Multi-target QSTR modeling for simultaneous prediction of multiple toxicity endpoints of nano-metal oxides

Toward Nano-Specific In Silico NAMs: How to Adjust Nano-QSAR to the Recent Advancements of Nanotoxicology?

The rapid development of engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) causes humans to become increasingly exposed to them. Therefore, a better understanding of the health impact of ENMs is highly demanded. Considering the 3Rs (Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement) principle, in vitro and computational methods are excellent alternatives for testing on animals. Among computational methods, nano-quantitative structure-activity relationship (nano-QSAR), which links the physicochemical and structural properties of EMNs with biological activities, is one of the leading method. The nature of toxicological experiments has evolved over the last decades; currently, one experiment can provide thousands of measurements of the organism's functioning at the molecular level. At the same time, the capacity of the in vitro systems to mimic the human organism is also improving significantly. Hence, the authors would like to discuss whether the nano-QSAR approach follows modern toxicological studies and takes full advantage of the opportunities offered by modern toxicological platforms. Challenges and possibilities for improving data integration are underlined narratively, including the need for a consensus built between the in vitro and the QSAR domains.

Quantitative multi-species toxicity modeling: Does a multi-species, machine learning model provide better performance than a single-species model for the evaluation of acute aquatic toxicity by organic pollutants?

The toxicological profile of any chemical is defined by multiple endpoints and testing procedures, including representative test species from different trophic levels. While computer-aided methods play an increasingly important role in supporting ecotoxicology research and chemical hazard assessment, most of the recently developed machine learning models are directed towards a single, specific endpoint. To overcome this limitation and accelerate the process of identifying potentially hazardous environmental pollutants, we are introducing an effective approach for quantitative, multi-species modeling. The proposed approach is based on canonical correlation analysis that finds a pair(s) of uncorrelated, linear combinations of the original variables that best defines the overall variability within and between multiple biological responses and predictor variables. Its effectiveness was confirmed by the machine learning model for estimating acute toxicity of diverse organic pollutants in aquatic species from three trophic levels: algae (Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata), daphnia (Daphnia magna), and fish (Oryzias latipes). The multi-species model achieved a favorable predictive performance that were in line with predictive models derived for the aquatic organisms individually. The chemical bioavailability and reactivity parameters (n-octanol/water partition coefficient, chemical potential, and molecular size and volume) were important to accurately predict acute ecotoxicity to the three aquatic organisms. To facilitate the use of this approach, an open-source, Python-based script, named qMTM (quantitative Multi-species Toxicity Modeling) has been provided.

Nano-QSAR modeling for predicting the cytotoxicity of metallic and metal oxide nanoparticles: A review

Given the rapid development of nanotechnology, it is crucial to understand the effects of nanoparticles on living organisms. However, it is laborious to perform toxicological tests on a case-by-case basis. Quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) is an effective computational technique because it saves time, costs, and animal sacrifice. Therefore, this review presents general procedures for the construction and application of nano-QSAR models of metal-based and metal-oxide nanoparticles (MBNPs and MONPs). We also provide an overview of available databases and common algorithms. The molecular descriptors and their roles in the toxicological interpretation of MBNPs and MONPs are systematically reviewed and the future of nano-QSAR is discussed. Finally, we address the growing demand for novel nano-specific descriptors, new computational strategies to address the data shortage, in situ data for regulatory concerns, a better understanding of the physicochemical properties of NPs with bioactivity, and, most importantly, the design of nano-QSAR for real-life environmental predictions rather than laboratory simulations.

New Mechanistic Insights on Carbon Nanotubes' Nanotoxicity Using Isolated Submitochondrial Particles, Molecular Docking, and Nano-QSTR Approaches

