Relationship between exhaled carbon monoxide and airway hyperresponsiveness in asthmatic patients

Does airway hyperresponsiveness monitoring lead to improved asthma control?

The current guidelines recommend an approach to asthma management based on asthma control, rather than asthma severity. Although several specific questionnaires have been developed and control criteria have been established based on clinical guidelines, the evaluation of asthma control is still not optimal. In general, these indicators provide adequate assessment of current control, but they are more limited when estimating future risk. There is much evidence demonstrating the persistence of airway inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) in patients with total control. Therefore, the objective of this review was to analyse the possible role of AHR monitoring as an instrument for assessing asthma control. We will evaluate its capacity as an indicator for future risk, both for estimating the possibility of clinical deterioration and loss of lung function or exacerbations. Furthermore, its relationship with inhaled corticosteroid treatment will be analysed, while emphasizing its capacity for predicting response and adjusting dosage, as well as information about the capability of AHR for monitoring treatment. Last of all, we will discuss the main limitations and emerging opportunities of AHR as an assessment instrument for asthma control.

Suppression of heme oxygenase-1 activity reduces airway hyperresponsiveness and inflammation in a mouse model of asthma

OBJECTIVE

Carbon monoxide (CO) levels in expired gas are higher in patients with bronchial asthma than in healthy individuals. Heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) is a rate-limiting enzyme that catalyzes the degradation of heme to yield biliverdin, CO and free iron. Thus, HO-1 is implicated in the pathogenesis of bronchial asthma. However, whether HO-1 expression and activity in lung tissue are related to allergic airway inflammation remains unclear. We investigated whether expression of HO-1 is related to allergic airway inflammation in lungs and whether HO-1 could influence airway hyperresponsiveness and eosinophilia in mice sensitized to ovalbumin (OVA).

METHODS

C57BL/6 mice immunized with OVA were challenged thrice with an aerosol of OVA every second day for 8 days. HO-1-positive cells were identified by immunostaining in lung tissue, and zinc protoporphyrin (Zn-PP), a competitive inhibitor of HO-1, was administered intraperitoneally to OVA-immunized C57BL/6 mice on day 23 (day before inhalation of OVA) and immediately before inhalation on the subsequent 4 days (total five doses). Mice were analyzed for effects of HO-1 on AHR, inflammatory cell infiltration and cytokine levels in lung tissue. Ethical approval was obtained from the concerned institutional review board.

RESULTS

Number of HO-1-positive cells increased in the subepithelium of the bronchi after OVA challenge, and HO-1 localized to alveolar macrophages. Zn-PP clearly inhibited AHR, pulmonary eosinophilia and IL-5 and IL-13 expression in the lung tissue.

CONCLUSION

Expression of HO-1 is induced in lung tissue during attacks of allergic bronchial asthma, and its activity likely amplifies and prolongs allergic airway inflammation.

Exhaled carbon monoxide in airway diseases: from research findings to clinical relevance

Breath tests have gained increasing interest in recent years mainly driven by the unmet clinical need to monitor airway diseases and to obtain information of unravelled aspects of respiratory disorders. Carbon monoxide is present in the exhaled breath and has been suggested to reflect ongoing oxidative stress, even if there are some confounding factors limiting its clinical usefulness. Increased concentration of exhaled carbon monoxide has been demonstrated in different acute and chronic airway diseases including allergic rhinitis, asthma, bronchiectasis, and post transplant bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome. Although exhaled carbon monoxide might not prove as a clinically useful biomarker of airway diseases, its measurement has helped to understand the place of heme oxygenase activity in allergic and non-allergic airway diseases. The scope of this review is the exciting field of exhaled carbon monoxide in airway diseases.

Exhaled carbon monoxide in asthmatic adults with bronchial reactivity: a prospective study

HYPOTHESIS

We hypothesized that eCO may permit non-invasive assessment of disease activity in adults with asthma and bronchial reactivity.

