Incomplete penetrance of CRX gene for autosomal dominant form of cone-rod dystrophy

Cone Rod Homeobox (CRX): literature review and new insights

The development of the neural retina requires a complex, spatiotemporally regulated network of gene expression. Here we review the role of the cone rod homeobox (CRX) transcription factor in specification and differentiation of retinal photoreceptors and its function in inherited retinal diseases such as cone-rod dystrophy (CoRD), dominant retinitis pigmentosa (RP), and Leber's congenital amaurosis (LCA). We delineate the findings of animal models and, more recently, human retinal organoids in elucidating molecular mechanisms of CRX activity and the pathogenesis of inherited photoreceptor degenerations. Lastly, we discuss implications of these findings in the development of therapies for inherited retinal diseases.

Clinical, Genetic, and Histopathological Characteristics of CRX-associated Retinal Dystrophies

PURPOSE

To describe phenotypic, genotypic, and histopathological features of inherited retinal dystrophies associated with the CRX gene (CRX-RDs).

DESIGN

Retrospective multicenter cohort study including histopathology.

SUBJECTS

Thirty-nine patients from 31 families with pathogenic variants in the CRX gene.

METHODS

Clinical data of 152 visits were collected from medical records. The median follow-up time was 9.1 years (interquartile range (IQR), 3.3-15.3 years; range, 0.0-48.8 years). Histopathologic examination of the eye of a 17-year-old patient with advanced early-onset CRX-RD was performed.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Visual acuity, retinal imaging, electroretinography, genotype-phenotype correlation, and histopathological examination were evaluated.

RESULTS

The age at onset ranged from birth to the eighth decade of life. Median visual acuity was 1.00 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) (IQR, 0.69-1.48 logMAR; range, 0.06-3.00 logMAR) at a mean age of 52.0 ± 19.9 years (range, 4.6-81.9 years). Sufficient imaging was available for 36 out of 39 patients (92.3%), and all showed degeneration of at least the macula. Of these 36 patients, 22 (61.1%) had only macular dystrophy. Another 10 patients (27.8%) had additional degeneration beyond the vascular arcades, and 4 patients (11.1%) panretinal degeneration. Two patients (5.1%) had Leber congenital amaurosis. In total, 21 different disease-associated heterozygous CRX variants were identified (10 frameshift, 7 missense, 2 deletion, 1 nonsense, 1 deletion-insertion variants). Missense variants in the CRX homeodomain and 2 variants deleting all functional domains, thus causing haploinsufficiency, generally tended to cause milder late-onset phenotypes. Histopathologic examination of the eye of a 17-year-old patient with advanced early-onset retinal dystrophy due to a heterozygous deletion of exons 3 and 4 of the CRX gene revealed loss of laminar integrity and widespread photoreceptor degeneration especially in the central retina, with extensive loss of photoreceptor nuclei and outer segments.

CONCLUSIONS

This study illustrates the large clinical and genetic heterogenic spectrum of CRX-RDs, ranging from Leber congenital amaurosis to mild late-onset maculopathy resembling occult macular dystrophy. Haploinsufficiency and missense variants tended to be associated with milder phenotypes. Patients showed degeneration predominantly affecting the central retina on imaging. The histopathological findings also mirror these clinical findings and features similar to previously reported animal models of CRX-RDs.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Dual inheritance patterns: A spectrum of non-syndromic inherited retinal disease phenotypes with varying molecular mechanisms

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) encompass a variety of disease phenotypes and are known to display both clinical and genetic heterogeneity. A further complexity is that for several IRD-associated genes, pathogenic variants have been reported to cause either autosomal dominant (AD) or autosomal recessive (AR) diseases. The possibility of dual inheritance can create a challenge for variant interpretation as well as the genetic counselling of patients. This review aims to determine whether the molecular mechanisms behind the dual inheritance of each IRD-associated gene is well established, not yet properly understood, or if the association is questionable. Each gene is discussed individually in detail due to different protein structures and functions, but there are overlapping characteristics. For example, eight genes only have a limited number of reported pathogenic variants or a hotspot region implicated in the second inheritance pattern. Whereas CRX and RP1 display distinct spatial patterns for AR and AD pathogenic variants based on the variant type and/or location. The genes with a questionable dual inheritance, namely AIPL1, CRB1, and RCBTB1 highlight the importance of carefully considering allele frequency data. Finally, the crucial role relevant functional studies in animal and cell models play in validating a variant's biochemical or molecular effect is emphasised.

