Lack of K1b9 light chains in Basilea rabbits is probably due to a mutation in an acceptor site for mRNA splicing

An overview of the lagomorph immune system and its genetic diversity

Our knowledge of the lagomorph immune system remains largely based upon studies of the European rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus), a major model for studies of immunology. Two important and devastating viral diseases, rabbit hemorrhagic disease and myxomatosis, are affecting European rabbit populations. In this context, we discuss the genetic diversity of the European rabbit immune system and extend to available information about other lagomorphs. Regarding innate immunity, we review the most recent advances in identifying interleukins, chemokines and chemokine receptors, Toll-like receptors, antiviral proteins (RIG-I and Trim5), and the genes encoding fucosyltransferases that are utilized by rabbit hemorrhagic disease virus as a portal for invading host respiratory and gut epithelial cells. Evolutionary studies showed that several genes of innate immunity are evolving by strong natural selection. Studies of the leporid CCR5 gene revealed a very dramatic change unique in mammals at the second extracellular loop of CCR5 resulting from a gene conversion event with the paralogous CCR2. For the adaptive immune system, we review genetic diversity at the loci encoding antibody variable and constant regions, the major histocompatibility complex (RLA) and T cells. Studies of IGHV and IGKC genes expressed in leporids are two of the few examples of trans-species polymorphism observed outside of the major histocompatibility complex. In addition, we review some endogenous viruses of lagomorph genomes, the importance of the European rabbit as a model for human disease studies, and the anticipated role of next-generation sequencing in extending knowledge of lagomorph immune systems and their evolution.

Accuracy and coverage assessment of Oryctolagus cuniculus (rabbit) genes encoding immunoglobulins in the whole genome sequence assembly (OryCun2.0) and localization of the IGH locus to chromosome 20

We report on the analyses of genes encoding immunoglobulin heavy and light chains in the rabbit 6.51× whole genome assembly. This OryCun2.0 assembly confirms previous mapping of the duplicated IGK1 and IGK2 loci to chromosome 2 and the IGL lambda light chain locus to chromosome 21. The most frequently rearranged and expressed IGHV1 that is closest to IG DH and IGHJ genes encodes rabbit VHa allotypes. The partially inbred Thorbecke strain rabbit used for whole-genome sequencing was homozygous at the IGK but heterozygous with the IGHV1a1 allele in one of 79 IGHV-containing unplaced scaffolds and IGHV1a2, IGHM, IGHG, and IGHE sequences in another. Some IGKV, IGLV, and IGHA genes are also in other unplaced scaffolds. By fluorescence in situ hybridization, we assigned the previously unmapped IGH locus to the q-telomeric region of rabbit chromosome 20. An approximately 3-Mb segment of human chromosome 14 including IGH genes predicted to map to this telomeric region based on synteny analysis could not be located on assembled chromosome 20. Unplaced scaffold chrUn0053 contains some of the genes that comparative mapping predicts to be missing. We identified discrepancies between previous targeted studies and the OryCun2.0 assembly and some new BAC clones with IGH sequences that can guide other studies to further sequence and improve the OryCun2.0 assembly. Complete knowledge of gene sequences encoding variable regions of rabbit heavy, kappa, and lambda chains will lead to better understanding of how and why rabbits produce antibodies of high specificity and affinity through gene conversion and somatic hypermutation.

Efficient immunoglobulin gene disruption and targeted replacement in rabbit using zinc finger nucleases

Rabbits are widely used in biomedical research, yet techniques for their precise genetic modification are lacking. We demonstrate that zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs) introduced into fertilized oocytes can inactivate a chosen gene by mutagenesis and also mediate precise homologous recombination with a DNA gene-targeting vector to achieve the first gene knockout and targeted sequence replacement in rabbits. Two ZFN pairs were designed that target the rabbit immunoglobulin M (IgM) locus within exons 1 and 2. ZFN mRNAs were microinjected into pronuclear stage fertilized oocytes. Founder animals carrying distinct mutated IgM alleles were identified and bred to produce offspring. Functional knockout of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus was confirmed by serum IgM and IgG deficiency and lack of IgM(+) and IgG(+) B lymphocytes. We then tested whether ZFN expression would enable efficient targeted sequence replacement in rabbit oocytes. ZFN mRNA was co-injected with a linear DNA vector designed to replace exon 1 of the IgM locus with ∼1.9 kb of novel sequence. Double strand break induced targeted replacement occurred in up to 17% of embryos and in 18% of fetuses analyzed. Two major goals have been achieved. First, inactivation of the endogenous IgM locus, which is an essential step for the production of therapeutic human polyclonal antibodies in the rabbit. Second, establishing efficient targeted gene manipulation and homologous recombination in a refractory animal species. ZFN mediated genetic engineering in the rabbit and other mammals opens new avenues of experimentation in immunology and many other research fields.