METHODS

A total of 209 participants 18 to 65 years of age with a diagnosis of asthma and bronchial reactivity provided data for analysis. The association between eCO and bronchial reactivity, forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV(1)), forced vital capacity (FVC), peak expiratory flow rate measurements (PEFR), asthma symptoms score, and bronchodilator use cross-sectionally and within-subject change in eCO were analyzed in relation to change in these variables over 6 weeks.

RESULTS

There was no difference in eCO in those who were taking inhaled corticosteroids and those who were not (p = 0.33). There was also no cross-sectional or within-in subject association between eCO and bronchial reactivity, FEV(1), FVC, PEFR, symptoms score, or bronchodilator use.

CONCLUSIONS

In a population of adults with bronchial reactivity, eCO has no or very limited potential as a biomarker of asthma activity.

Serum concentration of C-reactive protein is not a good marker of bronchial hyperresponsiveness

Introduction:

Asthmatic inflammation is responsible for vital features of the disease, including bronchial hyperresponsiveness (BHR). At present we do not have precise markers for monitoring asthmatic inflammation. C-reactive protein (CRP), a marker of systemic inflammation, seemed to be a factor which could also reflect the level of asthmatic inflammation expressed by BHR. Therefore the relationship between CRP concentration and BHR was evaluated.

Materials and Methods:

One hundred and two patients entered the study. A skin prick test with a broad spectrum of common aeroallergens as well as baseline spirometry and a histamine bronchoprovocation test were performed in each subject. Blood samples for high-sensitivity CRP (hsCRP) measurement were taken before the bronchial challenge tests.

Results:

Serum hsCRP concentrations ranged from 0.20 to 14.5 mg/l (median: 1.2 mg/l, 25–75% quartiles: 0.6–2.4). Positive skin prick tests were found in 26 subjects. Bronchial hyperresponsiveness was confirmed in 42 patients (first subgroup), while 60 subjects did not demonstrate BHR (second subgroup). Among the patients with BHR, asthma was diagnosed in 33 cases and Corrao syndrome in 9. In both subgroups, serum hsCRP concentrations had similar levels (median: 1.4 mg/l, 25–75% quartiles: 0.8–2.4 and median: 0.9 mg/l, 25–75% quartiles: 0.5–2.8, respectively; p=0.297). There was no statistically significant correlation (r= −0.163, p=0.302) between serum hsCRP concentration and the level of BHR expressed as the 20% provocative concentration for histamine. In addition, hsCRP serum concentration, after adjustment for age, atopy, body mass index, and gender, was not a significant predictor of positive histamine bronchoprovocation test results (p=0.22, OR=0.86, 95% CI).

Conclusions:

Serum hsCRP concentration is not a good marker of BHR, which is mainly dependent on asthmatic inflammation and is measured during bronchial challenge with histamine. This finding is important for interpreting and discussing results obtained from epidemiological and population-based studies on relationships between either CRP concentration and BHR or local and systemic inflammation.

