The effect of unilateral nephrectomy on the subsequent radiation response of the pig kidney

Radiotherapy of abdomen with precise renal assessment with SPECT/CT imaging (RAPRASI): design and methodology of a prospective trial to improve the understanding of kidney radiation dose response

Background

The kidneys are a principal dose-limiting organ in radiotherapy for upper abdominal cancers. The current understanding of kidney radiation dose response is rudimentary. More precise dose-volume response models that allow direct correlation of delivered radiation dose with spatio-temporal changes in kidney function may improve radiotherapy treatment planning for upper-abdominal tumours.

Our current understanding of kidney dose response and tolerance is limited and this is hindering efforts to introduce advanced radiotherapy techniques for upper-abdominal cancers, such as intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT). The aim of this study is to utilise radiotherapy and combined anatomical/functional imaging data to allow direct correlation of radiation dose with spatio-temporal changes in kidney function. The data can then be used to develop a more precise dose-volume response model which has the potential to optimise and individualise upper abdominal radiotherapy plans.

Methods/design

The Radiotherapy of Abdomen with Precise Renal Assessment with SPECT/CT Imaging (RAPRASI) is an observational clinical research study with participating sites at Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital (SCGH) in Perth, Australia and the Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre (PMCC) in Melbourne, Australia. Eligible patients are those with upper gastrointestinal cancer, without metastatic disease, undergoing conformal radiotherapy that will involve incidental radiation to one or both kidneys. For each patient, total kidney function is being assessed before commencement of radiotherapy treatment and then at 4, 12, 26, 52 and 78 weeks after the first radiotherapy fraction, using two procedures: a Glomerular Filtration Rate (GFR) measurement using the ⁵¹Cr-ethylenediamine tetra-acetic acid (EDTA) clearance; and a regional kidney perfusion measurement assessing renal uptake of ^99mTc-dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA), imaged with a Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography / Computed Tomography (SPECT/CT) system. The CT component of the SPECT/CT provides the anatomical reference of the kidney’s position. The data is intended to reveal changes in regional kidney function over the study period after the radiotherapy. These SPECT/CT scans, co-registered with the radiotherapy treatment plan, will provide spatial correlation between the radiation dose and regional renal function as assessed by SPECT/CT. From this correlation, renal response patterns will likely be identified with the purpose of developing a predictive model.

Trial registration

Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry: ACTRN12609000322235

Radiation nephropathy

The pronounced radiosensitivity of renal tissue limits the total radiotherapeutic dose that can be applied safely to treatment volumes that include the kidneys. The incidence of clinical radiation nephropathy has increased with the use of total-body irradiation (TBI) in preparation for bone marrow transplantation and as a consequence of radionuclide therapies. The clinical presentation is azotemia, hypertension, and, disproportionately, severe anemia seen several months to years after irradiation that, if untreated, leads to renal failure. Structural features include mesangiolysis, sclerosis, tubular atrophy, and tubulointerstitial scarring. Similar changes are seen in a variety of experimental animal models. The classic view of radiation nephropathy being inevitable, progressive, and untreatable because of DNA damage-mediated cell loss at division has been replaced by a new paradigm in which radiation-induced injury involves not only direct cell kill but also involves complex and dynamic interactions between glomerular, tubular, and interstitial cells. These serve both as autocrine and as paracrine, if not endocrine, targets of biologic mediators that mediate nephron injury and repair. The renin angiotensin system (RAS) clearly is involved; multiple experimental studies have shown that antagonism of the RAS is beneficial, even when not initiated until weeks after irradiation. Recent findings suggest a similar benefit in clinical radiation nephropathy.

The role of the tubulointerstitium in radiation-induced renal fibrosis

The functional and morphological response of the remaining hypertrophied kidney in unilaterally nephrectomized rats to single doses of 0-20 Gy X rays was investigated. Functional and histological end points were assessed serially 4-24 weeks postirradiation. Renal irradiation led to time- and dose-dependent reductions in renal function, seen in terms of a decreased glomerular filtration rate, increased blood urea nitrogen, and reduced hematocrit. These changes were accompanied by morphological changes in the glomerular, tubular and interstitial portions of the kidney. However, dose-dependent changes were observed only in terms of tubulointerstitial lesions. Significant increases in the degree of interstitial staining for collagen type III and fibronectin were observed 24 weeks postirradiation. These increases in extracellular matrix components were accompanied by a significant increase in interstitial alpha smooth muscle actin, suggesting activation of interstitial fibroblasts into myofibroblasts. There was no evidence of glomerular Tgfb after renal irradiation. A significant increase in tubular Tgfb staining was only seen 8 weeks postirradiation. In contrast, there was a shift of staining to the interstitium such that by 24 weeks postirradiation interstitial Tgfb staining was significantly greater than that seen in controls. These findings suggest that the tubule epithelial cell and the interstitial fibroblast are both active participants in the development and/or progression of radiation-induced renal fibrosis.

