Relationship between total serum immunoglobulin E levels, fractional exhaled breath nitric oxide levels and absolute blood eosinophil counts in atopic and non-atopic asthma: a controlled comparative study

Promising treatment biomarkers in asthma

Asthma is a highly heterogenous disease which researchers over time have attempted to classify into different phenotypes and endotypes to improve diagnosis, prognosis and treatment. Earlier classifications based on reaction to environmental allergens, age, sex and lung function have evolved, and today, the use of precision medicine guided by biomarkers offers new perspectives on asthma management. Identifying biomarkers that may reveal the underlying pathophysiology of the disease will help to select the patients who will benefit most from specific treatments. This review explores the classification of asthma phenotypes and focuses on the most recent advances in using biomarkers to guide treatment.

The Correlation Between Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO), Blood Eosinophil Count, Immunoglobulin E Levels, and Spirometric Values in Patients With Asthma

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In patients with asthma, fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) is a biomarker for eosinophilic airway inflammation. However, the correlation with the blood eosinophil count, immunoglobulin E (IgE), and spirometric values is not well established. We aimed to investigate the correlation between FeNO, blood eosinophils, IgE, and spirometric values in asthmatic patients.

METHODS

Data were extracted from the electronic medical records of adult asthmatic patients, and included the FeNO, blood eosinophil count, IgE, and spirometric values. The correlation between the markers was investigated using receiver operating characteristics (ROC) and the area under the curve (AUC).

RESULTS

A total of 135 adult patients (30% male) were analyzed. The mean FeNO was 36 ppb and almost half (48%) had a FeNO > 25 ppb. The mean blood eosinophil count was 377 cells/mm³, and 42% had a blood eosinophil count > 300 cells/mm³. There was a significant positive correlation between FeNO and the blood eosinophil count (r = 0.42, sensitivity 63%, specificity 77%, AUC 72%, p < 0.0001) as well as with the IgE (r = 0.35, sensitivity 78%, specificity 44%, AUC 68%, p < 0.0007). There was significant negative correlation between FeNO and FEV1% (r = -0.18, sensitivity 35%, specificity 85%, AUC 67%, p = 0.027).

CONCLUSION

The blood eosinophil count, IgE, and spirometric values were correlated with the severity of the eosinophilic airway inflammation (high FeNO). Asthmatic patients with a higher FeNO level had a higher eosinophil count, higher IgE levels, and lower FEV1 values.

Interval change in fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FENO) reflects short-term change in adherence following electronic inhaler reminders

BACKGROUND

In asthma, suppression of fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FENO) is a marker of adherence in the short-term. The usefulness of FENO to indicate change in adherence in the longer term is unknown. The aims of this study were to determine the relationship between changes in adherence and corresponding changes in FENO over short (1 week) and long-term (3 month) periods.

METHODS

After establishing initial ICS adherence using electronic inhaler monitor (EIM) devices, reminders were switched on for 1 week ('short-term') to optimize adherence. Reminders were then switched off and patients followed up after 3 months ('long-term'). FENO was measured at the start and end of each period. Using linear regression, we analyzed change in FENO in relation to change in adherence.

RESULTS

Forty-two patients contributed complete data for analysis. In the short-term, change in adherence was independently associated with change in FENO (β = -0.36, p = 0.036) even after adjusting for initial adherence and ICS dose. The higher the initial FENO, the greater the decline in FENO with improved adherence. This relationship between change in adherence and change in FENO was not observed in the long-term.

CONCLUSION

Change in adherence over 1 week following the use of EIM reminders independently predicted change in FENO. This relationship was not maintained at 3 months.

Supplementation of syringic acid-rich Phrynium pubinerve leaves imparts protection against allergic inflammatory responses by downregulating iNOS, COX-2, and NF-κB expressions

Background

The present study was designed to characterize the role of ethanolic leaf extract of Phrynium pubinerve Blume (EPP) supplement in attenuating allergic inflammation, encouraged by the presence of syringic acid in it, as this phenolic acid is reportedly promising in suppressing serum immunoglobulin E (IgE) and inflammatory cytokine levels.

