QSAR for the organophosphate-induced inhibition and 'aging' of the enzyme neuropathy target esterase (NTE)

Quantitative structure-activity relationships predict the delayed neurotoxicity potential of a series of O-alkyl-O-methylchloroformimino phenylphosphonates

Inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) versus inhibition and aging of neuropathy target esterase (NTE) by organophosphorus (OP) compounds in vivo can give rise to distinct neurological consequences: acute cholinergic toxicity versus OP compound-induced delayed neurotoxicity (OPIDN). Previous work has shown that the relative potency of an OP compound to react with NTE versus AChE in vitro may predict its capability to produce OPIDN. The present study was conducted to evaluate further the validity of such predictions and to enhance them with quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR) using a homologous series of alkyl phenylphosphonates (RO)C6H5P(O)ON = CCICH3 (PhP; R = alkyl). Neuropathic potential of PhP was assessed by measuring ki(NTE)ki(AChE) ratios in vitro and comparing these with ED50 ratios in vivo. Selectivity for NTE increased with rising R-group hydrophobicity. The ki(NTE)/ki(AChE) ratios were 0.42 (methyl), 3.6 (ethyl), 15 (isopropyl), 36 (propyl), 69 (isobutyl), 105 (butyl), and 124 (pentyl). Ratios > 1 suggest the potential to produce OPIDN at doses lower than the LD50. Inhibition of NTE and AChE in hen brain in vivo was studied 24 h after i.m. injection of hens with increasing doses of methyl and butyl derivatives. Analysis of dose-response curves yielded ED50(AChE)/ED50(NTE) ratio of 0.86 for methyl PhP and 22.1 for butyl PhP. These results predict that the butyl derivative should be more neuropathic than the methyl analogue. Excellent correspondence between in vivo and in vitro predictions of neuropathic potential indicate that valid predictive QSAR models may be based on the in vitro approach. Adoption of this system would result in reducing experimental animal use, lowering costs, accelerating data production, and enabling standardization of a biochemically based risk assessment of the neuropathic potential of OP compounds.