The influence of dose per fraction on the pathogenesis of radiation nephropathy

Both kidneys of male Wistar rats were irradiated with either a 10-Gy single dose or 26 Gy at a rate of 2 Gy per fraction per day. Serum blood urea nitrogen (BUN), creatinine and blood haematocrit levels were assessed prior to radiotherapy and at intervals of 8 weeks thereafter. A subset of animals from each dose group were killed at 4, 8, 16 and 24 weeks and both kidneys of each animal were examined by electron microscopy. In both dose groups a significant increase in BUN and creatinine levels, together with a decrease in haematocrit level, was observed at 16 weeks, and this was followed by an apparent improvement at 24 weeks. There was no statistical difference in these responses between the two groups. The morphological changes in both dose groups were essentially similar, but differed in severity. At 4 weeks after irradiation glomerular and proximal tubular injury were observed in both groups. A marked increase of glomerular and tubular injury in the 10-Gy dose group, without any apparent progression in the 26-Gy dose group, was detected at 8 weeks. By 16 weeks a noticeable improvement in both tubular and glomerular lesions (especially in the 10-Gy dose group) was observed. No apparent difference from the 16th week of evaluation was found at 24 weeks. These findings indicate that there is some recovery in kidney after irradiation, but the extent of the recovery process is somewhat limited.

A morphometric analysis of glomerular and tubular alterations following fast-neutron irradiation of the pig and monkey kidney

PURPOSE

The morphologic responses of the pig and monkey kidney to fractionated fast-neutron irradiation were assessed.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The right kidney of approximately 14-week-old female Large White pigs was irradiated with 6.6-12.2 Gy of fast neutrons (42 MeVd-->Be) given as 12 fractions over 18 days; the left kidney served as the contralateral unirradiated kidney. Both kidneys were removed at necropsy 2 years postirradiation. In addition, the remaining hypertrophied kidney of four unilaterally nephrectomized adult rhesus monkeys was irradiated with a total dose of 11.0 Gy fast neutrons (45 MeVp-->Be) given in an identical fractionation regimen to that used in the pig studies. These kidneys were removed when the animals exhibited renal failure, between 32-94 weeks postirradiation. Glomeruli were assessed for the presence of pathologic features, including intercapillary eosinophilic material (ICE), ectatic capillaries, thrombi, hemorrhage, and sclerosis. The relative proportion of renal cortex occupied by glomeruli, interstitium, normal, or abnormal tubules was determined using a Chalkley point grid.

RESULTS

The incidence of normal glomeruli, ectatic capillaries, thrombosis, and periglomerular fibrosis were significantly different in the irradiated pig kidneys compared with the unirradiated contralateral kidneys (p < or = 0.02). Linear regression analysis demonstrated a significant dose relationship in terms of normal glomeruli, ectatic capillaries, and ICE (r > or = 0.64; p < or = 0.04). Irradiation was also associated with a significant (p < 0.0001) decrease and increase in the volume of renal cortex occupied by normal and abnormal tubules, respectively. Similar morphometric changes were noted in the irradiated monkey kidneys.

CONCLUSIONS

The morphologic changes seen in the pig and monkey kidney after fractionated irradiation with fast neutrons are similar to those previously noted after single-dose or fractionated-photon irradiation. These findings support the hypothesis that the development of radiation nephropathy in these various models involves common pathophysiological mechanisms.