Materials and methods

HPLC-DAD dereplication analysis was performed to determine the presence of the vital polyphenolic metabolites. The efficacy of EPP against lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced inflammation in RAW 264.7 cells was evaluated by measuring its inhibitory effects on NO and ROS/RNS production. The expressions of major inflammation-associated molecules (iNOS, COX-2, NF-κB, IL-6, and TNF-α) in RAW 264.7 cells were assessed through Western blot. Physiological and behavioral changes, BMI, and different biochemical parameters in mice blood serum were investigated in the toxicological assays. Formaldehyde-induced paw edema test in mice was conducted using established animal model. TDI-induced allergic model in mice was carried out to determine different allergy-like symptoms, and differential white blood cell (WBC) counts in blood and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid. The intermolecular interaction analysis of the identified major metabolite of EPP with H1R and iNOS was studied by molecular docking.

Results

HPLC-DAD analysis showed the presence of syringic acid (89.19 mg/100 g EPP) and a few other compounds. LPS-induced NO generation was reduced by EPP in a concentration-dependent manner, showing IC50 of 28.20 ± 0.27 μg/mL. EPP exhibited a similar inhibitory effect on ROS/RNS production with IC50 of 29.47 ± 2.19 μg/mL. Western blotting revealed that EPP significantly downregulated the expressions of iNOS, COX-2, NF-κB, IL-6, and TNF-α in RAW 264.7 cells when challenged with LPS. The toxicological assays confirmed the dosage and organ-specific safety of EPP. In the formaldehyde-induced paw edema test, EPP caused a 66.41% reduction in mice paw volume at 500 mg/kg dose. It ameliorated TDI-induced allergy-like symptoms and decreased different inflammatory WBCs in mice's blood and BAL fluid in a dose-dependent manner. Finally, syringic acid demonstrated mentionable intermolecular binding affinity towards H1R (-6.6 Kcal/moL) and iNOS (-6.7 Kcal/moL).

Conclusions

Collectively, considerable scientific reasoning was obtained in favor of the suppressive potential of EPP against allergic inflammatory responses that are proposed to be exerted via the downregulation of iNOS, COX-2, and NF-κB expressions, H1R antagonism and suppression of cytokines, such as IL-6, and TNF-α.

Relationship between exhaled nitric oxide and biomarkers of atopy in children and adolescents with allergic rhinitis

INTRODUCTION

Measurement of the exhaled nitric oxide fraction (FeNO) has been proposed as an indirect and non-invasive method to detect eosinophilic airway inflammation. Allergic rhinitis (AR) is frequently associated with high levels of FeNO. Allergic sensitization can contribute to the recruitment of eosinophils in the airway and the consequent increase in FeNO.

OBJECTIVE

To correlate FeNO values with inflammatory and atopic sensitization biomarkers in patients with AR.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Observational, analytical, cross-sectional study. Children and adolescents with AR without asthma were included. FeNO, blood eosinophil count, total serum IgE were determined and skin tests with aeroallergens were performed by calculating the scores for PPC1 (number of positive allergens), STS2 (sum of millimeters of positive papules) and the atopy index (ratio between STS2/STS1). Spearman's correlation test was used between FeNO and variables of inflammation and atopy.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight patients between 6 and 17 years old were included. There was a significant positive correlation between FeNO and blood eosinophils (r=.38; p=.047) and between FeNO and the atopy index (r=.40; p=.03). No correlation was found between FeNO and total serum IgE (r=.24; p=.21), STS1 (r=.20; p=.32) and STS2 (r=.34; p=.08).

CONCLUSION

In children and adolescents with AR, FeNO was correlated with the atopy index and the blood eosinophil count. These last biomarkers could be used as alternatives for FeNO as biomarkers of lower airway inflammation in patients with AR.

Revisiting differences between atopic and non-atopic asthmatics: When age is shaping airway inflammatory profile

Background

Atopic asthma is one of the most common asthma phenotypes and is generally opposed to the non-atopic counterpart. There have been very few large-scale studies comparing atopic and non-atopic asthmatics in terms of systemic and airway inflammation across the age spectrum.

Methods

Here, we have undertaken a retrospective study investigating 1626 patients (924 atopic and 702 non-atopic asthmatics) recruited from our university asthma clinic who underwent extensive clinical investigations including induced sputum. Atopy was defined by any positive specific IgE to common aeroallergens (>0,35 kU/L). We performed direct comparisons between the groups and sought to appreciate the influence of age on the airway and systemic inflammatory components. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the University Hospital of Liege (Ref. 2016/276). Informed consents were obtained from healthy subjects.

