Calibration of Kodak EDR2 film for patient skin dose assessment in cardiac catheterization procedures

Application of Gafchromic film in the study of dosimetry methods in CT phantoms

Gafchromic film has been used for measurement of computed tomography (CT) dose distributions within phantoms. The film was calibrated in the beam from a superficial therapy unit and the accuracy confirmed by comparison with measurements with a 20 mm long ionisation chamber. The results have been used to investigate approaches to CT dosimetry. Dose profiles were recorded within standard CT head and body phantoms and scatter tail data fitted to exponential functions and extrapolated to predict dose levels in longer phantoms. The data have been used to simulate both CT dose index (CTDI) measurements with ionisation chambers of differing length and measurements of cumulative doses with a 20 mm chamber for scans of varying length. The results show that the length of a pencil ionisation chamber is the most significant factor affecting measurements of weighted CTDI (CTDI(w)) and a 100 mm chamber would record 50-61% of the dose measured with a 450 mm one. The cumulative dose measured at the centre of a 150 mm long body phantom records over 70% of the equilibrium dose from a helical scan of a longer phantom. For routine CT dosimetry tests, the determination of correction factors could allow measurements with a 100 mm chamber to be used to derive the CTDI that would be recorded with a longer chamber, and cumulative doses measured with a 20 mm chamber in shorter phantoms to be used to calculate equilibrium doses for helical scans.

A study of the relationship between peak skin dose and cumulative air kerma in interventional neuroradiology and cardiology

A study of peak skin doses (PSDs) during neuroradiology and cardiology interventional procedures has been carried out using Gafchromic XR-RV2 film. Use of mosaics made from squares held in cling film has allowed doses to the head to be mapped successfully. The displayed cumulative air kerma (CAK) has been calibrated in terms of cumulative entrance surface dose (CESD) and results indicate that this can provide a reliable indicator of the PSD in neuroradiology. Results linking PSD to CESD for interventional cardiology were variable, but CAK is still considered to provide the best option for use as an indicator of potential radiation-induced effects. A CESD exceeding 3 Gy is considered a suitable action level for triggering follow-up of patients in neuroradiology and cardiology for possible skin effects. Application of dose action levels defined in this way would affect 8% of neurological embolisation procedures and 5% of cardiology ablation and multiple stent procedures at the hospitals where the investigations were carried out. A close relationship was observed between CESD and dose-area product (DAP) for particular types of procedure, and DAPs of 200-300  Gy cm(2) could be used as trigger levels where CAK readings were not available. The DAP value would depend on the mean field size and would need to be determined for each application.

Comparison of measured and calculated skin doses in CT-guided interventional procedures

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to compare theoretic estimations of the dose to the patient's skin during CT-guided interventional procedures with measurements performed using radiation therapy verification films.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In each of the 12 interventions studied, a Kodak EDR2 film was positioned under the patient's anatomic area of concern. After processing, each film was scanned with a medical-grade scanner to produce a digital image from which the gray-scale profiles were obtained using the appropriate software. From these data and respective data from a series of calibration films, the entrance skin dose (ESD) profiles were derived. These ESD profiles were compared with the ESD profiles produced using a theoretic model and its revised version, which utilizes the DICOM data of each slice (i.e., tube potential, tube loading, slice thickness, slice location, pitch, and table height) and air-kerma output measurements from the CT tube.

RESULTS

In general, the ESD profiles calculated using the revised theoretic method were in better agreement with the profiles derived from the verification films than the ESD profiles derived from the original theoretic method. The deviations from the peak skin doses (PSDs) derived from the digital film images were within -3% and 27% of the PSDs derived from the verification films. The respective deviations of the ESD profiles calculated with the original theoretic method were quite larger.

CONCLUSION

The theoretic model provides a useful tool for estimating skin doses during CT-guided interventions with a reasonable level of accuracy. With further refinement and a little automation this method could be implemented for daily use.

Patient skin dose assessment during CT-guided interventional procedures

The purpose of this study was to investigate patient skin doses in the most frequent computed tomography-guided interventional radiology procedures. The study includes 14 abdominal biopsies and 15 radiofrequency (RF) ablations. Patient skin dose was assessed by slow verification films. The technical factors recorded were: tube kilovoltage (kVp), tube load (mAs), slice thickness and the total number of slices (S). The median value of maximum entrance skin dose (ESD(M)) in biopsy was 108 mGy (9.5-282 mGy). S had a range of 4-152 with a median of 44 slices. Significant correlation was found between S and dose (r = 0.80). Median ESD(M) in RF ablation was 238 mGy (104-500 mGy). S had a range of 108-175 with a median of 155 slices. No significant correlation was found between S and dose. The large range of results show that a more extensive investigation should be performed. In summary, diagnostic procedures such as biopsy present patient skin doses that are relatively low. On the other hand, patient skin dose in RF ablation can be high and can reach values higher than the value that a slow verification film is capable of measuring (1.2 Gy). For these procedures, an alternative method should be investigated.

