Regulatory idiotypes. T helper cells recognize a shared VH idiotope on phosphorylcholine-specific antibodies

Generalization of single immunological experiences by idiotypically mediated clonal connections

Clonal interactions of B cells by idiotope-specific mutual recognition of their antigen receptors with the participation of T cells were assumed to form a web of unknown density, referred to as the idiotypic network. Although these clonal connections were proposed to fulfill important internal regulatory functions, their biological significance, especially in relation to antigen-induced immune responses, remained a mystery. In view of this, we postulate that the basic function of the idiotypic internal connection between B and T cell antigen receptors is to transform antigen-induced cellular activations, by idiotypic crossreactivity, into the regulation of cell clones with different antigen specificities. This process leads not only to the suppression of major clones but also to the activation of minor ones. The latter activating property may allow the generalization of single antigenic experiences, so that the immune system in its entirety benefits in its battle against environmental microbes. Such idiotypic clonal interactions are particularly effective in early ontogeny. During a short neonatal imprinting period, maternal immunological knowledge in the form of somatically mutated, high-affinity IgG antibodies, acquired through a continuous encounter with external antigens, guides the initial ontogenetic development of the immune system and so exerts long-lasting transgenerational advantageous effects in the offspring.

Molecular characterization of J558 genes encoding tight-skin mouse autoantibodies: identical heavy-chain variable genes code for antibodies with different specificities

Tight-skin mouse, a mutant strain with a single gene defect, develops cutaneous hyperplasia and specific autoantibodies, like humans affected by scleroderma. The autoantibodies produced in the tight-skin mouse are encoded primarily by heavy-chain variable (VH) genes from the J558 family. To understand the genetic basis of production of autoantibodies, we have analyzed the structure of J558 genes encoding these autoantibodies. The results showed that J558 genes encoding these antibodies were not derived from a selected germ-line gene(s) or a single subfamily but were derived from genes belonging to diverse J558 subfamilies. However, two prototype VH genes representing two new subfamilies were found to be repeatedly expressed in their germ-line form in eight independent clones. Autoantibodies with distinct specificities appear to be generated by pairing of similar/identical VH genes with different V kappa genes derived from the same or different families. Fourteen of 18 autoantibodies shared a conserved heptapeptide sequence motif, YNEKFKG, in the second complementarity-determining region of heavy chains. Usage of germ-line genes from diverse J558 subfamilies bearing a common motif to encode autoantibodies suggests a regulatory role for this motif. Thus, selection and expansion of the autoreactive B-cell repertoire in the tight-skin mouse appear to be VH-gene mediated. The frequency of N nucleotide addition at diversity-joining (D-JH) junctions was lower, whereas the frequency of usage of the DFL16 segment was higher. Finally, in contrast to normal and other autoimmune mouse strains, the frequencies of D-D fusions and D inversions were higher in tight-skin mouse total immunoglobulin as well as autoantibody repertoires.

The IgG2a antibody response to thyroglobulin is linked to the Igh locus in mouse

The IgG-subclass usage by several strains of mice in the response to immunization with mouse thyroglobulin (mTg) was examined in the experimental autoimmune thyroiditis model. While the subclass usage by most mouse strains was similar, the Ighb allotype-bearing mice consistently produced lower IgG2a levels to mTg. Using CBA-Ighb congenic and recombinant inbred strains of mice, the lower level of IgG2a in the Ighb mouse was mapped to the Igh locus. The regulation of IgG2a appeared to be cis controlled, as the CBA x C57BL/6F1 mouse also produced reduced IgG2a of the Ighb (B6) allotype but not of the Ighj (CBA) allotype.