Single-walled carbon nanotubes can induce mitochondrial F0F1-ATPase nanotoxicity through inhibition. To completely characterize the mechanistic effect triggering the toxicity, we have developed a new approach based on the combination of experimental and computational study, since the use of only one or few techniques may not fully describe the phenomena. To this end, the in vitro inhibition responses in submitochondrial particles (SMP) was combined with docking, elastic network models, fractal surface analysis, and Nano-QSTR models. In vitro studies suggest that inhibition responses in SMP of F0F1-ATPase enzyme were strongly dependent on the concentration assay (from 3 to 5 µg/mL) for both pristine and COOH single-walled carbon nanotubes types (SWCNT). Besides, both SWCNTs show an interaction inhibition pattern mimicking the oligomycin A (the specific mitochondria F0F1-ATPase inhibitor blocking the c-ring F0 subunit). Performed docking studies denote the best crystallography binding pose obtained for the docking complexes based on the free energy of binding (FEB) fit well with the in vitro evidence from the thermodynamics point of view, following an affinity order such as: FEB (oligomycin A/F0-ATPase complex) = -9.8 kcal/mol > FEB (SWCNT-COOH/F0-ATPase complex) = -6.8 kcal/mol ~ FEB (SWCNT-pristine complex) = -5.9 kcal/mol, with predominance of van der Waals hydrophobic nano-interactions with key F0-ATPase binding site residues (Phe 55 and Phe 64). Elastic network models and fractal surface analysis were performed to study conformational perturbations induced by SWCNT. Our results suggest that interaction may be triggering abnormal allosteric responses and signals propagation in the inter-residue network, which could affect the substrate recognition ligand geometrical specificity of the F0F1-ATPase enzyme in order (SWCNT-pristine > SWCNT-COOH). In addition, Nano-QSTR models have been developed to predict toxicity induced by both SWCNTs, using results of in vitro and docking studies. Results show that this method may be used for the fast prediction of the nanotoxicity induced by SWCNT, avoiding time- and money-consuming techniques. Overall, the obtained results may open new avenues toward to the better understanding and prediction of new nanotoxicity mechanisms, rational drug design-based nanotechnology, and potential biomedical application in precision nanomedicine.

Evaluating the cytotoxicity of a large pool of metal oxide nanoparticles to Escherichia coli: Mechanistic understanding through In Vitro and In Silico studies

The toxic effect of eight metal oxide nanoparticles (MONPs) on Escherichia coli was experimentally evaluated following standard bioassay protocols. The obtained cytotoxicity ranking of these studied MONPs is Er₂O₃, Gd₂O₃, CeO₂, Co₂O₃, Mn₂O₃, Co₃O₄, Fe₃O₄/WO₃ (in descending order). The computed EC₅₀ values from experimental data suggested that Er₂O₃ and Gd₂O₃ were the most acutely toxic MONPs to E. coli. To identify the mechanism of toxicity of these 8 MONPs along with 17 other MONPs from our previous study, we employed seven classifications and machine learning (ML) algorithms including linear discriminant analysis (LDA), naïve bayes (NB), multinomial logistic regression (MLogitR), sequential minimal optimization (SMO), AdaBoost, J48, and random forest (RF). We also employed 1^st and 2^nd generation periodic table descriptors developed by us (without any sophisticated computing facilities) along with experimentally analyzed Zeta-potential, to model the cytotoxicity of these MONPs. Based on qualitative validation metrics, the LDA model appeared to be the best among the 7 tested models. The core environment of metal defined by the ratio of the number of core electrons to the number of valence electrons and the electronegativity count of oxygen showed a positive impact on toxicity. The identified properties were important for understanding the mechanisms of nanotoxicity and for predicting the potential environmental risk associated with MONPs exposure. The developed models can be utilized for environmental risk assessment of any untested MONP to E. coli, thereby providing a scientific basis for the design and preparation of safe nanomaterials.

Is intraspecies QSTR model answer to toxicity data gap filling: Ecotoxicity modeling of chemicals to avian species

Interspecies model represents an established approach for the response data gap filling for regulatory agencies and researchers. We propose a novel approach of intraspecies modeling within the animals of the same species, instead of animals from different species. The proposed intraspecies model is capable of more precise extrapolation of data than the interspecies model, as animals under the same species share a similar mechanism of action (MOA) and target sites for the response. Along with the advantage of better prediction over the interspecies model, the intraspecies model has all the significant features like recognition of MOA, species-specific toxicity, reduction of animal experimentation, and money and time. To establish and test the intraspecies modeling approach, we have modeled ecotoxicity of organic chemicals to three avian species: Anas platyrhynchos, Colinus virginianus, and Phasianus colchicus. The intraspecies models offer to identify the mechanistic interpretation of the ecotoxicity of the studied chemicals along with the toxicity data gap filling. The success of the intraspecies modeling relies on connecting the missing dots of toxicity for the regulatory purposes, especially when there is a scarcity of ecotoxicity experimental data and in silico models for avian species.

