Genetic resistance to the induction of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in Lewis rats. I. Genetic analysis of an apparent mutant strain with phenotypic resistance to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis

Inconsistent susceptibility to autoimmunity in inbred LEW rats is due to genetic crossbreeding involving segregation of the arthritis-regulating gene Ncf1

We recently identified a single-nucleotide polymorphism in the Ncf1 gene, a component of the NADPH oxidase complex, to be the cause of one of the strongest identified loci for arthritis severity in rats. This polymorphism was found to be naturally occurring in a collection of inbred rat strains as well as in wild rats. Among the inbred strains we found that different LEW substrains (LEW/Ztm and LEW/Mol), originating from different breeders, showed an allelic discrepancy in Ncf1, suggesting an impact on arthritis susceptibility between these substrains. In fact, the LEW/Mol strain was completely resistant to pristane-induced arthritis, in contrast to the LEW/Ztm strain, which was susceptible. Moreover, the LEW/Mol strain had higher production of radical oxygen species in peripheral blood leukocytes, a phenomenon most likely regulated by the polymorphisms in the Ncf1 gene. However, the phenotypic difference between LEW/Mol and LEW/Ztm is most likely a combination of several genes, of which Ncf1 is suggested to be the major regulating gene. This has also been confirmed by previous linkage analyses involving the LEW/Ztm strain which shows that a QTL on chromosome 12, most likely caused by polymorphism of Ncf1, is the major regulatory gene but that other loci are contributing. That more genes are likely to contribute was shown by a complete genome comparison of the LEW/Ztm and the LEW/Mol rat strains that uncovered an introduction of approximately 37% non-LEW genome into the LEW/Mol strain, which probably was caused by past crossbreeding. Therefore, the LEW/Mol should be regarded as a recombinant inbred strain.

The Wistar Kyoto (RT1(l)) rat is resistant to myelin basic protein-induced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis: comparison with the susceptible Lewis (RT1(l)) strain with regard to the MBP-directed CD4+ T cell repertoire and its regulation

Here, we demonstrate that the Wistar Kyoto (WKY/NHsd) rat, which bears the same RT1(l) haplotype as the experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE)-susceptible Lewis rat strain, is highly resistant to myelin basic protein (MBP)-induced EAE. No differences between Lewis and WKY strains were found in T cell proliferative specificity or the use of Vbeta8.2 T cell receptors in response to MBP. A Th2 cytokine bias correlated with WKY's EAE resistance. MBP challenge of WKY-into-Lewis adoptive transfer recipients produced a novel biepisodic EAE. The WKY strain should be useful in studies of many tissue-specific autoimmune diseases to which the Lewis rat is susceptible.

Cloning of myelin basic protein-reactive T cells from the experimental allergic encephalomyelitis-resistant rat strain, LER

Rats of the LER inbred strain are resistant to the active induction of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), although they are susceptible to adoptively transferred EAE when they are injected with encephalitogenic T cells from EAE-susceptible Lewis rats. The mechanism of resistance remains to be elucidated. We report here that myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific T cells can be cloned from LER rats immunized with MBP, that these CD4+ LER T cells can recognize the encephalitogenic peptide (MBP-EP) and will divide vigorously when it is presented to them, and that these T cells bear V beta 8 + TCR chains. Nevertheless, in contrast to Lewis T cells with the same specificity and TCR beta chains, LER T cells from MBP-EP-specific clones cannot induce EAE when adoptively transferred into naive rats of either strain. Thus, LER T cells can assemble and use a TCR with the canonical encephalitogenic V beta 8.2-D beta-J beta region in response to immunization with MBP, yet they continue to display resistance to EAE.

