Calcium dependence of the activation and inactivation kinetics of the light-activated phosphodiesterase of retinal rods

RGS9-1 phosphorylation and Ca2+

The duration of photoresponses in vertebrate rods and cones is controlled at the level of GTP hydrolysis by a GTPase accelerating protein (GAP) whose catalytic core is provided by RGS9-1. RGS9-1 is in turn regulated by phosphorylation on serine 475, in a reaction that is dependent on Ca2+. In living mice, the level of phosphorylation at this site is reduced by light. Thus RGS9-1 phosphorylation provides a potential mechanism by which light-regulated changes in intracellular [Ca2+] may feed back on phototransduction through effects on the lifetime of activated G protein and cGMP phosphodiesterase.

The gain of rod phototransduction: reconciliation of biochemical and electrophysiological measurements

We have resolved a central and long-standing paradox in understanding the amplification of rod phototransduction by making direct measurements of the gains of the underlying enzymatic amplifiers. We find that under optimized conditions a single photoisomerized rhodopsin activates transducin molecules and phosphodiesterase (PDE) catalytic subunits at rates of 120-150/s, much lower than indirect estimates from light-scattering experiments. Further, we measure the Michaelis constant, Km, of the rod PDE activated by transducin to be 10 microM, at least 10-fold lower than published estimates. Thus, the gain of cGMP hydrolysis (determined by kcat/Km) is at least 10-fold higher than reported in the literature. Accordingly, our results now provide a quantitative account of the overall gain of the rod cascade in terms of directly measured factors.

Regulation of sensitivity in vertebrate rod photoreceptors by calcium

Over the past decade and a half, there have been great advances in our understanding of how light is transduced into electrical signals by the retinal rod and cone photoreceptors in vertebrates. One essential feature of these sensory neurons is their ability to adapt to background illumination, which allows them to function over a broad range of light intensities. This adaptation appears to arise mostly from negative feedback on phototransduction that is mediated by calcium ions. Recent work has suggested that this feedback is fairly complex, and involves several pathways directed at different components of phototransduction. From direct measurements of these feedback pathways in rods, it is possible to evaluate their relative contributions to the overall sensitivity of the cell. At the same time, these feedback mechanisms, as currently known, appear to be sufficient for explaining the change in sensitivity of rods during adaptation to light.

Modulation of transduction gain in light adaptation of retinal rods

The effect of light adaptation on the period of photocurrent saturation induced by a bright stimulating flash was examined in rod photoreceptors of the larval-stage tiger salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum). Using suction electrodes, photocurrent responses to brief flashes were recorded from single, isolated rods in the presence and absence of steady background illumination. Background light decreased the saturation period (T) measured at fixed flash intensity (fixed If) and in this respect light-adapted the saturating response. Effects of the background on responses to weak (i.e. subsaturating) and bright flashes were compared with changes in a parameter, phi = e-delta T/TR*, where delta T is the decrease in saturation period, and where TR* is the slope of the line that relates T and ln If in a given state of adaptation. Dark- and light-adapted responses to flash intensities IDf and ILf, respectively, exhibited similar absolute peak photocurrent and falling-phase kinetics when IDf and ILf satisfied the relation, IDf = phi (ILf + IbTR*), where Ib is the background intensity. It is argued that phi approximates the relative PDE*/R* gain of transduction, i.e. the relative peak level of activated cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE*) produced by a given, small amount of photoactivated visual pigment (R*). Interpreted on this view, the results imply that light adaptation derives largely from a decrease in PDE*/R gain, rather than from the stimulation of guanylate cyclase activity. The data are consistent with the possibility that modulation of the lifetime of PDE* underlies the background dependence of phi.