Nanotoxicology data for in silico tools: a literature review

The exercise of non-testing approaches in nanoparticles (NPs) hazard assessment is necessary for the risk assessment, considering cost and time efficiency, to identify, assess, and classify potential risks. One strategy for investigating the toxicological properties of a variety of NPs is by means of computational tools that decode how nano-specific features relate to toxicity and enable its prediction. This literature review records systematically the data used in published studies that predict nano (eco)-toxicological endpoints using machine learning models. Instead of seeking mechanistic interpretations this review maps the pathways followed, involving biological features in relation to NPs exposure, their physico-chemical characteristics and the most commonly predicted outcomes. The results, derived from published research of the last decade, are summarized visually, providing prior-based data mining paradigms to be readily used by the nanotoxicology community in computational studies.

Practices and Trends of Machine Learning Application in Nanotoxicology

Machine Learning (ML) techniques have been applied in the field of nanotoxicology with very encouraging results. Adverse effects of nanoforms are affected by multiple features described by theoretical descriptors, nano-specific measured properties, and experimental conditions. ML has been proven very helpful in this field in order to gain an insight into features effecting toxicity, predicting possible adverse effects as part of proactive risk analysis, and informing safe design. At this juncture, it is important to document and categorize the work that has been carried out. This study investigates and bookmarks ML methodologies used to predict nano (eco)-toxicological outcomes in nanotoxicology during the last decade. It provides a review of the sequenced steps involved in implementing an ML model, from data pre-processing, to model implementation, model validation, and applicability domain. The review gathers and presents the step-wise information on techniques and procedures of existing models that can be used readily to assemble new nanotoxicological in silico studies and accelerates the regulation of in silico tools in nanotoxicology. ML applications in nanotoxicology comprise an active and diverse collection of ongoing efforts, although it is still in their early steps toward a scientific accord, subsequent guidelines, and regulation adoption. This study is an important bookend to a decade of ML applications to nanotoxicology and serves as a useful guide to further in silico applications.

Nano-(Q)SAR for Cytotoxicity Prediction of Engineered Nanomaterials

Although nanotechnology is a new and rapidly growing area of science, the impact of nanomaterials on living organisms is unknown in many aspects. In this regard, it is extremely important to perform toxicological tests, but complete characterization of all varying preparations is extremely laborious. The computational technique called quantitative structure–activity relationship, or QSAR, allows reducing the cost of time- and resource-consuming nanotoxicity tests. In this review, (Q)SAR cytotoxicity studies of the past decade are systematically considered. We regard here five classes of engineered nanomaterials (ENMs): Metal oxides, metal-containing nanoparticles, multi-walled carbon nanotubes, fullerenes, and silica nanoparticles. Some studies reveal that QSAR models are better than classification SAR models, while other reports conclude that SAR is more precise than QSAR. The quasi-QSAR method appears to be the most promising tool, as it allows accurately taking experimental conditions into account. However, experimental artifacts are a major concern in this case.

Importance of Choosing Relevant Biological End Points To Predict Nanoparticle Toxicity with Computational Approaches for Human Health Risk Assessment

Because it is impossible to assess in vitro or in vivo the toxicity of all nanoparticles available on the market on a case-by-case basis, computational approaches have been proposed as useful alternatives to predict in silico the hazard potential of engineered nanoparticles. Despite promising results, a major issue associated with these mathematical models lies in the a priori choice of the physicochemical descriptors and the biological end points. We performed a thorough bibliographic survey on the biological end points used for nanotoxicology purposes and compared them between experimental and computational approaches. They were found to be disparate: while conventional in vitro nanotoxicology assays usually investigate a large array of biological effects using eukaryotic cells (cytotoxicity, pro-inflammatory response, oxidative stress, genotoxicity), computational studies mostly focus on cell viability and also include studies on prokaryotic cells. We may thus wonder the relevance of building complex mathematical models able to predict accurately a biological end point if this latter is not the most relevant to support human health risk assessment. The choice of biological end points clearly deserves to be more carefully discussed. This could bridge the gap between experimental and computational nanotoxicology studies and allow in silico predictive models to reach their full potential.

Machine learning prediction of nanoparticle in vitro toxicity: A comparative study of classifiers and ensemble-classifiers using the Copeland Index