B cell and antibody repertoire development in rabbits: the requirement of gut-associated lymphoid tissues

The antibody repertoire of rabbits has interested immunologists for decades, in part because of the ease with which large quantities of high affinity antibodies can be obtained in serum, and in part because of the presence of genetic variants, allotypes, within V(H), C(H) and C(L) regions. Studies of these allotypes led to the initial descriptions of allelic exclusion, and neonatal suppression of serum Ig production (allotype suppression), and were instrumental in demonstrating that V and C regions are encoded by separate genes and are usually expressed in cis. The immune system of rabbit continues to be of interest primarily because of the use of both gene conversion and somatic hypermutation to diversify rearranged heavy and light chain genes and the role that gut-associated lymphoid tissues (GALT) and intestinal flora play in developing the primary (preimmune) antibody repertoire.

Rabbit immune repertoires as sources for therapeutic monoclonal antibodies: the impact of kappa allotype-correlated variation in cysteine content on antibody libraries selected by phage display

The rabbit immune repertoire has long been a rich source of diagnostic polyclonal antibodies. Now it also holds great promise as a source of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. On the basis of phage display technology, we recently reported the first humanization of a rabbit monoclonal antibody. The allotypic diversity of rabbit immunoglobulins prompted us to compare different rabbit immune repertoires for the generation and humanization of monoclonal antibodies that bind with strong affinity to antigens involved in tumor angiogenesis. In particular, we evaluated the diversity of unselected and selected chimeric rabbit/human Fab libraries that were derived from different kappa light chain allotypes. Most rabbit light chains have an extra disulfide bridge that links the variable and constant domains in addition to the two intrachain disulfide bridges shared with mouse and human kappa light chains. Here we evaluate the impact of this increased disulfide bridge complexity on the generation and selection of chimeric rabbit/human Fab libraries. We demonstrate that rabbits with mutant bas and wild-type parental b9 allotypes are excellent sources for therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. Featured among the selected clones with b9 allotype is a rabbit/human Fab that binds with a dissociation constant of 1nM to both human and mouse Tie-2, which will facilitate its evaluation in mouse models of human cancer. Examination of 228 new rabbit antibody sequences allowed for a comprehensive comparison of the LCDR3 and HCDR3 length diversity in rabbits. This study revealed that rabbits exhibit an HCDR3 length distribution more closely related to human antibodies than mouse antibodies.

Gene-conversion in rabbit B-cell ontogeny and during immune responses in splenic germinal centers

Combinatorial diversity is limited in rabbits because only a few V(H) genes rearrange. Most diversification of the primary repertoire is generated by somatic hypermutation and gene conversion-like changes of rearranged V(H) in B cells that migrate to appendix and other gut associated lymphoid tissues (GALT) of young rabbits. The changes are referred to as gene conversion-like because the non-reciprocal nature of the alterations introduced has not yet been demonstrated. There are many similarities between rabbits and chickens in how their B cells develop and diversify their repertoires. However, although the majority of rabbit B cells may have rearranged and diversified their V genes early in life, some B cells in adult rabbits have rearranged VH sequences that are identical or nearly identical to germline sequences. We found these cells in splenic germinal centers (GC) on days 7 and 10 after immunization of normal adult rabbits with DNP-BGG. By day 15, all rearranged V(H) sequences were diversified. We find an overall pattern of splenic precursor cells whose germline or near germline sequences change both by gene conversion and point mutations during early divisions and mainly by point mutations during later divisions. These events, in parallel with diversification of light chain sequences, may produce the diverse combining sites that serve as substrates for further affinity maturation by selection either within GC or later among emigrant cells in sites such as bone marrow. Some of the sequences altered by gene conversion in splenic germinal centers may also produce new members of the B-cell repertoire in adult rabbits comparable to those produced in GALT of neonatal rabbits.