Results

Atopic asthmatics were younger (P < .001), had a higher male/female ratio (P < .001), an earlier disease onset (P < .001) and a greater proportion of treated rhinitis (P < .001) while non-atopic asthmatics had greater smoke exposure (P < .001), lower FEV₁/FVC ratio (P = .01) and diffusing capacity (P < .001). There was no difference between the 2 groups regarding FEV₁ (% predicted), asthma control, asthma quality of life and exacerbations in the previous 12 months. Regarding inflammation, atopic patients had higher FeNO levels (median = 28 ppb, P < .001), were more eosinophilic both in blood (median = 2.8%, P < .001) and in sputum (median = 2.2%, P < .001) while non-atopic patients displayed greater blood (median = 57%, P = .01) and sputum (median = 58.8%, P = .01) neutrophilic inflammation. However, stratifying patients by age showed that non-atopic asthmatics above 50 years old became equally eosinophilic in the sputum (P = .07), but not in the blood, as compared to atopic patients. Likewise, FeNO rose in non-atopic patients after 50 years old but remained, however, lower than in atopic patients.

Conclusions

We conclude that, while sharing many features, atopic group still differentiates from non-atopic asthmatics by demographics, functional and inflammatory profiles. When atopic asthmatics showed a constant eosinophilic pattern across the age spectrum, non-atopic asthmatics were found to be neutrophilic before the age of 50 but eosinophilic above 50 years old.

Serum 14-3-3β protein: a new biomarker in asthmatic patients with acute exacerbation in an observational study

Background

The determination of systemic inflammatory markers is one of the important directions to study the pathogenesis of asthma and improve the diagnosis of asthma. Current studies have found that the 14-3-3 protein family subtypes interact with target proteins to participate in the pathogenesis of a variety of immune inflammatory diseases. However, studies on serum tyrosine3-monooxygenase/tryptophan5-monooxygenase activation protein β (14-3-3β) in asthma are scarce. This study aimed to assess the clinical significance of 14-3-3β in asthmatic patients.

Methods

We recruited 54 asthmatic patients with acute exacerbation and 50 asthmatic patients with chronic persistent. The normal control group included 54 healthy individuals. Clinical characteristics, clinical indicators [fractional expiratory nitric oxide (FeNO), eosinophil count, forced vital capacity (FVC), percent of predicted FVC (FVC% predicted), forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), percent of predicted FEV1 (FEV1% predicted), the ratio of forced expiratory volume in one second to forced vital capacity (FEV1/FVC) and serum 14-3-3β levels were measured to compare among each group. Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient was used to evaluate the correlation between 14-3-3β and clinical indicators. Finally, Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves analysis was used to determine the sensitivity and specificity of 14-3-3β.

Results

Our results showed that median (interquartile range) of serum 14-3-3β concentration (ng/mL) in acute exacerbation group of asthma (41.18 [33.06–51.76]) was much higher than that in normal control group (24.99 [17.43–29.91]; P < 0.001) and chronic persistent group of asthma (25.88 [21.03–34.55]; P < 0.001). Spearman’s correlation coefficient shows that the serum 14-3-3β level was positively correlated with FeNO (r = − 0.292, P = 0.032) and peripheral blood eosinophil count (r = 0.328, P = 0.016), and was negatively related to FEV1/FVC (r = − 0.293, P = 0.031) in the acute exacerbation group of asthma. At the same time, the serum 14-3-3β level was also negatively associated with FEV1 (r = − 0.297, P = 0.036) in the chronic persistent group of asthma. ROC curve analysis comparing acute exacerbation group of asthma with normal control group demonstrated a significant (P < 0.001) AUC of 0.90 (95% CI 0.85–0.96).

Conclusion

The serum 14-3-3β protein may become a potential biomarker in asthmatic patients with acute exacerbation.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13223-021-00608-4.

Determinants of blood eosinophilia in moderate and severe asthmatic patients during childhood: Evidence from the severe asthma molecular phenotype (SAMP) cohort

BACKGROUND

Asthma is a heterogeneous disease in which the interaction between genetic and environmental factors plays a major role. The significance of blood eosinophil is unclear. The aim of the study was to determine the significance of blood eosinophil count in moderate-to-severe asthmatic children of preschool age and school age.

METHODS

This was a prospective cross-sectional study performed from 2011 to 2015 including children from the severe asthma molecular phenotype (SAMP) cohort at Trousseau Hospital (Paris, France). We included children with severe and moderate asthma, or severe and moderate recurrent wheeze, aged from 1 to 15 years at the time of exploration.

