Temperature dependence of DNA translocations through solid-state nanopores

Analysis of Nanopore Data: Classification Strategies for an Unbiased Curation of Single-Molecule Events from DNA Nanostructures

Nanopores are versatile single-molecule sensors that are being used to sense increasingly complex mixtures of structured molecules with applications in molecular data storage and disease biomarker detection. However, increased molecular complexity presents additional challenges to the analysis of nanopore data, including more translocation events being rejected for not matching an expected signal structure and a greater risk of selection bias entering this event curation process. To highlight these challenges, here, we present the analysis of a model molecular system consisting of a nanostructured DNA molecule attached to a linear DNA carrier. We make use of recent advances in the event segmentation capabilities of Nanolyzer, a graphical analysis tool provided for nanopore event fitting, and describe approaches to the event substructure analysis. In the process, we identify and discuss important sources of selection bias that emerge in the analysis of this molecular system and consider the complicating effects of molecular conformation and variable experimental conditions (e.g., pore diameter). We then present additional refinements to existing analysis techniques, allowing for improved separation of multiplexed samples, fewer translocation events rejected as false negatives, and a wider range of experimental conditions for which accurate molecular information can be extracted. Increasing the coverage of analyzed events within nanopore data is not only important for characterizing complex molecular samples with high fidelity but is also becoming essential to the generation of accurate, unbiased training data as machine-learning approaches to data analysis and event identification continue to increase in prevalence.

Dwell Time Prolongation and Identification of Single Nucleotides Passing through a Solid-State Nanopore by Using Ammonium Sulfate Aqueous Solution

The ionic current blockades when poly(dT)₆₀ or dNTPs passed through SiN nanopores in an aqueous solution containing (NH₄)₂SO₄ were investigated. The dwell time of poly(dT)₆₀ in the nanopores in an aqueous solution containing (NH₄)₂SO₄ was significantly longer compared to that in an aqueous solution that did not contain (NH₄)₂SO₄. This dwell time prolongation effect due to the aqueous solution containing (NH₄)₂SO₄ was also confirmed when dCTP passed through the nanopores. In addition, when the nanopores were fabricated via dielectric breakdown in the aqueous solution containing (NH₄)₂SO₄, the dwell time prolongation effect for dCTP still occurred even after the aqueous solution was displaced with the aqueous solution without (NH₄)₂SO₄. Furthermore, we measured the ionic current blockades when the four types of dNTPs passed through the same nanopore, and the four types of dNTPs could be statistically identified according to their current blockade values.

Solid-State Quad-Nanopore Array for High-Resolution Single-Molecule Analysis and Discrimination

The ability to detect and distinguish biomolecules at the single-molecule level is at the forefront of today's biomedicine and analytical chemistry research. Increasing the dwell time of individual biomolecules in the sensing spot can greatly enhance the sensitivity of single-molecule methods. This is particularly important in solid-state nanopore sensing, where the detection of small molecules is often limited by the transit dwell time and insufficient temporal resolution. Here, a quad-nanopore is introduced, a square array of four nanopores (with a space interval of 30-50 nm) to improve the detection sensitivity through electric field manipulation in the access region. It is shown that dwell times of short DNA strands (200 bp) are prolonged in quad-nanopores as compared to single nanopores of the same diameter. The dependence of dwell times on the quad-pore spacing is investigated and it is found that the "retarding effect" increases with decreasing space intervals. Furthermore, ultra-short DNA (50 bp) detection is demonstrated using a 10 nm diameter quad-nanopore array, which is hardly detected by a single nanopore. Finally, the general utility of quad-nanopores has been verified by successful discrimination of two kinds of small molecules, metal-organic cage and bovine serum albumin (BSA).

