Non-genetic heterogeneity, criticality and cell differentiation

Tipping the Balance: A Criticality Perspective

Cell populations are often characterised by phenotypic heterogeneity in the form of two distinct subpopulations. We consider a model of tumour cells consisting of two subpopulations: non-cancer promoting (NCP) and cancer-promoting (CP). Under steady state conditions, the model has similarities with a well-known model of population genetics which exhibits a purely noise-induced transition from unimodality to bimodality at a critical value of the noise intensity σ2. The noise is associated with the parameter λ representing the system-environment coupling. In the case of the tumour model, λ has a natural interpretation in terms of the tissue microenvironment which has considerable influence on the phenotypic composition of the tumour. Oncogenic transformations give rise to considerable fluctuations in the parameter. We compute the λ−σ2 phase diagram in a stochastic setting, drawing analogies between bifurcations and phase transitions. In the region of bimodality, a transition from a state of balance to a state of dominance, in terms of the competing subpopulations, occurs at λ = 0. Away from this point, the NCP (CP) subpopulation becomes dominant as λ changes towards positive (negative) values. The variance of the steady state probability density function as well as two entropic measures provide characteristic signatures at the transition point.

A single-cell resolved cell-cell communication model explains lineage commitment in hematopoiesis

Cells do not make fate decisions independently. Arguably, every cell-fate decision occurs in response to environmental signals. In many cases, cell-cell communication alters the dynamics of the internal gene regulatory network of a cell to initiate cell-fate transitions, yet models rarely take this into account. Here, we have developed a multiscale perspective to study the granulocyte-monocyte versus megakaryocyte-erythrocyte fate decisions. This transition is dictated by the GATA1-PU.1 network: a classical example of a bistable cell-fate system. We show that, for a wide range of cell communication topologies, even subtle changes in signaling can have pronounced effects on cell-fate decisions. We go on to show how cell-cell coupling through signaling can spontaneously break the symmetry of a homogenous cell population. Noise, both intrinsic and extrinsic, shapes the decision landscape profoundly, and affects the transcriptional dynamics underlying this important hematopoietic cell-fate decision-making system.

This article has an associated ‘The people behind the papers’ interview.

Summary: Through theory and computational modeling, cell-cell communication is revealed to be a crucial and under-appreciated determinant of cell-fate decision-making during hematopoiesis.

Operating principles of circular toggle polygons

Decoding the dynamics of cellular decision-making and cell differentiation is a central question in cell and developmental biology. A common network motif involved in many cell-fate decisions is a mutually inhibitory feedback loop between two self-activating 'master regulators' A and B, also called as toggle switch. Typically, it can allow for three stable states-(high A, low B), (low A, high B) and (medium A, medium B). A toggle triad-three mutually repressing regulators A, B and C, i.e. three toggle switches arranged circularly (between A and B, between B and C, and between A and C)-can allow for six stable states: three 'single positive' and three 'double positive' ones. However, the operating principles of larger toggle polygons, i.e. toggle switches arranged circularly to form a polygon, remain unclear. Here, we simulate using both discrete and continuous methods the dynamics of different sized toggle polygons. We observed a pattern in their steady state frequency depending on whether the polygon was an even or odd numbered one. The even-numbered toggle polygons result in two dominant states with consecutive components of the network expressing alternating high and low levels. The odd-numbered toggle polygons, on the other hand, enable more number of states, usually twice the number of components with the states that follow 'circular permutation' patterns in their composition. Incorporating self-activations preserved these trends while increasing the frequency of multistability in the corresponding network. Our results offer insights into design principles of circular arrangement of regulatory units involved in cell-fate decision making, and can offer design strategies for synthesizing genetic circuits.

Fluctuation theory of immune response: A statistical mechanical approach to understand pathogen induced T-cell population dynamics

In this period of intense interest in human immunity, we attempt here to quantify the immune response against pathogen invasion through T-cell population dynamics. Borrowing concepts from equilibrium statistical mechanics, we introduce a new description of the immune response function (IMRF) in terms of fluctuations in the population number of relevant biological cells (effector and regulatory T-cells). We use a coarse-grained chemical reaction network model (CG-CRNM) to calculate the number fluctuations and show that the response function derived as such can, indeed, capture the crossover observed in a T-cell driven immune response. We employ the network model to learn the effect of vitamin-D as an immunomodulator. We solve our CG-CRNM using a stochastic Gillespie algorithm. Depending on the effector T-cell concentration, we can classify immune regulation regimes into three categories: weak, strong, and moderate. The IMRF is found to behave differently in these three regimes. A damped cross-regulatory behavior found in the dynamics of effector and regulatory T-cell concentration in the diseased states correlates well with the same found in a cohort of patients with specific malignancies and autoimmune diseases. Importantly, the crossover from the weakly regulated steady state to the other (the strongly regulated) is accompanied by a divergence-like growth in the fluctuation of both the effector and the regulatory T-cell concentration, characteristic of a dynamic phase transition. We believe such steady-state IMRF analyses could help not only to phase-separate different immune stages but also aid in the valuable connection between autoimmunity, optimal vitamin-D, and consequences of immunosuppressive stress and malignancy.

