Design and analysis of biodegradable buttress threaded screws for fracture fixation in orthopedics: a finite element analysis

Finite element method-based simulation on bone fracture fixation configuration factors for biodegradable embossed locking compression plate

As an evolution, biodegradable implants need to maximize mechanical performance thereby may lead to confusion in selection of the biodegradable material and implant design to the fracture site. This requires selecting a unique fixation configuration to fit within the fractured bone, factors of which can be bone-plate clearance, interfragmentary gap, alteration in screw fixation position and variation in the number of screws whose configuration optimization can re-maximize the mechanical performance of the biodegradable implant. Therefore, these factors have been optimized based on the induced minimum stress using the finite element method-based simulation for which biodegradable embossed locking plates (BELCP) via screws made of Mg-alloy have been fitted over two fragments of femur body (as hollow cylindrical cortical bone). An average human weight of 62 kg is applied to one segment of the femur for all different configurations of each factor, where another segment is assumed to be fixed. By this simulation, the most optimal fixation configuration was found at a minimum induced stress value of 41.96 MPa which is approximately 85%, 18%, 6% and 48% respectively less than all maximum stress induced configurations in each of the factor. This optimized configuration was at the minimum clearance between bone and plate with a 3 mm interfragmentary gap using 8 screws where the locking screw begins to apply from the center of the BELCP. Overall, BELCP may be a better biodegradable implant plate for bone fracture fixation with these optimized fixation configurations as the improved mechanical performance after experimental validation.

Biomechanical evaluation on a novel design of biodegradable embossed locking compression plate for orthopaedic applications using finite element analysis

In orthopaedics, conventional implant plates such as locking compression plate (LCP) made from non-biodegradable materials play a vital role in the fixation to support bone fractures, but also create a complication such as stress shielding. These again require a painful surgery to remove/replace after they have healed as it does not degrade into the physiological environment (PE). Currently, there has already been enough discovery of biodegradable materials that, despite being mechanically inefficient compared to non-biodegradable materials, can completely be biodegraded in PE during and after healing to avoid such problems. While there has been insufficient research on the design of biodegradable implant plates, the implementation of which may help achieve the goal with an effort of high mechanical strength. A novel design of biodegradable embossed locking compression plate (BELCP) is designed for biodegradable materials to approach superior mechanical performance and complete degradation over time, considering all such parameters and factors. For biomechanical evaluation, four-point bending test (4PBT), axial compressive and tensile test (ACTT) and torsion test (TT) have been performed on LCP, BELCP and its continuously degraded forms made of biodegradable material (Mg-alloy) using finite element method. BELCP has found 50%, 100% and 100% higher mechanical performance and safer in 4PBT, ACTT and TT, respectively, than LCP. Moreover, BELCP has also observed safe during continuous degradation up to 6 months after implantation under these three tests, considering an approximate sustained degradation rate of about 4 mm/year. Even Mg-alloy made BELCP can be sufficient and safer to support fractured bone than SS-alloy made LCP, but not Ti-alloy made LCP. BELCP can be a successful biodegradable bone implant plate after human/animal trials in the future.

Effectiveness of non-uniform thickness on a locking compression plate used as a biodegradable bone implant plate

Conventional locking compression plate (LCP) made of non-biodegradable materials are well-known bone implants for internal fracture fixation because of their proven experimental success. LCP, however, is mechanically underpowered when made up of biodegradable materials (even with Mg-alloy). The biodegradable implant plate should not only exhibit adequate mechanical performance during implantation but also perform well after fracture, at least until complete healing of the fractured bone. With the aim of achieving enhanced mechanical performance, the design of the LCP has been modified to the design of Biodegradable Locking Compression Plate (BLCP) by adding a suitable thickness in the middle (only 4.6% of the total volume of the LCP), which may help retain some additional strength during implantation and after degradation. Both BLCP and LCP have been comparatively analyzed via FEM with the aid of axial compression and four-point bending tests. BLCP has a better mechanical capability of withstanding loads in its degraded form than in its non-degradable form. Furthermore, BLCP is up to 15.83% mechanically better in the non-degraded form as compared to LCP, which again becomes up to 100% more mechanically adequate in the degraded forms of BLCP than in LCP. BLCP is found safe for degradation up to 2 mm or 6 months with an estimated degradation rate of 4 mm/year, which may allow it to support fractured bone for at least the standard healing time. BLCP can be considered as a superior biodegradable bone implant plate after experimental assurance with the physiological environment and may replace LCP.

Effectiveness of laddered embossed structure in a locking compression plate for biodegradable orthopaedic implants

Locking compression plate (LCP) has conventionally been the most extensively employed plate in internal fixation bone implants used in orthopaedic applications. LCP is usually made up of non-biodegradable materials that have a higher mechanical capability. Biodegradable materials, by and large, have less mechanical strength at the point of implantation and lose strength even more after a few months of continuous degradation in the physiological environment. To attain the adequate mechanical capability of a biodegradable bone implant plate, LCP has been modified by adding laddered - type semicircular filleted embossed structure. This improved design may be named as laddered embossed locking compression plate (LELCP). It is likely to provide additional mechanical strength with the most eligible biodegradable material, namely, Mg-alloy, even after continuous degradation that results in diminished thickness. For mechanical validation and comparison of LELCP made up of Mg-alloy, four-point bending test (4PBT) and axial compressive test (ACT) have been performed on LELCP, LCP and continuously degraded LELCP (CD-LELCP) with the aid of finite element method (FEM) for the assembly of bone segments, plate and screw segments. LELCP, when subjected to the above mentioned two tests, has been observed to provide 26% and 10.4% lower equivalent stress, respectively, than LCP without degradation. It is also observed mechanically safe and capable of up to 2 and 6 months of continuous degradation (uniform reduction in thickness) for 4PBT and ACT, respectively. These results have also been found reasonably accurate through real-time surgical simulations by approaching the most optimal mesh. According to these improved mechanical performance parameters, LELCP may be used or considered as a viable biodegradable implant plate option in the future after real life or in vivo validation.

Longitudinally centered embossed structure in the locking compression plate for biodegradable bone implant plate: a finite element analysis

In the current revolution of internal fixation implant in orthopaedics, a biodegradable implant is the most awaited and exceptional medical device where biodegradable material has paid more attention to the success of a biodegradable implant than the design of a biodegradable bone implant plate. By far, LCP is the most traditionally used implant plate (using non-biodegradable material) because of its experimental success, but not with qualified biodegradable material (Mg-alloy). This lack of mechanical performance is a major drawback that can be rectified by better structural design. This will help avoid few other problems as well. Therefore, with proper consideration, the LCP has been added to a semicircular filleted longitudinally centered embossed (LCE) structure to enhance overall mechanical performance that can help emphasize mechanical support even after continuous degradation when applied in a physiological environment. For mechanical verification of this advanced design of biodegradable bone implant plate, four-point bending test (4PBT) and axial compression test (ACT) have been performed using FEM on LCELCP, LCP, continuously degraded (CD)-LCELCP, and CD-LCP. LCELCP showed reduced stress of about 22% and 10% in 4PBT and ACT, respectively, compared to LCP. CD-LCELCP is safe during ACT over 6 months of continuous degradation when the degradation rate is assumed to be 4 mm/year. These results also ensured accuracy using mesh convergence and also mesh checked for quality assurance. Overall, LCELCP can be considered as a biodegradable bone implant plate because of its superior performance, if its ultimate validation is carried out through animal/human trials as future work.