Multiple Complex Chronic Conditions and Pediatric Hospice Utilization among California Medicaid Beneficiaries, 2007-2010

Healthcare service use for children with chronic complex diseases: A longitudinal six-year follow-up study

PURPOSE

The objective was analysed the patterns use of healthcare services of this population and the influence of their clinical and sociodemographic characteristics.

DESIGN AND METHODS

A six-year longitudinal follow-up study was performed to evaluate the annual healthcare resources use and clinical data among children with complex chronic diseases in Spain between 2015 and 2021. The sample trends in healthcare usage and the associated factors were analysed using ANCOVA and multivariable linear regression models.

RESULTS

Patients had high attendance during the follow-up period, with >15 episodes year. This trend decreased over time, especially in children with oncological diseases compared with other diseases (F (16.75; 825.4) = 32.457; p < 0.001). A multivariable model showed that children with a greater number of comorbidities (β = 0.17), shorter survival time (β = -0.23), who had contact with the palliative care unit (β = 0.16), and whose mothers had a higher professional occupation (β = 0.14), had a greater use of the healthcare system.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with a higher number of comorbidities and the use of medical devices made a greater frequentation of health services, showing a trend of decreasing use over time. Socioeconomic factors such as mothers' occupational status determine healthcare frequentation. These results suggest the existence of persistent gaps in care coordination sustained over time.

PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

Systematized and coordinated models of care for this population should consider the presence of inequalities in health care use.

How Do Children With Medical Complexity Die? A Scoping Review

Introduction: Advancement in medical expertise and technology has led to a growing cohort of children with medical complexity (CMC), who make up a rising proportion of childhood deaths. However, end of life in CMC is poorly understood and little is known about illness trajectories, communication, and decision-making experiences. Objective: To synthesize existing literature and characterize the end-of-life experience in CMC. Methods: A literature search of MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Scopus, Embase, and Google Scholar was conducted up to August 26, 2021. Studies reporting CMC at end of life were included and the extracted data were analyzed descriptively. Findings: Of 1535 publications identified, 23 studies were included. Most studies (15/23 [65%]) were published from 2015 to 2021 and were quantitative in nature (20/23 [87%]). The majority of studies that extracted data from a single country (18/20 [90%]) originated from North America. Study outcomes were categorized into four main domains: (1) place of death (2) health care use (3) interventions received or withdrawn (4) communication, and end-of-life experiences. The weighted percentage of in-hospital CMC deaths was 80.6%. Studies reported that CMC had increased health care use and were subjected to more intensive interventions at end of life compared with non-CMC. Qualitative studies highlighted the following themes: Intrinsic prognostic uncertainty, differing perspectives of the child's quality of life, the chronic illness experience, a desire to have parental expertise acknowledged, surprise at the terminal event, the experience of multiple losses, with an overarching theme of the need for compassionate care at end of life. Conclusions: This scoping review highlighted important characteristics of end of life in CMC, outlining the emerging evidence and knowledge gaps on this topic. A better understanding of this cohort of seriously and chronically ill children would serve to inform clinical practice, service development, and future research.

How are children with medical complexity being identified in epidemiological studies? A systematic review

BACKGROUND

There are different definitions to identify/classify children with medical complexity (CMC). We aimed to investigate and describe the definitions used to classify CMC in epidemiological studies.

METHODS

PubMed, SciELO, LILACS, and EMBASE were searched from 2015 to 2020 (last updated September 15th, 2020) for original studies that presented the definition used to classify/identify CMC in the scientific research method. We applied the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses methodology. From the included studies, the following were identified: first author, year of publication, design, population, study period, the definition of CMC used, limitations, and strengths.

RESULTS

Nine hundred and sixty-seven records were identified in the searched databases, and 42 met the inclusion criteria. Of the 42 studies included, the four most frequent definitions used in the articles included in this review were classification of CMC into nine diagnostic categories based on the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9) (35.7%, 15 articles); update of the previous classification for ICD-10 codes with the inclusion of other conditions in the definition (21.4%, nine articles); definition based on a medical complexity algorithm for classification (16.7%, seven articles); and a risk rating system (7.1%, three articles).

