How does a lifetime of painful experiences influence sensations and beliefs about pain in adults with severe haemophilia? A qualitative study

Moving towards Normalization of haemostasis and health equity: Evolving treatment goals for haemophilia A

BACKGROUND

Treatment options for people with haemophilia are evolving at a rapid pace and a range of prophylactic treatment options using various technologies are currently available, each with their own distinct safety and efficacy profile.

TREATMENT GOALS

The access to replacement therapy and prophylaxis has driven a dramatic reduction in mortality and resultant increase in life expectancy. Beyond this, the abolition of bleeds and preservation of joint health represent the expected, but rarely attained, goals of haemophilia treatment and care. These outcomes also do not address the complexity of health-related quality of life impacted by haemophilia and its treatment.

CONCLUSION

Capitalizing on the major potential of therapeutic innovations, 'Normalization' of haemostasis, as a concept, should include the aspiration of enabling individuals to live as normal a life as possible, free from haemophilia-imposed limitations. To achieve this-being supported by the data reviewed in this manuscript-the concept of haemostatic and life Normalization needs to be explored and debated within the wider multidisciplinary teams and haemophilia community.

Expert United Kingdom consensus on the preservation of joint health in people with moderate and severe haemophilia A: A modified Delphi panel

AIM

For people with haemophilia A (PwHA), bleeding in the joints leads to joint damage and haemophilia-related arthropathy, impacting range of motion and life expectancy. Existing guidelines for managing haemophilia A support healthcare professionals (HCPs) and PwHA in their efforts to preserve joint health. However, such guidance should be reviewed, considering emerging evidence and consensus as presented in this manuscript.

METHODS

Fifteen HCPs experienced in the management of PwHA in the UK participated in a three-round Delphi panel. Consensus was defined at ≥70% of panellists agreeing or disagreeing for Likert-scale questions, and ≥70% selecting the same option for multiple- or single-choice questions. Questions not reaching consensus were revised for the next round.

RESULTS

26.8% (11/41), 44.8% (13/29) and 93.3% (14/15) of statements reached consensus in Rounds 1, 2 and 3, respectively. HCPs agreed that prophylaxis should be offered to patients with a baseline factor VIII (FVIII) level of ≤5 IU/dL and that, where there is no treatment burden, the aim of prophylaxis should be to achieve a trough FVIII level ≥15 IU/dL and maintain a longer period with FVIII levels of ≥20-30 IU/dL to provide better bleed protection. The aspirational goal for PwHA is to prevent all joint bleeds, which may be achieved by maintaining normalised (50-150 IU/dL) FVIII levels.

CONCLUSION

The panel of experts were largely aligned on approaches to preserving joint health in PwHA, and this consensus may help guide HCPs.

Overview of Patients with Hemophilia in China: Demographics, Diseases, Treatment, and Health Status

Background

In China, there were over 65,000 hemophilia patients according to estimations requiring overall description. However, former Chinese studies related to hemophilia were based on data of relatively small sample size from single-center or selected multi-centers in specific areas.

Objective

This study is aimed to provide an overview of patients with hemophilia in China and basic information for optimized hemophilia care and policy decisions in the future.

Methods

We cooperated with the biggest patient organization of hemophilia in China, Hemophilia Home, got access to over ten thousand registered patients with hemophilia and conducted a national representative online survey in 2021. Descriptive statistics were conducted to describe the mean and standard deviation for continuous variables and numbers and proportions for categorical variables.

Results

Nine hundred and fifty patients with hemophilia aged 0-71 years were included in our analysis and divided into 538 children and 412 adults. Compared to international research, consistent results were found regarding the proportions of hemophilia types and hemophilia severity, while Chinese patients had less opportunity to receive the formal education and the lower rate to be employed or married. Although children with hemophilia had higher household income, timely treatment, and more prophylaxis treatment leading to better clinical outcomes and higher HRQoL than adults, there were still more annual bleeds, chronic pains, and lower EQ-VAS scores especially in adults than in other countries.

Conclusions and Recommendation

Our findings suggest the urgency for promoting hemophilia care and improving the social adaptation of hemophilia patients in China.

Using theory of change to co-create a programme theory for a telerehabilitation intervention for pain management in people with haemophilia

BACKGROUND

Improved approaches for chronic pain management are a clinical and research priority for people with haemophilia (PWH). Involving people with lived experience in the design of a complex rehabilitation intervention strengthens the credibility and plausibility of the intervention, particularly in relation to rare disorders. Here we describe using a 'Theory of Change' (ToC) dialogue-based stakeholder process to create a programme theory for a telerehabilitation intervention.

