The efficacy of fractional carbon dioxide (CO2) laser combined with terbinafine hydrochloride 1% cream for the treatment of onychomycosis

Efficacy of Fractional Versus Fully Ablative CO2 Laser for Distolateral Onychomycosis: Experience With 20 Patients

INTRODUCTION

Oral antifungals are the treatment choice for onychomycosis, and topical therapies are favored in cases of limited nail involvement. Recently, carbon dioxide (CO2) laser treatment has emerged as an option to enhance the effectiveness of topical therapies.

OBJECTIVES

Our objective was to compare the efficacy of fractional ablative and fully ablative CO2 laser treatments for distolateral subungual onychomycosis affecting a single toenail and caused by dermatophytes.

METHODS

The records of 10 patients treated with a single fully ablative CO2 session were matched with those of 10 patients who underwent a single CO2 fractional treatment. All had previously failed topical antifungal lacquers and were discharged with the prescription of topical ciclopirox nail lacquer (8%) for 3 months.

RESULTS

The clinical response rates were 80% for the fully ablative group and 60% for the fractional group. Additionally, the mean reduction in Onychomycosis Severity Index from baseline to 8.6±1.6 weeks after treatment completion was 6.9±5.4 in the fully ablative group and 3.6±6.6 in the fractional group. The relapse rate among responders was 12.5% in the fully ablative and 33.3% in the fractional group after a mean follow-up time of 29.4±2.3 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Fractional and fully ablative CO2 laser in combination with ciclopirox lacquer could increase the response rate in onychomycosis resistant to topical antifungals when systemic therapy is contraindicated or not yet pursued. Fully ablative mode therapy is significantly more effective than fractional (P < 0.05). Further studies are needed to identify prognostic response factors and assess the long-term effectiveness of CO2 laser treatment.

A focused review on laser- and energy-assisted drug delivery for nail disorders

The purpose of this review is to consolidate and summarize laser-assisted drug delivery (LADD) for nail diseases, particularly onychomycosis and psoriasis. A PubMed search was conducted in June 2023 using search terms (1) "laser assisted drug delivery" AND "nail," (2) "laser" AND "nail," and (3) "nail disorder" AND "laser treatment." References of papers were also reviewed, yielding 15 papers for this review. Fractional ablative CO2 laser (FACL) and Er:YAG laser can be used for LADD of topical medications such as amorolfine, terbinafine, and tioconazole to treat onychomycosis. A fungal culture should be performed to determine the type of dermatophyte, which will help determine which topical will be most effective. Laser settings varied between studies, but overall LADD tended to be more effective than topical treatments alone. Laser-assisted photodynamic therapy (PDT) was also found to be effective in treating onychomycosis. For psoriatic nails, LADD was used to deliver calcipotriol-betamethasone dipropionate foam, tazarotene, triamcinolone, or methotrexate into the nail. Again, LADD was found to be significantly more effective than topical treatment alone. FACL was the only laser noted for use for LADD in both diseases. Laser-assisted drug delivery for nail disease is a newer approach for onychomycosis and nail psoriasis with several benefits and drawbacks. Dermatologists should discuss the option of LADD with their patients who have recalcitrant onychomycosis or nail psoriasis.

Q-switched Nd:YAG laser versus itraconazole pulse therapy in treatment of onychomycosis: A clinical dermoscopic and mycologic study

BACKGROUND

Onychomycosis (OM) represents about 50% of nail disorders. Oral antifungals have proven efficacy in the treatment of onychomycosis but their associated side effects limit their use. Accordingly, there is an increased need for a safe and effective therapy to induce clearance and improve the esthetic appearance of diseased nails.

OBJECTIVE

The current study is an attempt to evaluate and compare the efficacy of Q-Switched Nd:YAG (1064 nm) laser as monotherapy versus pulse itraconazole in the clearance of onychomycosis.

METHODS

In this prospective study, 40 onychomycosis patients were equally divided into two groups: Groups I (laser group) and II (Itraconazole group). Patients of Group I are treated with six biweekly sessions of Q-Switched Nd:YAG (1064 nm) laser. Patients of Group II are treated with itraconazole pulse therapy. The assessment of clearance was rated using the "Onychomycosis Severity Index (OSI)", photographs, dermoscopy, and mycology. All 40 patients were followed up for 3 months after the end of treatment.

