Transcript Levels of Several Epigenome Regulatory Genes in Bovine Somatic Donor Cells Are Not Correlated with Their Cloning Efficiency

Validation of reference genes for use in untreated bovine fibroblasts

Proper normalization of RT-qPCR data is pivotal to the interpretation of results and accuracy of scientific conclusions. Though different approaches may be taken, normalization against multiple reference genes is now standard practice. Genes traditionally used and deemed constitutively expressed have demonstrated variability in expression under different experimental conditions, necessitating the proper validation of reference genes prior to utilization. Considering the wide use of fibroblasts in research and scientific applications, it is imperative that suitable reference genes for fibroblasts of different animal origins and conditions be elucidated. Previous studies on bovine fibroblasts have tested limited genes and/or samples. Herein, we present an extensive study investigating the expression stability of 16 candidate reference genes across 7 untreated bovine fibroblast cell lines subjected to controlled conditions. Data were analysed using various statistical tools and algorithms, including geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RefFinder. A combined use of GUSB and RPL13A was determined to be the best approach for data normalization in untreated bovine fibroblasts.

Investigating Markers of Reprogramming Potential in Somatic Cell Lines Derived from Matched Donors

Somatic cell biobanking and related technologies, somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), and induction of pluripotent stem cells offer significant promise for wildlife conservation, but have yet to achieve optimal success. Inefficiency and variability in outcome have been linked to incomplete nuclear reprogramming, highlighting the importance of donor cell contribution. Studies show significant differences in SCNT outcome in donor cell lines within and between individuals, highlighting the necessity for a standardized characterization method to evaluate cell line reprogramming potential. Stringently standardized bovine fibroblast cell lines were generated and assessed for inter- and intraindividual variability on cellular (morphology, chromosome number, apoptotic incidence; Experiment 1) and molecular (pluripotency and epigenetic-related gene expression; Experiment 2) levels encompassing putative biomarkers of reprogramming potential. Cellular parameters were similar across cell lines. While some statistically significant differences were observed in DNMT1, DNMT3B, and HAT1, but not HDAC1, their biological relevance could not be determined with the information at hand. This study lays the foundation for understanding cellular characteristics in cultured cell lines; however, further studies are required to determine any correlation with reprogramming potential.

Improves the In Vitro Developmental Competence and Reprogramming Efficiency of Cloned Bovine Embryos by Additional Complimentary Cytoplasm

Somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) is a useful technology; however, its efficiency is low. In this study, we investigated the effects of cytoplasmic transfer into enucleated oocytes on the developmental competence and quality of cloned preimplantation bovine embryos via terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick-end labeling, quantitative reverse transcription PCR, and immunocytochemistry. We used cytoplasm injection cloning technology (CICT), a new technique via which the cytoplasmic volume of an enucleated oocyte could be restored by injecting ∼30% of the cytoplasm of a donor oocyte. The percentages of embryos that underwent cleavage and formed a blastocyst were significantly higher (p < 0.05) in the CICT group than in the SCNT group (28.9 ± 0.8% vs. 20.2 ± 1.3%, respectively). Furthermore, the total cell number per day 8 blastocyst was significantly higher in the CICT group than in the SCNT group (176.2 ± 6.5 vs. 119.3 ± 7.7, p < 0.05). Moreover, CICT increased mitochondrial activity, as detected using MitoTracker^® Green. The mRNA levels of DNA methyltransferase 1 and DNA methyltransferase 3a were significantly lower (p < 0.05) in the CICT group than in the SCNT group. The mRNA level of DNA methyltransferase 3b was lower in the CICT group than in the SCNT group; however, this difference was not significant (p > 0.05). Taken together, these data suggest that CICT improves the in vitro developmental competence and quality of cloned bovine embryos.

Improved embryo development using high cysteamine concentration during IVM and sperm co-culture with COCs previous to ICSI in bovine

