Restrictions limiting the generation of DNA double strand breaks during chromosomal V(D)J recombination

Single-strand DNA breaks in Ig class switch recombination that depend on UNG but not AID

B lymphocytes switch from secreting IgM to secreting IgG, IgA or IgE through a DNA recombination, class switch recombination (CSR), whose mechanism is incompletely understood. CSR is thought to be triggered by activation-induced deaminase (AID), which is believed to deaminate cytosines to uracil in single-strand regions of switch region DNA. Subsequent excision of uracils by uracil DNA glycosylase (UNG) (product of the UNG gene) generates abasic sites, which are targeted for DNA cleavage, producing DNA breaks that are critical intermediates in CSR. Consistent with this model, CSR-related double-strand breaks (DSBs)--detected by ligation-mediated PCR (LMPCR)--have been reported to be dramatically reduced in B cells from either AID(-/-) or UNG(-/-) mice. Here we examine single-strand breaks (SSBs) using LMPCR and report, surprisingly, that CSR-related anti-sense strand breaks in Sgamma regions are dependent only on UNG, and not AID, suggesting participation of a cytosine deaminase other than AID. This conclusion is supported by the sequences at these DNA breaks, which show a bias for a consensus sequence different from that reported for AID. The SSBs appear to be part of the normal CSR pathway since in B cells in which CSR is blocked by deletion of Smu, the content of Sgamma SSBs is elevated as though the breaks resolve inefficiently owing to the lack of a recombination partner for completing mu-to-gamma CSR. These results suggest a narrower role for AID in CSR than previously recognized and prompt a search for a putative alternative cytosine deaminase participating in CSR.

Chromosomal reinsertion of broken RSS ends during T cell development

The V(D)J recombinase catalyzes DNA transposition and translocation both in vitro and in vivo. Because lymphoid malignancies contain chromosomal translocations involving antigen receptor and protooncogene loci, it is critical to understand the types of “mistakes” made by the recombinase. Using a newly devised assay, we characterized 48 unique TCRβ recombination signal sequence (RSS) end insertions in murine thymocyte and splenocyte genomic DNA samples. Nearly half of these events targeted “cryptic” RSS-like elements. In no instance did we detect target-site duplications, which is a hallmark of recombinase-mediated transposition in vitro. Rather, these insertions were most likely caused by either V(D)J recombination between a bona fide RSS and a cryptic RSS or the insertion of signal circles into chromosomal loci via a V(D)J recombination-like mechanism. Although wild-type, p53, p53 x scid, H2Ax, and ATM mutant thymocytes all showed similar levels of RSS end insertions, core-RAG2 mutant thymocytes showed a sevenfold greater frequency of such events. Thus, the noncore domain of RAG2 serves to limit the extent to which the integrity of the genome is threatened by mistargeting of V(D)J recombination.

Developmental stage-specific regulation of TCR-alpha-chain gene assembly by intrinsic features of the TEA promoter

The TCR delta- and alpha-chain genes lie in a single complex locus, the TCRalpha/delta locus. TCRdelta-chain genes are assembled in CD4(-)CD8(-) (double negative (DN)) thymocytes and TCRalpha-chain genes are assembled in CD4(+)CD8(+) (double positive) thymocytes due, in part, to the developmental stage-specific activities of the TCRdelta and TCRalpha enhancers (Edelta and Ealpha), respectively. Edelta functions with TCRdelta promoters to mediate TCRdelta-chain gene assembly in DN thymocytes. However, Edelta is unable to function with TCRalpha promoters such as the TEA promoter to drive TCRalpha-chain gene assembly in these cells. This is important, because the premature assembly of TCRalpha-chain genes in DN thymocytes would disrupt alphabeta and gammadelta T cell development. The basis for TEA inactivity in DN thymocytes is unclear, because Edelta can activate the Vdelta5 gene segment promoter that lies only 4 kb upstream of TEA promoter. In this study, we use gene targeting to construct a modified TCRalpha/delta locus (TCRalpha/delta(5DeltaT)) in which the TEA promoter lies in the same location as the Vdelta5 gene segment on the wild-type TCRalpha/delta allele. Remarkably, the TEA promoter on this allele exhibits normal developmental stage-specific regulation, being active in double positive thymocytes but not in DN thymocytes as is the case with the Vdelta5 promoter. Thus, the inactivity of the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes is due primarily to intrinsic developmental stage-specific features of the promoter itself and not to its location relative to other cis-acting elements in the locus, such as Edelta.