The origin of the autoimmune disease-resistant LER rat: an outcross between the buffalo and autoimmune disease-prone Lewis inbred rat strains

The Lewis (LEW) rat strain is highly susceptible to a large number of experimentally induced inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. The Lewis resistant (LER) rat strain, which reportedly arose as a spontaneous mutation in a closed colony of LEW rats, is resistant to many of these disorders. The mechanism of resistance is not yet clear. We report the analysis of 19 simple dinucleotide repeat polymorphisms in 13 rat strains including the LEW/N and LER/N rat strains. The LEW/N and LER/N alleles were the same in only 42% of cases. For all of the other polymorphisms, the LER/N and Buffalo (BUF/N) rat strain alleles were identical. These data provide evidence that the LER strain did not arise as a spontaneous mutation in the LEW strain but is the result of an outcross between the LEW and BUF rat strains. The LER rat strain is now a recombinant inbred rat strain. This information should facilitate the genetic analysis of the loci responsible for resistance to experimental autoimmune disease in the LER rat.

Relative susceptibility of SJL/J and B10.S mice to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is determined by the ability of prethymic cells in bone marrow to develop into EAE effector T cells

SJL/J mice are highly susceptible to actively induced experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), whereas B10.S mice are resistant. However, both strains share the H-2s haplotype. We have previously shown that the relative susceptibility of SJL/J and B10.S mice to acute EAE correlates, respectively, with high and low responsiveness to myelin basic protein (MBP), as determined by cloning and limiting dilution analysis of in vitro T cell proliferation. Here, we have investigated the ability of SJL/J and B10.S mice to generate EAE-effector T cells in vivo. We have developed a new mouse strain, B10.S Thy 1.1, that differs at the Thy 1 locus from SJL/J and B10.S mice (both Thy 1.2) but has the same MHC and resistance pattern to EAE as do B10.S mice. Using radiation bone marrow chimeras formed between SJL/J and B10.S Thy 1.1 mice, we have shown that a population of radiosensitive prethymic cells in SJL/J bone marrow has an intrinsic potential to generate EAE-effector T cells, whereas that in B10.S Thy 1.1 bone marrow does not. This lack of detectable EAE effector cells in B10.S Thy 1.1 mice does not appear to be due to the generation of suppressor T cells or to a defect in antigen-presenting cells. Moreover, the potential of SJL/J bone marrow to generate EAE-effector T cells is not inhibited by the concomitant presence of B10.S Thy 1.1 bone marrow cells, thymocytes or dendritic cells in mixed chimeras. Hence, the relative susceptibility of SJL/J and B10.S mice to EAE appears to be directly related to the respective responder status of their T cells to MBP, as evidenced by their ability (or inability) to generate EAE-effector T cells. This high and low responder status appears in turn to be linked to non-MHC background genes, although this has not been established formally.

Relative susceptibility of SJL/J and B10.S mice to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis is correlated with high and low responsiveness to myelin basic protein

SJL/J mice are highly susceptible to actively induced experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), whereas B10.S mice are not. Yet both strains share the H-2s major histocompatibility complex (MHC) haplotype. In order to help determine the cellular basis for the disparate susceptibility to EAE, the antigen-specific in vitro proliferative responses of lymph node (LN) T cells from SJL/J and B10.S mice primed with porcine myelin basic protein (MBP) were assessed. The results indicated that SJL/J mice were high responders and B10.S mice were low responders to both porcine and murine MBP, as demonstrated by limiting dilution analyses and cloning efficiency analysis of MBP-reactive T cells. The low response of B10.S mice to MBP was not due to elevated suppressor cell activity or to a discernible defect in antigen-presenting cell activity. Rather, it appeared to be due to a paucity (or defect in function) of high affinity MBP-reactive T cells in B10.S as compared to SJL/J mice. This difference in MBP responsiveness must, by necessity, be linked to non-MHC background genes. Therefore, assuming that the relative number of MBP-reactive T cells parallels that of EAE-effector T cells in SJL/J and B10.S mice (as separate in vivo studies indicate), the present results suggest that differences in the T cell repertoire for the encephalitogenic determinants of MBP may contribute significantly to the observed differences in antigen reactivity, and may relate to differences in susceptibility to EAE.