RESULTS

We analyzed data from 402 children: 248 of preschool age and 154 of school age. Blood eosinophil count third quartile thresholds were 322 and 600 cells/μL for the preschool- and school-age groups, respectively. In multivariate analysis, a blood eosinophil count over this threshold was associated with elevated total IgE (OR = 5.33, P < .01), multiple hospitalizations for asthma attacks (OR = 4.96, P = .03), and a maternal history of asthma (OR = 4.91, P = .01) in preschool children; and with staphylococcal toxin-specific IgE (OR = 2.75, P = .03) in children of school age. Random forest analysis reinforced these results.

CONCLUSION

High blood eosinophil count is linked to both atopic features and control of asthma with different parameters associated with these features depending on age.

The influence of individual characteristics and non-respiratory diseases on blood eosinophil count

Background

Blood eosinophil (B-Eos) count is an emerging biomarker in the management of respiratory disease but determinants of B-Eos count besides respiratory disease are poorly described. Therefore, we aimed to evaluate the influence of non-respiratory diseases on B-Eos count, in comparison to the effect on two other biomarkers: fraction of exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) and C-reactive protein (CRP), and to identify individual characteristics associated with B-Eos count in healthy controls.

Methods

Children/adolescents (<18 years) and adults with complete B-Eos data from the US National Health and Nutritional Examination Surveys 2005-2016 were included, and they were divided into having respiratory diseases (n = 3333 and n = 7,894, respectively) or not having respiratory disease (n = 8944 and n = 15,010, respectively). After excluding any respiratory disease, the association between B-Eos count, FeNO or CRP, and non-respiratory diseases was analyzed in multivariate models and multicollinearity was tested. After excluding also non-respiratory diseases independently associated with B-Eos count (giving healthy controls; 8944 children/adolescents and 5667 adults), the independent association between individual characteristics and B-Eos count was analyzed.

Results

In adults, metabolic syndrome, heart disease or stroke was independently associated with higher B-Eos count (12%, 13%, and 15%, respectively), whereas no associations were found with FeNO or CRP. In healthy controls, male sex or being obese was associated with higher B-Eos counts, both in children/adolescents (15% and 3% higher, respectively) and adults (14% and 19% higher, respectively) (p < 0.01 all). A significant influence of race/ethnicity was also noted, and current smokers had 17% higher B-Eos count than never smokers (p < 0.001).

Conclusions

Non-respiratory diseases influence B-Eos count but not FeNO or CRP. Male sex, obesity, certain races/ethnicities, and current smoking are individual characteristics or exposures that are associated with higher B-Eos counts. All these factors should be considered when using B-Eos count in the management of respiratory disease.

Genetic effects of allergen-specific IgE levels on exhaled nitric oxide in schoolchildren with asthma: The STOPPA twin study

BACKGROUND

Exhaled nitric oxide and blood eosinophils are clinical asthma T-helper type 2 markers in use. Immunoglobulin E (IgE) is often involved in the inflammation associated with atopic asthma. The effect of both blood eosinophils and allergen-specific IgE on exhaled nitric oxide levels is not completely understood. Twin-design studies can improve understanding of the underlying contribution of genetically and/or environmentally driven inflammation markers in asthma. Our aim was to disentangle the covariance between asthma and exhaled nitric oxide into genetic and environmental contributions that can account for inflammation markers in a paediatric population.

METHODS

This population-based, cross-sectional twin study enrolled 612 monozygotic (MZ) and same-sex dizygotic (DZ) schoolchildren. Multivariate structural equation modelling was utilized to separate the covariance between asthma and exhaled nitric oxide into genetic and/or environmental effects, taking allergen-specific IgE level and blood eosinophil count into account while controlling for confounding factors.

RESULTS

The cross-twin/cross-trait correlations had a higher magnitude in the MZ twins than in the DZ twins, indicating that genes affect the association. The likelihood ratio test for model fitting resulted in the AE model (ie additive genetic effects, A, and non-shared environmental effects, E) as the most parsimonious. A majority, 73%, of the phenotypic correlation between asthma and exhaled nitric oxide, r = .19 (0.05-0.33), was attributable to genetic effects which mainly was due to the allergen-specific IgE level.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that the association between asthma and exhaled nitric oxide in children is to a large extent explained by genetics via allergen-specific IgE level and not blood eosinophils. This might partly explain the clinical heterogeneity in this group. A next step could be to include allergen-specific IgE level in multivariate omic studies.