The physiology of anti-idiotypic interactions: from clonal to paratopic selection

On theoretical and experimental grounds, it has been proposed that the idiotypes of immunoglobulins and of T cell receptors are composed of multiple paratopes, as opposed to a single paratope and several idiotopes. This necessitates a revision of some of the basic principles of anti-idiotypic reactions. It is also possible to infer the presence of the same or similar paratopes on different idiotypes. A paratope cannot therefore be regarded as restricted to or unique on an idiotype. For these reasons, the perception of immunological specificity in terms of clonal units is misleading. This review proposes instead that the physiological unit of immunological specificity and regulation is the paratope. This essential alteration in the perception of the immune system is referred to as paratopic selection. The approach is assessed in terms of immunological regulation and specificity, and appears to allow new insights into these areas.

Revised immune network concepts

The idiotype network concept needs to be revised in order to be in agreement with current data on protein/protein interactions, with the phenomenon of T and B cell recognition of idiotopes, and with the failure of certain anti-idiotypes to stimulate a given immune response. It is proposed that the distinction among Ab2 alpha, beta, and gamma is abandoned, as well as the concept of an internal image idiotope which mimics the three-dimensional shape of nominal antigen. In place of these definitions, the concept of "network antigen" is introduced. Network antigens are potentially the entire repertoire of anti-idiotypes. However, their biological effectiveness is controlled and established by two factors: (i) the affinity to the idiotype Ig receptor; and (ii) the preexisting regulatory network segment that controls the outcome of immune stimulation or suppression. Screening for effective idiotype therapeutic agents has to be done with panels of anti-idiotype and idiotype antibodies in order to establish correlations between idiotope expression and disease progression. Recognizing the importance of network segments will be the first step in the direction toward a rational design of idiotype-based therapies.

Potential role of anti-idiotype antibodies in active tumor immunotherapy

The tumor-specified cellular and humoral immunity induced by anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2s) 2F10 and 3A4 has been studied. Ab2s were made against a monoclonal anti-L1210/GZL lymphoma, 11C1. They were screened for their ability to block 11C1 binding to tumor, induce tumor-specific DTH and CTL responses, and induce an anti-tumor humoral response. Two Ab2s, 2F10 and 3A4, which were found to have similar fine specificity and to induce similar cellular and humoral responses, were compared for their ability to elicit tumor-protective immunity. Interestingly, only preimmunization with the 2F10 Ab2 protected animals from live tumor challenge. The possible causes for this discriminatory biological effect induced by otherwise similar Ab2s are discussed.

Restriction of blood and marrow CLL-B cells to free L-chain Ig secretion: implication for normal B-cell function and control

The culture supernatant immunoglobulin (CSIg) of blood mononuclear cells (MNCs) from 14 patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) was determined using a panel of nanogram-sensitive radioimmunoassays that measured IgM, IgG, IgA, total kappa-Ig, and total lambda-Ig. Bone marrow cells from three patients were also cultured and the blood and marrow CSIg results were compared. The CSIg of 1-day cultures was employed as a measure of shed surface membrane Ig (SmIg) for the 7- and 14-day cultures. Adjusting for shed SmIg, it was found that in resting unstimulated conditions, monotypic free light (L) chain was virtually the only identifiable secreted Ig product in 12 of 14 blood MNC cultures and in three of three marrow cell cultures. In pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-stimulated cultures, monotypic free L chain also dominated, except for significant polyclonal Ig secretion found in three cultures from residual normal blood MNCs. The secretion by CLL-B cells of significant amounts of free L chain with a virtual absence of whole Ig raises important questions about the presence and function of phenotypically equivalent normal B cells in blood and bone marrow, and also the immunological role of secreted free L chain. Noting recent evidence that PWM-stimulated normal blood MNCs secrete significant amounts of polyclonal free L chain, the argument is advanced that normal blood and bone marrow contain B cells of CLL-B phenotype and that secreted free L-chain-bearing clonal idiotypic markers interact with autologous cells of the idiotypic regulatory network and possess a key role in the regulation of clonal growth and Ig synthesis.

