Characterization of Compton-scatter imaging with an analytical simulation method

Improving animal-specific radiotherapy quality assurance for kilovoltage X-ray radiotherapy using a 3D printed dog skull water phantom

Background

Accurate dose assessment during animal radiotherapy is beneficial for veterinary medicine and medical education.

Aim

To visualize the radiation treatment distribution of orthovoltage X-ray equipment in clinical practice using Monte Carlo simulations and create a dog skull water phantom for animal-specific radiotherapy.

Methods

EGSnrc-based BEAMnrc and DOSXYZnrc codes were used to simulate orthovoltage dose distributions. At 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 80 mm in a water phantom, the depth dose was measured with waterproof Farmer dosimetry chambers, and the diagonal off-axis ratio was measured with Gafchromic EBT3 film to simulate orthovoltage dose distributions. Energy differences between orthovoltage and linear accelerated radiotherapy were assessed with a heterogeneous bone and tissue virtual phantom. The animal-specific phantom for radiotherapy quality assurance (QA) was created from CT scans of a dog and printed with a three-dimensional printer using polyamide 12 nylon, with insertion points for dosimetry chambers and Gafchromic EBT3 film.

Results

Monte Carlo simulated and measured dose distributions differed by no more than 2.0% along the central axis up to a depth of 80 mm. The anode heel effect occurred in shallow areas. The orthovoltage radiotherapy percentage depth dose in bone was >40%. Build-up was >40%, with build-down after bone exit, whereas linear accelerator radiotherapy absorption changed little in the bone. A highly water-impermeable, animal-specific dog skull water phantom could be created to evaluate dose distribution.

Conclusion

Animal-specific water phantoms and Monte Carlo simulated pre-treatment radiotherapy are useful QA for orthovoltage radiotherapy and yield a visually familiar phantom that will be useful for veterinary medical education.

Experimental and numerical studies on kV scattered x-ray imaging for real-time image guidance in radiation therapy

Motion management is a critical component of image guided radiotherapy for lung cancer. We previously proposed a scheme using kV scattered x-ray photons for marker-less real-time image guidance in lung cancer radiotherapy. This study reports our recent progress using the photon counting detection technique to demonstrate potential feasibility of this method and using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and ray-tracing calculations to characterize the performance. In our scheme, a thin slice of x-ray beam was directed to the target and we measured the outgoing scattered photons using a photon counting detector with a parallel-hole collimator to establish the correspondence between detector pixels and scatter positions. Image corrections of geometry, beam attenuation and scattering angle were performed to convert the raw image to the actual image of Compton attenuation coefficient. We set up a MC simulation system using an in-house developed GPU-based MC package modeling the image formation process. We also performed ray-tracing calculations to investigate the impacts of imaging system geometry on resulting image resolution. The experiment demonstrated feasibility of using a photon counting detector to measure scattered x-ray photons and generate the proposed scattered x-ray image. After correction, x-ray scattering image intensity and Compton scattering attenuation coefficient were linearly related, with R ² greater than 0.9. Contrast to noise ratios of different objects were improved and the values in experimental results and MC simulation results agreed with each other. Ray-tracing calculations revealed the dependence of image resolution on imaging geometry. The image resolution increases with reduced source to object distance and increased collimator height. The study demonstrated potential feasibility of using scattered x-ray imaging as a real-time image guidance method in radiation therapy.

Modelling and Simulation of Compton Scatter Image Formation in Positron Emission Tomography

We present the comparative study of the analytical forward model and the statistical simulation of the Compton single scatter in the Positron Emission Tomography. The formula of the forward model has been obtained using the Single Scatter Simulation approximation under simplified assumptions and therefore we calculate scatter projections using independent Monte Carlo simulation mimicking the scatter physics. The numerical comparative study has been performed using a digital cylindrical phantom filled in with water and containing spherical sources of emission activity located at the central and several displaced positions. Good fits of the formula-based and statistically generated profiles of scatter projections are observed in the presented numerical results.

