The impact of living with transfeminine vocal gender dysphoria: Health utility outcomes assessment

Social Perception of External Laryngeal Anatomy Related to Gender Expression in a Web-based Survey

OBJECTIVE(S)

To quantify the effect of laryngeal prominence size on socially perceived attributes relating to gender expression. Chondrolaryngoplasty ("tracheal shave") is a common procedure performed for transgender women to feminize neck appearance. The extent of thyroid cartilage resection needed to convey socially-perceived feminine gender expression without destabilizing the voice is incompletely understood.

METHODS

Cross-sectional evaluation of a randomized allocation of images of varying laryngeal prominence to a non-repeated, random sample from November 2021 to December 2021. Photos of laryngeal prominence were isolated against a constant neck baseline with lateral, oblique, and frontal views. The images were embedded into a web-based survey with visual analog scales to capture perceived scaled gender expression (masculinity, femininity) and social traits (e.g., attractiveness, friendliness, leadership). We performed bivariate and multivariate analyses relating the laryngeal prominence to perceived gender expression and social traits.

RESULTS

The analytic sample included 1,026 respondents. Laryngeal grades similar to the demonstrated "grade M" in this study and smaller demonstrated similar perceptions of increased femininity and decreased masculinity. Grades larger than M demonstrate significantly increased perceived masculinity and significantly decreased perceived femininity. The lateral and oblique views of the neck appear to be the most gender-informative.

CONCLUSION

This crowd-sourced analysis of external laryngeal anatomy by a large population of observers provides clear, reproducible insights into social perceptions of gender identity and specifically femininity. These data will meaningfully inform patient counseling and surgical planning for gender-affirming interventions by establishing normative data representing the general public's perceptions.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 133:2292-2300, 2023.

Modern Responses to Traditional Pitfalls in Gender Affirming Behavioral Voice Modification

Gender-affirming behavioral voice modification has primarily been directed by cisgender clinicians who do not actively live or master the process of voice modification themselves but instead observe it from the outside looking in. The lack of a "lived experience" by cisgender instructors naturally leaves gaps and oversights that may reduce the effective potential of voice training. Input from transgender people who have learned voice modifications techniques is key to providing the best possible care. Ear training, direct vocal modeling, and mastery of gender-modification techniques are crucial elements that are less emphasized in the current system.