Characterization of a T-cell clone recognizing idiotypes as tumor-associated antigens

Although heterogeneous T cells recognizing idiotypic determinants have been demonstrated to occur spontaneously in vitro or to be expanded by immunization with antigen or idiotype, their in vitro propagation and cloning was not successful. These previous studies have relied extensively on soluble immunoglobulin to induce proliferation of idiotype-specific T cells. This report describes a unique approach to obtain a stable T-cell clone specific for a monoclonal beta 2-6 fructosan binding myeloma ABPC48 (BALB/c origin), bearing well-defined A48 regulatory idiotopes. Following repeated immunizations with ABPC48 myeloma protein of C.B/R3 mice (H-2d, VHb, CHa), which differ only in the VH locus from BALB/c mice (H-2d, VHa CHa), several stable T-cell clones were obtained after stimulation in vitro with ABPC48 myeloma cells. The proliferation of a T-cell clone A48.B2 was observed with irradiated myeloma cells or hybridomas producing antibodies bearing A48 idiotype encoded by genes deriving from the VH 441-4 family. Proliferation of the clone did not occur with soluble ABPC48 myeloma protein or with Sepharose 4B-bound ABPC48 myeloma protein. Both anti-A48Id and anti-Iad monoclonal antibodies can specifically inhibit the proliferation of this clone when stimulated with ABPC48 myeloma cells. These results demonstrate recognition of idiotypes on B-cell tumours by T cells and implicate the role of class II major histocompatibility complex determinants in this cellular interaction.

The induction of helper and suppressor cells with secondary anti-hen egg-white lysozyme B hybridoma cells in the absence of antigen

The results presented in this report define a dominant T cell-recognized public idiotype (SRId) expressed on monoclonal anti-chicken egg-white lysozyme (HEL) antibodies produced by hybridomas derived from secondary response lymphocytes. This Id mediates interactions between SRId+ B cells and SRId-recognizing T cells. In the absence of exogenous antigen, irradiated secondary anti-HEL B hybridoma cells (B-Hyb) of nonoverlapping specificity can be used to induce a helper T cell population capable of specifically stimulating an in vitro anti-HEL plaque-forming cell (PFC) response. Importantly, similar immunizations using carbodiimide-treated secondary anti-HEL B-Hyb cross-primed for a suppressor T cell population capable of suppressing this in vitro anti-HEL PFC response. That is, suppression was seen not only to the response induced by the homologous B-Hyb but to other B-Hyb which express anti-HEL monoclonal antibody of nonoverlapping specificity. This evidence is consistent with the presence of a pre-existent regulatory Id network involving SRId in antigennaive animals. After immunization with HEL, regulatory cells exert a strong selective pressure which leads to a secondary anti-HEL B population, of varying fine specificity, but uniformly positive for SRId.

Evidence by radioimmunoassay that mitogen-activated human blood mononuclear cells secrete significant amounts of light chain Ig unassociated with heavy chain

The culture supernatant (CS) Ig of PWM-activated human blood mononuclear cells was quantitatively determined using a panel of nanogram-sensitive radioimmunoassays (RIAs) that separately measured IgG, IgM, IgA, total kappa Ig, and total lambda Ig. After initial RIA quantitation, separate CS aliquots were exposed to either a polyisotypic anti-heavy (H) chain or a nonimmune IgG solid-phase immunoabsorbent, and then reassayed for Ig content. The reassay results revealed that the anti-H chain-absorbed CS aliquots retained significant amounts of kappa and lambda Ig, but yet had a virtual absence of isotypic IgG, IgM, and IgA. Comparisons of the absorbed CS aliquots suggested that as much as one-fourth to one-third of the total secreted L chain Ig in PWM-activated cultures lacked RIA-detectable associated H chain. This unexpected finding of significant amounts of unbound L chain in mitogen-stimulated cultures raises important theoretical issues relative to the functional role of secreted free L chain and the prospects that free L chain levels may represent useful quantitative markers of B-cell stimulation.