Polymer Translocation and Nanopore Sequencing: A Review of Advances and Challenges

Various biological processes involve the translocation of macromolecules across nanopores; these pores are basically protein channels embedded in membranes. Understanding the mechanism of translocation is crucial to a range of technological applications, including DNA sequencing, single molecule detection, and controlled drug delivery. In this spirit, numerous efforts have been made to develop polymer translocation-based sequencing devices, these efforts include findings and insights from theoretical modeling, simulations, and experimental studies. As much as the past and ongoing studies have added to the knowledge, the practical realization of low-cost, high-throughput sequencing devices, however, has still not been realized. There are challenges, the foremost of which is controlling the speed of translocation at the single monomer level, which remain to be addressed in order to use polymer translocation-based methods for sensing applications. In this article, we review the recent studies aimed at developing control over the dynamics of polymer translocation through nanopores.

Ionic heat dissipation in solid-state pores

Energy dissipation in solid-state nanopores is an important issue for their use as a sensor for detecting and analyzing individual objects in electrolyte solution by ionic current measurements. Here, we report on evaluations of heating via diffusive ion transport in the nanoscale conduits using thermocouple-embedded SiN_x pores. We found a linear rise in the nanopore temperature with the input electrical power suggestive of steady-state ionic heat dissipation in the confined nanospace. Meanwhile, the heating efficiency was elucidated to become higher in a smaller pore due to a rapid decrease in the through-water thermal conduction for cooling the fluidic channel. The scaling law suggested nonnegligible influence of the heating to raise the temperature of single-nanometer two-dimensional nanopores by a few kelvins under the standard cross-membrane voltage and ionic strength conditions. The present findings may be useful in advancing our understanding of ion and mass transport phenomena in nanopores.

Screening for Group A Streptococcal Disease via Solid-State Nanopore Detection of PCR Amplicons

Single-molecule detection methods are becoming increasingly important for diagnostic applications. Practical early detection of disease requires sensitivity down to the level of single copies of the targeted biomarkers. Of the candidate technologies that can address this need, solid-state nanopores show great promise as digital sensors for single-molecule detection. Here, we present work detailing the use of solid-state nanopores as downstream sensors for a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based assay targeting group A streptococcus (strep A), which can be readily extended to detect any pathogen that can be identified with a short nucleic acid sequence. We demonstrate that with some simple modifications to the standard PCR reaction mixture, nanopores can be used to reliably identify strep A in clinical samples. We also discuss methodological best practices for both adapting PCR-based assays to solid-state nanopore readout and analytical approaches by which to decide on sample status.

Shaped DNA origami carrier nanopore translocation influenced by aptamer based surface modification

DNA origami is widely used as a translocation carrier to assist solid-state nanopore analysis, e.g., soft linear origami carrier and special-shaped origami structures. In the linear origami carriers based nanopore sensing, molecular modifications induced tiny structural and charge changes, can result in significant variations on translocation signals to facilitating single-molecule sensing. However, an understanding on the influences of surface modifications on special-shaped DNA origami structures during solid-state (SS) nanopores translocation is still far elusive. Herein, we reported a surface modification strategy using aptamer/target-binding to influence the translocation of the shaped origami ribbon carrier through SS-nanopore. Our measurements indicate that the translocation signal variations can respond to ATP/aptamer binding on the carrier surface, even to the surface modifications induced by spatial distributions and enzyme catalysis. Meanwhile, the results also suggest a possibility to identify small spatial and electronic changes on DNA origami by using SS-nanopore. We envision that the surface aptamer-binding influenced origami translocation strategy could find more applications in origami carrier assisted SS-nanopore sensing and detection.

From Water Solutions to Ionic Liquids with Solid State Nanopores as a Perspective to Study Transport and Translocation Phenomena

Solid state nanopores are single-molecular devices governed by nanoscale physics with a broad potential for technological applications. However, the control of translocation speed in these systems is still limited. Ionic liquids are molten salts which are commonly used as alternate solvents enabling the regulation of the chemical and physical interactions on solid-liquid interfaces. While their combination can be challenging to the understanding of nanoscopic processes, there has been limited attempts on bringing these two together. While summarizing the state of the art and open questions in these fields, several major advances are presented with a perspective on the next steps in the investigations of ionic-liquid filled nanopores, both from a theoretical and experimental standpoint. By analogy to aqueous solutions, it is argued that ionic liquids and nanopores can be combined to provide new nanofluidic functionalities, as well as to help resolve some of the pertinent problems in understanding transport phenomena in confined ionic liquids and providing better control of the speed of translocating analytes.

