Impact of a contrast-to-noise ratio driven and material specific exposure control on image quality and radiation exposure in angiography

Lowest reported dose area product of 2.4 Gy∗cm2 for ultra-low-dose endovascular aortic aneurysm repair of a standard infrarenal aortic aneurysm

This is a report of successful treatment of an abdominal aortic aneurysm via standard endovascular aortic repair with an ultra-low dose (ULD) of 2.4 Gy∗cm2 using the latest imaging software in a hybrid operating room. To the best of our knowledge, no case has yet been reported achieving a successful outcome with such ULD values to date. The key factors to achieving an ULD regarding the dose area product comprise the right technology, procedural standardization, and team education and training. This case highlights the potential for reducing the radiation dose routinely for patients and staff alike, especially for operating room staff with daily radiation exposure.

Image Quality and Radiation Exposure in Abdominal Angiography: A Head-to-Head Comparison of Conventional Detector-Dose-Driven Versus Contrast-to-Noise Ratio-Driven Exposure Control at Various Source-to-Image Receptor Distances and Collimations in a Pilot Phantom and Animal Study

OBJECTIVES

This phantom and animal pilot study aimed to compare image quality and radiation exposure between detector-dose-driven exposure control (DEC) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)-driven exposure control (CEC) as functions of source-to-image receptor distance (SID) and collimation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

First, an iron foil simulated a guide wire in a stack of polymethyl methacrylate and aluminum plates representing patient thicknesses of 15, 25, and 35 cm. Fluoroscopic images were acquired using 5 SIDs ranging from 100 to 130 cm and 2 collimations (full field of view, collimated field of view: 6 × 6 cm). The iron foil CNRs were calculated, and radiation doses in terms of air kerma rate were obtained and assessed using a multivariate regression. Second, 5 angiographic scenarios were created in 2 anesthetized pigs. Fluoroscopic images were acquired at 2 SIDs (110 and 130 cm) and both collimations. Two blinded experienced readers compared image quality to the reference image using full field of view at an SID of 110 cm. Air kerma rate was obtained and compared using t tests.

RESULTS

Using DEC, both CNR and air kerma rate increased significantly at longer SID and collimation below the air kerma rate limit. When using CEC, CNR was significantly less dependent of SID, collimation, and patient thickness. Air kerma rate decreased at longer SID and tighter collimation. After reaching the air kerma rate limit, CEC behaved similarly to DEC. In the animal study using DEC, image quality and air kerma rate increased with longer SID and collimation (P < 0.005). Using CEC, image quality was not significantly different than using longer SID or tighter collimation. Air kerma rate was not significantly different at longer SID but lower using collimation (P = 0.012).

CONCLUSIONS

CEC maintains the image quality with varying SID and collimation stricter than DEC, does not increase the air kerma rate at longer SID and reduces it with tighter collimation. After reaching the air kerma rate limit, CEC and DEC perform similarly.

Material-Specific Roadmap Modes Can Improve the Visibility of Liquid Embolic Agents for Endovascular Embolization: A Systematic In Vitro Study

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Endovascular embolization using liquid embolic agents is a safe and effective treatment option for AVMs and fistulas. Because reliable visibility of these liquid embolic agents is essential for intraprocedural visual control to prevent complications, novel angiographic systems are equipped with material-specific roadmap modes. The aim of this study was the systematic in vitro comparison of conventional and material-specific roadmap modes regarding the visibility of the most used liquid embolic agents.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A recently introduced in vitro model, resembling cerebral vessels, was embolized with Onyx 18, Squid 18, PHIL 25%, and n-BCA mixed with iodized oil (n = 4 for each liquid embolic agent), as well as with contrast medium and saline, both serving as a reference. Imaging was performed in conventional and material-specific roadmap modes. The visibility of the liquid embolic agents in both modes was compared quantitatively and qualitatively.

RESULTS

Significant differences between conventional and material-specific roadmap modes regarding the visibility of the liquid embolic agents were observed for all study groups. All liquid embolic agents were better visible in the material-specific roadmap modes compared with the conventional mode in qualitative and quantitative analyses (eg, Onyx in conventional-versus-material-specific modes along the 1.0-mm sector: mean contrast-to-noise ratio, 5.69 [SD, 0.85] versus 47.18 [SD, 5.72]; P < .001, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In this in vitro study, we demonstrated a better visibility of all investigated liquid embolic agents by using material-specific roadmap modes compared with the conventional roadmap technique. Especially in complex anatomic situations, these novel roadmap modes could improve the visual control and thus the safety and efficacy of embolization procedures in clinical practice.