A snapshot of exhaled nitric oxide and asthma characteristics: experience from high to low income countries

Nitric oxide is a gas produced in the airways of asthmatic subjects and related to T2 inflammation. It can be measured as fractional nitric oxide (FeNO) in the exhaled air and used as a non-invasive, easy to evaluate, rapid marker. It is now widely used in many settings to determine airway inflammation. The aim of this narrative review is to report relationship between FeNO and the physiopathologic characteristics of asthmatic patients. Factors affecting FeNO levels have also been analysed as well as the impact of corticosteroid, target therapies and rehabilitation programs. Considering the availability of the test, spreading this methodology to low income countries has also been considered as a possibility for evaluating airway inflammation and monitoring adherence to inhaled corticosteroid therapy. PubMed data search has been performed restricted to English language papers. Research was limited to studies in adults unless studies in children were the only ones reported for a particular issue. This revision could be useful to summarize the role of FeNO in relation to asthma characteristics and help in the use of FeNO in different clinical settings particularly in low income countries.

Clinical Features of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease with High Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide

Background

The fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FENO) test is useful in asthma patients. However, a few studies on its usefulness in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients have been reported. We analyzed the FENO level distribution and clinical characteristics according to the FENO level in COPD patients.

Methods

From December 2014 to June 2019, COPD patients who underwent pulmonary function and FENO tests at Chonnam National University Hospital were retrospectively evaluated for FENO, comorbidities, asthma history, blood eosinophil, and pulmonary function test. The high FENO group was defined as those with FENO level>25 parts per billion (ppb).

Results

A total of 849 COPD patients (mean age, 70.3±9.4 years) were included. The mean forced expiratory volume at 1 second was 66.5±21.7% and the mean FENO level was 24.3±20.5 ppb. Patients with FENO ≤25 ppb were 572 (67.4%) and those with FENO >25 ppb were 277 (32.6%). Blood eosinophil percentage was significantly higher (4.2±4.8 vs. 2.7±2.5, p<0.001) in patients with the high FENO group than the low FENO group. The high FENO group revealed a significantly higher frequency of patients with blood eosinophil percentage >3% (46.9% vs. 34.8%, p=0.001) and asthma history (25.6% vs. 8.6%, p<0.001) than the lower FENO group. Asthma history, blood eosinophil percentage >3%, and positive bronchodilator response (BDR) were independent risk factors for the high FENO level (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 3.85; p<0.001; aOR, 1.46; p=0.017; and aOR, 1.57, p=0.034, respectively) in the multivariable analysis.

Conclusion

The FENO level distribution varied in COPD patients and the mean FENO value was slightly elevated. Asthma history, eosinophil percent, and positive BDR were independent risk factors for the high FENO level.

Comparison of fractional exhaled nitric oxide, spirometry, and Asthma Control Test, in predicting asthma exacerbations: A prospective cohort study

Context

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) is a noninvasive test for airway inflammation in asthma. The usefulness of FeNO in predicting exacerbations is uncertain.

Aims

The study aims to assess and compare the ability of FeNO, spirometry, and asthma control test (ACT) in predicting future exacerbations of asthma and their correlation with each other.

Settings and Design

This prospective, cohort study was conducted at the Department of Respiratory Medicine, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal.

Materials and Methods

Adult asthma patients of age 18-65 years were included. Patients with a smoking history of >10 pack-years and those in whom spirometry was contraindicated were excluded. Patients who consented underwent FeNO and spirometry. The control of asthma was assessed using the ACT questionnaire. We captured the number of exacerbations in the follow-up period of 4 months.

Statistical Analysis Used

Mann-Whitney test was used to compare the utility of FeNO, spirometry, ACT in predicting exacerbations and Spearman's correlation coefficient was used to ascertain the correlation among them.

Results

Of 154 study patients, 28% had exacerbations. We found that there was no significant difference in FeNO in patients with and without exacerbations. The median (interquartile range [IQR]) FEV1% in the patients with and without exacerbations were 68 (55-79) and 75 (65-88), respectively (P = 0.013). The median (IQR) ACT score in patients with exacerbations was 12 (10-16) which was significantly lower than in those without exacerbation in whom it was 16 (14-18) (P = 0.003). There was a negative correlation of ACT with FeNO (Correlation coefficient: -0.167, P = 0.038). The median (IQR) FeNO level (ppb) was lower in patients who were on inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) than in the other group values being 22 (14-38) and 30 (17-58), respectively (P = 0.05).