Defects in coding joint formation in vivo in developing ATM-deficient B and T lymphocytes

Ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM)–deficient lymphocytes exhibit defects in coding joint formation during V(D)J recombination in vitro. Similar defects in vivo should affect both T and B cell development, yet the lymphoid phenotypes of ATM deficiency are more pronounced in the T cell compartment. In this regard, ATM-deficient mice exhibit a preferential T lymphopenia and have an increased incidence of nontransformed and transformed T cells with T cell receptor α/δ locus translocations. We demonstrate that there is an increase in the accumulation of unrepaired coding ends during different steps of antigen receptor gene assembly at both the immunoglobulin and T cell receptor loci in developing ATM-deficient B and T lymphocytes. Furthermore, we show that the frequency of ATM-deficient αβ T cells with translocations involving the T cell receptor α/δ locus is directly related to the number of T cell receptor α rearrangements that these cells can make during development. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that ATM deficiency leads to broad defects in coding joint formation in developing B and T lymphocytes in vivo, and they provide a potential molecular explanation as to why the developmental impact of these defects could be more pronounced in the T cell compartment.

TCR trans-rearrangements: biological significance in antigen recognition vs the role as lymphoma biomarker

V(D)J rearrangements occur within loci of TCR and BCR genes, thus generating the diversity of the AgR repertoire. In addition, interlocus V(D)J rearrangements occur, giving rise to so-called "trans-rearrangements." Such trans-rearrangements increase the diversity of the immune receptor repertoire and can be expressed as functional chimeric TCR proteins on the surface of T cells. Although chimeric receptors are not pathogenic per se, the frequency of AgR trans-rearrangements correlates with the level of genetic instability and thus could be used as a predictive biomarker for lymphoma risk.

V(D)J recombination of chromosomally integrated, wild-type deletional and inversional substrates occur at similar frequencies with no preference for orientation

Efficient and correct recombination of V(D)J substrates results in the generation of antibodies. The RSS substrates are oriented in two directions with respect to each other: deletional and inversional. Deletional recombination results in the formation of the coding joint and excision of the intervening sequences. Inversional recombination retains all the genomic sequences and forms both a coding joint and a signal joint. A bias for deletional recombination has been characterized with specific loci in vivo and recapitulated in experiments using extrachromosomal substrates. We constructed retroviral substrates of RSS in the deletional and inversional orientation. We introduced the substrates into wild-type and scid pre-B cells and measured the frequency of functional recombination in addition to open/shut recombination. We also mutated the RSSs to determine whether mutated sequences influenced orientation bias. We show that pre-B cells recombine the wild-type substrates at a 1.6 ratio of deletion:inversion. Nonamer mutated substrates recombined with a deletional bias whereas heptamer mutated substrates recombined with an inversional bias. A spacer length mutation and drastic mutations in the RSS abolish all recombination. These results suggest that there is no orientation bias with wild-type RSSs but that orientation bias occurs when RSSs are mutated.

Regulation of T-cell receptor beta-chain gene assembly by recombination signals: the beyond 12/23 restriction

Assembly of antigen receptor genes is regulated in several important contexts during lymphocyte development. This regulation occurs through modulation of gene segment accessibility to the V(D)J recombinase and/or at the level of the recombination reaction due, in part, to constraints imposed by recombination signal (RS) sequences. RSs are composed of conserved heptamer and nonamer sequences that flank relatively non-conserved spacer sequences of either 12 or 23 base pairs. Recombination occurs only between RSs of dissimilar spacer lengths, a restriction known as the 12/23 rule. Recently, we have shown that RSs can impose significant constraints on antigen receptor gene assembly beyond enforcing the 12/23 rule. This restriction, termed B12/23, was revealed by analysis of T-cell receptor beta (TCRbeta) locus rearrangements, where Dbeta 12RSs and not Jbeta 12RSs are capable of efficiently targeting Vbeta 23RSs' rearrangement. The B12/23 restriction occurs at or prior to the DNA-cleavage step of the V(D)J recombination reaction, relies on features of the Dbeta 12RSs and Vbeta 23RSs, and is not absolutely dependent on lymphoid-specific factors other than the recombinase-activating gene-1 (RAG-1) and RAG-2 proteins. By preserving Dbeta gene segment utilization, the B12/23 restriction is required, at a minimum, for the generation of a diverse repertoire of TCRbeta chains.

