Epidemiologically closely related viruses from hemophilia B patients display high homology in two hypervariable regions of the HIV-1 env gene

Fifteen years of env C2V3C3 evolution in six individuals infected clonally with human immunodeficiency virus type 1

The study of the evolution of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) requires blood samples collected longitudinally and data on the approximate time point of infection. Although these requirements were fulfilled in several previous studies, the infectious sources were either unknown or heterogeneous genetically. In the present study, HIV-1 env C2V3C3 (nt 7029-7315) evolution was examined retrospectively in a cohort of hemophiliacs. Compared to other cohorts, the area of interest here was the infection of six hemophiliacs by the same virus strain, that is, the infecting viruses shared an identical genome. As expected, divergence from the founder sequence as well as interpatient divergence of the predominant virus strains increased significantly over time. Based on the V3 nucleotide sequences, CCR5 usage was predicted exclusively throughout the whole period of infection in all patients. Interestingly, common patterns of viral evolution were detected in the patients of the cohort. Four amino acid substitutions within the V3 loop emerged and persisted subsequently in five (positions 305 and 308 of the HXB2 gp120 reference sequence) and six patients (positions 325 and 328 in HXB2 gp120), respectively. These common changes within the V3 loop are likely to be enforced by HIV-1 specific immune response.

The molecular epidemiology of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 in six cities in Britain and Ireland

We have sequenced the p17 coding regions of the gag gene from 211 patients infected either through injecting drug use (IDU) or by sexual intercourse between men from six cities in Scotland, N. England, N. Ireland, and the Republic of Ireland. All sequences were of subtype B. Phylogenetic analysis revealed substantial heterogeneity in the sequences from homosexual men. In contrast, sequence from over 80% of IDUs formed a relatively tight cluster, distinct both from those of published isolates and of the gay men. There was no large-scale clustering of sequences by city in either risk group, although a number of close associations between pairs of individuals were observed. From the known date of the HIV-1 epidemic among IDUs in Edinburgh, the rate of sequence divergence at synonymous sites is estimated to be about 0.8%. On this basis we estimate the date of divergence of the sequences among homosexual men to be about 1975, which may correspond to the origin of the B subtype epidemic.

Risks and issues for the health care worker in the human immunodeficiency virus era

The perception of degree of risk can vary markedly from actual risk. About 5% of the cases of AIDS and HIV infection in the United States have occurred in health care workers, a percentage that has remained stable over time. Nearly all of these infections are related to lifestyle factors, not occupational risk. The rise of occupational transmission is greatest with parenteral injuries. If there is an HIV risk to patients, it appears to be very much smaller than the risk to workers although it has received even more publicity. Apprehension exists concerning the future framework of the medical care delivery system and who will care for whom. The sensitive handling of legitimate fears and the balancing of conflicting risks will continue to be a challenging task in the decades ahead.

Elucidation of an HIV-1 transmission from mother to child in west Africa by sequence analysis

A pregnant woman living in Germany went to Ghana for several months, where she received 4 blood transfusions. Her newborn child also received one blood transfusion in West Africa. After return to Germany, HIV-1 infection was detected in both of them. Serotyping with V3 peptides revealed that the sera reacted only poorly with the subtype B-specific antigens. To investigate whether the child had been infected by vertical or parenteral transmission, we amplified different proviral HIV-1 gene segments from samples obtained 1-3 years after infection. Sequence analysis of the hypervariable regions V1 and V2 of the proviral env gene was misleading, since the viral population of the mother was highly heterogeneous, whereas only one predominant viral variant was found in the child. In contrast, sequences of the gag p17 gene and the regulatory genes nef and vif were homogeneous and revealed a very high homology, suggesting that the child had been infected by the mother. This was confirmed by phylogenetic tree analysis showing that sequences of mother and child clustered together and that both were infected by HIV-1 subtype A which is common in West Africa. The results suggest that sequence analysis of the hypervariable regions V1 and V2 alone can lead to unclear results, especially if not single genomes are analysed but a mixture of quasi-species. It is recommended that investigations into HIV transmission should be based on sequence analysis of several HIV genes.

The genetic diversification of the HIV type 1 gag p17 gene in patients infected from a common source

An evolutionary analysis was undertaken of HIV-1 gag p17 sequences taken from a small cohort of hemophilia B patients infected from a common batch of clotting factor concentrate. The sequence population found at seroconversion was highly homogeneous, suggesting that the infecting batch also contained little sequence variation. Genetic diversification was found in follow-up sequences taken approximately 3 years later and was generally found to be complex. Greater rates of synonymous to nonsynonymous substitution were observed, especially when comparing distantly related isolates, and the rate of synonymous substitution was used to estimate times of divergence for a number of isolates of HIV-1 including the origin of the subtypes A to H. The p17 region is therefore proposed as a useful marker for future epidemiological studies.