Genetic control of rat T-cell response to Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxins (SE)

Rat T cells, like those of mouse and human origin, respond strongly to superantigens (SAg) derived from Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxins A and B (SEA, SEB). Lewis and ACI are high responders, whereas Brown Norway (BN) is a low responder. Congenic and back-cross rat studies indicate that the degree of responsiveness is controlled by at least one non-MHC gene. The action of these genes may reside in the antigen-presenting cells (APC), since both Sephadex G10 non-adherent BN spleen cells and purified BN T cells in the presence of Lewis APC can respond well to SE. Responses to concanavalin A (Con A) and SEA generally segregate together in back-cross rats. Surprisingly, the degree of responsiveness to Con A and SEA is not correlated with the susceptibility to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) either in independently derived inbred rat strains or in (Lewis x BN) x BN back-cross rats.

Genetic differences in the T cell receptor alleles of LEW rats and their encephalomyelitis-resistant derivative, LER, and their impact on the inheritance of EAE resistance

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is an animal model for the human disease, multiple sclerosis. The LEW rat strain is very susceptible to induction of EAE, whereas the closely related, major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-identical, inbred strain LER is resistant. In this report, the two rat strains have been compared for differences at a number of immunologically relevant loci by restriction fragment length analysis and by nucleotide sequencing. A major difference between the two strains was discovered at the T cell receptor beta chain locus (TcR beta). Both variable (V beta 8) and constant (C beta 1) region elements of TcR beta showed allelic variation between LEW and LER. The known genetic influences in rat models of autoimmunity are currently limited to those encoded by the rat MHC, RT-1. In this study we report our characterization of the allelic differences in TcR beta chains between two rats which differ in their susceptibility to induced EAE, with the goal of understanding the role played by these allelic forms of TcR in the pathogenesis of EAE. The importance of the TcR beta allelic difference in resistance or susceptibility to EAE was assessed in a study of backcross rats scored for both EAE and for the novel LER TcR beta allele. We found that the TcR beta allele from the susceptible strain was present in three out of four susceptible rats, suggesting that it is an important, but not the only, genetic factor in EAE. Supporting this conclusion were the observations that 12 of 13 rats with homozygous LER-derived TCR beta alleles were resistant to EAE.

Genetic control of resistance to clinical EAE accompanied by histological symptoms

The susceptibility of rats to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) induced by myelin basic protein (MBP) was studied in a variety of genetic crosses. Rats were evaluated according to weight loss, neurological symptoms, and histological criteria. The results demonstrate that three different types of genes are involved in susceptibility. An RT1-linked gene is necessary but not sufficient for full expression of EAE induced by MBP in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA). Additional genes are required for the occurrence of histological EAE, but a full-blown inflammatory reaction is not sufficient for the expression of clinical EAE. A third type of gene, which can be demonstrated in appropriate crosses, is required for the consistent expression of clinical symptoms. Dominant genes for resistance to clinical symptoms were transferred to the Lewis (LEW) background from the BN.B1 strain through two generations of backcrossing. Thus, there are genetically controlled mechanisms involved in the neurological expression of EAE which are independent of the inflammatory reaction as observed in central nervous system (CNS) histology.