Regulation of intracellular cyclic GMP concentration by light and calcium in electropermeabilized rod photoreceptors

This study examines the regulation of cGMP by illumination and by calcium during signal transduction in vertebrate retinal photoreceptor cells. We employed an electropermeabilized rod outer segment (EP-ROS) preparation which permits perfusion of low molecular weight compounds into the cytosol while retaining many of the features of physiologically competent, intact rod outer segments (ROS). When nucleotide-depleted EP-ROS were incubated with MgGTP, time- and dose-dependent increases in intracellular cGMP levels were observed. The steady state cGMP concentration in EP-ROS (0.007 mol cGMP per mol rhodopsin) approached the cGMP concentration in intact ROS. Flash illumination of EP-ROS in a 250-nM free calcium medium resulted in a transient decrease in cGMP levels; this occurred in the absence of changes in calcium concentration. The kinetics of the cGMP response to flash illumination of EP-ROS were similar to that of intact ROS. To further examine the effects of calcium on cGMP metabolism, dark-adapted EP-ROS were incubated with MgGTP containing various concentrations of calcium. We observed a twofold increase in cGMP steady state levels as the free calcium was lowered from 1 microM to 20 nM; this increase was comparable to the behavior of intact ROS. Measurements of guanylate cyclase activity in EP-ROS showed a 3.5-fold increase in activity over this range of calcium concentrations, indicating a retention of calcium regulation of guanylate cyclase in EP-ROS preparations. Flash illumination of EP-ROS in either a 50- or 250-nM free calcium medium revealed a slowing of the recovery time course at the lower calcium concentration. This observation conflicts with any hypothesis whereby a reduction in free calcium concentration hastens the recovery of cytoplasmic cGMP levels, either by stimulating guanylate cyclase activity or by inhibiting phosphodiesterase activity. We conclude that changes in the intracellular calcium concentration during visual transduction may have more complex effects on the recovery of the photoresponse than can be accounted for solely by guanylate cyclase activation.

In retinal cones, membrane depolarization in darkness activates the cGMP-dependent conductance. A model of Ca homeostasis and the regulation of guanylate cyclase

We measured outer segment currents under voltage clamp in solitary, single cone photoreceptors isolated from the retina of striped bass. In darkness, changes in membrane voltage to values more positive than 10 mV activate a time- and voltage-dependent outward current in the outer segment. This dark, voltage-activated current (DVAC) increases in amplitude with a sigmoidal time course up to a steady-state value, reached in 0.75-1.5 s. DVAC is entirely suppressed by light, and its current-voltage characteristics and reversal potential are the same as those of the light-sensitive currents. DVAC, therefore, arises from the activation by voltage in the dark of the light-sensitive, cGMP-gated channels of the cone outer segment. Since these channels are not directly gated by voltage, we explain DVAC as arising from a voltage-dependent decrease in cytoplasmic Ca concentration that, in turn, activates only guanylate cyclase and results in net synthesis of cGMP. This explanation is supported by the finding that the Ca buffer BAPTA, loaded into the cytoplasm of the cone outer segment, blocks DVAC. To link a decrease in cytoplasmic Ca concentration to the synthesis of cGMP and the characteristics of DVAC, we develop a quantitative model that assumes cytoplasmic Ca concentration can be continuously calculated from the balance between passive Ca influx via the cGMP-gated channel and its active efflux via a Na/Ca,K exchanger, and that further assumes that guanylate cyclase is activated by decreasing cytoplasmic Ca concentration with characteristics identical to those described for the enzyme in rods. The model successfully simulates experimental data by adjusting the Ca conductance of the cGMP-gated channels as a function of voltage and the Ca buffering power of the cytoplasm. This success suggests that the activity of guanylate cyclase in cone outer segments is indistinguishable from that in rods.

Rhodopsin phosphorylation as a mechanism of cyclic GMP phosphodiesterase regulation by S-modulin

During light-adaptation by the vertebrate eye, the rods are desensitized and the light response is accelerated. When light is absorbed by the rods, a phosphodiesterase is activated that hydrolyses cyclic GMP. A light-induced decrease in cytoplasmic Ca2+ concentration is part of this light-adaptation process. The protein S-modulin (M(r) 26,000) is known to increase the fraction of light-activated cyclic GMP-phosphodiesterase (PDE) at high Ca2+ concentrations in frog rod photoreceptors. Here I present evidence that S-modulin lengthens the lifetime of active PDE (PDE*) at high Ca2+ concentrations. These S-modulin effects are observed in the physiological range of Ca2+ concentration (30 nM to 1 microM; half-maximum effects at 200-400 nM). At the high Ca2+ concentrations at which S-modulin prolongs the lifetime of PDE*, S-modulin inhibits rhodopsin phosphorylation (half-maximum effect at approximately 100 nM Ca2+). ATP is necessary for the S-modulin effects on PDE activation. I therefore conclude that the Ca(2+)-dependent regulation of PDE by S-modulin is mediated by rhodopsin phosphorylation. This regulation seems to be the principal mechanism of light adaptation in vertebrate photoreceptors.

