Stable tissue-mimicking materials and an anatomically realistic, adjustable head phantom for electrical impedance tomography

Towards a thoracic conductive phantom for EIT

Phantom experiments are a crucial step for testing new hardware or imaging algorithms for electrical impedance tomography (EIT) studies. However, constructing an accurate phantom for EIT research remains critical; some studies have attempted to model the skull and breasts, and even fewer, as yet, have considered the thorax. In this study, a critical comparison between the electrical properties (impedance) of three materials is undertaken: a polyurethane foam, a silicone mixture and a thermoplastic polyurethane filament. The latter was identified as the most promising material and adopted for the development of a flexible neonatal torso. The validation is performed by the EIT image reconstruction of the air filled cavities, which mimic the lung regions. The methodology is reproducible for the creation of any phantom that requires a slight flexibility.

Bi-Frequency Symmetry Difference EIT-Feasibility and Limitations of Application to Stroke Diagnosis

OBJECTIVE

Bi-Frequency Symmetry Difference (BFSD)-EIT can detect, localize and identify unilateral perturbations in symmetric scenes. Here, we test the viability and robustness of BFSD-EIT in stroke diagnosis.

METHODS

A realistic 4-layer Finite Element Method (FEM) head model with and without bleed and clot lesions is developed. Performance is assessed with test parameters including: measurement noise, electrode placement errors, contact impedance errors, deviations in assumed tissue conductivity, deviations in assumed anatomy, and a frequency-dependent background. A final test is performed using ischemic patient data. Results are assessed using images and quantitative metrics.

RESULTS

BFSD-EIT may be feasible for stroke diagnosis if a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of ≥60 dB is achievable. Sensitivity to errors in electrode positioning is seen with a tolerance of only ±5 mm, but a tolerance of up to ±30 mm is possible if symmetry is maintained between symmetrically opposite partner electrodes. The technique is robust to errors in contact impedance and assumed tissue conductivity up to at least ±50%. Asymmetric internal anatomy affects performance but may be tolerable for tissues with frequency-dependent conductivity. Errors in assumed external geometry marginally affect performance. A frequency-dependent background does not affect performance with carefully chosen frequency points or use of multiple frequency points across a band. The Global Left-Hand Side (LHS) & Right-Hand Side (RHS) Mean Intensity metric is particularly robust to errors.

CONCLUSION

BFSD-EIT is a promising technique for stroke diagnosis, provided parameters are within the tolerated ranges.

SIGNIFICANCE

BFSD-EIT may prove an important step forward in imaging of static scenes such as stroke.

Bi-frequency symmetry difference electrical impedance tomography-a novel technique for perturbation detection in static scenes

OBJECTIVE

A novel method for the imaging of static scenes using electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is reported with implementation and validation using numerical and phantom models. The technique is applicable to regions featuring symmetry in the normal case, asymmetry in the presence of a perturbation, and where there is a known, frequency-dependent change in the electrical conductivity of the materials in the region.

APPROACH

The stroke diagnostic problem is used as a motivating sample application. The head is largely symmetrical across the sagittal plane. A haemorrhagic or ischaemic lesion located away from the sagittal plane will alter this natural symmetry, resulting in a symmetrical imbalance that can be detected using EIT. Specifically, application of EIT stimulation and measurement protocols at two distinct frequencies detects deviations in symmetry if an asymmetrically positioned lesion is present, with subsequent identification and localisation of the perturbation based on known frequency-dependent conductivity changes. Anatomically accurate computational models are used to demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed technique using different types, sizes, and locations of lesions with frequency-dependent (or independent) conductivity. Further, a realistic experimental head phantom is used to validate the technique using frequency-dependent perturbations emulating the key numerical simulations.

MAIN RESULTS

Lesion presence, type, and location are detectable using this novel technique. Results are presented in the form of images and corresponding robust quantitative metrics. Better detection is achieved for larger lesions, those further from the sagittal plane, and when measurements have a higher signal-to-noise ratio.

SIGNIFICANCE

Bi-frequency symmetry difference EIT is an exciting new modality of EIT with the ability to detect deviations in the symmetry of a region that occur due to the presence of a lesion. Notably, this modality does not require a time change in the region and thus may be used in static scenarios such as stroke detection.

Symmetry difference electrical impedance tomography-a novel modality for anomaly detection

OBJECTIVE

The theoretical basis, experimental implementation, and proof of concept of a novel electrical impedance tomography (EIT) imaging technique, called symmetry difference EIT, is described. This technique is applicable in situations where there is inherent symmetry in the region being imaged.

METHODS

The sample scenario of the human head is used to describe the technique. The head is largely symmetrical across the sagittal plane. A unilateral lesion such as a haemorrhage or region of ischaemia distorts that symmetry. This distortion may be visualised using EIT. Measurement sets from a ring of electrodes placed on the boundary in both clockwise and counter-clockwise orientations are compared to detect the anomaly. Computer simulations featuring a hemispherical model of the head and brain are used initially to demonstrate the theory. Then, a more complex numerical model with anatomically accurate finite element models (FEMs) is used to expand on the concept with a more realistic scenario. Finally, tank experiments are performed with phantom lesions to validate the technique in the real world.

RESULTS

Deviations from normal symmetry, due to the presence of lesions, are detectable using this new modality. The ease of detection improves with larger lesions and those far from the plane of symmetry. Quantitative metrics, as well as an image, help to robustly detect and identify both the presence of an abnormality and the cause (haemorrhagic or ischaemic lesion in the scenarios tested) or indeed indicate where no detection is possible.

CONCLUSION

Symmetry difference EIT is a valuable new modality that is applicable to cases where the 'normal' features symmetry across a plane. Significantly, a change in the region of interest is not required and hence this technique may be suited to static or quasi-static cases where time difference EIT cannot be used.

A realistic pelvic phantom for electrical impedance measurement

OBJECTIVE

To design and fabricate an anatomically and conductively accurate phantom for electrical impedance studies of non-invasive bladder volume monitoring.

APPROACH

A modular pelvic phantom was designed and fabricated, consisting of a mechanically and conductively stable boundary wall, a background medium, and bladder phantoms. The wall and bladders are made of conductive polyurethane. The background material is an ultrasound gel-based mixture, with conductivity matched to a weighted average of the pelvic cavity organs, bone, muscle and fat. The phantom boundary is developed using a computer tomography model of a male human pelvis. The bladder phantoms were designed to correlate with human bladder dimensions. Electrical impedance measurements of the phantom were recorded, and images produced using six different bladder phantoms and a realistic finite element model.

MAIN RESULTS

Five different bladder volumes were successfully imaged using an empty bladder as a reference. The average conductivity index from the reconstructed images showed a strong positive correlation with the bladder phantom volumes.

SIGNIFICANCE

A conductively and anatomically accurate pelvic phantom was developed for non-invasive bladder volume monitoring using electrical impedance measurements. Several bladders were designed to correlate with actual human bladder volumes, allowing for accurate volume estimation. The conductivity of the phantom is accurate over 50-250 kHz. This phantom can allow changeable electrode location, contact and size; multi-layer electrodes configurations; increased complexity by addition of other organ or bone phantoms; and electrode movement and deformation. Overall, the pelvic phantom enables greater scope for experimentation and system refinement as a precursor to in-man clinical studies.