RESULTS

Group I's clinical improvement response was a marked improvement in 19 cases and moderate improvement in one case (OSI before treatment was 24.5 and after was 0). A dermoscopic cure occurred in 19 cases. Mycological cure was obtained in 19 cases. Group II's clinical improvement response was marked in 15 and moderate in 5 (OSI before treatment was 24 and after was 0). Dermoscopic cure occurred in 15 cases. Mycological cure was obtained in 15 cases. There were no adverse effects. The clinical response, the dermoscopic cure, and the mycological cure were equal in both groups, with no significant difference found between them.

CONCLUSION

Q-Switched Nd:YAG (1064 nm) laser can be used as an effective and safe modality in the clearance of nail onychomycosis, particularly in patients who have a contraindication to or refuse the use of oral antifungals.

Fractional CO2 laser with topical 1% terbinafine cream versus oral itraconazole in the management of onychomycosis: A randomized controlled trial

Background Onychomycosis accounts for 20-40% of all nail disorders. It is difficult to cure with resistance to anti-fungal drugs, their side effects and drug interactions limiting treatment options. Itraconazole is a widely accepted oral medication used for onychomycosis while fractional CO2 laser along with a topical anti-fungal has shown promising results for nail plate clearance in onychomycosis. Aim To compare the efficacy of fractional CO2 laser with 1% terbinafine cream versus itraconazole in the management of onychomycosis. Methods A prospective, randomised, single-centre, two-arm, parallel-group interventional study was conducted at Command Hospital Air Force, Bangalore. Onychomycosis cases confirmed by KOH mount/culture-positive were included. Patients were randomly divided into two groups. Group A received 4 sessions of fractional CO2 laser every fourth week with twice-daily application of 1% terbinafine cream; Group B received one-week pulse therapy with capsule itraconazole once every four-week for three pulses. The response was assessed by Onychomycosis Severity Index, a validated onychomycosis assessment scale, at baseline and at six months. Results Group A had 50 patients with a total of 98 nails. Clinical improvement was seen in 83/98 (84.7%) nails. The average reduction in Onychomycosis Severity Index was 8.65 (P < 0.05). Group B had 50 patients with a total of 136 nails. Clinical improvement was seen in 104/136 (76.5%) nails. The average reduction in Onychomycosis Severity Index was 7.37 (P < 0.05). Both groups showed statistically significant improvement measured by 'Reduction in Onychomycosis Severity Index' at six months; however, there was no significant difference between the two arms. Limitations The main limitations of the study are the small sample size and lack of long-term follow-up to assess recurrence of infection. Conclusion Fractional CO2 laser with 1% terbinafine cream is an effective and safe method for inducing nail clearance in onychomycosis and has efficacy similar to itraconazole pulse therapy.

Vergleich der fraktionierten laserunterstützten Medikamentengabe und der intraläsionalen Injektion von Triamcinolonacetonid bei Nagelpsoriasis

HINTERGRUND UND ZIELE

Die Behandlung der Nagelpsoriasis ist wegen mangelnder Penetration topischer Therapeutika durch die Nagelplatte häufig unbefriedigend. Daher sind innovative Methoden zur adäquaten Verabreichung des Arzneimittels in den Nagel erforderlich. In dieser Studie vergleichen wir die Wirksamkeit der intraläsionalen Corticosteroid-Injektion mit topischer Applikation nach fraktionierter CO₂ -Laser-Behandlung bei Fingernagelpsoriasis.

PATIENTEN UND METHODEN

In der Studie wurden 36 Patienten mit Fingernagelpsoriasis in zwei Gruppen eingeteilt. Bei Gruppe A wurden die Nägel mit intraläsionalen Injektionen von Triamcinolon behandelt, in Gruppe B durch fraktionierte CO₂ -Lasertherapie, gefolgt von topischer Applikation des Arzneimittels in sechs Sitzungen. Die Beurteilung erfolgte anhand des NAPSI und eines dermatoskopischen Scores.