Syndromic Retinitis Pigmentosa

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is a progressive inherited retinal dystrophy, characterized by the degeneration of photoreceptors, presenting as a rod-cone dystrophy. Approximately 20-30% of patients with RP also exhibit extra-ocular manifestations in the context of a syndrome. This manuscript discusses the broad spectrum of syndromes associated with RP, pathogenic mechanisms, clinical manifestations, differential diagnoses, clinical management approaches, and future perspectives. Given the diverse clinical and genetic landscape of syndromic RP, the diagnosis may be challenging. However, an accurate and timely diagnosis is essential for optimal clinical management, prognostication, and potential treatment. Broadly, the syndromes associated with RP can be categorized into ciliopathies, inherited metabolic disorders, mitochondrial disorders, and miscellaneous syndromes. Among the ciliopathies associated with RP, Usher syndrome and Bardet-Biedl syndrome are the most well-known. Less common ciliopathies include Cohen syndrome, Joubert syndrome, cranioectodermal dysplasia, asphyxiating thoracic dystrophy, Mainzer-Saldino syndrome, and RHYNS syndrome. Several inherited metabolic disorders can present with RP including Zellweger spectrum disorders, adult Refsum disease, α-methylacyl-CoA racemase deficiency, certain mucopolysaccharidoses, ataxia with vitamin E deficiency, abetalipoproteinemia, several neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses, mevalonic aciduria, PKAN/HARP syndrome, PHARC syndrome, and methylmalonic acidaemia with homocystinuria type cobalamin (cbl) C disease. Due to the mitochondria's essential role in supplying continuous energy to the retina, disruption of mitochondrial function can lead to RP, as seen in Kearns-Sayre syndrome, NARP syndrome, primary coenzyme Q10 deficiency, SSBP1-associated disease, and long chain 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency. Lastly, Cockayne syndrome and PERCHING syndrome can present with RP, but they do not fit the abovementioned hierarchy and are thus categorized as 'Miscellaneous'. Several first-in-human clinical trials are underway or in preparation for some of these syndromic forms of RP.

Atypic Retinitis Pigmentosa Clinical Features Associated with a Peculiar CRX Gene Mutation in Italian Patients

Purpose: To describe an atypical phenotypic pattern of late-onset retinitis pigmentosa (RP) due to the same specific c.425A>G (p.Tyr142Cys) heterozygous mutation in the cone-rod homeobox gene (CRX gene) in two unrelated Italian patients. Case 1: A 67-year-old woman (P.P.) was incidentally diagnosed with sector RP at the age of 50. The patient was initially asymptomatic and did not have any family history of retinal dystrophy. Fundus examination showed the presence of typical retinal pigmentary deposits with a peculiar pericentral/sector distribution. Genomic sequencing disclosed the missense mutation c.425A>G (p.Tyr142Cys) in the CRX gene. During the follow-up period of 7 years, the patient maintained good visual acuity and complained only of mild symptoms. Case 2: A 76-year-old man (P.E.) presented with nyctalopia and visual field constriction since the age of 50. Fundus examination showed the presence of retinal pigment deposits with a concentric pericentral and perimacular pattern. A full-field electroretinogram (ffERG) showed extinguished scotopic responses and reduced abnormal photopic and flicker cone responses. Genomic sequencing identified the same missense mutation, c.425A>G (p.Tyr142Cys), in the CRX gene. Similarly to the first case, during the whole follow-up of 7 years, the visual acuity remained stable, as did the visual field and the patient's symptoms. Conclusions: We report the first cases of late-onset retinitis pigmentosa related to a specific heterozygous CRX gene mutation in exon 4. We also report two atypical phenotypic RP patterns related to mutations in the CRX gene.