Useful optical density range in film dosimetry: limitations due to noise and saturation

The optical density (OD) range for the scanners used in film dosimetry is limited due to saturation and noise. As the OD increases, saturation causes the rate of change of the output with respect to the input to become smaller, while at the same time noise remains fairly constant or increases. The combined effect leads to a degradation of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at high optical densities. In this study, the uncertainty in the OD measurement, d(m), is expressed as a function of the optical density d. The functional relationship obtained gives the amplitude w of an interval around d in which d(m) will be found with a given probability p. The relationship w = w(d, p) is later used to determine which OD ranges fulfil a set of requirements on w and p. As an application of the procedure, the noise and saturation characteristics of a commercial film digitizer system are measured. Their contribution to the uncertainties of the dosimetric procedure is reported, and the data are used to provide an optical density range for a given uncertainty and confidence level associated with the digitizer. These data can be further combined with the data from other sources of noise such as film noise in order to estimate the final uncertainty of the dosimetric process.

TG-69: Radiographic film for megavoltage beam dosimetry

TG-69 is a task group report of the AAPM on the use of radiographic film for dosimetry. Radiographic films have been used for radiation dosimetry since the discovery of x-rays and have become an integral part of dose verification for both routine quality assurance and for complex treatments such as soft wedges (dynamic and virtual), intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), image guided radiation therapy (IGRT), and small field dosimetry like stereotactic radiosurgery. Film is convenient to use, spatially accurate, and provides a permanent record of the integrated two dimensional dose distributions. However, there are several challenges to obtaining high quality dosimetric results with film, namely, the dependence of optical density on photon energy, field size, depth, film batch sensitivity differences, film orientation, processing conditions, and scanner performance. Prior to the clinical implementation of a film dosimetry program, the film, processor, and scanner need to be tested to characterize them with respect to these variables. Also, the physicist must understand the basic characteristics of all components of film dosimetry systems. The primary mission of this task group report is to provide guidelines for film selection, irradiation, processing, scanning, and interpretation to allow the physicist to accurately and precisely measure dose with film. Additionally, we present the basic principles and characteristics of film, processors, and scanners. Procedural recommendations are made for each of the steps required for film dosimetry and guidance is given regarding expected levels of accuracy. Finally, some clinical applications of film dosimetry are discussed.

A mathematical model for patient skin dose assessment in cardiac catheterization procedures

A mathematical model has been developed for the assessment of patient skin doses from cardiac catheterization procedures. This uses exposure and projection data stored in the DICOM image files. Since these contain only information about the acquisition runs, a correction is needed to estimate and include the contribution from fluoroscopy. Maximum skin doses calculated by the model were found to correlate well with those measured on Kodak EDR2 film. Three methods for including the contribution from fluoroscopy were investigated, and all successfully identified patients receiving skin doses in excess of 1 Gy. It is hoped to automate this tool for routine assessment of skin doses in our cardiac catheterization laboratories.

Kodak EDR2 film for patient skin dose assessment in cardiac catheterization procedures

Patient skin doses were measured using Kodak EDR2 film for 20 coronary angiography (CA) and 32 percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) procedures. For CA, all skin doses were well below 1 Gy. However, 23% of PTCA patients received skin doses of 1 Gy or more. Dose-area product (DAP) was also recorded and was found to be an inadequate indicator of maximum skin dose. Practical compliance with ICRP recommendations requires a robust method for skin dosimetry that is more accurate than DAP and is applicable over a wider dose range than EDR2 film.

Analysis of the sources of uncertainty for EDR2 film-based IMRT quality assurance

In our institution, patient‐specific quality assurance (QA) for intensity‐modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) is usually performed by measuring the dose to a point using an ion chamber and by measuring the dose to a plane using film. In order to perform absolute dose comparison measurements using film, an accurate calibration curve should be used. In this paper, we investigate the film response curve uncertainty factors, including film batch differences, film processor temperature effect, film digitization, and treatment unit. In addition, we reviewed 50 patient‐specific IMRT QA procedures performed in our institution in order to quantify the sources of error in film‐based dosimetry. Our study showed that the EDR2 film dosimetry can be done with less than 3% uncertainty. The EDR2 film response was not affected by the choice of treatment unit provided the nominal energy was the same. This investigation of the different sources of uncertainties in the film calibration procedure can provide a better understanding of the film‐based dosimetry and can improve quality control for IMRT QA.

PACS numbers: 87.86.Cd, 87.53.Xd, 87.57.Nk

Radiosensitive Functional Dye: Clinical Application for Estimation of Patient Skin Dose

Institutional review board approval and informed patient consent were obtained. The purpose of the study was to prospectively evaluate the use of radiosensitive indicators to estimate patient entrance skin dose (ESD). Forty-six patients wore a jacket with 48 or 52 indicators adhered to the back during percutaneous coronary interventions; they had eight additional indicators on their upper arms. The patients' ESDs were calculated according to the change in color of the indicators. There were good correlations between the ESDs estimated by using color measurements performed with an optical instrument and those estimated at visual observation (P < .001) and between the ESDs estimated by using a thermoluminescent dosimeter and those estimated by using color measurements (P < .001). The radiosensitive indicator method seems to be useful for estimating ESDs and their distribution during percutaneous coronary intervention; however, visual observation is reliable for estimating doses of up to 5 Gy only. (c) RSNA, 2006.