Association between secondary mutations in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease and therapeutic outcome

Mortality of treated HIV-1 positive individuals according to viral subtype in Europe and Canada: collaborative cohort analysis

OBJECTIVES

To estimate prognosis by viral subtype in HIV-1-infected individuals from start of antiretroviral therapy (ART) and after viral failure.

DESIGN

Collaborative analysis of data from eight European and three Canadian cohorts.

METHODS

Adults (N>20 000) who started triple ART between 1996 and 2012 and had data on viral subtype were followed for mortality. We estimated crude and adjusted (for age, sex, regimen, CD4 cell count, and AIDS at baseline, period of starting ART, stratified by cohort, region of origin and risk group) mortality hazard ratios (MHR) by subtype. We estimated MHR subsequent to viral failure defined as two HIV-RNA measurements greater than 500 copies/ml after achieving viral suppression.

RESULTS

The most prevalent subtypes were B (15 419; 74%), C (2091; 10%), CRF02AG (1057; 5%), A (873; 4%), CRF01AE (506; 2.4%), G (359; 1.7%), and D (232; 1.1%). Subtypes were strongly patterned by region of origin and risk group. During 104 649 person-years of observation, 1172/20 784 patients died. Compared with subtype B, mortality was higher for subtype A, but similar for all other subtypes. MHR for A versus B were 1.13 (95% confidence interval 0.85,1.50) when stratified by cohort, increased to 1.78 (1.27,2.51) on stratification by region and risk, and attenuated to 1.59 (1.14,2.23) on adjustment for covariates. MHR for A versus B was 2.65 (1.64,4.28) and 0.95 (0.57,1.57) for patients who started ART with CD4 cell count below, or more than, 100 cells/μl, respectively. There was no difference in mortality between subtypes A, B and C after viral failure.

CONCLUSION

Patients with subtype A had worse prognosis, an observation which may be confounded by socio-demographic factors.

Short communication: low prevalence of genotypic drug resistance mutations among antiretroviral-naive HIV type 1 patients in Malaysia

To assess the prevalence of mutations associated with drug resistance in antiretroviral-naive patients in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, genotypic resistance testing was conducted among drug-naive HIV-1 patients attending the University Malaya Medical Center (UMMC) between July 2003 and June 2004. Reverse transcriptase (RT) and protease genes of plasma virions were sequenced from 100 individuals. The majority of the patients were recently diagnosed. Codons 20-255 of the RT and 1-96 of the protease gene were examined for major and minor mutations associated with antiretroviral resistance reported by the International AIDS Society- USA (IAS-USA) Drug Resistance Mutations Group. The prevalence of patients with at least one major mutation conferring drug resistance was 1%, with only one patient having a Y181C amino acid substitution in the RT gene that confers high-level resistance to nevirapine and delavirdine. Minor mutations were detected in high prevalence in the protease gene. Amino acid substitutions I13V, E35D, and M36I were associated with CRF01_AE while L63P, V77I, and I93L were associated with subtype B. Baseline prevalence of major mutations associated with resistance to antiretroviral drugs was low among antiretroviral-naive HIV-1 patients, suggesting that routine drug resistance testing may be unnecessary for all individuals newly diagnosed with HIV or all patients beginning antiretroviral therapy.

Polymorphism and drug-selected mutations in the protease gene of human immunodeficiency virus type 2 from patients living in Southern France

The susceptibility of human immunodeficiency virus type 2 (HIV-2) to protease inhibitors (PI) is largely unknown. We studied HIV-2 protease genes from 21 HIV-2-infected patients who were exposed or not exposed to PI. The aim of this study was (i). to characterize the polymorphism of HIV-2 protease in the absence of drug, (ii). to know whether the HIV-2 protease gene naturally harbors HIV-1 drug resistance codons, and (iii). to identify mutations emerging under PI-selective pressure. Sixty-five HIV-2 RNA or proviral DNA samples were directly sequenced from the plasma or peripheral blood mononuclear cells of 8 patients who had received PI and 13 patients who had never received any antiretroviral. In untreated patients, the highest amino acid variability in HIV-2 protease was observed at positions 14, 40, 43, 46, 65 and 70, and seven codons (10V, 32I, 36I, 46I, 47V, 71V, and 73A) associated with drug resistance in HIV-1 were highly prevalent. In addition, at six positions (positions 7, 46, 62, 71, 90, and 99), the amino acid variability or the amino acid frequencies or both differed significantly in PI-treated and untreated patients, suggesting that mutations 7K-->R, 46V-->I, 62V-->A/T, 71V-->I, 90L-->M and 99L-->F were occurring under PI-selective pressure. At these positions, at least one sample simultaneously harbored both wild-type and mutated codons, while substitutions at positions 62, 71, 90, and 99 were confirmed in a longitudinal analysis. Moreover, the presence of codons 46I and 99F in the absence of drug in HIV-2 subtype B proteases may reflect natural resistance to PI. In conclusion, the present study revealed that HIV-2 strains harbor specific patterns of natural polymorphism and resistance.