ERGEBNISSE

Beide Modalitäten führten zu signifikanter Besserung der Psoriasis an Nagelmatrix und Nagelbett. Statistisch signifikante Unterschiede zwischen den Gruppen bestanden weder klinisch noch dermatoskopisch. Die Laserbehandlung war mit signifikant geringeren Schmerz-Scores (P = 0,03) und höherer Patientenzufriedenheit (P = 0,007) verbunden.

SCHLUSSFOLGERUNGEN

Die fraktionierte CO₂ -Laser-unterstützte Applikation topischer Steroide könnte eine effektive und gut verträgliche Therapie der Nagelpsoriasis sein, die eine der intraläsionalen Injektion vergleichbare Wirksamkeit hat.

Comparison of fractional laser-assisted drug delivery and intralesional injection of triamcinolone acetonide in nail psoriasis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The treatment of nail psoriasis is often unsatisfactory due to poor penetration of topical therapeutics through the nail plate. The development of innovative methods that provide adequate delivery of the drug into the nail is warranted. In this study, we aim to compare the efficacy of intralesional corticosteroid injection versus its topical application after fractional CO₂ laser in the treatment of fingernail psoriasis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study included 36 patients with fingernail psoriasis divided into two groups. The nails in group A were treated with intralesional injection of triamcinolone acetonide while the nails in group B received fractional CO₂ laser therapy followed by topical application of the drug for six sessions. The evaluation was performed using NAPSI and dermatoscopic scores.

RESULTS

Both modalities yielded a significant improvement of the nail matrix and bed psoriatic signs. No statistically significant difference was found between the two groups by both clinical and dermatoscopic assessment. The laser treatment was associated with significantly lower pain scores (P = 0.03) and higher patient satisfaction (P = 0.007).

CONCLUSIONS

Fractional CO₂ laser-assisted delivery of topical corticosteroids can be a potentially effective and well-tolerated therapeutic modality in the treatment of nail psoriasis with comparable efficacy to intralesional injection.

Efficacy of laser therapy combined with topical antifungal agents for onychomycosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials

INTRODUCTION

Onychomycosis is a common fungal infection of the nail. Laser and topical antifungal agent combination therapy is an emerging treatment for onychomycosis. The objective of this study was to systematically evaluate the efficacy and safety of laser and topical antifungal agent combination therapy for onychomycosis.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang and VIP databases were searched from inception to November 2021. Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) on laser therapy combined with topical antifungal agents for onychomycosis were included. The Cochrane Collaboration tool was used to assess the risk of bias, and Revman 5.3 software was used in the meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Twelve studies involving 869 patients were included in this meta-analysis. The results showed that compared with topical antifungal agents alone, laser and topical antifungal agent combination therapy was superior in terms of the complete cure rate (RR 6.04,95% CI (2.17, 16.85), P = 0.0006), mycological cure rate (RR 1.27, 95% CI (1.10, 1.48), P = 0.001), clinical effective rate (RR 1.38, 95% CI (1.20, 1.57), P < 0.00001) and patient satisfaction rate (RR 1.47,95% CI (1.17, 1.84), P = 0.0009).The subgroup analysis of outcome indicators, including mycological cure rate and clinical effective rate, demonstrated that both carbon dioxide (CO₂) laser therapy combined with topical antifungal therapy and 1064-nm neodymium-doped:yttrium aluminium garnet (Nd:YAG) laser therapy combined with topical antifungal therapy showed better results than topical antifungal therapy alone. No adverse events were identified except for three studies reporting transient burning sensation without treatment and mild to moderate pain, both of which were well tolerated.

CONCLUSION

The present study indicated that laser and topical antifungal agent combination therapy is effective for onychomycosis. However, more large-scale and well-designed RCTs are warranted.

Fractional CO2 laser ablation leads to enhanced permeation of a fluorescent dye in healthy and mycotic nails-An imaging investigation of laser-tissue effects and their impact on ungual drug delivery

Purpose

Conventional oral antifungal therapies for onychomycosis (OM) often do not achieve complete cure and may be associated with adverse effects, medical interactions, and compliance issues restricting their use in a large group of patients. Topical treatment can bypass the systemic side effects but is limited by the physical barrier of the nail plate. Ablative fractional laser (AFL) treatment can be used to improve the penetration of topical drugs into the nail. This study visualized the effects of laser ablation of nail tissue and assessed their impact on the biodistribution of a fluorescent dye in healthy and fungal nail tissue.