Constricted Apertures for Dynamic Trapping and Micro-/Nanoscale Discrimination Based on Recapture Kinetics

Sensing via analyte passage through a constricted aperture is a powerful and robust technology which is being utilized broadly, from DNA sequencing to single virus and cell characterization. Micro- and nanoscale structures typically translocate a constricted aperture, or pore, using electrophoretic force. In the present work, we explore the advances in metrology which can be achieved through rapid directional switching of hydrodynamic forces. Interestingly, multipass measurements of microscale and nanoscale structures achieve cell discrimination. We explore this cell-discrimination phenomenon as well as other features of hydrodynamic focusing such as dynamic trapping and discrete interval sensing.

Solid-state nanopores towards single-molecule DNA sequencing

Nanopore DNA sequencing offers a new paradigm owing to its extensive potential for long-read, high-throughput detection of nucleotide modification and direct RNA sequencing. Given the remarkable advances in protein nanopore sequencing technology, there is still a strong enthusiasm in exploring alternative nanopore-sequencing techniques, particularly those based on a solid-state nanopore using a semiconductor material. Since solid-state nanopores provide superior material robustness and large-scale integrability with on-chip electronics, they have the potential to surpass the limitations of their biological counterparts. However, there are key technical challenges to be addressed: the creation of an ultrasmall nanopore, fabrication of an ultrathin membrane, control of the ultrafast DNA speed and detection of four nucleotides. Extensive research efforts have been devoted to resolving these issues over the past two decades. In this review, we briefly introduce recent updates regarding solid-state nanopore technologies towards DNA sequencing. It can be envisioned that emerging technologies will offer a brand new future in DNA-sequencing technology.

Solid-state nanopores towards single-molecule DNA sequencing

Nanopore DNA sequencing offers a new paradigm owing to its extensive potential for long-read, high-throughput detection of nucleotide modification and direct RNA sequencing. Given the remarkable advances in protein nanopore sequencing technology, there is still a strong enthusiasm in exploring alternative nanopore-sequencing techniques, particularly those based on a solid-state nanopore using a semiconductor material. Since solid-state nanopores provide superior material robustness and large-scale integrability with on-chip electronics, they have the potential to surpass the limitations of their biological counterparts. However, there are key technical challenges to be addressed: the creation of an ultrasmall nanopore, fabrication of an ultrathin membrane, control of the ultrafast DNA speed and detection of four nucleotides. Extensive research efforts have been devoted to resolving these issues over the past two decades. In this review, we briefly introduce recent updates regarding solid-state nanopore technologies towards DNA sequencing. It can be envisioned that emerging technologies will offer a brand new future in DNA-sequencing technology.

Silicon nitride nanopore created by dielectric breakdown with a divalent cation: deceleration of translocation speed and identification of single nucleotides

Nanopore DNA sequencing with a solid-state nanopore requires deceleration of the ultrafast translocation speed of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). We report an unexpected phenomenon: controlled dielectric breakdown (CBD) with a divalent metal cation, especially Ca2+, provides a silicon nitride nanopore with the ability to decelerate ssDNA speed to 100 μs per base even after solution replacement. This speed is two orders of magnitude slower than that for CBD with a conventional monovalent metal cation. Temperature dependence experiments revealed that the enthalpic barrier for a nanopore created via CBD with Ca2+ is 25-30kBT, comparable to that of a biological nanopore. The slowing effect originates from the strong interaction between ssDNA and divalent cations, which were coated on the sidewall of the nanopore during the CBD process. In addition, we found that the nanopore created via CBD with Ca2+ can decelerate the speed of even single-nucleotide monomers, dNMPs, to 0.1-10 ms per base. The four single nucleotides could be statistically identified according to their blockade currents. Our approach is simple and practical because it simultaneously allows nanopore fabrication, ssDNA deceleration and the identification of nucleotide monomers.