Generating the antibody repertoire in rabbit

We describe a model for B cell development and generation of the antibody repertoire in rabbits. In this model, B cells develop early in ontogeny, migrate to GALT, and undergo the first round of diversification by a somatic gene conversion-like process and by somatic mutation. We designate the repertoire developed by this mechanism as the primary antibody repertoire and it is this repertoire that makes the rabbit immunocompetent. We invoke GALT as the site for development of the primary repertoire because (1) surgical removal of GALT from neonatal rabbits results in highly immunocompromised animals, (2) in germfree rabbits essentially no lymphoid development occurs in GALT and the rabbits are immunoincompetent, and (3) the follicular development of rabbit GALT is highly similar to that of the chicken bursa, the site in which the primary antibody repertoire develops by somatic gene conversion in chicken. We suggest that once the primary antibody repertoire is formed, it is maintained by self-renewing CD5+ B cells and is expanded to a secondary antibody repertoire after the B cells encounter antigen.

In utero suppression of kappa 2 isotype in homozygous bas/bas rabbits through embryo transfer

Allotypes of rabbit Ig provide a useful tool for the study of quantitative expression of alternative allelic forms. In the rabbit, maternal Ig is transmitted to the foetus and protects the immunologically immature newborn during several of the first weeks of life. Induced maternal antibodies directed towards a paternally inherited allotype of the offspring can influence the expression of that allotype drastically. Normal Ig level in heterozygous allotype suppressed animals is provided by increased expression of the alternative allele. On the other hand, allotype suppression in homozygous animals leads to increased expression of non-allelic alternative gene products. We quantitatively analysed the expression of bas, a marker on the kappa 2 light chain isotype of the mutant strain Basilea, in homozygous bas/bas rabbits which had been fostered in utero of b4/b6 mothers producing anti-bas. All of the offspring studied expressed the kappa 2 isotype at a very low level at two months of age, and, in some individuals, bas was hardly expressed after 6 to 12 months. A suppressed rabbit, which was immunized to produce auto-antibodies against bas, continued to do so for at least 2.5 years. The long duration of homozygous bas suppression contrasts with homozygous suppression of other allotypes (CL kappa 1 and VHa) which generally lasts for a much shorter period.

Mutation of immunoglobulin J chi splice sites does not affect the rearrangement frequency of J chi segments

The rabbit b9 kappa 1 locus contains 5 joining (J chi) gene segments, only two of which, J chi 1 and J chi 2, are utilized in assembly of a complete variable region gene (as shown by Akimenko, M.-A., Mariamé, B. and Rougeon, F. (1986) Proc. natl. Acad. Sci. (Wash.), 83, 5180-5183). J chi 4 and J chi 5 do not rearrange because of deficient recombination signal sequences. The J chi 3 gene segment is also not rearranged and has a non-functional splice site. In view of the proposed relationship between transcription and rearrangement of immunoglobulin genes, we sought to determine whether splicing of the germline transcript is implicated in the rearrangement process. We addressed this question by introducing mutations in the splice sites of the J chi segments of an unrearranged kappa light chain immunoglobulin transgene. Rearrangement was analysed by polymerase chain reaction on transgenic spleen DNA. We observed that mutation of the splice sites had no effect on the utilization of the J chi gene segments, demonstrating that there is no relationship between splicing and rearrangement.

Mapping of the duplicated rabbit immunoglobulin kappa light chain locus

The rabbit has two isotypic forms of the immunoglobulin kappa light chain, K1 and K2, which probably arose by duplication. In the normal rabbit, only traces of K2 light chains are produced. However, K2 levels are elevated in allotype-suppressed rabbits and in the Basilea strain which does not produce K1 because of a K1 mRNA splice site mutation. Previous cloning and sequencing showed that each isotype has its own set of J kappa genes but it was not known whether the two isotypes utilize shared or separate sets of V kappa genes. In addition, although genetic linkage of allotypes associated with the K1 and K2 genes has been demonstrated, physical linkage had not been previously demonstrated by overlapping cosmid or phage clones. We used pulsed field and transverse alternating field electrophoresis to obtain megabase maps and to estimate the size of the duplication of the rabbit kappa light chain locus. We found that the two C kappa genes are about 1 megabase apart. One explanation for the poor expression of K2, could be great physical distance from V kappa genes. However, we found that there are V kappa, J kappa and C kappa 2 genes within a approximately 105-kb fragment. Thus, physical distance of V kappa from C kappa 2 may not be the basis for poor K2 expression.