Methods

For the qualitative assessment of CO₂ AFL effects on healthy nail tissue, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), coherent anti‐Stokes Raman scattering microscopy (CARS‐M), and widefield fluorescence microscopy (WFM) were used. To quantitate the effect of laser‐pretreatment on the delivery of a fluorescent dye, ATTO‐647N, into healthy and fungal nail tissue, ablation depth, nail plate thickness, and ATTO‐647N fluorescence intensity in three nail plate layers were measured using WFM. A total of 30 nail clippings (healthy n = 18, fungal n = 12) were collected. An aqueous ATTO‐647N solution was directly applied to the dorsal surface of 24 nail samples (healthy n = 12, fungal n = 12) and incubated for 4 hours, of which half (healthy n = 6, fungal n = 6) had been pretreated with AFL (30 mJ/mb, 15% density, 300 Hz, pulse duration <1 ms).

Results

Imaging revealed a three‐layered nail structure, an AFL‐induced porous ablation crater, and changes in autofluorescence. While intact fungal samples showed a 106% higher ATTO‐647N signal intensity than healthy controls, microporation led to a significantly increased fluorophore permeation in all samples (p < 0.0001). AFL processing of nail tissue enhanced topical delivery of ATTO‐647N in all layers, (average increase: healthy +108%, fungal +33%), most pronounced in the top nail layer (healthy +122%, fungal +68%). While proportionally deeper ablation craters correlated moderately with higher fluorescence intensities in healthy nail tissue, fungal samples showed no significant relationship.

Conclusion

Fractional CO₂ laser microporation is a simple way of enhancing the passive delivery of topically applied ATTO‐647N. Although the impaired nail plate barrier in OM leads to greater diffusion of the aqueous solution, AFL can increase the permeability of both structurally deficient and intact nails.

Real-world Effectiveness of a Fractional CO2 Laser with Topical Antifungal Agents for the Treatment of Onychomycosis

BACKGROUND

Current therapeutic agents for onychomycosis have limited efficacy or cause side effects. Recently, successful treatment using fractional CO₂ lasers has been reported; however, the results are inconsistent.

OBJECTIVE

We analyzed the real-world effectiveness of a Fractional CO₂ laser for the treatment of Onychomycosis METHODS: A single-center retrospective chart review was conducted during January 2015-December 2018. Patients, diagnosed with onychomycosis through fungal culture and/or potassium hydroxide staining, underwent three or more fractional CO₂ laser treatments and used topical antifungal agents. Treatment effects were assessed by using clinical images at 6 months, 12 months, and the last visit.

RESULTS

Ninety-six patients were included; they underwent an average of 7.7 laser treatment sessions. Finally, 15 patents (15.6%) showed complete response (CR, 100% clearing of all nails), 24 patients (25%) showed partial response, and 57 patients (59.4%) showed no response (no 100% clearing of nails among all treated toenails per patient including mild improvement or temporary cosmetic improvement). Multivariable logistic regression analysis revealed longer disease duration (P=0.006, OR=1.16(95% CI: 1.05-1.31)), patients with diabetes (P=0.021, OR=9.82(95% CI:1.75-94.01)) and fewer number of laser treatment sessions (P=0.001, OR=0.76(95% CI:0.64-0.89)) were significantly associated with non-response group.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, fractional CO2 laser with topical antifungal could be a safe alternative treatment in patients with onychomycosis, who are difficult to take oral antifungals. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Carbon Dioxide Laser Plus Topical 5% Luliconazole: A Better Combination Therapeutic Modality for Onychomycosis

Background

Onychomycosis has always been a therapeutic challenge because of longer treatment duration, potential adverse effects of oral antifungals, and limited efficacy of topical agents. During the past few years, the emergence of laser therapy has been the topic of discussion as a newer, safe, minimally invasive modality of treatment.

Aim

The aim of this study was to evaluate the role of fractional CO₂ laser and topical luliconazole 5% lotion in the treatment of onychomycosis, as a combined treatment and as independent modalities.