Plasmonic-Nanopore Biosensors for Superior Single-Molecule Detection

Plasmonic and nanopore sensors have separately received much attention for achieving single-molecule precision. A plasmonic "hotspot" confines and enhances optical excitation at the nanometer length scale sufficient to optically detect surface-analyte interactions. A nanopore biosensor actively funnels and threads analytes through a molecular-scale aperture, wherein they are interrogated by electrical or optical means. Recently, solid-state plasmonic and nanopore structures have been integrated within monolithic devices that address fundamental challenges in each of the individual sensing methods and offer complimentary improvements in overall single-molecule sensitivity, detection rates, dwell time and scalability. Here, the physical phenomena and sensing principles of plasmonic and nanopore sensing are summarized to highlight the novel complementarity in dovetailing these techniques for vastly improved single-molecule sensing. A literature review of recent plasmonic nanopore devices is then presented to delineate methods for solid-state fabrication of a range of hybrid device formats, evaluate the progress and challenges in the detection of unlabeled and labeled analyte, and assess the impact and utility of localized plasmonic heating. Finally, future directions and applications inspired by the present state of the art are discussed.

Active Delivery of Single DNA Molecules into a Plasmonic Nanopore for Label-Free Optical Sensing

Plasmon resonance biosensors provide ultimate sensitivity at the single-molecule level. This sensitivity is, however, associated with a nanometer-sized confined hotspot, and molecular transport toward the sensor relies on inefficient diffusion. Here, we combine a plasmonic nanoantenna with a solid-state nanopore and demonstrate that single DNA molecules can be efficiently delivered to the plasmonic hotspots and detected in a label-free manner at submillisecond acquisition rates by monitoring the backscattered light intensity from the plasmonic nanoantennas. Our method realizes a better than 200 μs temporal resolution together with a down to subsecond waiting time, which is orders of magnitude better than traditional single-molecule plasmonic resonance sensing methods. Furthermore, the electric field applied to the nanopore can actively drive biomolecules away from the hotspot, preventing molecules to permanently bind to the gold sensor surface and allowing efficient reuse of the sensor. Our plasmonic nanopore sensor thus significantly outperforms conventional plasmon resonance sensors and provides great opportunities for high-throughput optical single-molecule-sensing assays.

Thermostable virus portal proteins as reprogrammable adapters for solid-state nanopore sensors

Nanopore-based sensors are advancing the sensitivity and selectivity of single-molecule detection in molecular medicine and biotechnology. Current electrical sensing devices are based on either membrane protein pores supported in planar lipid bilayers or solid-state (SS) pores fabricated in thin metallic membranes. While both types of nanosensors have been used in a variety of applications, each has inherent disadvantages that limit its use. Hybrid nanopores, consisting of a protein pore supported within a SS membrane, combine the robust nature of SS membranes with the precise and simple engineering of protein nanopores. We demonstrate here a novel lipid-free hybrid nanopore comprising a natural DNA pore from a thermostable virus, electrokinetically inserted into a larger nanopore supported in a silicon nitride membrane. The hybrid pore is stable and easy to fabricate, and, most importantly, exhibits low peripheral leakage allowing sensing and discrimination among different types of biomolecules.

Thermophoresis-Controlled Size-Dependent DNA Translocation through an Array of Nanopores

Large arrays of nanopores can be used for high-throughput biomolecule translocation with applications toward size discrimination and sorting at the single-molecule level. In this paper, we propose to discriminate DNA length by the capture rate of the molecules to an array of relatively large nanopores (50-130 nm) by introducing a thermal gradient by laser illumination in front of the pores balancing the force from an external electric field. Nanopore arrays defined by photolithography were batch processed using standard silicon technology in combination with electrochemical etching. Parallel translocation of single, fluorophore-labeled dsDNA strands is recorded by imaging the array with a fast CMOS camera. The experimental data show that the capture rates of DNA molecules decrease with increasing DNA length due to the thermophoretic effect of the molecules. It is shown that the translocation can be completely turned off for the longer molecule using an appropriate bias, thus allowing a size discrimination of the DNA translocation through the nanopores. A derived analytical model correctly predicts the observed capture rate. Our results demonstrate that by combining a thermal and a potential gradient at the nanopores, such large nanopore arrays can potentially be used as a low-cost, high-throughput platform for molecule sensing and sorting.