Amplification and kinetics of the activation steps in phototransduction

We can summarize our investigation of amplification in the activation steps of vertebrate phototransduction as follows. (1) A theoretical analysis of the activation steps of the cGMP cascade shows that after a brief flash of phi photoisomerizations the number of activated PDE molecules should rise as a delayed ramp with slope proportional to phi, and that, as a consequence, the cGMP-activated current should decay as a delayed Gaussian function of time (Eqn. 20). (i) Early in the response to a flash, the normalized response R(t) can be approximated as rising as 1/2 phi At2 (after a short delay), where A is the amplification constant characteristic of the individual photoreceptor. (ii) The delayed ramp behavior of PDE activation and the consequent decline of current in the form of the delayed Gaussian are confirmed by experiments in a variety of photoreceptors; the analysis thus yields estimates of the amplification constant from these diverse photoreceptors. (iii) Eqn. 20 further predicts that the response-intensity relation at any fixed time should saturate exponentially, as has been found experimentally. (2) The amplification constant A can be expressed as the product of amplification factors contributed by the individual activation steps of phototransduction, i.e., A = nu RG cGP beta sub n (Eqns. 9 and 21), where (i) nu RG is the rate of G* production per Rh*; (ii) cGP is the efficiency of the coupling between G* production and PDE* production; (iii) beta sub is the increment in hydrolytic rate constant produced by one PDE*, i.e., a single activated catalytic subunit of PDE; and (iv) n is the Hill coefficient of opening of the cGMP-activated channels. (3) The amplification factor beta sub includes the ratio kcat/Km, which characterizes the hydrolytic activity of the PDE in vivo where cG << Km. Two different analyses based upon photocurrents were developed which provide lower bounds for kcat/Km in vivo; these analyses establish that kcat/Km probably exceeds 10(7) M-1 s-1 (and is likely to be higher) in both amphibian and mammalian rods. Few biochemical studies (other than those using trypsin activation) have yielded such high values. A likely explanation of many of the relatively low biochemical estimates of kcat/Km is that Km may have been overestimated by a factor of about 4 in preparations in which stacks of disks are left intact, due to diffusion with hydrolysis in the stacks.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Light-sensitivity modulating protein in frog rods

Cyclic GMP is the second messenger in the phototransduction mechanism in rod photoreceptors. Light-induced activation of cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE), the hydrolyzing enzyme of cGMP, reduces cytoplasmic cGMP concentration to close the cGMP-activated channel and thereby causes a hyperpolarizing light response. Ca2+ concentration decreases during light-adaptation and this decrease is thought to be at least one of the underlying mechanisms of light-adaptation. Our previous electrophysiological work suggested that PDE in frog rod photoreceptors is regulated by this Ca2+ concentration decrease. In the present work, we isolated a protein that binds to disk membranes at high Ca2+ concentrations. In the presence of this protein (a 26 kDa protein), PDE light sensitivity becomes high at high Ca2+ concentrations. The effect was observed at physiological ranges of Ca2+ concentrations. Thus we could explain high light-sensitivity of photoreceptors under the dark-adapted condition. According to its function, we termed the 26 kDa protein 'sensitivity-modulating protein' or 'S-modulin'. During the purification we noticed that there are additional mechanisms present that may contribute to light-adaptation in frog rod photoreceptors.

Deactivation of visual transduction without guanosine triphosphate hydrolysis by G protein

G proteins couple receptors to their target enzymes in many signal transduction cascades. It has generally been thought that deactivation of such cascades cannot occur without the hydrolysis of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) by G protein. This requirement has now been reexamined in both vertebrate and invertebrate phototransduction. Results indicate that GTP hydrolysis is not required for deactivation. Evidence is presented for an alternative model in which the target enzyme is deactivated by an inhibitory factor that is available even when GTP hydrolysis is blocked.

