiation-induced oncogenic transformation: the interplay between dose, dose protraction, and radiation quality

There is now a substantial body of evidence for end points such as oncogenic transformation in vitro, and carcinogenesis and life shortening in vivo, suggesting that dose protraction leads to an increase in effectiveness relative to a single, acute exposure--at least for radiations of medium linear energy transfer (LET) such as neutrons. Table I contains a summary of the pertinent data from studies in which the effect is seen. [table: see text] This phenomenon has come to be known as the "inverse dose rate effect," because it is in marked contrast to the situation at low LET, where protraction in delivery of a dose of radiation, either by fractionation or low dose rate, results in a decreased biological effect; additionally, at medium and high LET, for radiobiological end points such as clonogenic survival, the biological effectiveness is independent of protraction. The quantity and quality of the published reports on the "inverse dose rate effect" leaves little doubt that the effect is real, but the available evidence indicates that the magnitude of the effect is due to a complex interplay between dose, dose rate, and radiation quality. Here, we first summarize the available data on the inverse dose rate effect and suggest that it follows a consistent pattern in regard to dose, dose rate, and radiation quality; second, we describe a model that predicts these features; and, finally, we describe the significance of the effect for radiation protection.

Neutron carcinogenesis: past, present, and future

An interest in the possible cancer causing ability of neutrons began soon after their discovery. Early use of neutrons from radioactive sources and from cyclotrons led to a need to define risk for such exposures. This need was soon followed by a more tangible need to define risk to the general population of high LET radiation from nuclear fall out and use of the Atomic bomb and possible use of the H-bomb. Neutrons were soon found to be very effective cell killing agents compared to conventional ionizing radiation. However High LET radiation sources and neutrons in particular, come in many different energies and from many types of sources. I will survey the differences between different energy neutrons and conventional types of radiation, particularly with respect to the dose rate of exposures and the influence of repair or lack thereof and more recently the effect of cell cycle distribution on the carcinogenic outcome. I will illustrate these ideas with examples of carcinogenicity studies and mutation studies from my own laboratory and in some cases from the work of others. Lastly I will introduce some possible avenues for molecular studies of neutron effects that might answer such vexing questions as the real risk at very low doses, is repair error free or error prone, do neutrons cause genetic instability for many cell generations after exposure, and others? There remain many questions about the biology of neutron action that require answers if we are to protect the ever increasing number of people exposed to them because of their growing use in medicine, in the military and in commercial industry.

Evidence for a role of delayed death and genomic instability in radiation-induced neoplastic transformation of human hybrid cells

HeLa x skin fibroblast human hybrid cells have been developed into a model of radiation-induced neoplastic transformation. The authors' studies indicate that the loss of putative tumour suppressor loci on fibroblast chromosomes 11 and 14 is evident after radiation-induced neoplastic transformation. How these fibroblast chromosomes/putative tumour suppressor loci are lost after radiation exposure is currently being investigated. It has been shown that the appearance of transformed foci correlates with the onset of the delayed reduction in plating efficiency or delayed death. This delayed death appears to be the result of the onset of a novel delayed apoptosis in the irradiated progeny beginning around day 8 post-irradiation. It was proposed that the reduction in plating efficiency and subsequent neoplastic transformation are all the result of a radiation-induced genomic instability. The instability process has two relevant outcomes: (1) cell death due to the induction of a delayed apoptosis in cells; and (2) neoplastic transformation of a small subset of survivors that have lost fibroblast chromosomes 11 and 14 (tumour suppressor loci) but either have not acquired enough genetic damage to induce the apoptotic response or have undergone molecular changes allowing them to bypass apoptosis. Data from the genomic instability and delayed death literature will be reviewed in terms of relevance to radiation-induced neoplastic transformation. New data are presented which demonstrate that use of growth media supplemented with a specific lot of calf serum was found to increase the number of cells undergoing radiation-induced neoplastic transformation, compared with standard serum after a fixed dose of radiation. This correlates with an increase in delayed death in the irradiated progeny which the authors propose is the result of increased genomic instability post-irradiation of cells grown in this serum. Preliminary data are presented indicating that a delayed apoptosis is also seen after high-energy He- particle exposure in this system.

