Patients with TSH-Receptor Blocking Antibodies Give a “Positive” Result for Stimulating Activity in Several Commercial Assays

Performance and Specificity of 6 Immunoassays for TSH Receptor Antibodies: A Multicenter Study

BACKGROUND

The measurement of TSH receptor (TSHR) antibodies is warranted for diagnosis of Graves' disease (GD).

OBJECTIVE

The performance, detection sensitivity, and specificity of 6 TSHR immunoassays were compared.

METHODS

Two bioassays and 4 binding assays (Kronus, Immulite, Kryptor, Dynex) were compared in a dilution study performed in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease. Both bioassays were compared to 2 binding assays using stimulatory (M22) and blocking (K1-70) monoclonal antibody (MAb) mixtures.

RESULTS

Thirty samples from stimulatory (TSAb)-positive/blocking (TBAb)-negative patients with GD were diluted serially and measured in all assays. Samples were positive until dilution 1:2,187 in the TSAb bioassay, 1:81 in the Immulite (p < 0.002 vs. bioassay) and Kronus ELISA (p = 0.039) assays, and 1:27 in the Kryptor and Dynex ELISA (p < 0.001 vs. bioassay). Ten samples from TBAb-positive/TSAb-negative patients with GD or Hashimoto's thyroiditis were positive in all binding assays. None of the binding assays differentiated between TSAb and TBAb. Mixtures of 100% K1-70 (200 ng/mL), 80% K1-70 + 20% M22, 60% K1-70 + 40% M22, 40% K1-70 + 60% M22, 20% K1-70 + 80% M22, and 100% M22 (20 ng/mL) tested positive in both Immulite (26.4, 20.2, 15.2, 10.5, 6.3, 2.00 IU/L) and Kronus assays (27.1, 23.3, 19.3, 12.0, 5.7, 2.2 IU/L). These MAb mixtures were tested in the TBAb bioassay and showed 82, 61, 24 (negative), -26 (negative), -77 (negative), and -95% (negative) inhibition, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The sample dilution study showed higher detection sensitivity for the TSAb bioassay, and the antibody mixture study demonstrated exclusive specificity of the bioassays over all automated and ELISA binding assays.