Bias and confounding in longitudinal measures of exhaled monoxides

The measurement of exhaled nitric oxide and carbon monoxide concentrations is an emerging method of monitoring airway inflammation longitudinally in community-based studies. Inhaled concentrations of these monoxides influence exhaled concentrations. Little is known about the degree to which inhaled concentrations distort temporal trends in, or estimated effects of air pollutants on, exhaled monoxides. We sought to evaluate whether estimated effects of air pollutants on exhaled monoxides are distorted by trends in indoor and outdoor monoxides, and to characterize determinants of exhaled monoxide concentrations among residents of public housing. In a panel study, 42 residents of public housing provided over 1000 exhaled breath samples. Samples from all subjects were analyzed for nitric oxide; samples from 27 of these subjects were also analyzed for carbon monoxide. The effects of indoor and outdoor monoxide concentrations on exhaled concentrations were quantified. Confounding of associations between particulate matter concentrations and exhaled nitric oxide concentrations was explored. Determinants of exhaled monoxide concentrations among public housing residents are similar to those of other populations. Exhaled monoxide concentrations are more strongly associated with indoor than with outdoor monoxide concentrations. Approximately half of the variability in exhaled monoxide concentrations over time can be explained by changes in indoor monoxide concentrations. Indoor monoxide concentrations can markedly distort both temporal trends in exhaled concentrations as well as estimated effects of particulate matter on exhaled monoxides. Prior estimated effects of particulate matter on exhaled nitric oxide concentrations may have been confounded by nitric concentrations indoors at the time of exhaled air collection. To prevent distortions of longitudinal trends in airway inflammation and estimated health effects of air pollutants, inspiratory scrubber use is necessary but not sufficient to remove the confounding effect of indoor monoxides, and analyses should adjust exhaled monoxide concentrations for concentrations indoors.

[Role of oxidative stress in respiratory diseases and its monitoring]

Together with inflammation and subsequent remodeling of airways, an imbalance between oxidative and anti-oxidative agents is generated during the development of numerous pulmonary diseases. This process seems to be involved in both the pathogenesis and chronification of asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), SOAS, interstitial lung diseases and cystic fibrosis. Reactive oxygen species including superoxide anion, hidroxyl radicals and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) are synthetised as a response of inflammatory cells and are responsible of the oxidation of nucleic acids, proteins and membrane lipids, leading to cell damage and enhanced inflammation. Until recently, it was difficult to quantify the airway production of reactive oxidative species (ROS). In fact, it has been only in the last few years when it has been possible to determine indirectly the levels of ROS in expired air and in tissue of asthmatic patients. The analysis of exhaled air is a single, reproducible and non-invasive technique which is useful in the study of volatile and non-volatile gases generated in different conditions. The determination of exhaled nitric oxide and carbon monoxide (CO) has a great usefulness in the assessment of asthma. Nitric oxide seems to be closely related to the physiopathology of asthma and COPD. In fact, it is correlated with the levels of sputum eosinophils and with the response to the treatment with steroids. Yet a correlation with the degree of airflow obstruction and the seriousness of the process has not been found. Exhaled CO is another indirect marker of inflammation and it is increased in asthma, COPD, cystic fibrosis and bronchectases. Even though numerous studies have shown its usefulness as a marker of inflammation and in the response to corticosteroids, its clinical application has limitations. In particular, it is not a specific and exclusive marker of oxidative stress and its levels are highly influenced by tobacco smoke. On the other hand, the association between exhaled CO and FEV1 is not clear and no relationship has been proved so far with the improvement of pulmonary function after steroid therapy and with the decrease of maximum expiratory flow at relapses. In this Review, we describe the advances in the knowledge of oxidative stress as a decisive factor in the pathogenesis of prevalent pulmonary diseases, as well as the methods allowing its analysis and monitoring.

Exhaled carbon monoxide levels in atopic asthma: a longitudinal study

Exhaled carbon monoxide (eCO) is a potential non-invasive marker of airway inflammation. We have investigated the cross-sectional and longitudinal relationship between eCO and lung function and bronchial reactivity in 69 adults with atopic asthma, in the course of participation in a 6-week randomised placebo-controlled trial of vitamin E supplementation. At baseline, there was no cross-sectional association between absolute eCO levels and either forced expiratory volume (FEV(1)), forced vital capacity (FVC) or bronchial reactivity. However, in the longitudinal analysis within the placebo group, a rise in mean eCO was significantly associated with improvement in bronchial reactivity (change in eCO (parts per million) per natural log unit change in bronchial hyperreactivity 0.498, 95% confidence interval 0.071 to 0.924, P=0.024). These findings suggest that, contrary to previous data, there is no cross-sectional relationship between eCO and lung function or bronchial reactivity, but that there may be a longitudinal trend with bronchial reactivity that is worth further investigation.