Limiting-dilution analysis of the frequency of myelin basic protein-reactive T cells in Lewis, PVG/c and BN rats. Implication for susceptibility to autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Susceptibility to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), which is an autoimmune disease inducible by immunization with a brain-specific antigen in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA), is different among strains. In an attempt to resolve the immune mechanisms by which the difference in susceptibility to EAE is regulated, we re-estimated susceptibility of several strains of rats, and the frequency of antigen-reactive T cells in each strain was determined by limiting-dilution analysis. EAE was induced in Lewis (LEW), PVG/c and BN rats using four different methods: (i) active immunization with guinea-pig myelin basic protein (GPBP) in CFA; (ii) immunization with GPBP in CFA that had been further supplemented with Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Ra (supplemented CFA); (iii) adoptive transfer of GPBP-activated spleen cells into syngeneic rats; and (iv) transfer of a GPBP-specific T-cell line. The LEW strain was susceptible to all four methods. The PVG/c strain was resistant to immunization with GPBP in conventional CFA (GPBP/conv. CFA), but was susceptible to immunization with GPBP in supplemented CFA (GPBP/suppl. CFA) and to transfer of activated spleen cells. The BN strain was resistant to all methods. Limiting-dilution analysis using T cells from LEW, PVG/c or BN rats has revealed that each strain of rat displays a different pattern of frequencies of GPBP-reactive or the 68-88 sequence (GP68-88)-reactive T cells. LEW rats showed relatively high frequencies of GPBP-reactive and GP68-88-reactive T cells after immunization with either GPBP/conv. CFA or GPBP/suppl. CFA, symptomatic rats showing higher values than asymptomatic rats. In asymptomatic PVG/c rats, the frequency of GP68-88-reactive T cells was lower than that of GPBP-reactive T cells. In PVG/c rats with clinical EAE, however, GP68-88-reactive T cells increased in frequency and were almost the same as GPBP-reactive T cells. BN rats, on the other hand, responded very poorly not only to the GP68-88 sequence but also to the whole GPBP molecule, even after immunization with GPBP/suppl. CFA. These findings, obtained by limiting-dilution analysis, strongly suggest that the development of EAE in LEW, PVG/c and BN rats is closely related to the frequency of GPBP-reactive T cells. Furthermore, it is shown that resistance to EAE found in PVG/c and BN rats may be generated by different immune mechanisms.

Genetic resistance in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. I. Analysis of the mechanism of LeR resistance using radiation chimeras

Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is a cell-mediated autoimmune disease of the central nervous system that has been extensively studied in the rat. The Lewis rat is highly susceptible to the induction of EAE, while the Lewis resistant (LeR) rat is known to be resistant. In this paper, we demonstrate that the LeR rat, which was derived from the Lewis strain by inbreeding of fully resistant animals, is histocompatible with the Lewis strain. Radiation chimeras, a tool for distinguishing between immunologic and nonimmunologic resistance mechanisms, were utilized to analyze the cellular mechanisms involved in genetic resistance to EAE. By transplanting bone marrow cells from LeR rats into irradiated Lewis recipients, Lewis rats were rendered resistant to EAE induction. Likewise, transplanting Lewis bone marrow cells into irradiated LeR recipients rendered LeR rats susceptible. Mixed lymphoid cell chimeras using bone marrow, spleen, and thymus cells in Lewis recipient rats revealed individual lymphoid cell types and cell interactions that significantly affected the incidence and severity of EAE. Our results suggest that LeR resistance is mediated by hematopoietic/immune cells, and that cells located in the spleen appear to play a critical role in the resistance/susceptibility to EAE induction. Depletion of splenic adherent cells did not change the patterns of EAE resistance. In vivo cell mixing studies suggested the presence of a suppressor cell population in the LeR spleen preparations which exerted an inhibitory effect on Lewis autoimmune responses. Thus, the mechanism of LeR resistance appears to be different from that in other EAE-resistant animals.

Actively induced experimental allergic orchitis in Lewis-resistant (Le-R) rats: reversibility of disease resistance by immunization with Bordetella pertussis

Differential susceptibility to the induction of experimental allergic orchitis (EAO) was examined in Lewis/NCr and Le-R subline rats. Lewis/NCr rats were found to be fully susceptible to the induction of EAO whereas Le-R subline rats were not. Disease resistance exhibited by Le-R rats could be overcome by including Bordetella pertussis in the immunization protocol. However, reversal of resistance with B. pertussis was dependent on the dose of rat testicular homogenate in the inoculum and found to be effective only at lower doses of antigen (10 mg/rat). Disease resistance in Le-R rats as well as B. pertussis-induced reversal of resistance did not appear to be associated with either (1) a significant difference in the number of mast cells in the ductus efferentes, the anatomic location of the earliest inflammatory infiltrates, or (2) an alteration in the phenotypic expression of either innate or B. pertussis-induced sensitivity to vasoactive amines. The results are discussed in the context of the role of B. pertussis in other animal models of organ-specific autoimmune diseases. It is proposed that the phenotypic expression of resistance to EAO in Le-R rats is a result of a mutation in a common regulatory locus affecting susceptibility to multiple autoimmune diseases and whose immunoregulatory action is normally exerted during the sensitization phase of the immune response.