Alpha-particle-induced neoplastic transformation in synchronized hybrid cells of HeLa and human skin fibroblasts

Survival and oncogenic transformation frequencies were determined through the cell cycle in hybrid cells (HeLa x human skin fibroblasts), exposed to 0.30 and 0.15 Gy 4.3 MeV (LET= 101 keV/microm) alpha-particles. The cells were synchronized by mitotic collection and irradiated at times ranging from 2 to 10 h after collection, corresponding to G1 and early S. At 0.30 Gy the highest value in the transformation frequency (1.6 +/- 0.3) x 10(-4) transformants/survivor, occurred 4 h after mitotic collection, corresponding to mid-G1 and was about twice as high as that for the asynchronous population (0.7 +/- 0.1) x 10(-4) transformants/survivor. A similar pattern was seen at 0.15 Gy albeit less marked. The results are similar to previous findings with C3H10T1/2 exposed to 0.30 Gy where (1.8 +/- 0.4) x 10(-4) and (0.8 +/- 0.4) x 10(-4) transformants/survivor were found in mid-G1 and in the asynchronous population respectively. The results of both these studies with 101 keV/microm alpha particles indicate that mid-G1 cells may be more sensitive than asynchronous cells by up to a factor of two. However, it is unlikely that such a factor is sufficient to represent the cell cycle 'hot spot' for transformation postulated to explain the inverse dose-rate effect.

Sensitivity of C3H 10T1/2 cells to radiation-induced killing and neoplastic transformation as a function of cell cycle

Cell-age sensitivity to both cell killing and neoplastic transformation induced by radiation was investigated using synchronized populations of C3H10T1/2 cells. Mitotic-cell suspensions, collected using a mitotic shake-off procedure, were irradiated with 4Gy 250 kVp X-rays or 0.5 Gy fission neutrons from the RSV-TAPIRO reactor at CR-Casaccia. For study of cell killing the mitotic-cell suspensions were either irradiated immediately after collection, or plated for subsequent irradiation, which was performed every hour, covering an interval of 17 h. The response pattern observed was similar after X-rays and neutron irradiation, but the magnitude of the variation through the cell cycle was smaller in the case of neutrons (1.3- compared with 5-fold). For study of neoplastic transformation induction the irradiation was performed immediately after collection, i.e. in M phase, or at later times corresponding to mid-G1, G1/S and G2 phases. The sensitivity of the G2/M phase was examined by irradiating the cells with 4Gy X-rays while still attached to the flask bottom, and dislodging them after 25 min. SimilarLy to cell survival, the transformation frequency showed a small variation after neutron irradiation (1.4- compared with 3.1-fold) for the phases examined.

Energy deposition events produced by fission neutrons in aqueous solutions of plasmid DNA

Using an agarose gel electrophoresis assay, single-strand breaks (ssb) induced by fission neutrons and 60Co gamma-rays in aerobic aqueous solutions of pBR322 plasmid DNA were studied. The energy-deposition events of the two radiations were characterized using a Rossi-type proportional counter to measure lineal-energy spectra. For neutrons, the dose-weighted lineal-energy mean, yD, is 63 keV micron-1--about 30 times that for gamma-rays. With increasing yD, hydroxyl radicals produced within spurs or tracks are less likely to survive due to recombination effects, resulting in decreased ssb yields. In TE buffer solution, the ssb yield induced by gamma-rays is 3.2 +/- 0.66 times that induced by neutrons at the same dose. Since the direct radiation effect is small under these conditions, we can estimate that the previously unknown G for hydroxyl radical production by fission neutrons is 0.088 mumol J-1. For glycerol concentrations that give the solution a hydroxyl radical scavenging capacity similar to that of cellular environments, the ssb yield induced by gamma-rays is about 2.0 +/- 0.24 times that induced by neutrons. Analysis shows that this trend with added scavenger is caused primarily by hydroxyl radical yields.

Radon-induced cancer: a cell-based model of tumorigenesis due to protracted exposures

In 1982, results with C3H mouse embryo cells showed that the frequency of neoplastic transformation was enhanced when exposures to fission-spectrum neutrons were protracted in time. This finding was unexpected because the opposite was found with low-LET radiations. Similar neutron enhancements were reported with normal life-span Syrian hamster embryo cells, and with human hybrid cells. Because other studies did not confirm the preceding, in 1990--at a conference convened by the US Armed Forces Radiobiological Research Institute--a biophysical model was proposed to explain the basis for the enhancement observed in some experiments but not in others. The model attributed special sensitivities, related to killing and neoplastic transformation, to cells in and around mitosis. Subsequently, it was shown that late G2/M phase cells constituted this window of sensitivity. In the instance of tumorigenesis, the model predicted that protracted exposures to a high-LET radiation would result in enhanced frequencies of transformation providing that susceptible cells were cycling or could be induced to cycle. The model explained data on lung tumour induction in rats breathing radon at different concentrations, and uranium miners working in atmospheres containing different concentrations of radon. The model also explains the anomalous finding that lung cancer deaths are often sublinearly correlated with indoor radon concentration.