Scatter imaging during lung stereotactic body radiation therapy characterized with phantom studies

By collecting photons scattered out of the therapy beam, scatter imaging creates images of the treated volume. Two phantoms were used to assess the possible application of scatter imaging for markerless tracking of lung tumors during stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) treatment. A scatter-imaging camera was assembled with a CsI flat-panel detector and a 5 mm diameter pinhole collimator. Scatter images were collected during the irradiation of phantoms with megavoltage photons. To assess scatter image quality, spherical phantom lung tumors of 2.1-2.8 cm diameters were placed inside a static, anthropomorphic phantom. To show the efficacy of the technique with a moving target (3 cm diameter), the position of a simulated tumor was tracked in scatter images during sinusoidal motion (15 mm amplitude, 0.25 Hz frequency) in a dynamic lung phantom in open-field, dynamic conformal arc (DCA), and volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) deliveries. Anatomical features are identifiable on static phantom scatter images collected with 10 MU of delivered dose (2.1 cm diameter lung tumor contrast-to-noise ratio of 4.4). The contrast-to-noise ratio increases with tumor size and delivered dose. During dynamic motion, the position of the 3.0 cm diameter lung tumor was identified with a root-mean-square error of 0.8, 1.2, and 2.9 mm for open field (0.3 s frame integration), DCA (0.5 s), and VMAT (0.5 s), respectively. Based on phantom studies, scatter imaging is a potential technique for markerless lung tumor tracking during SBRT without additional imaging dose. Quality scatter images may be collected at low, clinically relevant doses (10 MU). Scatter images are capable of sub-millimeter tracking precision, but modulation decreases accuracy.

Optimizing Coded Aperture Imaging techniques to allow for online tracking of fiducial markers with high-energy scattered radiation from treatment beam

PURPOSE

Real-time visualization of target motion using fiducial markers during radiation therapy treatment will allow for more accurate dose delivery. The purpose of this study was to optimize techniques for online fiducial marker tracking by detecting the scattered treatment beam through coded aperture imaging (CAI). Coded aperture imaging is a novel imaging technique that can allow target tracking in real time during treatment, and do so without adding any additional radiation dose, by making use of the scattered treatment beam radiation.

METHODS

Radiotherapy beams of various energies, incident on phantoms containing gold fiducial markers were modeled using MCNP6.2 Monte Carlo transport code. Orthogonal scatter radiographs were collected through a CAI geometry. After decoding the simulated radiograph data, the centroid location and FWHM/SNR of the fiducial signals were analyzed. The effects of properties related to the CA (rank, pattern, and physical dimensions), detector (dimensions and pixel count), position (CA and phantom), and the incident beam (spectrum and direction) were investigated. These variables were evaluated by quantifying the positional accuracy, resolution, and SNR of the fiducials' signal. The effects of phantom scatter and decoding artifacts were reduced via Fourier filtering to avoid treatment interruption and physical interaction with the coded mask.

RESULTS

The method was able to accurately localize the markers to within 1 pixel of a simulated radiograph. A 10 × 10 × 2 cm tungsten mask was chosen to attenuate >99 % of incident scatter through opaque elements, while minimizing collimation artifacts which arise from vignetting of the coded radiograph. Clear separation of centroids from fiducial signals with 2.5 mm separation was maintained, and initial optimization of parameters has produced an aperture which decodes the location of multiple fiducial markers inside a human phantom properly with a high SNR in the final radiograph image.

CONCLUSION

Current results show a proof of concept for a novel real-time imaging method. Coded aperture imaging is a promising technique for extracting the fiducial scatter signal from a broader Compton-scatter background. These results can be used to further optimize the CAI parameter space and guide fabrication and testing of a clinical device.

Compton scatter imaging: A promising modality for image guidance in lung stereotactic body radiation therapy

PURPOSE

Lung stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) requires delivering large radiation doses with millimeter accuracy, making image guidance essential. An approach to forming images of patient anatomy from Compton-scattered photons during lung SBRT is presented.

METHODS

To investigate the potential of scatter imaging, a pinhole collimator and flat-panel detector are used for spatial localization and detection of photons scattered during external beam therapy using lung SBRT treatment conditions (6 MV FFF beam). MCNP Monte Carlo software is used to develop a model to simulate scatter images. This model is validated by comparing experimental and simulated phantom images. Patient scatter images are then simulated from 4DCT data.

RESULTS

Experimental lung tumor phantom images have sufficient contrast-to-noise to visualize the tumor with as few as 10 MU (0.5 s temporal resolution). The relative signal intensity from objects of different composition as well as lung tumor contrast for simulated phantom images agree quantitatively with experimental images, thus validating the Monte Carlo model. Scatter images are shown to display high contrast between different materials (lung, water, bone). Simulated patient images show superior (~double) tumor contrast compared to MV transmission images.

CONCLUSIONS

Compton scatter imaging is a promising modality for directly imaging patient anatomy during treatment without additional radiation, and it has the potential to complement existing technologies and aid tumor tracking and lung SBRT image guidance.