The B12/23 restriction is critically dependent on recombination signal nonamer and spacer sequences

Ag receptor variable region gene assembly is initiated through the formation of a synaptic complex which minimally includes the recombination-activating gene (RAG) 1/2 proteins and a pair of recombination signals (RSs) flanking the recombining gene segments. RSs are composed of conserved heptamer and nonamer sequences flanking relatively nonconserved spacers of 12 or 23 bp. RSs regulate variable region gene assembly within the context of the 12/23 rule which mandates that recombination only occurs between RSs of dissimilar spacer length. RSs can exert additional constraints on variable region gene assembly beyond imposing spacer length requirements. At a minimum this restriction, termed B12/23, is imposed on the Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangement step by the 5' Dbeta RS and is enforced at or before the DNA cleavage step of the V(D)J recombination reaction. In this study, the components of the 5' Dbeta RS required for enforcing the B12/23 rule are assessed on chromosomal substrates in vivo in the context of normal murine thymocyte development and on extrachromosomal substrates induced to undergo recombination in nonlymphoid cell lines. These analyses reveal that the integrity of the nonamer sequence as well as the highly conserved spacer nucleotides of the 5' Dbeta1 RS are critical for enforcing the B12/23 restriction. These findings have important implications for understanding the B12/23 restriction and the manner in which RS synaptic complexes are assembled in vivo.

The T cell receptor beta enhancer promotes access and pairing of Dbeta and Jbeta gene segments during V(D)J recombination

The precise function of cis elements in regulating V(D)J recombination is still controversial. Here, we determined the effect of inactivation of the TCRbeta enhancer (Ebeta) on cleavage and rearrangement of Dbeta1, Dbeta2, Jbeta1, and Jbeta2 gene segments in CD4-CD8- [double-negative (DN)] and CD4+CD8+ [double-positive (DP)] thymocytes. In Ebeta-deficient mice, (i) Dbeta1 rearrangements were more severely impaired than Dbeta2 rearrangements; (ii) most of the Dbeta and Jbeta cleavages and rearrangements occurred in DP, rather than in DN, thymocytes; and (iii) most of the 3' Dbeta1 cleavages were coupled to 5' Dbeta2 cleavages instead of to Jbeta cleavages, resulting in nonstandard Dbeta1-Dbeta2-Jbeta2 joints. These findings suggest that the Ebeta regulates TCRbeta rearrangement by promoting accessibility of Dbeta and Jbeta gene segments in DN thymocytes and proper pairing between Dbeta1 and Jbeta gene segments for cleavage and joining in DP thymocytes.

DNA-Rag Protein Interactions in the Control of Selective D Gene Utilization in the TCRβ Locus

Ordered assembly of Ag receptor genes by VDJ recombination is a key determinant of successful lymphocyte differentiation and function. Control of gene rearrangement has been traditionally viewed as a result of complex reorganization of the nucleochromatin mediated by several nuclear factors. Selective recombination of the variable (V) genes to the diversity (D), but not joining (J), gene segments within the TCRbeta locus has been shown to be controlled by recombination signal (RS) sequences that flank the gene segments. Through ex vivo and in vitro recombination assays, we demonstrate that the Rag proteins can discriminate between the RS of the D and J genes and enforce selective D gene incorporation into the TCRbeta variable domain in the absence of other nuclear factors or chromatin structure. DNA binding studies indicate that discrimination is not simply caused by higher affinity binding of the Rag proteins to the isolated 12RS of the D as opposed to the J genes. Furthermore, we also demonstrate that the 12RS within the TCRbeta locus is functionally inferior to the consensus 12RS. We propose that selective gene segment usage is controlled at the level of differential assembly and/or stability of synaptic RS complexes, and that evolutionary "deterioration" of the RS motifs may have been important to allow the VDJ recombinase to exert autonomous control over gene segment use during gene rearrangement.

Restraining the V(D)J recombinase

Chromosome breakage--a dangerous event that has triggered the evolution of several double-strand break repair pathways--has been co-opted by the immune system as an integral part of B- and T-cell development. This is a daring strategy, as improper repair can be deadly for the cell, if not for the whole organism. Even more daring, however, is the choice of a promiscuous transposase as the nuclease responsible for chromosome breakage, as the possibility of transposition brings an entirely new set of risks. What mechanisms constrain the dangerous potential of the recombinase and preserve genomic integrity during immune-system development?