Radiation-induced changes in glomerular and tubular cell kinetics and morphology following irradiation of a single kidney in the pig

PURPOSE

Radiation-induced changes in glomerular and tubular cell kinetics and morphology following irradiation of a single pig kidney were assessed.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The right kidney of 13 adult female Large White pigs was irradiated with a single dose of 9.8 Gy gamma rays. Animals were serially killed between 2 and 24 weeks postirradiation (PI); 1 h prior to postmortem each pig received 500 mg bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd). At postmortem, both kidneys were removed and tissue taken to prepare cell suspensions. The labeling index (LI) of these suspensions was measured using flow cytometry; in vivo BrdUrd incorporation in glomerular and tubular cells was determined immunohistochemically. The kidneys were also assessed histologically.

RESULTS

Irradiation of the right kidney alone resulted in a significant increase in renal cell LI in both the irradiated and the contralateral unirradiated kidney within 2 weeks of irradiation; peak values of 1.57 +/- 0.32% and 1.04 +/- 0.13%, respectively, were seen 4 weeks PI, significantly greater (P < 0.001) than the preirradiation value of 0.18 +/- 0.01%. The LI values then declined with time, but remained greater than those seen prior to irradiation. A similar pattern of response was determined from counts of labeled glomerular and tubular cells identified immunohistochemically. The increase in labeled glomerular cells was seen 2 weeks PI, whereas that for the tubular cells did not occur until 4 weeks PI. The irradiated kidney exhibited diffuse, progressive glomerular alterations. In contrast, tubular damage was focal; the irradiated kidney also exhibited a prominent vasculopathy, involving arteriolar and peripheral interlobular artery thickening. The contralateral unirradiated kidney appeared unchanged.

CONCLUSION

These findings confirm the hypothesis that the morphologic and kinetic responses observed after irradiation of a single kidney are similar to those observed after irradiation of both kidneys. Renal irradiation results in significant alterations in glomerular and tubular cell proliferation and morphology within 2-4 weeks of irradiation; glomerular changes appear predominant.

Radiation response of the monkey kidney following contralateral nephrectomy

PURPOSE

The long-term functional and morphologic responses of the hypertrophied monkey kidney after unilateral nephrectomy to fractionated irradiation were assessed.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The right kidney of 13 adult female rhesus monkeys was removed. Twelve weeks after unilateral nephrectomy (UN) the remaining kidney received fractionated doses of gamma-rays ranging from 35.2 Gy/16 fractions (F) up to 44 Gy/20 F. Glomerular filtration rate, effective renal plasma flow, blood urea nitrogen, serum creatinine, and hematocrit values were measured up to 107 weeks postirradiation (PI). The monkeys were killed and the remaining kidneys were removed 107 weeks PI or earlier when end-stage renal failure was exhibited. Glomeruli were scored for the presence/absence of several pathologic features including increased intercapillary eosinophilic material (ICE), ectatic capillaries, and thrombi. The relative proportion of renal cortex occupied by glomeruli, interstitium, normal tubules or abnormal tubules was determined using a Chalkley point grid. These quantal dose response data were analyzed using a logistic regression model.

RESULTS

Irradiation of the remaining kidney in UN monkeys resulted in a dose-dependent reduction in renal function and anemia. Glomerular dysfunction preceded tubular dysfunction. Animals receiving 44 Gy all manifested progressive clinical renal failure. Conversely, those receiving < or = 39.6 Gy showed stable, albeit impaired, renal function for the duration of the observation period of 107 weeks. Morphologically, the incidence of ICE, ectatic glomerular capillaries, thrombi, and periglomerular fibrosis was significantly dose-related (p < 0.005). A significant (p < 0.001) dose-related increase in the relative proportion of renal cortex occupied by abnormal tubules was indicative of tubular injury. A highly significant (p < 0.001) dose-dependent increase in the proportion of abnormal to normal tubules was also seen.

CONCLUSION

The pathogenesis of radiation nephropathy is difficult to fully understand because of the complex and dynamic interactions among all components of the nephron that make discrimination between primary radiation effects and secondary pathophysiological consequences very difficult. Notwithstanding, the current experiment shows that the functional and morphological expressions of radiation injury in the kidney are dose dependent. Renal failure occurs when both the glomeruli and tubules are dysfunctional. In monkeys following UN, a total dose of 44 Gy to the remaining kidney damages all components of the nephron and causes renal failure in less than 45 weeks. With lower doses, changes to the glomeruli predominate and the animals survive. Kidney doses of up to 39.6 Gy/18 fractions of 2.2 Gy are compatible with survival for at least 2 years in primates.