Materials and Methods

This was a prospective, randomized, triple-limb comparative observational study in which 106 patients with KOH and culture-proven onychomycosis were randomly assigned to three groups. Group A received fractional CO₂ laser (10,600nm) triweekly for four sessions (0, 3, 9, and 12 weeks) plus topical luliconazole 5.0% lotion applied twice daily on the affected nail plates and nail folds for 12 weeks. Group B received only fractional CO₂ with the same frequency of sessions and laser parameters as in group A. Group C received only topical luliconazole 5.0% solution twice daily for 12 weeks. Treatment outcome was evaluated using onychomycosis severity index (OSI) score, mycological parameters, and level of satisfaction of patients.

Results

The degree of clinical improvement, mycological cure, and patient's satisfaction was significantly better in the combined group than individual modalities. There were no severe adverse effects that warranted the discontinuation of the treatment in any of these patients.

Conclusion

Fractional CO₂ laser combined with topical luliconazole 5% lotion is a safe and effective treatment for onychomycosis especially in those who have contraindications to oral antifungals.

Race reporting and representation in onychomycosis clinical trials: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Onychomycosis is the most common nail disease seen in clinical practice. Inclusion of diverse groups in onychomycosis clinical trials subjects is necessary to generalise efficacy data.

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to systematically review race and ethnicity reporting and representation, as well as, treatment outcomes in onychomycosis clinical trials.

METHODS

A PubMed search for onychomycosis clinical trials was performed in August 2020. Primary clinical trial data were included and post hoc analyses were excluded. Categorical variables were compared using chi-squared and Fisher's exact tests. Statistical significance was set at p < .05. Photos in articles were categorised by Fitzpatrick skin type.

RESULTS

Only 32/182 (17.5%) trials reported on race and/or ethnicity and only one trial compared treatment efficacy in different subgroups. Darker skin colours were infrequently depicted in articles. Topical treatment, location with ≥1 US-based site, industry funding type and publication date after 2000 were significantly associated with reporting of racial/ethnic data (p < .05 for all comparisons).

LIMITATIONS

Demographics on excluded subjects and methods of recruitment were not available. Assigning Fitzpatrick skin type is inherently subjective.

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights a need for consistent reporting of races and ethnicities of onychomycosis clinical trial participants with subgroup analyses of treatment efficacies.

Fractionated carbon dioxide (CO2) laser treatment contributes to trans-nail penetration of rhodamine B and changes of cytokine microenvironment

This study is to determine the role of the fractional CO2 laser in topical drug delivery and the impact of local immune responses. Experimental rabbit nails were treated with fractionated CO2 laser at varied fluencies of 20 mJ, 25 mJ, and 30 mJ and half of which were coated with rhodamine B (RhB). Histological examination was performed by hematoxylin and eosin staining; the penetration of RhB was assessed by the use of confocal laser scanning microscopy; and the expressions of IFN-γ and IL-4 mRNA in situ were detected by means of qPCR at 12 h, 24 h, 3 days, and 7 days post-laser irritation. The fractional CO2 laser could generate microscopic treatment zones in nail plates, and the depths of these micropores as well as the permeation of RhB in nails increased significantly in an energy-dependent manner. Importantly, the laser irritation led an upregulation of local IFN-γ mRNA expression accompanied by a downregulation of IL-4 mRNA expression. The ultrapulsed ablative fractionated CO2 laser may assist topical drug delivery, and may drive stronger local Th1 responses due to an imbalance of IFN-γ/IL-4 expressions, suggesting that the combination of ablative fractionated CO2 laser with topical agents would be an effective option for the treatment of onychomycosis.

Morphometric Optical Imaging of Microporated Nail Tissue: An Investigation of Intermethod Agreement, Reliability, and Technical Limitations

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

While optical imaging is a useful technique to quantitate morphological differences and treatment effects, comparative investigations of the various techniques are lacking. This study aimed at evaluating intermethod agreement, reliability, and technical limitations of wide-field microscopy (WFM), reflectance confocal microscopy (RCM), and optical coherence tomography (OCT) for morphometry by assessing fractionally ablated nail tissue.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty healthy nail clippings were processed with a fractionated CO₂ -laser (20 mJ/microbeam, density 15%), measured with calipers, and imaged using WFM, OCT, and RCM. Images were assessed for nail plate thickness, micropore dimensions, degree of poration, and artifacts. Repeated measurements (2-5) were taken to evaluate method repeatability using Cronbach's α and coefficients of variation (CoV), and estimate the intermethod correlation through linear correlation assessment (Pearson correlation coefficient [PCC]), ranked correlation (Kendall's tau; tau-c), and intraclass correlation (Shrout-Fleiss reliability coefficient; ICC).