Induction of hyperacute brain inflammation and demyelination by activated encephalitogenic T cells and a monoclonal antibody specific for a myelin/oligodendrocyte glycoprotein

CNS demyelinating inflammatory disease can be a multifactorial process mediated by cellular and antibody-mediated immune processes. Myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific T cells and pathogenic 8-18C5 antibody, specific for a myelin/oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG), a minor component of CNS white matter, can coexist in rats without triggering disease. However, transfer of activated MBP-specific T-cells followed by the injection of 8-18C5 antibody resulted in hyperacute disease progression and CNS demyelination. Transfer of activated T cells specific for an irrelevant antigen or transfer of activated but irradiated encephalitogenic T cells did not induce disease in the presence of 8-18C5 antibody. When needle lesions were induced in brains of 8-18C5 antibody treated rats, no enhancement of demyelination was seen around the needle track. Thus, accessibility of the brain parenchyma to 8-18C5 antibody was not sufficient to induce local demyelination. Therefore, it appears that activated encephalitogenic T cells are involved in initiating the 8-18C5 antibody-mediated demyelinating process.

Differential susceptibility to actively induced experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and experimental allergic orchitis among BALB/c substrains

Experimental allergic orchitis (EAO) and experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) are animal models of organ-specific autoimmune disease. In this study, BALB/cByJ and BALB/cAnNCr mice were susceptible to both autoimmune diseases whereas BALB/cJ subline mice were resistant. Disease resistance in BALB/cJ mice did not appear to be a reflection of either (i) a nonspecific generalized impairment of cellular immunity or (ii) an alteration in the phenotypic expression of Bordetella pertussis-induced histamine sensitization, a phenotype which has been shown to be associated with susceptibility to both diseases. Susceptibility to both EAE and EAO was inherited as a dominant trait in F1 hybrid animals. Segregation analysis in a (BALB/cByJ X BALB/cJ) X BALB/cJ backcross population suggested that disease resistance may be associated with a single genotypic difference in a common regulatory gene affecting susceptibility to both diseases. Linkage analysis of the backcross population failed to demonstrate an association of disease resistance with the mutant raf-1b allele carried by BALB/cJ mice. The results of these studies support previous observations that multiple genotypic differences may in fact exist in mice of the BALB/cJ subline and that such differences play a significant role in the genetic control of susceptibility to EAE and EAO.

Modification of the clinical and histopathologic expression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis by the vasoactive amine antagonist cyproheptadine

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is an autoimmune syndrome that can be induced in Lewis rats by myelin basic protein (BP) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA). Rats that have recovered from a primary episode of EAE display paradoxical long-term resistance to EAE reinduction by BP-CFA. Previous observations indicated, however, that clinical disease could be reinduced in convalescent rats by a concomitant secondary challenge with BP-CFA + Bordetella pertussis extract (PERT). Vascular permeability changes in the central nervous system (CNS) paralleled disease reinduction. To further probe the relationship between disease reinduction and vascular permeability, convalescent rats were treated with the vasoactive amine antagonist cyproheptadine (CYP) prior to a secondary challenge with BP-CFA + PERT. Data presented here indicate that CYP treatment results in substantial protection of convalescent rats from clinical disease reinduction by BP-CFA + PERT. CYP did not, however, prevent the development of new CNS lesions. CYP therapy also altered the clinical course of EAE induced by a primary injection of BP-CFA + PERT. In these rats, there was a delay in the onset of clinical signs as well as in the appearance of CNS lesions. Nevertheless, both CYP-treated and untreated naive rats challenged with BP-CFA + PERT eventually developed severe and usually lethal EAE. The effect of CYP on EAE induced in naive rats without including PERT in the sensitization protocol was also evaluated. In contrast to the mitigating effect of CYP on EAE induced or reinduced by BP-CFA + PERT, CYP treatment did not affect the clinical course or the development of CNS lesions in rats challenged with BP-CFA alone. Likewise, the passive transfer of EAE, mediated by mitogen-stimulated cells obtained from BP-CFA-sensitized donors, was not affected by CYP treatment. Collectively, these data indicate that CYP therapy altered the expression of EAE induced by regimens that included PERT, but did not affect EAE induced without PERT. In view of the opposing effects of PERT and CYP on vascular permeability, these data are consistent with the hypothesis that alterations in vascular permeability may play a crucial role in controlling the expression of autoimmune neurological diseases.