In contrast to other species, intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) in bovine remains inefficient, resulting in low embryo developmental rates. It is unclear whether such inefficiency is due to the poor response of bovine ooplasms to the injection stimulus, or to the inability of bull sperm to induce oocyte activation. In order to facilitate these events, two strategies were assessed: the use of high concentration of cysteamine [Cys] during IVM; and the selection of sperm attached to cumulus cells after incubation with COCs for ICSI. First, COCs were IVM with increasing [Cys] and subjected to IVF. Zygotes from all groups were cultured under different O₂ tensions and development to blastocyst was evaluated. In a second experiment, sperm were co-cultured for 3 h with COCs and acrosome reaction was studied. Afterwards, the best IVM and IVC conditions determined on Experiment 1 were used for ICSI assay. COCs were matured for 21 h with 1 (Cys 1) or 0.1 mM Cys (Cys 0.1 groups, standard condition). In addition, COCs were incubated for ≥3 h with 16 × 10⁶ sperm/ml and only sperm attached to cumulus cells were selected for ICSI (ICSI + Co-cult groups). After chemical activation, embryos were cultured in SOF medium under low O₂ tension. Cleavage and blastocyst rates were evaluated at days 2 and 7 of IVC, respectively. Finally, the relative expression of eight genes indicators of embryo quality was compared between ICSI and IVF control blastocysts by qPCR. Cleavage rates were higher for Cys 0.1 ICSI + Co-cult and Cys 1 ICSI + Co-cult groups (n = 117, 92% and n = 116, 79%, respectively) compared to their controls (n = 132, 60% for Cys 0.1 ICSI and n = 108, 52% for Cys 1 ICSI) (p ≤ 0.05). Interestingly, the combined treatment (Cys 1 ICSI + Co-cult) showed higher blastocyst rates than all other ICSI groups (23 vs. 11, 18 and 14% for Cys 0.1 ICSI + Co-cult, Cys 1 ICSI, and Cys 0.1 ICSI, respectively) (p ≤ 0.05). Moreover, incubation with COCs increased the rates of live acrosome reacted sperm (p ≤ 0.05). The relative abundance of mRNAs coding for INFτ, CAT, DNMT1, OCT4, and HDAC3 did not differ between treatments (p ≤ 0.05). SOD2, HADC1 and HADC2 expression was higher for Cys 0.1 ICSI than for IVF embryos (p ≤ 0.05). Group Cys 1 ICSI did not differ from IVF for those three genes, neither did Cys 1 ICSI + Co-cult, except for HDAC1 (p ≤ 0.05). In conclusion, the use of 1 mM Cys during IVM and of sperm incubated with mature COCs might be a good strategy to improve ICSI outcomes in cattle.

Effects of co-culture of cumulus oocyte complexes with denuded oocytes during in vitro maturation on the developmental competence of cloned bovine embryos

This study evaluated the effects of co-culture of immature cumulus oocyte complexes (COCs) with denuded immature oocytes (DO) during in vitro maturation on the developmental competence and quality of cloned bovine embryos. We demonstrated that developmental competence, judged by the blastocyst formation rate, was significantly higher in the co-cultured somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT+DO, 37.1 ± 1.1%) group than that in the non-co-cultured somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT-DO, 25.1 ± 0.9%) group and was very similar to that in the control IVF (IVF, 38.8 ± 2.8%) group. Moreover, the total cell number per blastocyst in the SCNT+DO group (101.7 ± 6.2) was higher than that in the SCNT-DO group (81.7 ± 4.3), while still less than that in the IVF group (133.3 ± 6.0). Furthermore, our data showed that mRNA levels of the methylation-related genes DNMT1 and DNMT3a in the SCNT+DO group were similar to that in the IVF group, while they were significantly higher in the SCNT-DO group. Similarly, while the mRNA levels of the deacetylation-related genes HDAC2 and HDAC3 were significantly higher in the SCNT-DO group, they were comparable between the IVF and SCNT+DO groups. However, the mRNA levels of HDAC1 and DNMT3B were significantly higher in the SCNT+DO group than in the other groups. In conclusion, the present study demonstrated that co-culture of COCs with DO improves the in vitro developmental competence and quality of cloned embryos, as evidenced by increased total cell number.

Reshaping the transcriptional frontier: epigenetics and somatic cell nuclear transfer

Somatic-cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) experiments have paved the way to the field of cellular reprogramming. The demonstrated ability to clone over 20 different species to date has proven that the technology is robust but very inefficient, and is prone to developmental anomalies. Yet, the offspring from cloned animals exhibit none of the abnormalities of their parents, suggesting the low efficiency and high developmental mortality are epigenetic in origin. The epigenetic barriers to reprogramming somatic cells into a totipotent embryo capable of developing into a viable offspring are significant and varied. Despite their intimate relationship, chromatin structure and transcription are often not uniformly reprogramed after nuclear transfer, and many cloned embryos develop gene expression profiles that are hybrids between the donor cell and an embryonic blastomere. Recent advances in cellular reprogramming suggest that alteration of donor-cell chromatin structure towards that found in an normal embryo is actually the rate-limiting step in successful development of SCNT embryos. Here we review the literature relevant to the transformation of a somatic-cell nucleus into an embryo capable of full-term development. Interestingly, while resetting somatic transcription and associated epigenetic marks are absolutely required for development of SCNT embryos, life does not demand perfection.

