“I think we should all be singing from the same hymn sheet” – English and Swedish midwives’ views of advising pregnant women about alcohol

Midwives' experiences of discussing health behaviour change within routine maternity care: A qualitative systematic review and meta-synthesis

PROBLEM

Behaviours, such as smoking, alcohol use, unhealthy diet, lack of physical activity and vaccination non-adherence may lead to adverse pregnancy outcomes.

BACKGROUND

Pregnancy has been identified as an opportune time for midwives to support women to make health behaviour changes.

AIM

To synthesise existing qualitative research exploring midwives' experiences of discussing health behaviour change with women within routine care.

METHODS

A systematic search was conducted across: Maternity and Infant Care, PsycINFO, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, and Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts. Thematic analysis was used to synthesise the data. A professional and public advisory group provided feedback during the synthesis stage.

FINDINGS

Twenty-two studies, published between 2005 and 2023, which represented findings from eight countries, were included in the review. The meta-synthesis revealed three themes: The midwife-woman relationship; Reflective and tailored behaviour change communication; Practical barriers to behaviour change conversations. This led to one overarching theme: Although midwives recognised the importance of behaviour change discussions, these conversations were not prioritised in clinical practice.

CONCLUSION

Health behaviour change discussions were de-prioritised in midwives' clinical practice. Future research should explore intervention development to support midwives with their health behaviour change communication.

Opening Pandora's box: A meta-ethnography about alcohol use in pregnancy from midwives' and other healthcare providers' perspectives

INTRODUCTION

Alcohol consumption has increased in recent years, including among women of childbearing age. A woman's alcohol intake during pregnancy is linked to complications and injuries in the newborn, and the risk of the child being harmed by the mother's alcohol use increases in proportion to the amount of alcohol she consumes. This meta-ethnography aims to explore midwives' and other healthcare providers' experiences of screening pregnant women for alcohol use in pregnancy and counselling them on the subject.

METHODS

A systematic literature search in CINAHL, Maternity & Infant Care, MEDLINE, and Scopus was conducted in August 2021 and updated in January 2023. The CASP checklist was used to assess the included articles and meta-ethnography was used to synthesize the data.

RESULTS

Fourteen qualitative studies were included. In the synthesis, we use the metaphor of Pandora's box to deepen our understanding of the topic. We found that some healthcare providers tiptoe around the box, not wanting to face the consequences and responsibilities of asking women about their alcohol use. Others refuse or are reluctant to open the box because they lack knowledge about screening and counselling. Some eventually open the box, understanding the importance of establishing a trusting relationship to address alcohol use and seeing the need for knowledge and screening tools.

CONCLUSIONS

Healthcare education has the important task of ensuring that healthcare personnel have sufficient evidence-based knowledge about alcohol use in pregnancy. In the future, a health-promoting, tailored approach offering women in pre-pregnancy and early pregnancy sufficient evidence-based information should be implemented.

Prevalence of self-reported alcohol consumption among pregnant women in Russia between 1994 and 2018

BACKGROUND

Although pregnant women in Russia are thought to have a high level of alcohol consumption, nationwide data have not been available. We compared changes in consumption among pregnant and nonpregnant women of childbearing age from 1994 to 2018 and examined predictors of consumption among the pregnant women.

METHODS

Data were obtained from the annual, nationally representative Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey (RLMS-HSE), comprising 1,943 pregnant and 80,237 nonpregnant women of childbearing age. Past 30-day alcohol prevalence and current pregnancy status were self-reported. Logistic regressions using generalized linear mixed models examined two dependent variables: (1) current drinkers (any alcohol in the past 30 days) versus nondrinkers and (2) current drinkers and occasional drinkers (ever drinkers at any level) versus nondrinkers. Analyses included a series of predictors and control variables.

RESULTS

Between 1994 and 2018, a decrease in the 30-day prevalence of alcohol consumption was observed in both pregnant (from 25.6 (95% CI ± 3.3) to 9.4% (95% CI ± 2.2)) and nonpregnant (from 57.3 (95% CI ± 0.7) to 39.0% (95% CI ± 0.6)) women. Between 2006 and 2018, the percentage of pregnant abstainers increased from 46.8% (95% CI ± 4.2) to 54.6% (95% CI ± 3.6) while occasional drinking among pregnant women remained at 35% (95% CI ± 4.0). Time period, preventative check-ups, hospitalization, and frequent doctor's visits were significant predictors of the decrease in the 30-day prevalence of alcohol intake in pregnant women, but these did not predict the prevalence of occasional drinking.