Tantalum-specific contrast-to-noise ratio or conventional detector dose-driven exposure control in angiography: radiation dose and image quality evaluation in a porcine model

Background

The aim of this animal study was to compare the fluoroscopic image quality (IQ) and radiation dose between a tantalum (Ta)-specific contrast-to-noise ratio-driven exposure control (Ta-CEC) and a detector dose-driven exposure control (DEC) in abdominal angiography.

Methods

Nine angiography scenarios were created in seven anaesthetised pigs using Ta-based embolisation material during percutaneous liver and kidney intervention. Fluoroscopic images were acquired using three DEC protocols with different dose levels and Ta-CEC protocols with different IQ levels, sampled in small steps. Polymethyl-methacrylate and aluminium plates were used to simulate attenuation of three water equivalent thicknesses (WET). Three blinded readers evaluated the IQ of DEC and dose equivalent Ta images and selected the Ta-IQ equivalent image corresponding to the DEC image.

Results

Interobserver agreement for the IQ assessment was 0.43 for DEC, 0.56 for Ta-CEC and for the assessment of incident air kerma at the interventional reference point (K_a,r) for the Ta-IQ equivalent image 0.73. The average IQ of the dose equivalent Ta images was superior compared to the DEC images (p < 0.001) and also for every WET (26, 31, or 36 cm) and dose level (p ≤ 0.022). The average K_a,r for the Ta-IQ equivalent images was 59 ± 16% (mean ± standard deviation) lower compared to the DEC images (p < 0.001).

Conclusions

Compared to DEC, Ta-CEC significantly improved the fluoroscopic depiction of Ta, while maintaining the K_a,r. Alternatively, the K_a,r can be significantly reduced by using Ta-CEC instead of DEC, while maintaining equivalent IQ.

Review and investigation of automatic brightness/dose rate control logic of fluoroscopic imaging systems in cardiovascular interventional angiography

In this article, we review automatic brightness control (ABC) for fluoroscopy imaging systems. Starting from the simple manual control, the discussion is extended to the kV-primary ABC system, and then to the most recent contrast-to-noise ratio optimized (CNR Optimized) automatic dose rate control system (ADRC). The nature of this review article is trifold. First, it describes the ABC/ADRC and associated circuits governing the operation of the fluoroscopy imaging chain. Second, we show the characteristics of a control logic from a radiation physics point of view. Third, we introduce the most recent activities in the evaluation of CNR-optimized fluoroscopy systems and the phantom design that would be compatible with the design concept of the ADRC. Because of these three subject items in the discussion process, this article is also educational in nature written for medical physicists and radiological technologists who might be less familiar with the design concept of fluoroscopy operation, specifically on the ABC and ADRC. We insert a few related matters associated with fluoroscopy automatic control circuits where they seem applicable and appropriate to enhance the understanding of fluoroscopy operation logic.

Comparison of a contrast-to-noise ratio-driven exposure control and a regular detector dose-driven exposure control in abdominal imaging in a clinical angiography system

PURPOSE

The first purpose of this phantom study was to verify whether a contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)-driven exposure control (CEC) can maintain target CNR in angiography more precisely compared to a conventional detector dose-driven exposure control (DEC). The second purpose was to estimate the difference between incident air kerma produced by CEC and DEC when both exposure controls reach the same CNR.

METHODS

A standardized 3D-printed phantom with an iron foil and a cavity, filled with iodinated contrast material, was developed to measure CNR using different image acquisition settings. This phantom was placed into a stack of polymethylmethacrylate and aluminum plates, simulating a patient equivalent thickness (PET) of 2.5-40 cm. Images were acquired using fluoroscopy and digital radiography modes with CEC using one image quality level and four image quality gradients and DEC having three different detector dose levels. The spatial frequency weighted CNR and incident air kerma were determined. The differences in incident air kerma between DEC and CEC were estimated.

RESULTS

When using DEC, CNR decreased continuously with increasing attenuation, while CEC within physical limits maintained a predefined CNR level. Furthermore, CEC could be parameterized to deliver the CNR as a predefined function of PET. To provide a given CNR level, CEC used equal or lower air kerma than DEC. The mean estimated incident air kerma of CEC compared to DEC was between 3% (PET 20 cm) and 40% (PET 27.5 cm) lower in fluoroscopy and between 1% (PET 20 cm) and 55% (PET 2.5 cm) lower in digital radiography while maintaining CNR.

CONCLUSION

Within physical and legislative limits, the CEC allows for a flexible adjustment of the CNR as a function of PET. Thus, the CEC enables task-dependent examination protocols with predefined image quality in order to easier achieve the as low as reasonably achievable principle. CEC required equal or lower incident air kerma than DEC to provide similar CNR, which allows for a substantial reduction of skin radiation dose in these situations.