Activation of immunoglobulin allotype-specific T cells by B cells

To investigate the role of Ia and immunoglobulin (Ig) molecules of B cells in alloantigen-specific and nominal antigen-specific T-cell activations, the ability of B cells to stimulate Ig allotype-specific T cells was examined. T15-primed B10.BR T cells responded to MOPC 315 (IgA myeloma protein derived from BALB/c) as well as T15 but not to MOPC31c (IgG1 myeloma protein). These T cells were stimulated by papain-digested Fc fragment of T15. Thus, T15-primed B10.BR T cells were shown to be specific for Ig allotype of T15, that is, Igh-2a. T15-specific B10.BR T cells were selected by 10-day cultures with T15 in vitro. They responded to BALB.K spleen cells without addition of soluble T15 antigen to the assay culture. Stimulator cells in this mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR)-like response between T15-specific B10.BR T cells and BALB.K spleen cells were Thy-1-, Ia+ cells and these responses were blocked by anti-Iak antibodies. Furthermore, Sephadex G-10-passed BALB.K B cells stimulated the proliferation of T15-specific B10.BR T cells, while they failed to stimulate allogeneic BALB/c spleen cells. The stimulating ability of B cells in this MLR-like response of T15-specific B10.BR T cells was shown to be genetically restricted, namely, both H-2 and non-H-2 genes are involved in the manifestation of the stimulating ability. This system will provide a useful model for studying the role of B-cell surface Ig and Ia molecules in the activation of antigen-specific T cells and alloreactive T cells.

Idiotypic analysis of potential and available repertoires in the arsonate system

We have shown that, by suitable idiotypic manipulation, BALB/c mice can express the major cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) of A/J mice in response to azophenylarsonate (Ars). In order to know if the CRIA idiotype is present in the potential repertoire of BALB/c before any intentional selection, we used polyclonal activation in vitro and limiting dilution analysis. The readout was done with two monoclonal anti-CRIA antibodies that recognize distinct idiotopes on a CRIA+ A/J germline-encoded monoclonal antibody. We studied the frequency of CRIA+ lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-reactive cells in the spleens of nonimmune and immune A/J mice and in the spleens of naive and manipulated (i.e., producing CRIA+ antibodies) BALB/c mice. A/J and BALB/c naive individuals presented very high frequencies of Ars-specific B cells while the frequency of CRIA+ B cells was only a minor subset (0.5%) of the total Ars-specific subset in the two strains. When A/J mice were immunized with Ars-keyhole limpet hemocyanin, a clear preferential expansion of the CRIA+ minor subset of A/J mice was observed (100x). No such enhancement was observed in BALB/c mice similarly treated. Manipulated BALB/c mice presented a higher frequency of CRIA+ anti-Ars B cells than naive or antigen-immunized BALB/c individuals.

T-cell helper circuits

T helper cells specific for trinitrophenylated PC-binding myeloma and hybridoma antibodies are induced by priming with PC antigen, idiotype or anti-idiotypic antibody. These T helper cells are specific for a shared idiotope present on T15 and M167. Priming with the isolated heavy chains of T15 or M167, or the light chain of anti-T15 hybridoma antibody is equally effective in generating T helper cells. Evidently, the idiotope that is recognized by T cells is not dependent upon the conformation of the 7s Ig molecule. Collectively, these and other findings indicate the existence of a TH1-TH2-B cellular circuit which is based on the recognition of idiotopic determinants on T cell receptors. The implications of these findings in terms of network theory are explored.

Human auto-antiidiotypes regulating T cell-mediated reactivity to tetanus toxoid

While investigating the effect on B cells of repetitive in vivo immunization with tetanus toxoid (TT), we observed the subsequent development of specific anergy for T cell delayed hypersensitivity (DTH) to TT. This appeared approximately 35 d after a series of five booster immunizations. Concurrently, in vitro T cell blastogenic responses were preserved. Serum obtained when the skin tests were nonreactive demonstrated a profound inhibitory activity on T cell reactivity. This activity was shown to be anti-antibody activity that was both anti-F(ab)'2 and, specifically, anti-TT F(ab)'2. It blocked binding of TT to a pool of allogeneic antibodies and also inhibited allogeneic antigen-specific T cell blastogenesis. Thus, we could identify activity in the serum of hyperimmunized individuals that appeared auto-anti-idiotypic (anti-id) and represented a single or family of major crossreacting idiotypes (id) for TT. The expression of the auto-anti-id correlated with the loss of T cell reactivity in vivo and in vitro. Subsequent examinations revealed persistent, specific cutaneous anergy beyond six months, which was then associated with a failure of T cells to react with antigen in vitro. Mixing experiments with cells from these later times and cryopreserved autologous cells obtained prior to hyperimmunization revealed there had been the development of antigen-specific T suppressor cells. Thus, in vivo DTH tolerance following hyperimmunization was associated with an inhibitory serum activity that appeared to be anti-id. Persistence of tolerance (greater than 6 mo) occurred with the development of T suppressor cells.