Biochemical mechanism of light adaptation in vertebrate photoreceptors

Vertebrate photoreceptors can adjust their sensitivity to a wide range of light intensities spanning several orders of magnitude, the phenomenon of which is called light adaptation. Electrophysiological and biochemical studies have revealed that calcium can serve as an intracellular transmitter of light adaptation under the control of cGMP metabolism. After illumination, the cytoplasmic calcium concentration of a photoreceptor decreases, which in turn strongly activates photoreceptor guanylate cyclase. This calcium-dependent effect is mediated by a novel calcium-binding protein (recoverin) and leads to the restoration of the depleted cGMP pool after illumination.

P26-calcium binding protein from bovine retinal photoreceptor cells

The primary structure of bovine retinal calcium binding protein P26 has been determined by parallel analysis of protein and corresponding cDNA. This protein is identical to recovering and shares 59% homology with visinin, a cone specific calcium binding protein from chicken retina. Preliminary data are presented on expression of P26 as a fusion protein in E. coli.

Calcium and light adaptation in retinal photoreceptors

In the past several years there has been great progress in the understanding of the phototransduction process in retinal photoreceptors. Recently, this knowledge has expanded and we now understand the mechanism of background light adaptation in these cells and the role that calcium has to play.

Light adaptation in turtle cones. Testing and analysis of a model for phototransduction

Light adaptation in cones was characterized by measuring the changes in temporal frequency responses to sinusoidal modulation of light around various mean levels spanning a range of four log units. We have shown previously that some aspects of cone adaptation behavior can be accounted for by a biochemical kinetic model for phototransduction in which adaptation is mediated largely by a sigmoidal dependence of guanylate cyclase activity on the concentration of free cytoplasmic Ca2+, ([Ca2+]i) (Sneyd and Tranchina, 1989). Here we extend the model by incorporating electrogenic Na+/K+ exchange, and the model is put to further tests by simulating experiments in the literature. It accounts for (a) speeding up of the impulse response, transition from monophasic to biphasic waveform, and improvement in contrast sensitivity with increasing background light level, I0; (b) linearity of the response to moderate modulations around I0; (c) shift of the intensity-response function (linear vs. log coordinates) with change in I0 (Normann and Perlman, 1979); the dark-adapted curve adheres closely to the Naka-Rushton equation; (d) steepening of the sensitivity vs. I0 function with [Ca2+]i fixed at its dark level, [Ca2+]i dark; (Matthews et al., 1988, 1990); (e) steepening of the steady-state intensity-response function when [Ca2+]i is held fixed at its dark level (Matthews et al., 1988; 1990); (f) shifting of a steep template saturation curve for normalized photocurrent vs. light-step intensity when the response is measured at fixed times and [Ca2+]i is held fixed at [Ca2+]i dark (Nakatani and Yau, 1988). Furthermore, the predicted dependence of guanylate cyclase activity on [Ca2+] closely matches a cooperative inhibition equation suggested by the experimental results of Koch and Stryer (1988) on cyclase activity in bovine rods. Finally, the model predicts that some changes in response kinetics with background light will still be present, even when [Ca2+]i is held fixed at [Ca2]i dark.

Incorporation of chelator into guinea-pig rods shows that calcium mediates mammalian photoreceptor light adaptation

1. The effects of steady light on the sensitivity and kinetics of the photocurrent response were studied in the rod photoreceptors of the guinea-pig, using suction pipette recordings of circulating current. 2. The sensitivity of the flash response decreased with increasing background intensity according to Weber's law. Ultimately for the brightest backgrounds saturation ensued. The recovery phase of the flash response was accelerated by steady light, while the early rising phase was little affected. 3. These results indicate that guinea-pig rods adapt to light in much the same way as do the rods and cones of lower vertebrates. 4. The role of cytoplasmic calcium concentration in this adaptation was studied by incorporation of the calcium chelator bis(o-aminophenoxy)ethane- N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid (BAPTA) into the rod cytoplasm. Superfusion with a solution containing the membrane-permeant acetoxymethyl ester resulted in progressive changes in the response to light. 5. BAPTA incorporation retarded the falling phase of the flash response, thereby increasing receptor sensitivity, but did not affect the early rising phase of the response. BAPTA also slowed the adaptation of the response to steady illumination. 6. These results indicate that cytoplasmic calcium concentration plays a similar role in the light adaptation of guinea-pig rods to that in the adaptation of the rods and cones of lower vertebrates. Calcium therefore appears to act as the messenger of light adaptation in mammalian rods.