Nano-Particles (NPs) are well established as important components across a broad range of products from cosmetics to electronics. Their utilization is increasing with their significant economic and societal potential yet to be fully realized. Inroads have been made in our understanding of the risks posed to human health and the environment by NPs but this area will require continuous research and monitoring. In recent years Machine Learning (ML) techniques have exploited large datasets and computation power to create breakthroughs in diverse fields from facial recognition to genomics. More recently, ML techniques have been applied to nanotoxicology with very encouraging results. In this study, categories of ML classifiers (rules, trees, lazy, functions and bayes) were compared using datasets from the Safe and Sustainable Nanotechnology (S2NANO) database to investigate their performance in predicting NPs in vitro toxicity. Physicochemical properties, toxicological and quantum-mechanical attributes and in vitro experimental conditions were used as input variables to predict the toxicity of NPs based on cell viability. Voting, an ensemble meta-classifier, was used to combine base models to optimize the classification prediction of toxicity. To facilitate inter-comparison, a Copeland Index was applied that ranks the classifiers according to their performance and suggested the optimal classifier. Neural Network (NN) and Random forest (RF) showed the best performance in the majority of the datasets used in this study. However, the combination of classifiers demonstrated an improved prediction resulting meta-classifier to have higher indices. This proposed Copeland Index can now be used by researchers to identify and clearly prioritize classifiers in order to achieve more accurate classification predictions for NP toxicity for a given dataset.

Algal toxicity of binary mixtures of zinc oxide nanoparticles and tetrabromobisphenol A: Roles of dissolved organic matters

The present study investigated the impacts of dissolved organic matters (DOM) on joint toxicity involved in zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs) and tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) at relevant low-exposure concentrations (<1 mg/L). It was found that ZnO NPs in single and combined systems exhibited severe inhibition effects on a freshwater microalgae Scenedesmus obliquus. However, the presence of DOM slightly alleviated the growth inhibition toxicity induced by the binary mixtures of ZnO NPs and TBBPA. Ultrastructure analysis revealed that ZnO NPs caused structural damage to cells, including plasmolysis, membrane destruction, and the disruption of thylakoid in the chloroplast, regardless of the presence of coexisting substances. Oxidative stress biomarker quantitative analysis and in situ observations indicated that the massive accumulation of reactive oxygen species in the binary mixtures of ZnO NPs and TBBPA caused severe oxidative damage, but the presence of DOM significantly mitigated the damage.

Modelling the water-plant cuticular polymer matrix membrane partitioning of diverse chemicals in multiple plant species using the support vector machine-based QSAR approach

In this study, a support vector machine (SVM) based multi-species QSAR (quantitative structure-activity relationship) model was developed for predicting the water-plant cuticular polymer matrix membrane (MX) partition coefficient, K_MXw of diverse chemicals using two simple molecular descriptors derived from the chemical structures and following the OECD guidelines. Accordingly, the Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. data were used to construct the QSAR model that was externally validated using three other plant species data. The diversity in chemical structures and end-points were verified using the Tanimoto similarity index and Kruskal-Wallis statistics. The predictive power of the developed QSAR model was tested through rigorous validation, deriving a wide series of statistical checks. The MLOGP was the most influential descriptor identified by the model. The model yielded a correlation (r²) of 0.966 and 0.965 in the training and test data arrays. The developed QSAR model also performed well in another three plant species (r² > 0.955). The results suggest the appropriateness of the developed model to reliably predict the plant chemical interactions in multiple plant species and it can be a useful tool in screening the new chemical for environmental risk assessment.

Modeling the pH and temperature dependence of aqueousphase hydroxyl radical reaction rate constants of organic micropollutants using QSPR approach

Designing of advanced oxidation process (AOP) requires knowledge of the aqueous phase hydroxyl radical (^●OH) reactions rate constants (k _OH), which are strictly dependent upon the pH and temperature of the medium. In this study, pH- and temperature-dependent quantitative structure-property relationship (QSPR) models based on the decision tree boost (DTB) approach were developed for the prediction of k _OH of diverse organic contaminants following the OECD guidelines. Experimental datasets (n = 958) pertaining to the k _OH values of aqueous phase reactions at different pH (n = 470; 1.4 × 10⁶ to 3.8 × 10¹⁰ M^-1 s^-1) and temperature (n = 171; 1.0 × 10⁷ to 2.6 × 10¹⁰ M^-1 s^-1) were considered and molecular descriptors of the compounds were derived. The Sanderson scale electronegativity, topological polar surface area, number of double bonds, and halogen atoms in the molecule, in addition to the pH and temperature, were found to be the relevant predictors. The models were validated and their external predictivity was evaluated in terms of most stringent criteria parameters derived on the test data. High values of the coefficient of determination (R ²) and small root mean squared error (RMSE) in respective training (> 0.972, ≤ 0.12) and test (≥ 0.936, ≤ 0.16) sets indicated high generalization and predictivity of the developed QSPR model. Other statistical parameters derived from the training and test data also supported the robustness of the models and their suitability for screening new chemicals within the defined chemical space. The developed QSPR models provide a valuable tool for predicting the ^●OH reaction rate constants of emerging new water contaminants for their susceptibility to AOPs.