Parallel evolution in the V3 region of HIV type 1 after infection of hemophiliacs from a homogeneous source

To determine the genetic diversification in the highly functional V3 loop, we followed up five hemophiliacs who were infected by a homogeneous HIV-1 population from a contaminated clotting factor lot. Initially, all patients displayed identical DNA sequences in this part of the proviral env gene. Therefore, this unique outbreak allows us to investigate the biological and genetic development of a common ancestor virus in different patients. A high degree of homology is maintained in the predominant sequences from 5 until 35 months after seroconversion. Only one patient showed a remarkable diversification 3 years postinfection. However, these genetic changes in the V3 region were not associated with disease progression. Discontinuous sequence changes were observed mainly in a region downstream of the V3 loop. Two positions in particular are involved in a sequence evolution within the V3 loop leading to the same amino acids in different patients. These directed changes occurred at sites that are reported to be critical for the specificity of antibodies (position 308) and viral cytopathicity (position 324). However, the parallel evolution was associated neither with differentiation of the viral phenotype nor with progression of the disease.

Diversification of HIV-1 strains after infection from a unique source

In 1990, 7 hemophilia B patients were infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) after exposure to a single common lot of clotting factor. The hypervariable regions V1 and V2 of the proviral env gene from the patients shared a homology between 97.5% and 100% at the time of seroconversion. To determine the in vivo diversification of these epidemiologically closely related virus strains, the patients were followed up in the early phase of HIV infection. Direct sequencing of the V1/V2 region in the env gene still revealed a very high degree of homology (96.5%-100%). In the case of the patient who showed the highest decrease of CD4+ cells, moderate genetic diversification of the virus was associated with a biological differentiation. The strain originally presenting two expressed substitutions displayed three more deviations 9 months after the first investigation (including one reversion to the consensus sequence). In addition, the virus that originally could not be cultivated could now be isolated as a low cytopathogenic agent. This study provides evidence that the high genetic homogeneity of HIV-1 observed at the time of seroconversion is maintained as a predominant consensus sequence in the following so-called latent phase of infection.

Characterization of the specificity of the human antibody response to the V3 neutralization domain of HIV-1

The major neutralization domain of HIV-1, contained in the third variable region (V3) of the external envelope, is highly variable at positions flanking a conserved glycine-proline-glycine sequence. We investigated the relation between V3 sequences of HIV-1 variants circulating in a host and that host's antibody specificity. Multiple V3 sequences were obtained directly, via PCR and subsequent cloning, from serum RNA or cellular DNA from 26 individuals (from 12 around seroconversion). Then, specificity of sera from these individuals to a panel of V3 peptides was determined. The specificity (best recognized peptide) of the early antibody response accurately reflected the virus population circulating around seroconversion in 12/12 individuals and 4/4 HIV-1-infected chimpanzees. A change in serum specificity at later stages of infection was rare: five years after seroconversion, only 3 of 46 individuals had a specificity that differed completely from that in the first year. However, the V3 domain of the virus does change over time, as evidenced by the poor correlation between V3 sequences obtained late in infection and V3 antibody reactivity at the same time point. Thus, in contrast to the accurate antibody response to HIV-1 variants early after infection, generally a specific response to variants emerging at later stages seemed to be absent or of low level. Instead, the early response appeared to be preserved. Finally, we made use of the observed accurate reflection to analyze the variation for the V3 domain of HIV-1 in the Netherlands by probing specificities of early sera from 129 Dutch seroconverting individuals. Specific reactivity to RKSIHIGPGRAFYTTG was found in 36%, to RKSINIGPGRAFYTTG in 12% and to RKSIPIGPGRAFYTTG in 18% of these Dutch sera.

HIV-1 genomic RNA diversification following sexual and parenteral virus transmission

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genomic RNA variation was studied in seven presumed donor-recipient pairs directly following sexual (6/7) or parenteral (1/7) transmission. The first RNA-positive serum sample of each recipient and the serum sample of the virus transmitter, identified by epidemiological history and taken within a time bracket of three months of the recipient seroconversion, were analyzed by polymerase chain reaction amplification followed by sequencing of eight cDNA clones of 276 bp, including the V3 coding region. The sequence populations of the recipients were without exception homogeneous, while the sequence populations of the transmitters showed varying degrees of heterogeneity. Nucleotide distance between consensus sequences of unrelated individuals from the Amsterdam population (interpatient variation) averaged 11% (range 7-15%). The largest distance between two clonal sequences of one individual (intrapatient variation) was also 11%. Consensus sequences of five recipients differed by only 0-1% from the consensus sequence of the presumed transmitter, including two pairs of which the transmission was either proven or highly probable. This contrasted with a difference of 10-12% in two pairs, casting doubt on the epidemiological relatedness. Antibody reactivity to a panel of V3 peptides with varying degrees of similarity to the V3 sequences obtained did not augment the discriminatory power of sequence analysis. Results of the sequential sequencing of samples of one transmitter suggest that this was due to an anamnestic antibody response of the transmitter to early variants. From the loss of sequence heterogeneity following transmission and the consensus sequence similarities observed within five transmitter-recipient pairs, we conclude that HIV-1 transmission results in the selection of a limited number of genomes carrying on the infection in the new host, but does not generally lead to a shift in the sequence population as defined by the consensus sequence.

HIV infection and the healthcare worker

The perception of degree of risk can vary markedly from actual risk. About 5% of the cases of AIDS and HIV infection in the United States have occurred in healthcare workers, a percentage that has remained stable over time. Nearly all of these infections are related to lifestyle factors, not occupational risk. The risk to patients appears to be very much smaller, but has received even more publicity. Apprehension exists concerning the future framework of our medical care delivery system and who will care for whom. The sensitive handling of legitimate fears and the minimization and balancing of conflicting risks will be a challenging task in the decades ahead.