Regulatory idiotopes. Induction of idiotype-recognizing helper T cells by free light and heavy chains

Previously, we have demonstrated the induction of T helper cells that recognize idiotype by antigen (19), idiotype (20), and antiidiotype (12). The T cell population has been characterized and found to recognize both the T15 and M167 myeloma proteins, which share PC binding specificity but differ in idiotypic specificities. In the present work, we used isolated heavy and light chains of T15 and M167 to generate T helper cells, and examined the response to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-T15 and TNP-M167. We found that the heavy chains induced a dose-dependent response to TNP-T15 and TNP-M167, while the light chain priming was ineffective. When isolated chains of a monoclonal anti-T15 antibody (F6-3) were used to induce idiotype-recognizing T cells, only the F6-3 light chains generated T cell help for TNP-T15 and TNP-M167. Evidently, the idiotypic determinant that is recognized by the T cells is not dependent upon the conformation of combined heavy and light chains. These data show that the Th2 helper cells for the T15/M167 idiotopes are induced by free heavy chains of T15 and M167; the Th1 T cells that interact with the Th2 population, of T15 and M167; the Th1 T cells that interact with the Th2 population, however, can be triggered by free light chains of an antiidiotypic hybridoma antibody. These provocative findings suggest a new model for the T helper cell network.

Idiotype-specific T-helper cells

In the present study we investigated the induction and fine specificity of T-helper cells that recognize idiotypes. The data presented show that both low-dose priming with anti-T15 antiserum and priming with PC-Hy are effective in stimulating T15-specific T help. Phosphorylcholine-hemocyanin priming can generate these T cells in either PC-responding or nonresponding strains of mice. Furthermore, the PC-primed T-helper cells can also recognize another anti-PC myeloma, M167, that is idiotypically different from T15. The fine specificity of the anti-PC-idiotype recognizing T-helper cells was examined by studying the effect of in vitro inhibitors on the T-cell help. Both PC and PC-BSA as well as T15 and M167 had an inhibitory effect on the T help. Free T15 and M167 heavy chains also blocked the helper activity for T15; T15 and M167 light chains had no effect, however. Viewed collectively, these results show that PC-Hy priming induces T-helper cells that recognize idiotypic determinants common to both T15 and M167, and that the proteins' H chain is the major structural component of the determinant. Finally, the generation of these idiotype-recognizing T cells was found to occur by way of a T-T interaction loop, based on the finding that T-helper cells are induced by PC-Hy priming in animals that lack PC-responding B cells.