Calcium-dependent regulation of cyclic GMP phosphodiesterase by a protein from frog retinal rods

In vertebrate photoreceptors, light reduces cyclic GMP concentration and closes cGMP-activated channels to induce a hyperpolarizing response. As Ca2+ can permeate the channels and the Na(+)-Ca2+ exchanger continuously extrudes Ca2+, closure of the channel results in a reduction of the inter-rod Ca2+ concentration. This is believed to be one of the mechanisms of light-adaptation produced by activation of guanylate cyclase. Effects of Ca2+ on the cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE) have been reported, but their physiological significance has remained unclear. We have perfused the inside-out preparation of a frog rod outer segment (I/O ROS, originally termed truncated ROS, and find that Ca2+ in a physiological range regulates the light-activation of PDE. Therefore, PDE regulation by Ca2+ must be involved in light-adaptation in rods. The effect is mediated by a newly found protein which binds to disk membranes at high Ca2+ concentrations and prolongs PDE activation.

Calcium and the mechanism of light adaptation in vertebrate photoreceptors

Vertebrate photoreceptors transduce the absorption of light into a hyperpolarizing change in membrane potential. The mechanism of transduction is becoming fairly well understood and has been shown to occur via a G protein-coupled decrease in cyclic GMP. Attention is now turning to the way the enzymatic machinery in the outer segment of the photoreceptor cell is modulated during light adaptation. Recent studies show that light adaptation cannot occur if changes in the concentration of cytoplasmic free calcium in the outer segment are prevented, suggesting that calcium functions as a second messenger in sensitivity regulation.

Effect of bleached rhodopsin on signal amplification in rod visual receptors

Bleaching of rhodopsin markedly desensitizes the vertebrate visual system during a subsequent period of dark adaptation. Previous studies have indicated an origin of bleaching desensitization in the visual pigment itself, but have not identified the mechanism of action. A candidate for the site at which densensitization is initially expressed is the activation of transducin (formation of T*) on the rod disk membranes; this reaction directly involves rhodopsin in its photoactivated (R*) form and mediates initial amplification of the visual signal (reviewed in refs 7-9). We have analysed the effect of bleaching on the sensitivity of a flash-induced light-scattering signal known to monitor the disk-based amplifier, and which has been established as specifically monitoring transducin activation. We have recorded this signal from functioning retinal rods in situ ('ATR' signal) and find that bleaches inducing a pronounced, sustained loss in rod electrophysiological sensitivity do not alter the sensitivity of the ATR response after correction for reduced quantum catch. Our results indicate that the biochemical gain of the R*----T* transduction stage remains unchanged in the presence of bleached pigment and implicate a subsequent reaction as the first to show a sustained, bleaching-dependent gain reduction.

Cyclic GMP and calcium: the internal messengers of excitation and adaptation in vertebrate photoreceptors

The roles of cyclic GMP (cGMP) and calcium (Ca2+) in vertebrate rod phototransduction are reviewed, with the emphasis on developments since the discovery of the cGMP-activated conductance of the rod outer segment. The first hypothesis subjected to critical examination is that cGMP acts as the sole internal messenger of excitation. This hypothesis is evaluated with a formal, quantitative model of the biochemical actions of cGMP. Application of the model shows a remarkable agreement between independent electrophysiological and biochemical measurements of the resting dark amounts of (1) total cGMP (2) free cGMP (3) fraction of open cGMP-activated channels and (4) the rate of cGMP hydrolysis. The second hypothesis examined is that Ca2+ acts as an internal messenger in rod light adaptation. Recent electrophysiological evidence has shown minimization of the normal light-induced reduction of free Ca2+ prevents rods from exhibiting the change in sensitivity and speed characteristic of light adaptation. Physiological effects, formerly attributed to a role of calcium as an excitational messenger are shown to be consistent with a biochemical model in which Ca2+ serves as the cytoplasmic signal in a powerful feedback loop that acts to restore the concentration of cGMP both during and after exposure to light. Residual problems facing the "cGMP cascade theory of phototransduction" are reviewed. Issues are itemized that will have to be resolved quantitatively before it will be possible to develop a fully comprehensive theory of photoreceptor excitation, restoration and adaptation combining the roles of Ca2+ and cGMP.