CONCLUSIONS

CMC definitions using diagnostic codes were more frequent. However, several limitations were found in its uses. Our research highlighted the need to improve health information systems to accurately characterize the CMC population and promote the provision of comprehensive care.

A National Study of Healthcare Service Patterns at the End of Life Among Children With Cardiac Disease

BACKGROUND

Heart diseases are one of the leading causes of health-related deaths among children. Concurrent hospice care offers hospice and nonhospice healthcare services simultaneously, but the use of these services by children with cardiac disease has been rarely investigated.

OBJECTIVE

The aims of this study were to identify patterns of nonhospice healthcare services used in concurrent hospice care and describe the profile of children with cardiac disease in these clusters.

METHODS

This study was a retrospective cohort analysis of Medicaid claims data collected between 2011 and 2013 from 1635 pediatric cardiac patients. The analysis included descriptive statistics and latent class analysis.

RESULTS

Children in the sample used more than 314 000 nonhospice healthcare services. The most common services were inpatient hospital procedures, durable medical equipment, and home health. Latent class analysis clustered children into "moderate intensity" (60.0%) and "high intensity" classes (40.0%). Children in "moderate intensity" had dysrhythmias (31.7%), comorbidities (85.0%), mental/behavioral health conditions (55%), and technology dependence (71%). They commonly resided in urban areas (60.1%) in the Northeast (44.4%). The health profile of children in the "high intensity" class included dysrhythmias (39.4%), comorbidities (97.6%), mental/behavioral health conditions (71.5%), and technology dependence (85.8%). These children resided in rural communities (50.7%) in the South (53.1%).

CONCLUSIONS

Two patterns of use of nonhospice healthcare services were identified in this study. This information may be used by nurses and other healthcare professionals working in concurrent hospice care to assess the healthcare service needs of children with cardiac conditions at the end of life.

Patterns of Healthcare Services Among Children With Advanced Cancer in Concurrent Hospice Care

BACKGROUND

Children with advanced cancer have access to comprehensive cancer care and hospice care if they enroll in concurrent hospice care. However, little is known about the patterns of nonhospice healthcare services used by these children.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to examine the patterns of nonhospice healthcare services among children with cancer in concurrent hospice care.

METHODS

This study was a retrospective cohort analysis of 2011-2013 Medicaid claims data from 862 pediatric cancer patients. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and latent class analysis (LCA).

RESULTS

Children used 120 388 healthcare services, including inpatient and outpatient hospital services, laboratories and x-rays, durable medical equipment, medications, and others. These services clustered into 2 classes with moderate-intensity (57.49%) and high-intensity (42.50%) healthcare service use. Children in the high-intensity cluster were more likely to reside in the South with comorbidities, mental/behavioral health conditions, and technology dependence and were less likely to have solid tumors, compared with the moderate-intensity group.

CONCLUSIONS

Nonhospice healthcare services clustered together in 2 distinct classes, providing critical insight into the complexity of the healthcare use among children with cancer in concurrent hospice care.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Understanding that pediatric patients in concurrent care may have different healthcare service patterns may assist oncology nurses caring for children with advanced cancer. These findings also have policy implications.

Identifying Patterns of Pediatric Mental and Behavioral Health at End of Life: A National Study

Children, who enroll in hospice, have complex mental and behavioral health (MHBH) problems. There is limited literature on patterns of these problems among children at their end of life. Using the national database of 6195 children enrolled in hospice between January 1, 2011, and December 31, 2013, and latent class analysis, this study identified 4 distinctive classes of children. Neurodevelopment and anxiety class (26.5% of the sample) had 41.3% of children of 15 years or older, who had an average of 1.4 MHBH comorbidities and took 17 medications; 29.1% had physical health comorbidities, and 23% were dependent on technology. In the Behavior and Neurodevelopment class (20%), 53.1% of the children were between ages 6 and 14 years, who had an average of 2 MHBH comorbidities and took 17 medications. In the Physiology class (43.4%), 65.5% of children were younger than 5 years, had 1 MHBH comorbidity, and took 19 medications. In the Mood, Behaviors, and Anxiety class (10.2%), more than 90% of children were older than 6 years, had 4 MHBH comorbidities, and took 30 medications. In the latter 3 classes, approximately half of the children either had physical health comorbidities or were technology dependent. These findings highlight the importance of end-of-life care that accounts for the likely presence of complicated patterns of MHBH conditions.

