‘Inter Silvas Academi Quaerere Verum’: Reply to Letter to the Editor by M. M. Elkind

Application of the constant exposure time technique to transformation experiments with fission neutrons: failure to demonstrate dose-rate dependence

A direct comparison of the effectiveness of fission neutrons at high (11.0-31.3 cGy/min) or several low dose-rates (0.14-3.2 cGy/min) was carried out under identical conditions. Monolayers of exponentially growing C3H/10T1/2 cells were exposed at 37 degrees C to reactor-produced neutrons (fluence-mean energy En = 0.68 MeV, < or = 5% gamma component, frequency mean linear energy yF = 21 keV/micron, dose mean lineal energy yD = 42 keV/micron in an 8-micron spherical cavity). Survival or transformation induction were studied at five doses from 10.5 to 94 cGy. In low dose-rate irradiations, these doses were protracted over 0.5, 1, 3 or 4.5 h, resulting in 17 different dose-rates. Up to six experiments were performed at each of five exposure times. Concurrently with transformation we studied cell proliferation in control versus cells irradiated at 40 cGy (acute and a 4.5-h protraction) and found no evidence of a shift in the cell cycle distribution among these cells. At a given dose and dose-rate, the effect of dose protraction on survival or transformation was assessed by the dose-rate modifying factor (DRMF), defined as the low:high dose-rate effect ratio at the same dose. Survival or transformation induction curves were nearly linear with initial slopes, respectively, of about 6.5 x 10(-3) or 6.2 x 10(-6) cGy-1. Consistent with dose-response curves, DRMFs were independent of the dose and dose-rate. The mean values of the DRMF with their uncertainties and 99% confidence intervals, based on measurements in individual doses and dose-rates for survival or transformation were, respectively: 1.01 +/- 0.03 (0.92, 1.09) or 0.98 +/- 0.04 (0.83, 1.08) indicating a similar precision in determining DRMF for survival or transformation, and no dose or dose-rate influence on these end points.

Effects of WR-1065 and WR-151326 on survival and neoplastic transformation in C3H/10T1/2 cells exposed to TRIGA or JANUS fission neutrons

We demonstrated the ability of aminothiols WR-1065 and WR-151326, each at concentration 1 mM, to protect C3H/10T1/2 cells against the transforming effects of fission neutrons under two distinct sets of experimental conditions. Experiments with WR-1065 were performed with stationary cultures of C3H/10T1/2 cells, and a TRIGA reactor-generated fission neutron field at the Armed Forces Radiobiology Research Institute (USA). Experiments with WR-151326 were performed with proliferating cultures of C3H/10T1/2 cells and a JANUS reactor-generated fission neutron field at the Argonne National Laboratory (USA). Radioprotectors were present before, during, and after irradiation for total-periods of 35 min (WR-151326; 10 min pre-incubation) or 1 h (WR-1065; 30 min pre-incubation). Bioavailability of WR-1065 and WR-151326 in extracellular medium under experimental conditions simulating those of the transformation experiments was studied by measuring oxidation rates in the presence of attached C3H/10T1/2 cells in plateau and exponential phase of growth for periods of up to 5 h. Estimated half-lives for autoxidation of WR-1065 or WR-151326 were approximately 8 min or 1 h regardless of the proliferative status of cells. In the absence of WR-compounds, dose-response data for transformation induction by neutrons from TRIGA and JANUS reactors were fitted to a common curve with a linear coefficient of about 7 x 10(-4)/Gy. WR-151326 and WR-1065 were found to provide significant radioprotection by factors of 1.79 +/- 0.08 and 3.23 +/- 0.19, respectively, against fission neutron-induced neoplastic transformation. No significant protection against neutron-induced cell lethality was observed.