Exploring the mechanisms of cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation via intercellular communication

In the past years, the mechanisms of cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation via the way of gene regulation, stochastic fluctuations, or chemical induction to realize cell type transitions from the perspectives of single cells were explored. In multicellular organisms, intercellular communication plays crucial roles in cell fate decisions. However, the importance of intercellular communication to the processes of cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation is often neglected. In this paper, the mechanisms of cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation by intercellular communication are investigated. A two-gene circuit with mutual inhibition and self-activation as a basic model is selected. Then, a coupling mechanism via intercellular communication by introducing a specific signaling molecule into the gene circuit is considered. Finally, the influence of coupling intensity on the dynamics of the coupled system of two cells is analyzed. Moreover, when the coupling intensity changes with respect to the cell number in a discrete way, the effects of coupling intensity on cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation are discussed. Some theoretical analysis of stability and bifurcation of the systems are also given. Our research shows that cells can realize cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation via intercellular interaction at opportune coupling intensity. These results not only further enrich previous studies but also are beneficial to understand the mechanisms of cell reprogramming and transdifferentiation via intercellular communication in the growth and development of multicellular organisms.

Universality of biochemical feedback and its application to immune cells

We map a class of well-mixed stochastic models of biochemical feedback in steady state to the mean-field Ising model near the critical point. The mapping provides an effective temperature, magnetic field, order parameter, and heat capacity that can be extracted from biological data without fitting or knowledge of the underlying molecular details. We demonstrate this procedure on fluorescence data from mouse T cells, which reveals distinctions between how the cells respond to different drugs. We also show that the heat capacity allows inference of the absolute molecule number from fluorescence intensity. We explain this result in terms of the underlying fluctuations, and we demonstrate the generality of our work.

Reprogramming, oscillations and transdifferentiation in epigenetic landscapes

Waddington’s epigenetic landscape provides a phenomenological understanding of the cell differentiation pathways from the pluripotent to mature lineage-committed cell lines. In light of recent successes in the reverse programming process there has been significant interest in quantifying the underlying landscape picture through the mathematics of gene regulatory networks. We investigate the role of time delays arising from multi-step chemical reactions and epigenetic rearrangement on the cell differentiation landscape for a realistic two-gene regulatory network, consisting of self-promoting and mutually inhibiting genes. Our work provides the first theoretical basis of the transdifferentiation process in the presence of delays, where one differentiated cell type can transition to another directly without passing through the undifferentiated state. Additionally, the interplay of time-delayed feedback and a time dependent chemical drive leads to long-lived oscillatory states in appropriate parameter regimes. This work emphasizes the important role played by time-delayed feedback loops in gene regulatory circuits and provides a framework for the characterization of epigenetic landscapes.

Modeling of cytometry data in logarithmic space: When is a bimodal distribution not bimodal?

Recent efforts in systems immunology lead researchers to build quantitative models of cell activation and differentiation. One goal is to account for the distributions of proteins from single-cell measurements by flow cytometry or mass cytometry as readout of biological regulation. In that context, large cell-to-cell variability is often observed in biological quantities. We show here that these readouts, viewed in logarithmic scale may result in two easily-distinguishable modes, while the underlying distribution (in linear scale) is unimodal. We introduce a simple mathematical test to highlight this mismatch. We then dissect the flow of influence of cell-to-cell variability proposing a graphical model which motivates higher-dimensional analysis of the data. Finally we show how acquiring additional biological information can be used to reduce uncertainty introduced by cell-to-cell variability, helping to clarify whether the data is uni- or bimodal. This communication has cautionary implications for manual and automatic gating strategies, as well as clustering and modeling of single-cell measurements. © 2018 International Society for Advancement of Cytometry.

Reprogramming cell fate with artificial transcription factors

Transcription factors (TFs) reprogram cell states by exerting control over gene regulatory networks and the epigenetic landscape of a cell. Artificial transcription factors (ATFs) are designer regulatory proteins comprised of modular units that can be customized to overcome challenges faced by natural TFs in establishing and maintaining desired cell states. Decades of research on DNA-binding proteins and synthetic molecules has provided a molecular toolkit for ATF design and the construction of genome-scale libraries of ATFs capable of phenotypic manipulation and reprogramming of cell states. Here, we compare the unique strengths and limitations of different ATF platforms, highlight the advantages of cooperative assembly, and present the potential of ATF libraries in revealing gene regulatory networks that govern cell fate choices.