Leukocyte subpopulations which amplify or suppress antigen-induced proliferation in Syrian hamsters

The proliferative response of spleen cells, obtained from Syrian hamsters sensitized to hen egg albumin emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant, is lower in magnitude than the response of draining lymph node cells. In this study, the cellular regulatory mechanisms which may lead to splenic hyporesponsiveness were examined. Although unfractionated spleen cells were not suppressive, the addition of nylon wool nonadherent normal spleen cells to sensitized draining lymph node (target) cells markedly suppressed antigen- but not mitogen-induced proliferation. Suppressor cell activity was not detected in normal lymph nodes. Suppression could be overcome by culturing splenic suppressor plus target cell mixtures in the presence of large quantities of antigen. Suppressor cell activity was radioresistant. In addition to nonadherent suppressor cells, the hamster spleen also contains an adherent cell population(s) which amplified antigen-induced proliferation. Adherent cells with amplifying activity were also present in lymph nodes. The addition of adherent cells abrogated splenic suppression of proliferation. Collectively, these data indicate that the hamster spleen contains both suppressive and amplifying leukocyte subpopulations which may be involved in the regulation of the immune response to certain antigenic stimuli.

Low susceptibility to the induction of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in a substrain of the otherwise susceptible Lewis rat

A substrain of the Lewis rat, Lew/Mol, differing from ordinary Lewis rats in that it is hardly susceptible to the induction of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is described. The Lew/Mol rats did not mount a host-vs.-graft response towards cells from an EAE-susceptible substrain of Lewis rats (Lew/Mai) and vice versa. This argues against the possibility that the origin of Lew/Mol rats involves accidental cross-breeding with other rat strains. Thus the EAE-resistance in Lew/Mol rats in interpreted as being due to a mutation(s) in a gene(s) regulating the susceptibility to EAE. Specific pathogen-free Lew/Mol rats were more resistant to EAE induction than Lew/Mol rats bred under conventional conditions, emphasizing the importance of environmental factors. Neither cyclophosphamide treatment nor increased age resulted in marked susceptibility in the Lew/Mol rats, although aging apparently had some effect, as a few animals did show neurological signs. Approximately half of (Lew/Mol x Lew/Mai)F1 hybrids developed EAE with neurological signs. In this respect, Lew/Mol rats differ from another recently described EAE-resistant substrain of the Lewis rat (LeR).

Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in hybrids between Lewis and Brown Norway rats

The susceptibility to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in Lewis (Lew) and Brown Norway (BN) rats was studied in breeding experiments, evaluating EAE from clinical signs of the disease. The Lew strain is highly susceptible, the BN strain is resistant to EAE. F1 hybrids between the strains show an intermediate susceptibility as described by earlier authors. Back-cross experiments verify that susceptibility is inherited in a complex way, at least according to a two-gene model previously suggested. Analysis of the F1 hybrids showed a bi-modal distribution of clinical scores, one group of rats which appear to have the same degree of susceptibility as the Lew strain, and another group with very low susceptibility. Study of F2 rats produced by F1 rats with high or low susceptibility showed that this property was probably not inherited, arguing against a residual heterozygosity in the parental strains. As an alternative hypothetical explanation, the possibility of allogeneic exclusion of genes regulating suppression of EAE is discussed.