RESULTS

The repeatability varied substantially between methods and target measurements. The level of intermethod agreement for thickness measurements performed with calipers, WFM, and OCT was high (tau-c ≥ 0.7; ICC ≥ 0.8; PCC ≥ 0.9). RCM could only image 28 out of 50 samples due to its limited penetration depth. OCT demonstrated the highest repeatability of all imaging techniques (CoV 4-7%) and nail thickness showed the highest measurement reliability (α = 0.92). Micropore dimensions correlated strongest between OCT and RCM (tau-c/ICC/PCC ≥ 0.5). All modalities were prone to artifacts, which may have adversely affected measurement variation and intermethod agreement.

CONCLUSION

Intermethod agreement and reliability appear to be highly dependent on the specific modality and target measurement. To reap the benefits of each technique while mitigating their limitations, an integrated approach to optical imaging is recommended. Lasers Surg. Med. © 2020 Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Fractional CO2-assisted photodynamic therapy improves the clinical outcome and patient's satisfaction in toenail onychomycosis treatment: an intra-patient comparative single-center study

Background: Device-based therapies have been used for onychomycosis patients with intolerance to systemic treatments. Photodynamic therapy (PDT) improves onychomycosis, while fractional carbon dioxide (FrCO₂) augments the topical drug delivery. Comparative studies between PDT alone and laser-assisted one are lacking.Objective: We aimed to evaluate the efficacy of PDT alone versus FrCO₂-assisted PDT for treatment of onychomycosis.Methods: Twenty-one patients with bilateral onychomycosis of toenails with nearly the same degree of affection were enrolled in this prospective intra-patient-controlled study. The right affected toenail was treated via PDT alone. The left toenail was treated via a FrCO₂ followed immediately by PDT. The sessions were bimonthly for a total of six sessions. Direct microscopy, fungal cultures, clinical evaluation, onychomycosis severity index scoring, and patient's satisfaction were assessed before and 12 weeks after the last session.Results: Both treatments reduced significantly the onychomycosis severity index (p < .05) without significant difference between them. The improvement in nail appearance and patient's satisfaction were higher in laser-assisted PDT than PDT alone (p < .05).Conclusion: Both treatments effectively reduced the severity of onychomycosis with a high degree of safety and tolerability. Fractional CO₂-assisted PDT enhanced the clinical outcome via improving the nail appearance and patient's satisfaction.Key messagePhotodynamic therapy has a good success rate in clearing onychomycosis. Addition of fractional CO₂ to photodynamic therapy improves the nail appearance and induces better satisfaction to treatment.

Fractional CO2 laser plus topical antifungal versus fractional CO2 laser versus topical antifungal in the treatment of onychomycosis

Onychomycosis is an important medical disorder affecting both health and quality of life of patients. This study was done to compare the efficacy of CO₂ laser in combination with topical tioconazole versus CO₂ laser only versus topical tioconazole alone in onychomycosis. A total of 120 patients with onychomycosis were randomly assigned to three groups. Group A patients were treated with fractional CO₂ laser followed by topical tioconazole 28% for five sessions with 3 weeks interval. Group B patients were treated with only fractional CO₂ laser for five sessions with 3 weeks interval. Group C patients were treated with only topical tioconazole 28% for 16 weeks. The clinical effect, KOH examination, and culture for the affected nails in the three groups were analyzed. One month after the last session, regarding clinical response, 55% showed complete clinical improvement in Group A versus 30% in Group B versus 25% in Group C with a significant difference in between. There was a significant difference between the three studied groups as regard KOH test and culture after treatment. Fractional CO₂ laser combined with topical antifungal is a safe and effective treatment for onychomycosis.