Operating principles of tristable circuits regulating cellular differentiation

Many cell-fate decisions during embryonic development are governed by a motif comprised of two transcription factors (TFs) A and B that mutually inhibit each other and may self-activate. This motif, called as a self-activating toggle switch (SATS), can typically have three stable states (phenotypes)-two corresponding to differentiated cell fates, each of which has a much higher level of one TF than the other-[Formula: see text] or [Formula: see text]-and the third state corresponding to an 'undecided' stem-like state with similar levels of both A and B-[Formula: see text]. Furthermore, two or more SATSes can be coupled together in various topologies in different contexts, thereby affecting the coordination between multiple cellular decisions. However, two questions remain largely unanswered: (a) what governs the co-existence and relative stability of these three stable states? (b) What orchestrates the decision-making of coupled SATSes? Here, we first demonstrate that the co-existence and relative stability of the three stable states in an individual SATS can be governed by the relative strength of self-activation, external signals activating and/or inhibiting A and B, and mutual degradation between A and B. Simultaneously, we investigate the effects of these factors on the decision-making of two coupled SATSes. Our results offer novel understanding into the operating principles of individual and coupled tristable self-activating toggle switches (SATSes) regulating cellular differentiation and can yield insights into synthesizing three-way genetic circuits and understanding of cellular reprogramming.

Cell Fate Decision as High-Dimensional Critical State Transition

Cell fate choice and commitment of multipotent progenitor cells to a differentiated lineage requires broad changes of their gene expression profile. But how progenitor cells overcome the stability of their gene expression configuration (attractor) to exit the attractor in one direction remains elusive. Here we show that commitment of blood progenitor cells to the erythroid or myeloid lineage is preceded by the destabilization of their high-dimensional attractor state, such that differentiating cells undergo a critical state transition. Single-cell resolution analysis of gene expression in populations of differentiating cells affords a new quantitative index for predicting critical transitions in a high-dimensional state space based on decrease of correlation between cells and concomitant increase of correlation between genes as cells approach a tipping point. The detection of “rebellious cells” that enter the fate opposite to the one intended corroborates the model of preceding destabilization of a progenitor attractor. Thus, early warning signals associated with critical transitions can be detected in statistical ensembles of high-dimensional systems, offering a formal theory-based approach for analyzing single-cell molecular profiles that goes beyond current computational pattern recognition, does not require knowledge of specific pathways, and could be used to predict impending major shifts in development and disease.

A certain type of multipotent progenitor cell of the blood can commit to either the white (myeloid) or the red (erythroid) blood cell lineage, thus making a discrete binary cell fate decision. To test a theory on fundamental principles of cell fate dynamics (as opposed to the usually studied molecular mechanisms), we monitored such a fate decision in vitro using single-cell resolution gene expression analysis. We found that blood progenitor cells undergoing a fate decision to commit to either lineage after treatment with fate-determining cytokines, according to theory, first destabilized their original state. Cell states hereby diversified, manifesting the predicted flattening of an attractor’s potential well, which allows the increasingly vacillating progenitor cells to “spill” into adjacent potential wells corresponding to either lineage—myeloid or erythroid. This destabilization of an old stable state until suddenly opening access to new stable states is consistent with a critical transition (tipping point). We propose and demonstrate a new type of early warning signal that precedes critical transitions: an index I_C based on a change in the high-dimensional cell population structure obtained from single-cell resolution measurements. This index may be used to predict imminent tipping point–like transitions in multicell systems, e.g., before pathological changes in tissues.

Entropy, Ergodicity, and Stem Cell Multipotency

Populations of mammalian stem cells commonly exhibit considerable cell-cell variability. However, the functional role of this diversity is unclear. Here, we analyze expression fluctuations of the stem cell surface marker Sca1 in mouse hematopoietic progenitor cells using a simple stochastic model and find that the observed dynamics naturally lie close to a critical state, thereby producing a diverse population that is able to respond rapidly to environmental changes. We propose an information-theoretic interpretation of these results that views cellular multipotency as an instance of maximum entropy statistical inference.

Implications of the Hybrid Epithelial/Mesenchymal Phenotype in Metastasis

Transitions between epithelial and mesenchymal phenotypes – the epithelial to ­mesenchymal transition (EMT) and its reverse the mesenchymal to epithelial transition (MET) – are hallmarks of cancer metastasis. While transitioning between the epithelial and mesenchymal phenotypes, cells can also attain a hybrid epithelial/mesenchymal (E/M) (i.e., partial or intermediate EMT) phenotype. Cells in this phenotype have mixed epithelial (e.g., adhesion) and mesenchymal (e.g., migration) properties, thereby allowing them to move collectively as clusters. If these clusters reach the bloodstream intact, they can give rise to clusters of circulating tumor cells (CTCs), as have often been seen experimentally. Here, we review the operating principles of the core regulatory network for EMT/MET that acts as a “three-way” switch giving rise to three distinct phenotypes – E, M and hybrid E/M – and present a theoretical framework that can elucidate the role of many other players in regulating epithelial plasticity. Furthermore, we highlight recent studies on partial EMT and its association with drug resistance and tumor-initiating potential; and discuss how cell–cell communication between cells in a partial EMT phenotype can enable the formation of clusters of CTCs. These clusters can be more apoptosis-resistant and have more tumor-initiating potential than singly moving CTCs with a wholly mesenchymal (complete EMT) phenotype. Also, more such clusters can be formed under inflammatory conditions that are often generated by various therapies. Finally, we discuss the multiple advantages that the partial EMT or hybrid E/M phenotype have as compared to a complete EMT phenotype and argue that these collectively migrating cells are the primary “bad actors” of metastasis.