Medical complexity and concurrent hospice care: A national study of Medicaid children from 2011 to 2013

PURPOSE

Pediatric hospice is a comprehensive model of care for medically complex children at end of life. The Affordable Care Act changed regulatory requirements for pediatric Medicaid enrollees to allow for enrollment into hospice services while still receiving life-prolonging therapy. There are gaps in understanding factors associated with pediatric concurrent hospice care use. The objectives were to examine the prevalence of concurrent hospice care overtime and investigated the relationship between medical complexity and concurrent hospice care among Medicaid children.

DESIGN AND METHODS

We used national Medicaid data and included children less than 21 years with an admission to hospice care. Medical complexity was defined with four criteria (i.e., chronic conditions, functional limitations, high health care use and substantial needs). Using multivariate logistic regression, we evaluated the influence of medical complexity on concurrent hospice care use, while controlling for demographic, hospice, and community characteristics.

RESULTS

Thirty-four percent of the study sample used concurrent hospice care. Medical complexity was unrelated to concurrent hospice care. However, the four individual criteria were associated. A complex chronic condition was negatively related to concurrent hospice care, whereas technology dependence, multiple complex chronic conditions, and mental/behavioral disorders were positively associated to concurrent care use.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

These findings suggest that concurrent hospice care may be important for a subset of medically complex children with functional limitations, high health utilization, and substantial needs at end of life.

A National Profile of Children Receiving Pediatric Concurrent Hospice Care, 2011 to 2013

When the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) was passed, it fundamentally changed end-of-life care for children. Concurrent Care for Children (ACA, section 2302) enables Medicaid/Children's Health Insurance Program children with a prognosis of 6 months to live to use hospice care while continuing treatment for their terminal illness. Although ACA, section 2302, was enacted a decade ago, little is known about these children. The purpose of this study was to generate the first-ever national profile of children enrolled in concurrent hospice care. Using data from multiple sources, including US Medicaid data files from 2011 to 2013, a descriptive analysis of the demographic, community, hospice, and clinical characteristics of children receiving concurrent hospice care was conducted. The analysis revealed that the national sample was extremely medically complex, even for children at end of life. They received care within a complicated system involving primary care providers, hospices, and hospitals. These findings have clinical and care coordination implications for hospice nurses.

Pediatric Complex Chronic Conditions: Evaluating Two Versions of the Classification System

The original pediatric complex chronic conditions (CCC) classification system developed in 2000/2001 is the gold standard in classifying children with life-limiting illnesses. It was significantly modified in 2014; yet the two systems have not been evaluated. The objective of this study was to evaluate the agreement and validity of the original versus the modified CCC classification systems. Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP) Kids' Inpatient Database (KID) data from 2012 was used with a sample of infant decedents less than 1 years. The agreement (i.e., Cohen's Kappa Statistic) and validity (i.e., sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value [PPV]) statistics were calculated. Among the 10,175 infants that were classified, the modified system performed well in identifying infants who had a CCC, and it captured infants that the original classification did not. The modified system represents an improvement over the original, but additional testing is warranted.

HPNA 2019-2022 Research Agenda: Development and Rationale

Building on the strong work of previous research agendas (2009-2012, 2012-2015, 2015-2018), the Hospice and Palliative Nurses Association Research Advisory Council developed the 2019-2022 Research Agenda in consultation with Hospice and Palliative Nurses Association (HPNA) membership and assessment of major trends in palliative nursing. The HPNA Research Advisory Council identified 5 priority areas and asked subject experts in each area to summarize the state of the science, identify critical gaps, and provide recommendations for future research. This document expands the executive summary published on the HPNA website (www.advancingexpertcare.org/hpna/) and provides supporting evidence for the 2019-2022 recommendations. The 5 priority areas are as follows: (1) pediatric hospice and palliative nursing research; (2) family caregiving; (3) interprofessional education and collaborative practice; (4) big data science, precision health, and nursing informatics; and (5) implementation science.