Structure of rearranged and germ-line rabbit V kappa genes indicated that the CDR3 is encoded by the V kappa gene

The third complementary-determining regions (CDR3) of rabbit kappa chains are unusually long and the length is more heterogeneous when compared to those of the mouse and the human kappa chains. To study how the rabbit kappa light (L) chain genes create diversity and generate CDR3, we analyzed the structure of a rearranged variable kappa gene (Vr) and the variable (Vg) and joining (Jg) regions of the putative precursor genes. Alignment of the Vr gene sequence with that of the Vg and Jg regions allowed precise determination of the recombination event. Five nucleotides between the recombination point and the J2 heptamer were deleted, indicating flexibility in the recombination producing rabbit kappa chains. The entire Vg is contained in the rearranged product demonstrating that neither a D element nor an N sequence addition are required for the CDR3 formation. Comparison of the Vr and the Vg gene sequences show base substitutions suggesting that somatic mutations may contribute to rabbit kappa L chain diversity.

Rearrangement of the immunoglobulin kappa light chain genes in a b4 rabbit and a Basilea rabbit

The immunoglobulin chi light chain gene family of the rabbit is characterized by the presence of two constant region exons, C chi 1 and C chi 2 encoded at the chi 1 and chi 2 loci, and linked to their own cluster of joining pieces (J chi). The gene segments at the two loci are very unequally expressed. Thus, in domestic rabbits, the immunoglobulin light chains are essentially of the chi 1 type, even though the gene segments at the chi 2 locus are structurally functional. We have investigated the origin of the weak expression of the genes at the chi 2 locus by analysing the pattern of rearrangement of the chi 1 and chi 2 J chi segments in rabbit B-cell populations. Southern blot analysis of B cells isolated from a rabbit expressing chi 1 light chains suggests that the genes at the chi 2 locus underwent very few, if any, rearrangements. However, using more sensitive approaches, it was possible to detect transcripts originating from the rearranged chi 2 locus. In contrast, in B cells isolated from a Basilea rabbit, which cannot express chi 1 chains, Southern blots revealed the rearrangement of the chi 2 genes, whereas the chi 1 rearranged fragments were barely detectable. These results could be explained either by preferential rearrangement of genes at the chi 1 locus or by clonal amplification of only cells producing chi 1. Furthermore, results of Southern blot analysis provide evidence that V-J recombination may be accompanied by an inversion of the intervening DNA region.

Linked genetic markers of the rabbit kappa light chain are not linked to the Tcr beta chain genes

In order to investigate linkage, we used serum allotypes of the two rabbit C kappa isotypes and restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) of the genes for V kappa, C kappa, and T-cell receptor C beta. The inheritance of these genetic markers was studied through backcross and F2 matings. Southern analysis and hybridization of genomic DNA with a C kappa probe detected a 5 kb Pst I fragment linked to expression of the K2bas1 allotype and the presence of the kappa 1bbas gene and a 6.6 kb Pst I fragment linked to the expression of the K1b9 allotype, the presence of the kappa 2bas2 gene and lack of expression of the K2bas1 allotype. A V kappa probe detected a 1.3 kb Eco RI fragment linked to the presence of the kappa 1bbas gene and expression of the K2bas1 allotype. In contrast, the 9 or 14 kb Eco RI RFLP (C beta a or C beta b) detected with a Tcr beta chain probe segregated independently from C kappa allotypes and RFLPs. It has previously been found that C kappa and C beta are also unlinked in man, whereas in the mouse they are linked at a distance of approximately 8 centimorgans.

Evolution of genes for allelic and isotypic forms of immunoglobulin kappa chains and of the genes for T-cell receptor beta chains in rabbits