Transcriptional precision in photoreceptor development and diseases - Lessons from 25 years of CRX research

The vertebrate retina is made up of six specialized neuronal cell types and one glia that are generated from a common retinal progenitor. The development of these distinct cell types is programmed by transcription factors that regulate the expression of specific genes essential for cell fate specification and differentiation. Because of the complex nature of transcriptional regulation, understanding transcription factor functions in development and disease is challenging. Research on the Cone-rod homeobox transcription factor CRX provides an excellent model to address these challenges. In this review, we reflect on 25 years of mammalian CRX research and discuss recent progress in elucidating the distinct pathogenic mechanisms of four CRX coding variant classes. We highlight how in vitro biochemical studies of CRX protein functions facilitate understanding CRX regulatory principles in animal models. We conclude with a brief discussion of the emerging systems biology approaches that could accelerate precision medicine for CRX-linked diseases and beyond.

The Value of Electroretinography in Identifying Candidate Genes for Inherited Retinal Dystrophies: A Diagnostic Guide

Inherited retinal dystrophies (IRDs) are a group of heterogeneous diseases caused by genetic mutations that specifically affect the function of the rod, cone, or bipolar cells in the retina. Electroretinography (ERG) is a diagnostic tool that measures the electrical activity of the retina in response to light stimuli, and it can help to determine the function of these cells. A normal ERG response consists of two waves, the a-wave and the b-wave, which reflect the activity of the photoreceptor cells and the bipolar and Muller cells, respectively. Despite the growing availability of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology, identifying the precise genetic mutation causing an IRD can be challenging and costly. However, certain types of IRDs present with unique ERG features that can help guide genetic testing. By combining these ERG findings with other clinical information, such as on family history and retinal imaging, physicians can effectively narrow down the list of candidate genes to be sequenced, thereby reducing the cost of genetic testing. This review article focuses on certain types of IRDs with unique ERG features. We will discuss the pathophysiology and clinical presentation of, and ERG findings on, these disorders, emphasizing the unique role ERG plays in their diagnosis and genetic testing.

Targeted next generation sequencing and family survey enable correct genetic diagnosis in CRX associated macular dystrophy - a case report

Background

We present 3 members of a family with macular dystrophy, originally diagnosed as Stargardt disease, with a significantly variable age at onset, caused by a heterozygous mutation in CRX.

Case presentation

A 43-year-old female with bull’s eye maculopathy, whose sister was diagnosed with Stargardt disease previously at another centre, was found to have a single ABCA4 variant. Further examination of the family revealed that the asymptomatic father was also affected, indicating a dominant pattern of inheritance. In addition, the ABCA4 variant was not identified in the sister originally diagnosed with Stargardt disease. Next generation sequencing identified a heterozygous c.121C > T, p.R41W missense mutation in CRX in all 3 affected members.

Conclusions

We describe a common phenotype, but with variable age at onset, with autosomal dominant inheritance and reduced penetrance in a family found to have a pathogenic sequence variant in CRX. This illustrates the importance of panel based molecular genetic testing accompanied by family studies to establish a definitive diagnosis.

Application of CRISPR Tools for Variant Interpretation and Disease Modeling in Inherited Retinal Dystrophies

Inherited retinal dystrophies are an assorted group of rare diseases that collectively account for the major cause of visual impairment of genetic origin worldwide. Besides clinically, these vision loss disorders present a high genetic and allelic heterogeneity. To date, over 250 genes have been associated to retinal dystrophies with reported causative variants of every nature (nonsense, missense, frameshift, splice-site, large rearrangements, and so forth). Except for a fistful of mutations, most of them are private and affect one or few families, making it a challenge to ratify the newly identified candidate genes or the pathogenicity of dubious variants in disease-associated loci. A recurrent option involves altering the gene in in vitro or in vivo systems to contrast the resulting phenotype and molecular imprint. To validate specific mutations, the process must rely on simulating the precise genetic change, which, until recently, proved to be a difficult endeavor. The rise of the CRISPR/Cas9 technology and its adaptation for genetic engineering now offers a resourceful suite of tools to alleviate the process of functional studies. Here we review the implementation of these RNA-programmable Cas9 nucleases in culture-based and animal models to elucidate the role of novel genes and variants in retinal dystrophies.