A New Era in Pediatric Hospice Care for Military Families

: This series on palliative care is developed in collaboration with the Hospice and Palliative Nurses Association (HPNA; https://advancingexpertcare.org). The HPNA aims to guide nurses in preventing and relieving suffering and in giving the best possible care to patients and families, regardless of the stage of disease or the need for other therapies. The HPNA offers education, certification, advocacy, leadership, and research.

Children Enrolled in Hospice Care Under Commercial Insurance: A Comparison of Different Age Groups

Background:

Although most children at end of life have commercial insurance, little is known about their demographic and clinical characteristics, what care they are receiving, and how much it costs.

Objectives:

To describe commercially insured children who enrolled in hospice care during their last year of life and to examine differences across age-groups.

Methods:

A retrospective cohort study was conducted using 2005 to 2014 data from the MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters database from Truven Health Analytics. Variables were created for demographics, health, utilization, and spending. Analyses included χ2 and analysis of variance tests of differences.

Results:

Among the 17 062 children who utilized hospice, 49% had a preferred provider organization (PPO). Hospice length of stay averaged less than 5 days. Over 80% of children visited their primary care physician. Eight percent had hospital readmissions, and 38% had emergency department (ED) visits. Average expenditures were US$3686 per month or US$44 232 annually. The most common condition for children less than 1 year was cardiovascular (21.96%). Neuromuscular conditions were the most frequent (7.89%) in children aged 1 to 5 years, while malignancies (10.53% and 11.32%, respectively) were prevalent in ages 6 to 14 and 15 to 17. Children less than 1 year had the highest frequency of hospital readmissions (16.25%) with the lowest ED visits (28.67%) while incurring the highest expenses (US$11 211/month).

Conclusions:

The findings suggest that commercially insured children, who enroll in hospice, have flexible coverage with a PPO. Hospital readmissions and ED visits were relatively low for a population who was seriously ill. There were significant age-group differences.

The ethics of concurrent care for children: A social justice perspective

Recent estimates indicate that over 40,000 children die annually in the United States and a majority have life-limiting conditions. Children at end of life require extensive healthcare resources, including multiple hospital readmissions and emergency room visits. Yet, many children still suffer from symptoms at end of life-including fatigue, pain, dyspnea, and anxiety-with less than 10% of these children utilizing hospice care services. A critical barrier to pediatric hospice use was the original federal regulations associated with the hospice care that required a diagnosis of 6 months to live and the discontinuation of all curative treatments. The Concurrent Care Provision of the United States' Affordable Care Act eliminated the need to forgo curative therapies in order to enroll in hospice for children in Medicaid or Children's Health Insurance Program. Concurrent care for children can help mitigate the tension families experience in choosing between essential forms of care, as well as contribute to improved end-of-life outcomes for the child and possibly bereavement outcomes for the family. Understanding concurrent care for children from a social justice perspective has important advocacy and research implications for hospice and palliative care clinicians providing care for children and their families. We apply Powers and Faden's theory of social justice "as the moral foundation of public health and health policy" to the provision of concurrent care to children near end of life and families in the United States. The goals of applying this theory are to explore additional insights and perspectives into concurrent care policy may provide and to assess the usefulness of this theory when applied to end-of-life health policy. We argue that concurrent care policy is socially just since it has potential to promote well-being in vulnerable children and families and can limit the inequity children at end-of-life experience in access to high-quality hospice care.

Quality of paediatric hospice care for children with and without multiple complex chronic conditions

BACKGROUND

Hospice care for children with multiple complex chronic conditions (MCCC) is complicated given their unique health at the end of life (EOL). Little is known about the quality of the hospice care MCCC children receive and how that might differ from children without MCCC.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the quality of hospice care (i.e., structures, processes, outcomes) between children with and without MCCC.

METHODS

This retrospective, comparative study used data from the National Home and Hospice Care Survey, which included a nationally representative sample of paediatric hospice patients. The Pearson chi-square and Wald tests for comparisons were used.

RESULTS

MCCC children enrolled in hospice care for over 2 months with multiple visits by hospice staff. They had low symptom burden with minimal discontinuity of care at EOL. Children without MCCC had short length of stays in hospice with few visits by nurses and other clinicians. These children had high symptom burden and significant disenrollment from hospice care to receive more aggressive treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings revealed significant differences in paediatric hospice care between MCCC and non-MCCC children, which provides critical insight into the quality of hospice care.