Longitudinal study of reproductive performance of female cattle produced by somatic cell nuclear transfer

The objective of this study was to determine whether or not reproductive performance in cattle produced by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) is significantly different from that of their genetic donors. To address this question, we directed two longitudinal studies using different embryo production procedures: (1) superovulation followed by artificial insemination (AI) and embryo collection and (2) ultrasound-guided ovum pick-up followed by in vitro fertilization (OPU-IVF). Collectively, these two studies represent the largest data set available for any species on the reproductive performance of female clones and their genetic donors as measured by their embryo production outcomes in commercial embryo production program. The large-scale study described herein was conducted over a six-year period of time and provides a unique comparison of 96 clones to the 40 corresponding genetic donors. To our knowledge, this is the first longitudinal study on the reproductive performance of cattle clones using OPU-IVF. With nearly 2,000 reproductive procedures performed and more than 9,200 transferable embryos produced, our observations show that the reproductive performance of cattle produced by SCNT is not different compared to their genetic donors for the production of transferable embryos after either AI followed by embryo collection (P = 0.77) or OPU-IVF (P = 0.97). These data are in agreement with previous reports showing that the reproductive capabilities of cloned cattle are equal to that of conventionally produced cattle. In conclusion, results of this longitudinal study once again demonstrate that cloning technology, in combination with superovulation, AI and embryo collection or OPU-IVF, provides a valuable tool for faster dissemination of superior maternal genetics.

Critical developmental stages for the efficiency of somatic cell nuclear transfer in zebrafish

Somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) has been performed extensively in fish since the 1960s with a generally low efficiency of approximately 1%. Little is known about somatic nuclear reprogramming in fish. Here, we utilized the zebrafish as a model to study reprogramming events of nuclei from tail, liver and kidney cells by SCNT. We produced a total of 4,796 reconstituted embryos and obtained a high survival rate of 58.9-67.4% initially at the 8-cell stage. The survival rate exhibited two steps of dramatic decrease, leading to 8.7-13.9% at the dome stage and to 1.5-2.96% by the shield stage. Concurrently, we observed that SCNT embryos displayed apparently delayed development also at the two stages, namely the dome stage (1:30 ± 0:40) and the shield stage (2:50 ± 0:50), indicating that the dome and shield stage are critical for the SCNT efficiency. Interestingly, we also revealed that an apparent alteration in klf4 and mycb expression occurred at the dome stage in SCNT embryos from all the three donor cell sources. Taken together, these results suggest that the dome stage is critical for the SCNT efficiency, and that alternated gene expression appears to be common to SCNT embryos independently of the donor cell types, suggesting that balanced mycb and klf4 expression at this stage is important for proper reprogramming of somatic nuclei in zebrafish SCNT embryos. Although the significant alteration in klf4 and mycb expression was not identified at the shield stage between ZD and SCNT embryos, the importance of reprogramming processes at the shield stage should not be underestimated in zebrafish SCNT embryos.

Examination of DNA methyltransferase expression in cloned embryos reveals an essential role for Dnmt1 in bovine development

In studies of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), the ability of factors within the oocyte to epigenetically reprogram transferred nuclei is essential for embryonic development of the clone to proceed. However, irregular patterns of X-chromosome inactivation, abnormal expression of imprinted genes, and genomic DNA hypermethylation are frequently observed in reconstructed embryos, suggesting abnormalities in this process. To better understand the epigenetic events underlying SCNT reprogramming, we sought to determine if the abnormal DNA methylation levels observed in cloned embryos result from a failure of the oocyte to properly reprogram transcription versus differential biochemical regulation of the DNA methyltransferase family of enzymes (DNMTs) between embryonic and somatic nuclei. To address this question, we conducted real-time quantitation of Dnmt transcripts in bovine preimplantation embryos generated though in vitro fertilization (IVF), parthenogenic activation, and SCNT. By the 8-cell stage, transcripts encoding Dnmt1 become significantly down-regulated in cloned embryos, likely in response to the state of genomic hypermethylation, while the de novo methyltransferases maintain an expression pattern indistinguishable from their IVF and parthenote counterparts. Depletion of embryonic/maternal Dnmt1 transcripts within IVF embryos using short-interfering RNAs, while able to lower genomic DNA methylation levels, resulted in developmental arrest at the 8/16-cell stage. In contrast, SCNT embryos derived from a stable, Dnmt1-depleted donor cell line develop to blastocyst stage, but failed to carry to term. Our results indicate an essential role for Dnmt1 during bovine preimplantation development, and suggest proper transcriptional reprogramming of this gene family in SCNT embryos.