Clinical spectrum, genetic complexity and therapeutic approaches for retinal disease caused by ABCA4 mutations

The ABCA4 protein (then called a “rim protein”) was first identified in 1978 in the rims and incisures of rod photoreceptors. The corresponding gene, ABCA4, was cloned in 1997, and variants were identified as the cause of autosomal recessive Stargardt disease (STGD1). Over the next two decades, variation in ABCA4 has been attributed to phenotypes other than the classically defined STGD1 or fundus flavimaculatus, ranging from early onset and fast progressing cone-rod dystrophy and retinitis pigmentosa-like phenotypes to very late onset cases of mostly mild disease sometimes resembling, and confused with, age-related macular degeneration. Similarly, analysis of the ABCA4 locus uncovered a trove of genetic information, including >1200 disease-causing mutations of varying severity, and of all types – missense, nonsense, small deletions/insertions, and splicing affecting variants, of which many are located deep-intronic. Altogether, this has greatly expanded our understanding of complexity not only of the diseases caused by ABCA4 mutations, but of all Mendelian diseases in general. This review provides an in depth assessment of the cumulative knowledge of ABCA4-associated retinopathy – clinical manifestations, genetic complexity, pathophysiology as well as current and proposed therapeutic approaches.

Association of CRX genotypes and retinal phenotypes confounded by variable expressivity and electronegative electroretinogram

IMPORTANCE

A framework for understanding the phenotypic features of CRX retinopathy was established.

BACKGROUND

To perform a phenotype-genotype correlation analysis in two groups of patients with heterozygous mutations in distinct locations of the CRX gene, encoding the cone-rod homeobox.

DESIGN

Multicentre retrospective study.

PARTICIPANTS

Twenty-one Japanese patients from 14 families with a heterozygous CRX mutation.

METHODS

Retrospective data analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Clinical records on CRX mutation, symptoms, best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), visual field, fundus photography, fundus auto-fluorescence, optical coherence tomography and electroretinograms (ERGs).

RESULTS

Six different CRX heterozygous mutations were identified in the subjects. Twelve patients from 9 families shared the p.R41W mutation and 1 patient had the p.R43C mutation, both of which affect the homeobox domain of CRX. These patients often displayed adult-onset retinal dystrophy with macular degeneration. In contrast, five patients with downstream mutations (p.S204fs, p.S213fs, p.G243X and p.L299F) displayed retinal degeneration or macular degeneration with bone-spicule pigmentation. Three asymptomatic carriers with different mutations (p.R41W, p.S213fs and p.G243X) were present in both groups. Nearly all patients and carriers had an electronegative ERG in response to a bright flash under dark adaptation. There was no cross-sectional association between patients' age and BCVA, despite progressive decline in BCVA.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

Heterozygous mutations within or downstream of the homeobox domain in CRX relate to the difference associated retinal phenotypes, which was confounded by variable expressivity and electronegative ERGs. CRX mutations should be considered in patients with an electronegative ERG with minimal or no macular changes.

A recurrent arcuate retinopathy in familial cone-rod dystrophy secondary to heterozygous CRX deletion

Purpose: To describe an arcuate retinopathy appearance in a familial cone-rod dystrophy and the underlying genetic cause.Methods: Retrospective case series of an affected three-generation family (eight affected members, eight unaffected members)Results: The proband, a 47-year-old male, noted significant visual loss since his early thirties. In addition to central macular atrophic changes, retinal examination was notable for peripapillary atrophy and an arcuate of drusenoid deep yellow lesions in the temporal macula. Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography in the area of the lesions showed regional outer neurosensory retina loss with nasal extension (forming a ring around the central retina) but no drusen. Full-field electroretinography revealed cone-rod dysfunction with an electronegative waveform. Fifteen other available family members were examined, and seven (age range 13-71 years old) showed variable expressivity for similar phenotypic findings, most notably the arcuate lesions in all but the oldest individual who had end-stage atrophy. Exome sequencing of the proband's affected daughter uncovered a heterozygous CRX deletion [NM_000554.4: CRX: c.(100 + 1_101-1)_(c.900 + 1_?)del] that segregated with the disease.Conclusion: An unusual familial cone-rod dystrophy phenotype was associated with heterozygous CRX deletion, a pathogenic variant that had a presumed mechanism of haploinsufficiency. The consistent finding of arcuate temporal macular lesions among affected family members was striking, particularly given the variable expressivity previously associated with CRX-related retinopathy. Additional phenotypic studies are needed to assess how frequently this temporal arcuate retinopathy appearance occurs in individuals harboring a similar deletion who are not from the current family.