Conclusions

In our study, FEV1% and ACT score could predict exacerbations of asthma whereas FeNO could not. FeNO level correlated inversely with ACT score. FeNO level decreased with inhaled corticosteroid usage.

Determinants of fractional exhaled nitric oxide in healthy men and women from the European Community Respiratory Health Survey III

INTRODUCTION

The fractional exhaled nitric oxide (F_E NO) is a marker for type 2 inflammation used in diagnostics and management of asthma. In order to use F_E NO as a reliable biomarker, it is important to investigate factors that influence F_E NO in healthy individuals. Men have higher levels of F_E NO than women, but it is unclear whether determinants of F_E NO differ by sex.

OBJECTIVE

To identify determinants of F_E NO in men and women without lung diseases.

METHOD

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide was validly measured in 3881 healthy subjects that had answered the main questionnaire of the European Community Respiratory Health Survey III without airways or lung disease.

RESULTS

Exhaled NO levels were 21.3% higher in men compared with women P < 0.001. Being in the upper age quartile (60.3-67.6 years), men had 19.2 ppb (95% CI: 18.3, 20.2) higher F_E NO than subjects in the lowest age quartile (39.7-48.3 years) P = 0.02. Women in the two highest age quartiles (54.6-60.2 and 60.3-67.6 years) had 15.4 ppb (14.7, 16.2), P = 0.03 and 16.4 ppb (15.6, 17.1), P = <0.001 higher F_E NO, compared with the lowest age quartile. Height was related to 8% higher F_E NO level in men (P < 0.001) and 5% higher F_E NO levels in women (P = 0.008). Men who smoked had 37% lower F_E NO levels and women had 30% lower levels compared with never-smokers (P < 0.001 for both). Men and women sensitized to both grass and perennial allergens had higher F_E NO levels compared with non-sensitized subjects 26% and 29%, P < 0.001 for both.

CONCLUSION AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide levels were higher in men than women. Similar effects of current smoking, height, and IgE sensitization were found in both sexes. F_E NO started increasing at lower age in women than in men, suggesting that interpretation of F_E NO levels in adults aged over 50 years should take into account age and sex.

Nitric Oxide Detector Based on WO3-1wt%In2O3-1wt%Nb2O5 with State-of-the-Art Selectivity and ppb-Level Sensitivity

Fast, sensitive, and precise detection of nitric oxide (NO) is critical to many applications in environmental monitoring and early disease diagnosis via respiratory testing. An effective detection system requires a sensor to detect NO gas at the parts per billion (ppb) level, and this system should possess a high degree of anti-interference selectivity. To achieve these targets, a series of gas sensor thin films based on intrinsic WO₃, one-additive-doped WO₃ (prepared by doping In₂O₃ or Nb₂O₅), and two-additive-doped WO₃ (synthesized by doping with In₂O₃ and Nb₂O₅) oxides were successfully grown. By analyzing the properties of sensitivity, selectivity, responsiveness, and recovery time of the gas sensors, we found that WO₃-1wt%In₂O₃-1wt%Nb₂O₅ has overwhelming advantages over intrinsic WO₃, WO₃-In₂O₃, and WO₃-Nb₂O₅. A sensing response value of 2.4 was observed for NO concentrations as low as 20 ppb from the WO₃-1wt%In₂O₃-1wt%Nb₂O₅ sensor. With 100 ppb NO gas, the WO₃-1wt%In₂O₃-1wt%Nb₂O₅ sensor achieved a high response of 56.1 at 70 °C, which is a state-of-the-art performance for NO detection at low working temperature settings. WO₃-1wt%In₂O₃-1wt%Nb₂O₅ also yields significantly improved selectivity and stability over intrinsic WO₃, WO₃-In₂O₃, and WO₃-Nb₂O₅. Studies on the sensing mechanism show that the grain size, rather than the n-n heterostructure effect, plays a dominant role in the observed results. By decreasing the grain size so that it is close to the thickness of the space-charge layer, the sensing response is enhanced. Although room remains to further improve the sensing properties, the performance of WO₃-1wt%In₂O₃-1wt%Nb₂O₅ is sufficient for implementation in low-content NO detection devices.