METHODS

An online workshop was convened and stakeholders received a briefing document in advance. Five stakeholders took part (3 PWH and 2 physiotherapists). At the workshop the group first agreed the overall aim of the intervention. Discussions then identified the resources, activities, barriers and enablers needed to achieve this outcome. All discussions were recorded and annotated by the workshop moderator. Behaviour change techniques were mapped for inclusion in the theory.

RESULTS

A programme theory and narrative report were produced. All stakeholders reviewed these for clarity and to ensure a true reflection of the workshop discussions. Agreement was based on how meaningful, well-defined, do-able, plausible, credible, and testable each component was. Stakeholders highlighted the importance of issues unique to PWH. Key components included the need for physiotherapists to be knowledgeable of the condition, a range of exercises that were inclusive of all abilities, and the need for people to feel safe and supported whilst taking part.

CONCLUSIONS

Co-developed theory based approaches to intervention design offer an inclusive and transparent way to develop novel and meaningful interventions for people with complex health conditions. The ToC is wholly transparent in its design and content. Together with the identified behaviour change techniques, the theory informs the protocol for a feasibility study evaluating a telerehabilitation intervention. Importantly, it allows the opportunity to revise, adapt and improve the programme theory for further implementation and evaluation.

Prevalence and perceptions of pain in people with haemophilia: A UK study

INTRODUCTION

Joint bleeds in haemophilia cause destruction of articular structures, impaired function and pain. Up to 70% of people with haemophilia (PWH) report chronic pain. Little is known about the pain experiences in PWH in the UK.

AIM

To identify prevalence and perceptions of pain among PWH living in the UK.

METHODS

A cross-sectional, non-interventional survey study conducted among PWH (all severities). The survey incorporated elements from validated tools (EQ-5D; EQ-VAS) and was distributed via participating treatment centres.

RESULTS

Five hundred and ninety-nine PWH responded, 91% aged > 18. 81% used factor prophylactically or on demand. More pain was reported by those treated on demand versus prophylaxis particularly in those who reported daily pain. 65% reported 'problem joints' based on individual impact rather than medically defined 'target joints', 2/3 reported multiple joint issues. The ankle was most commonly affected. 59% reported frequent pain, with 56% aware of pain constantly or most of the time and were more likely to report less favourable EQ-5D or EQ-VAS scores (p < .001). Pain frequency/awareness was consistent across all severities. Most discussed pain with care teams, 31% only when asked; 25% did not discuss it. Pain discussions resulted in physiotherapy referral (63%) analgesia prescription (48%), and a minority specialist pain referral (9%). Most felt well supported with regard to their pain, but 70% reported learning to live with it.

CONCLUSION

Pain affects PWH of all ages and severities even in a well-resourced country significantly impacting quality of life. Clinicians must be more aware of chronic pain in PWH. Biopsychosocial approaches to pain assessment and management are recommended.

The experiences and beliefs of people with severe haemophilia and healthcare professionals on pain management, and their views of using exercise as an aspect of intervention: a qualitative study

PURPOSE

To explore the experiences, views and beliefs of people with severe haemophilia and healthcare professionals (HCPs) on approaches for pain management, as well as their views on exercise being used as an aspect of management.

METHODS

Taking a qualitative inquiry approach using focus groups and semi-structured interviews, participants included people with severe haemophilia living with chronic pain and haemophilia HCPs. Data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Fourteen men with haemophilia with a median age of 47 (range 23-73) and six haemophilia HCPs agreed to participate. Of the people with haemophilia, 11 attended two focus groups and three were interviewed over telephone. Healthcare professionals were interviewed face-to-face. Two themes were conceptualised from the data: (i) haemophilia management and pain management is discordant (imbalance between good haemophilia care but poor pain management, historical medico-social influences on pain management, the need for trust); (ii) uncertain about exercise but clear on what matters (conflicting views on exercise, the need for proof of safety, personalised care).

CONCLUSIONS

Options for effective pain management remain limited and what is used is heavily influenced by beliefs and experience. Exercise as a treatment option in pain management is conceptually acceptable for people with haemophilia. Effective pain management requires understanding of individual beliefs and fears, and a personalised approach supported by knowledgeable, trusted clinicians.Implications for rehabilitationMusculoskeletal joint pain and its relationship with bleeding in people with haemophilia continues to be a management challenge.Current pain management strategies are of limited effectiveness with little evidence of an approach that reflects the multi-modal pain experience.Whilst exercise and rehabilitation approaches are conceptually possible for people with severe haemophilia, barriers remain regarding perception of overall safety and effectiveness.People with severe haemophilia may consider exercise as part of a pain management strategy if it is individualised, and they are supported to do it by clinicians who understand them and their haemophilia.