Idiotype-recognizing T helper cells that are not idiotype specific

In this study T helper cells that recognize idiotypes as carriers for a hapten-specific B cell response were analyzed under limiting dilution conditions. T helper cells, induced by phosphorylcholine-hemocyanin (PC-Hy) priming, recognize trinitrophenylated TEPC-15 and MOPC-167 (TNP-T15, TNP-167) equally well. Limiting dilution analysis indicates identical frequencies of helper cells for TNP-T15 and TNP-167. Double immunization protocols using TNP-T15 and TNP-167 fail to demonstrate additive effects. Inhibition of carrier recognition in vitro using free hapten, PC, and unconjugated T15 or M167 indicates identical specificities of helper cells for T15 and M167. Collectively, these results provide strong evidence that PC-Hy priming induces only one population of idiotype-recognizing helper cells that are unable to distinguish between the T15 and the M167 idiotopes. The helper cell induction circuit was further analyzed. PC-Hy priming induces T15/167-specific helper T cells in X-linked immune defect-expressing F1 mice. This indicates that a B cell response to PC is not required to induce idiotype-recognizing T cells. Adoptive cotransfer of B cells from PC-Hy-primed mice together with normal T cells fails to induce idiotype-recognizing T cells. These results indicate the existence of a T helper1-T helper2 induction loop. In this scheme, the T helper1 cell carries T15-like receptors and the T helper2 cells, anti-T15-like receptors. Monoclonal antiidiotypic antibodies specific for T15 also induce a T15/167-recognizing T helper cell population. This finding demonstrates that idiotope-specific priming induces non-idiotype-specific T cells. Evidently, the idiotypic T cell network is based on a different selection of idiotope determinants than the selection of the B cell idiotype network.

Induction of a cross-reactive idiotype dextran-positive antibody response in two IgH-Cb mouse strains treated with anti-J558 cross-reactive idiotype antibodies

The effect of IdX-specific rabbit and allogeneic antiidiotype antibodies (Ab2) was investigated in vivo in Igh-Cb mouse strains with respect to the induction of a cross-reactive idiotype (IdX)-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dextran (Dex) response. These C.B20 and C57Bl/6 mice have an allotype-linked incapacity to respond with IdX-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies upon conventional immunization with Dex B1355. 7 d after the rabbit Ab2 injections, IdX-positive Ig (Ab3) and IdX-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies (Ab1') were detected in the sera of each tested mouse. The affinity-purified Ab1' were idiotypically indistinguishable from reference BALB/c IdX-positive myeloma proteins and BALB/c anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies (Ab1) in a competitive inhibition radioimmunoassay, while Ab3 Ig appeared idiotypically deficient and did not bind to Dex. The response to the alpha (1-6) linkage of Dex was not affected in these mice. A large fraction of the Ab1' and Ab3 responses of both mouse strains were of the IgG1 class. The Ab1' antibodies differed from BALB/c Ab1 by lower relative binding to five of eight tested Dex, and by expressing the Igh4b allotype determinants on the IgG1 antibodies. This study identifies the products of a VHDex gene that appears to be under regulatory control in the Ighb mice. Its association with the b haplotype suggests that this gene may differ structurally from the BALB/c VHDex gene.

Identification of an idiotypic marker of a major regulatory T cell of the immune response in B10.BR mice to ferredoxin. The relationship of idiotypic regulation to conventional hapten-carrier effects

An anti-idiotypic antiserum was raised in rabbits to a monoclonal antibody (Fd-1) with specificity for one (the N epitope) of the two antigenic epitopes found on the ferredoxin (Fd) molecule. The anti-idiotypic antiserum (anti-Fd-1) was used to demonstrate that the Fd-1 idiotype was expressed at significant levels in most anti-Fd antisera raised in B10.BR mice. Examination of antisera raised in other mouse strains demonstrated that expression of this idiotype mapped to the IgH gene complex and was found in the antisera of all mouse strains examined with the Ig-1 allotype. When splenocytes from Fd-immune B10.Br mice were treated with anti-Fd-1 and transferred to irradiated syngeneic recipients, the adoptive secondary response was significantly higher in animals receiving treated cells as opposed to control animals, which received normal rabbit serum-treated cells. This response produced a net increase in antibody to both determinants, and the relative amount of Fd-1 idiotype was not significantly altered. Further studies with separated cell populations showed that the overall increase of anti-Fd antibody produced was attributable to the effects of the anti-idiotypic serum on a population(s) of T cells. Treatment of mice with the Fd-1 monoclonal antibody (which should react with anti-idiotypic cells) had an analogous effect to that of the anti-idiotype, in that mice so treated produced higher concentrations of anti-Fd antibodies when they were immunized and these antibodies exhibited net increases to both determinants. A model is presented to explain these results.