Effects of Nanopore Charge Decorations on the Translocation Dynamics of DNA

We have investigated the dynamics of single-stranded DNA as it translocates through charge-mutated protein nanopores. Translocation of DNA is a crucial step in nanopore-based sequencing platforms, where control over translocation speed remains one of the main challenges. Taking advantage of the interactions between negatively charged DNA and positively charged amino acid residues, the translocation speed of DNA can be manipulated by deliberate charge decorations inside the nanopore. We employed coarse-grained Langevin dynamics simulations to monitor the step-by-step movement of DNA through different mutations of α-hemolysin protein nanopores. We found that although the average translocation time per nucleotide is longer, in agreement with experiments, the DNA nucleotides do not translocate with a uniform speed. Furthermore, the location and spacing of the charge decorations can alter the translocation dynamics significantly, trapping DNA in some cases. Our findings can give insights when designing charge patterns in nanopores.

Single Molecule Trapping and Sensing Using Dual Nanopores Separated by a Zeptoliter Nanobridge

There is a growing realization, especially within the diagnostic and therapeutic community, that the amount of information enclosed in a single molecule can not only enable a better understanding of biophysical pathways, but also offer exceptional value for early stage biomarker detection of disease onset. To this end, numerous single molecule strategies have been proposed, and in terms of label-free routes, nanopore sensing has emerged as one of the most promising methods. However, being able to finely control molecular transport in terms of transport rate, resolution, and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is essential to take full advantage of the technology benefits. Here we propose a novel solution to these challenges based on a method that allows biomolecules to be individually confined into a zeptoliter nanoscale droplet bridging two adjacent nanopores (nanobridge) with a 20 nm separation. Molecules that undergo confinement in the nanobridge are slowed down by up to 3 orders of magnitude compared to conventional nanopores. This leads to a dramatic improvement in the SNR, resolution, sensitivity, and limit of detection. The strategy implemented is universal and as highlighted in this manuscript can be used for the detection of dsDNA, RNA, ssDNA, and proteins.

Temperature dependence of the translocation time of polymer through repulsive nanopores

The forced translocation of a polymer chain through repulsive nanopores was studied by using Langevin dynamics simulations. The polymer is in the compact globule state at low temperature and in the random coil state at high temperature. Simulation results show that the mean translocation time 〈τ〉 is highly dependent on the temperature T and the minimal 〈τ〉 is located near the coil-globule transition temperature. Moreover, the scaling behaviors 〈τ〉 ∼ N^α and 〈τ〉 ∼ F^-δ are studied, with N the polymer length and F the driving force inside the nanopore. Universal values α = 1.4 and δ = 0.85 are observed for the polymer in the random coil state. While for the polymer in the compact globule state, α decreases from α = 2 at weak driving to 1.2 at strong driving for short N and δ increases with decreasing T in the low F region, but we find universal exponents α = 1.6 for long N and δ = 0.85 in the large F region. Results show that polymer's conformation plays a much more important role than the diffusion coefficient in controlling the translocation time of the polymer chain.

Large Rectification Effect of Single Graphene Nanopore Supported by PET Membrane

Graphene is an ideal candidate for the development of solid state nanopores due to its thickness at the atomic scale and its high chemical and mechanical stabilities. A facile method was adopted to prepare single graphene nanopore supported by PET membrane (G/PET nanopore) within the three steps assisted by the swift heavy ion irradiation and asymmetric etching technology. The inversion of the ion rectification effect was confirmed in G/PET nanopore while comparing with bare PET nanopore in KCl electrolyte solution. By modifying the wall charge state of PET conical nanopore with hydrochloric acid from negative to positive, the ion rectification effect of G/PET nanopore was found to be greatly enhanced and the large rectification ratio up to 190 was obtained during this work. Moreover, the high ionic flux and high ion separation efficiency was also observed in the G/PET nanopore system. By comparing the "on" and "off" state conductance of G/PET nanopore while immersed in the solution with pH value lower than the isoelectric point of the etched PET (IEP, pH = 3.8), the voltage dependence of the off conductance was established and it was confirmed that the large rectification effect was strongly dependent on the particularly low off conductance at higher applied voltage.