New insights into the evolution of the families of genes encoding immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors of rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) have come from molecular genetic studies. In contrast to human and mouse, rabbits were shown to have two genes for the constant region of immunoglobulin light chains (C kappa 1 and C kappa 2 isotypes) and complex allelic variants of K1 (allotypes). Although K1 allotype protein sequences differed at up to 41% of the amino acid positions, 3' untranslated, 5', and 3' flanking regions were conserved, and in the coding regions 78-80% of the codons with differences had replacement changes. Proportions of silent changes and changes in noncoding regions were comparable. Thus, in spite of their markedly different protein sequences, the K1b4, b5, and b9 allotypes appeared to be products of allelic genes. Molecular genetic analyses suggested that they may have undergone rapid divergence after an ancestral K2-like gene duplicated. Some rabbits were found to have two similar T-cell receptor C beta genes as do humans and many strains of mice, but others appeared to have three different C beta. In addition, we found allotypic forms of C beta. Some of the C beta allotypic differences occurred at positions where analogous C kappa allotypic differences were found. We also found V beta in mouse and human that were more similar to rabbit V beta than closely linked rabbit genes were to each other. This contrasts with rabbit immunoglobulin VH gene sequences that reflect concerted evolution. The data suggested that T-cell receptor V beta genes duplicated prior to mammalian radiation.

Expression of K2 isotype mRNA in normal and Basilea rabbits

Molecular genetic techniques were used to study the regulated expression of the kappa light chains in the rabbit. Two isotypic kappa genes, kappa 1 and kappa 2, have been identified in the genome of all rabbits; however, the majority of secreted immunoglobulins produced by most domestic rabbits bear only K1 light chains. S1 nuclease protection experiments utilizing a single-stranded cDNA probe encoding the K2 constant region were performed to identify K2 mRNA in normal rabbits and in the mutant Basilea rabbit strain in which K2 light chains were first described. Varying amounts of K2 message were observed in the non-Basilea samples, between 0.05-1% of the K2 RNA found in a comparable preparation of Basilea RNA. Evidence for alternatively spliced messages was also noted. In addition, a K2 oligonucleotide probe is described which will distinguish between the K2 allotypic forms, bas1 and bas2.

Generation of the antibody repertoire in individuals with multiple immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region gene deletions

Antibodies against protein antigens are largely restricted to the IgG1 subclass in man, whereas anti-carbohydrate antibodies, at least in adults, are almost exclusively confined to the IgG2 subclass. In IgG2-deficient donors where the C gamma 2 gene is retained in the genome, antibodies against most polysaccharide antigens are absent. We therefore undertook a study of the antibody repertoire in 11 adult donors with immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region gene deletions, homozygous or heterozygous defects, encompassing the C gamma 2 gene. In all cases, antibodies against polysaccharide antigens were present and restricted to the remaining subclasses (IgG1 and/or IgG3). These results suggest an unrestricted use of the available VH gene repertoire in donors lacking the C gamma 2 gene, and imply that the limited antibody repertoire found in IgG2-deficient individuals with a retained C gamma 2 gene may be a consequence of an altered regulatory mechanism or a structural VH gene defect. However, furthermore, the deletion of multiple C gamma heavy chain constant region genes did not appear to decrease the IgG switch probability as such, since total serum levels of IgG appear to be normal.

Allotype-specific probes. A molecular approach to the study of serologically defined determinants

A new approach to the study of serologically defined immunoglobulin determinants is described. We designed DNA probes which distinguished between the rabbit kappa light chain allotypic sequences in Northern analyses of mRNAs and Southern analyses of genomic DNAs. S1 nuclease protection experiments are described which detect allotype-specific sequences in as little as 100 pg of total RNA. The use of molecular biological techniques overcomes many of the problems inherent in using serological reagents and techniques. In addition, the sensitivity of the assays described here allows the detection of low level expression of the allotypic genes. This work was extended to include the discrimination of the VHa allotypes.

Mutation affecting the expression of immunoglobulin variable regions in the rabbit

We have found a variant of the allotype allele a2 in the rabbit, which presumably arose by mutation, that segregates as expected for an allele at the a locus. This allele is called "ali" and the corresponding rabbit strain is called "Alicia." In heterozygous animals (ali/a1 and ali/a3) the concentration of a2 molecules is lower by a factor of 1000 than in standard a2/a2 homozygotes. In homozygous ali/ali individuals the a2 concentration varies with age--i.e., very low in young rabbits and higher in older ones--but it never reaches normal levels. The low level of a2 is compensated by increased amounts of a-negative molecules. Southern blot analysis did not reveal any gross changes in the intron between JH and C mu (joining region of immunoglobulin heavy chain and constant region of immunoglobulin mu chain) or in the number of VH gene segments encoding a locus specificities. We suggest that the ali phenotype is due to a mutation in a control element.