Secondary Mutations M36I and A71V in the Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Protease Can Provide an Advantage for the Emergence of the Primary Mutation D30N

Development of resistance mutations in enzymatic targets of human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1) hampers the ability to provide adequate therapy. Of special interest is the effect mutations outside the active site of HIV-1 protease have on inhibitor binding and virus viability. We engineered protease mutants containing the active site mutation D30N alone and with the nonactive site polymorphisms M36I and/or A71V. We determined the K(i) values for the inhibitors nelfinavir, ritonavir, indinavir, KNI272, and AG1776 as well as the catalytic efficiency of the mutants. Single and double mutation combinations exhibited a decrease in catalytic efficiency, while the triple mutant displayed catalytic efficiency greater than that of the wild type. Variants containing M36I or A71V alone did not display a significant change in binding affinities to the inhibitors tested. The variant containing mutation D30N displayed a 2-6-fold increase in K(i) for all inhibitors tested, with nelfinavir showing the greatest increase. The double mutants containing a combination of mutations D30N, M36I, and A71V displayed -0.5-fold to +6-fold changes in the K(i) of all inhibitors tested, with ritonavir and nelfinavir most affected. Only the triple mutant showed a significant increase (>10-fold) in K(i) for inhibitor nelfinavir, ritonavir, or AG-1776 displaying 22-, 19-, or 15-fold increases, respectively. Our study shows that the M36I and A71V mutations provide a greater level of inhibitor cross-resistance combined with active site mutation D30N. M36I and A71V, when present as natural polymorphisms, could aid the virus in developing active site mutations to escape inhibitor binding while maintaining catalytic efficiency.

Brazilian Network for HIV Drug Resistance Surveillance (HIV-BResNet): a survey of chronically infected individuals

OBJECTIVE

To study the prevalence of HIV drug resistance mutations and subtype distribution in a Brazilian drug-naive population. Asymptomatic, drug-naive HIV-1-infected individuals were targeted in 13 voluntary counseling and testing centers spread around the country.

METHODS

Plasma viral RNA was extracted from 535 HIV-1-positive subjects. Protease (PR) and reverse transcriptase (RT) genomic regions were sequenced for subtype determination and analysis of drug resistance mutations.

RESULTS

Eight samples (2.24 %) showed primary mutations related to protease inhibitor (PI) resistance, eight (2.36%) to nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTI) and seven (2.06%) to non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTI). Accessory mutations were found in the PR gene at the following positions: L63P/V/T/A/I [153/345 (44.3%)], M36I/L [149/345 (43.2%)], L10I/F/V [82/345 (23.8%)], V77I [60/345 (17.4%)], A71V/T [11/345 (3.2%)], K20M/R [10/345 (2.9%)], and V82I [4/345 (1.2%)]. Mutations known to be associated with reduced sensitivity to NRTI or NNRTI (V118I, E44D, K219R, T69A, and V75L) were found in a low prevalence (0.6-2.4%). A high proportion of the isolates from subtype C was found in the southern states. Subtype F-related viruses were the main non-B variant in the rest of the country.

CONCLUSIONS

Brazil has a low prevalence of drug-resistant strains circulating among recently diagnosed individuals. However, there was an increase in these rates compared with similar studies performed with samples collected in Brazil from 1996 to 1998. Continued surveys are required to detect trends in these rates, but routine genotypic testing in the drug-naive population prior to antiretroviral initiation is not required in Brazil.