Evolutionarily conserved pattern of gene segment usage within the mammalian TCRbeta locus

Antigen receptor gene rearrangement is mediated by interactions between the VDJ recombinase and the recombination signal sequences that flank the antigen receptor gene segments. In this report I present phylogenetic analyses that suggest a remarkable evolutionary conservation of the recombination signal sequences flanking some of the orthologous T-cell receptor-beta locus gene segments between human and mouse. Comparison of published data on the usage of the same gene segments between human and mouse indicates similar conservation in the shape of the primary T-cell receptor-beta repertoire. I propose that interactions between the recombinase and its cognate recognition sequences play a hitherto underestimated role in the formation of the specific pattern of the primary, combinatorial antigen receptor repertoire and that this pattern appears to be conserved in diverse mammalian species. Generation of a conserved pattern of the primary T-cell receptor repertoire may be critical for efficient selection of immature T lymphocytes.

Assessing the role of the T cell receptor beta gene enhancer in regulating coding joint formation during V(D)J recombination

To assess the role of the T cell receptor (TCR) beta gene enhancer (Ebeta) in regulating the processing of VDJ recombinase-generated coding ends, we assayed TCRbeta rearrangement of Ebeta-deleted (DeltaEbeta) thymocytes in which cell death is inhibited via expression of a Bcl-2 transgene. Compared with DeltaEbeta, DeltaEbeta Bcl-2 thymocytes show a small accumulation of TCRbeta standard recombination products, including coding ends, that involves the proximal Dbeta-Jbeta and Vbeta14 loci but not the distal 5' Vbeta genes. These effects are detectable in double negative pro-T cells, predominate in double positive pre-T cells, and correlate with regional changes in chromosomal structure during double negative-to-double positive differentiation. We propose that Ebeta, by driving long range nucleoprotein interactions and the control of locus expression and chromatin structure, indirectly contributes to the stabilization of coding ends within the recombination processing complexes. The results also illustrate Ebeta-dependent and -independent changes in chromosomal structure, suggesting distinct modes of regulation of TCRbeta allelic exclusion depending on the position within the locus.

Cutting edge: targeting of V beta to D beta rearrangement by RSSs can be mediated by the V(D)J recombinase in the absence of additional lymphoid-specific factors

Assembly of TCRbeta variable region genes is ordered during thymocyte development with Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangement preceding Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangement. The 5'Dbeta 12-RSS is required to precisely and efficiently target Vbeta rearrangement beyond simply enforcing the 12/23 rule. By prohibiting direct Vbeta to Jbeta rearrangement, this restriction ensures Dbeta gene segment use in the assembly of essentially all TCRbeta variable region genes. In this study, we show that rearrangement of Vbeta 23-RSSs is significantly biased to the Dbeta 12-RSS over Jbeta 12-RSSs on extrachromosomal recombination substrates in nonlymphoid cells that express the recombinase-activating gene-1/2 proteins. These findings demonstrate that targeting of Vbeta to Dbeta rearrangement can be enforced by the V(D)J recombinase in the absence of lymphoid-specific factors other than the recombinase-activating gene-1/2 proteins.

Extrachromosomal recombination substrates recapitulate beyond 12/23 restricted VDJ recombination in nonlymphoid cells

V(D)J recombination occurs efficiently only between gene segments flanked by recombination signals (RSs) containing 12 and 23 base pair spacers (the 12/23 rule). A further limitation "beyond the 12/23 rule" (B12/23) exists at the TCRbeta locus and ensures Dbeta usage. Herein, we show that extrachromosomal V(D)J recombination substrates recapitulate B12/23 restriction in nonlymphoid cells. We further demonstrate that the Vbeta coding flank, the 12-RS heptamer/nonamer, and the 23-RS spacer each can significantly influence B12/23 restriction. Finally, purified core RAG1 and RAG2 proteins (together with HMG2) also reproduce B12/23 restriction in a cell-free system. Our findings indicate that B12/23 restriction of V(D)J recombination is cemented at the level of interactions between the RAG proteins and TCRbeta RS sequences.

The "dispensable" portion of RAG2 is necessary for efficient V-to-DJ rearrangement during B and T cell development

Previous in vitro studies defined the minimal regions of RAG1 and RAG2 essential for V(D)J recombination. In order to characterize the role of the C-terminal "dispensable" portion of RAG2, we generated core-RAG2 knock-in mice. We found that the core-RAG2-containing recombinase complex is selectively defective in catalyzing V-to-DJ rearrangement at the IgH and TCRbeta loci, resulting in partial developmental blocks in B and T lymphopoiesis. Analysis of recombination intermediates showed defects at the cleavage phase of the reaction. We also observed a reduction in overall recombinase activity in core-RAG2-expressing thymocytes, leading us to suggest that the interaction of a defective recombinase with RSS sequences unique to VH and Vbeta gene segments may underlie the specific V-to-DJ rearrangement defect in core-RAG2 mice.