High Temperature Extends the Range of Size Discrimination of Nonionic Polymers by a Biological Nanopore

We explore the effect of temperature on the interaction of polydisperse mixtures of nonionic poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) polymers of different average molar masses with the biological nanopore α-hemolysin. In contrast with what has been previously observed with various nanopores and analytes, we find that, for PEGs larger than a threshold molar mass (2000 g/mol, PEG 2000), increasing temperature increases the duration of the PEG/nanopore interaction. In the case of PEG 3400 the duration increases by up to a factor of 100 when the temperature increases from 5 °C to 45 °C. Importantly, we find that increasing temperature extends the polymer size range of application of nanopore-based single-molecule mass spectrometry (Np-SMMS)-type size discrimination. Indeed, in the case of PEG 3400, discrimination of individual molecular species of different monomer number is impossible at room temperature but is achieved when the temperature is raised to 45 °C. We interpret our observations as the consequence of a decrease of PEG solubility and a collapse of PEG molecules with higher temperatures. In addition to expanding the range of application of Np-SMMS to larger nonionic polymers, our findings highlight the crucial role of the polymer solubility for the nanopore detection.

Integrated solid-state nanopore platform for nanopore fabrication via dielectric breakdown, DNA-speed deceleration and noise reduction

The practical use of solid-state nanopores for DNA sequencing requires easy fabrication of the nanopores, reduction of the DNA movement speed and reduction of the ionic current noise. Here, we report an integrated nanopore platform with a nanobead structure that decelerates DNA movement and an insulating polyimide layer that reduces noise. To enable rapid nanopore fabrication, we introduced a controlled dielectric breakdown (CDB) process into our system. DNA translocation experiments revealed that single nanopores were created by the CDB process without sacrificing performance in reducing DNA movement speed by up to 10 μs/base or reducing noise up to 600 pA_rms at 1 MHz. Our platform provides the essential components for proceeding to the next step in the process of DNA sequencing.

Molecular Dynamics Simulation of DNA Capture and Transport in Heated Nanopores

The integration of local heat sources with solid-state nanopores offers new means for controlling the transmembrane transport of charged biomacromolecules. In the case of electrophoretic transport of DNA, recent experimental studies revealed unexpected temperature dependences of the DNA capture rate, the DNA translocation velocity, and the ionic current blockades produced by the presence of DNA in the nanopore. Here, we report the results of all-atom molecular dynamics simulations that elucidated the effect of temperature on the key microscopic processes governing electric field-driven transport of DNA through nanopores. Mimicking the experimental setup, we simulated the capture and subsequent translocation of short DNA duplexes through a locally heated nanopore at several temperatures and electrolyte conditions. The temperature dependence of ion mobility at the DNA surface was found to cause the dependence of the relative conductance blockades on temperature. To the first order, the effective force on DNA in the nanopore was found to be independent of temperature, despite a considerable reduction of solution viscosity. The temperature dependence of the solution viscosity was found to make DNA translocations faster for a uniformly heated system but not in the case of local heating that does not affect viscosity of solution surrounding the untranslocated part of the molecule. Increasing solution temperature was also found to reduce the lifetime of bonds formed between cations and DNA. Using a flow suppression algorithm, we were able to separate the effects of electro-osmotic flow and direct ion binding, finding the reduced durations of DNA-ion bonds to increase, albeit weakly, the effective force experienced by DNA in an electric field. Unexpectedly, our simulations revealed a considerable temperature dependence of solvent velocity at the DNA surface-slip velocity, an effect that can alter hydrodynamic coupling between the motion of DNA and the surrounding fluid.

Ionic liquid prolongs DNA translocation through graphene nanopores

Ionic liquid molecules interact strongly with DNA and effectively reduce its translocation speed via graphene nanopore.