CONCLUSION

Despite significant reductions in consumption among pregnant women in Russia, a substantial proportion reported occasional drinking. Conflicting information on how low alcohol intake affects health risks limited efforts to promote abstinence. Occasional drinking reflects a self-control domain for women that, depending on perceptions of a healthy pregnancy, is framed by social institutions and the environment.

"The Problem Is that We Hear a Bit of Everything…": A Qualitative Systematic Review of Factors Associated with Alcohol Use, Reduction, and Abstinence in Pregnancy

Understanding the factors that contribute to women's alcohol use in pregnancy is critical to supporting women's health and wellness and preventing Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder. A systematic review of qualitative studies involving pregnant and recently postpartum women was undertaken to understand the barriers and facilitators that influence alcohol use in pregnancy (PROSPERO: CRD42018098831). Twenty-seven (n = 27) articles were identified through EMBASE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, PubMed and Web of Science. The included articles were thematically analyzed using NVivo12. The analysis was informed by Canada's Action Framework for Building an Inclusive Health System to articulate the ways in which stigma and related barriers are enacted at the individual, interpersonal, institutional and population levels. Five themes impacting women's alcohol use, abstention and reduction were identified: (1) social relationships and norms; (2) stigma; (3) trauma and other stressors; (4) alcohol information and messaging; and (5) access to trusted equitable care and essential resources. The impact of structural and systemic factors on prenatal alcohol use was largely absent in the included studies, instead focusing on individual choice. This silence risks perpetuating stigma and highlights the criticality of addressing intersecting structural and systemic factors in supporting maternal and fetal health.

Barriers and enablers of implementation of alcohol guidelines with pregnant women: a cross-sectional survey among UK midwives

Background

In 2016, the UK Chief Medical Officers revised their guidance on alcohol and advised women to abstain from alcohol if pregnant or planning pregnancy. Midwives have a key role in advising women about alcohol during pregnancy. The aim of this study was to investigate UK midwives’ practices regarding the 2016 Chief Medical Officers Alcohol Guidelines for pregnancy, and factors influencing their implementation during antenatal appointments.

Methods

Online cross-sectional survey of a convenience sample of UK midwives recruited through professional networks and social media. Data were gathered using an anonymous online questionnaire addressing knowledge of the 2016 Alcohol Guidelines for pregnancy; practice behaviours regarding alcohol assessment and advice; and questions based on the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) to evaluate implementation of advising abstinence at antenatal booking and subsequent antenatal appointments.

Results

Of 842 questionnaire respondents, 58% were aware of the 2016 Alcohol Guidelines of whom 91% (438) cited abstinence was recommended, although 19% (93) cited recommendations from previous guidelines. Nonetheless, 97% of 842 midwives always or usually advised women to abstain from alcohol at the booking appointment, and 38% at subsequent antenatal appointments. Mean TDF domain scores (range 1–7) for advising abstinence at subsequent appointments were highest (indicative of barriers) for social influences (3.65 sd 0.84), beliefs about consequences (3.16 sd 1.13) and beliefs about capabilities (3.03 sd 073); and lowest (indicative of facilitators) for knowledge (1.35 sd 0.73) and professional role and identity (1.46 sd 0.77). Logistic regression analysis indicated that the TDF domains: beliefs about capabilities (OR = 0.71, 95% CI: 0.57, 0.88), emotion (OR = 0.78; 95%CI: 0.67, 0.90), and professional role and identity (OR = 0.69, 95%CI 0.51, 0.95) were strong predictors of midwives advising all women to abstain from alcohol at appointments other than at booking.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that skill development and reinforcement of support from colleagues and the wider maternity system could support midwives’ implementation of alcohol advice at each antenatal appointment, not just at booking could lead to improved outcomes for women and infants. Implementation of alcohol care pathways in maternity settings are beneficial from a lifecourse perspective for women, children, families, and the wider community.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12884-021-03583-1.