1
|
Khayal IS, Barnato AE. What is in the palliative care 'syringe'? A systems perspective. Soc Sci Med 2022; 305:115069. [PMID: 35691210 DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2022.115069] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [MESH Headings] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 02/25/2022] [Revised: 05/20/2022] [Accepted: 05/21/2022] [Indexed: 11/18/2022]
Abstract
The diffusion of palliative care has been rapid, yet uncertainty remains regarding palliative care's "active ingredients." The National Consensus Project Guidelines for Quality Palliative Care identified eight domains of palliative care. Despite these identified domains, when pressed to describe the specific maneuvers used in clinical encounters, palliative care providers acknowledge that "it's complex." The field of systems has been used to explain complexity across many different types of systems. Specifically, engineering systems develop a representation of a system that helps manage complexity to help humans better understand the system. Our goal was to develop a system model of what palliative care providers do such that the elements of the model can be described concretely and sequentially, aggregated to describe the high-level domains currently described by palliative care, and connected to the complexity described by providers and the literature. Our study design combined methodological elements from both qualitative research and systems engineering modeling. The model drew on participant observation and debriefing semi-structured interviews with interdisciplinary palliative care team members by a systems engineer. The setting was an interdisciplinary palliative care service in a US rural academic medical center. In the developed system model, we identified 59 functions provided to patients, families, non-palliative care provider(s), and palliative care provider(s). The high-level functions related to measurement, decision-making, and treatment address up to 8 states of an individual, including an overall holistic state, physical state, psychological state, spiritual state, cultural state, personal environment state, and clinical environment state. In contrast to previously described expert consensus domain-based descriptions of palliative care, this model more directly connects palliative care provider functions to emergent behaviors that may explain system-level mechanisms of action for palliative care. Thus, a systems modeling approach provides insights into the challenges surrounding the recurring question of what is in the palliative care "syringe."
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Inas S Khayal
- The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Lebanon, NH, USA; Department of Biomedical Data Science, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Lebanon, NH, USA; Department of Computer Science, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, USA.
| | - Amber E Barnato
- The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Lebanon, NH, USA; Section of Palliative Care, Department of Medicine, Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, NH, USA
| |
Collapse
|
2
|
Busquet-Duran X, Moreno-Gabriel E, Jiménez-Zafra EM, Tura-Poma M, Bosch-DelaRosa O, Moragas-Roca A, Martin-Moreno S, Martínez-Losada E, Crespo-Ramírez S, Lestón-Lado L, Salamero-Tura N, Llobera-Estrany J, Salvago-Leiracha A, López-García AI, Manresa-Domínguez JM, Morandi-Garde T, Persentili-Viure ES, Torán-Monserrat P. Gender and Observed Complexity in Palliative Home Care: A Prospective Multicentre Study Using the HexCom Model. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH 2021; 18:12307. [PMID: 34886027 PMCID: PMC8656577 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph182312307] [Citation(s) in RCA: 1] [Impact Index Per Article: 0.3] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [MESH Headings] [Track Full Text] [Download PDF] [Figures] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 10/08/2021] [Revised: 11/19/2021] [Accepted: 11/20/2021] [Indexed: 11/26/2022]
Abstract
This study analyses gender differences in the complexity observed in palliative home care through a multicentre longitudinal observational study of patients with advanced disease treated by palliative home care teams in Catalonia (Spain). We used the HexCom model, which includes six dimensions and measures three levels of complexity: high (non-modifiable situation), medium (difficult) and low. Results: N = 1677 people, 44% women. In contrast with men, in women, cancer was less prevalent (64.4% vs. 73.9%) (p < 0.001), cognitive impairment was more prevalent (34.1% vs. 26.6%; p = 0.001) and professional caregivers were much more common (40.3% vs. 24.3%; p < 0.001). Women over 80 showed less complexity in the following subareas: symptom management (41.7% vs. 51,1%; p = 0.011), emotional distress (24.5% vs. 32.8%; p = 0.015), spiritual distress (16.4% vs. 26.4%; p = 0.001), socio-familial distress (62.7% vs. 70.1%; p = 0.036) and location of death (36.0% vs. 49.6%; p < 0.000). Men were more complex in the subareas of "practice" OR = 1.544 (1.25-1.90 p = 0.000) and "transcendence" OR = 1.52 (1.16-1.98 p = 0.002). Observed complexity is related to male gender in people over 80 years of age. Women over the age of 80 are remarkably different from their male counterparts, showing less complexity regarding care for their physical, psycho-emotional, spiritual and socio-familial needs.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Xavier Busquet-Duran
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Eduard Moreno-Gabriel
- Research Support Unit Metropolitana Nord, Primary Care Research Institute Jordi Gol (IDIAPJGol), 08303 Mataró, Spain; (J.M.M.-D.); (P.T.-M.)
| | - Eva Maria Jiménez-Zafra
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Magda Tura-Poma
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Olga Bosch-DelaRosa
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Anna Moragas-Roca
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Susana Martin-Moreno
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Emilio Martínez-Losada
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Silvia Crespo-Ramírez
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Lola Lestón-Lado
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Núria Salamero-Tura
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Joana Llobera-Estrany
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Ariadna Salvago-Leiracha
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Ana Isabel López-García
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Josep María Manresa-Domínguez
- Research Support Unit Metropolitana Nord, Primary Care Research Institute Jordi Gol (IDIAPJGol), 08303 Mataró, Spain; (J.M.M.-D.); (P.T.-M.)
- Department of Nursing, Autonomous University of Barcelona, 08193 Barcelona, Spain
| | - Teresa Morandi-Garde
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Eda Sara Persentili-Viure
- Home Care Program, Granollers Support Team (PADES), Vallès Oriental Primary Care Service, Catalan Health Institute, 08520 Granollers, Spain; (E.M.J.-Z.); (M.T.-P.); (O.B.-D.); (A.M.-R.); (S.M.-M.); (E.M.-L.); (S.C.-R.); (L.L.-L.); (N.S.-T.); (J.L.-E.); (A.S.-L.); (A.I.L.-G.); (T.M.-G.); (E.S.P.-V.)
| | - Pere Torán-Monserrat
- Research Support Unit Metropolitana Nord, Primary Care Research Institute Jordi Gol (IDIAPJGol), 08303 Mataró, Spain; (J.M.M.-D.); (P.T.-M.)
| |
Collapse
|
3
|
Busquet-Duran X, Jiménez-Zafra EM, Manresa-Domínguez JM, Tura-Poma M, Bosch-delaRosa O, Moragas-Roca A, Galera Padilla MC, Martin Moreno S, Martínez-Losada E, Crespo-Ramírez S, López-Garcia AI, Torán-Monserrat P. Describing Complexity in Palliative Home Care Through HexCom: A Cross-Sectional, Multicenter Study. J Multidiscip Healthc 2020; 13:297-308. [PMID: 32256078 PMCID: PMC7090197 DOI: 10.2147/jmdh.s240835] [Citation(s) in RCA: 14] [Impact Index Per Article: 3.5] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Download PDF] [Figures] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 12/02/2019] [Accepted: 02/18/2020] [Indexed: 12/19/2022] Open
Abstract
BACKGROUND Complexity has become a core issue in caring for patients with advanced disease and/or at the end-of-life. The Hexagon of Complexity (HexCom) is a complexity assessment model in the process of validation in health-care settings. Our objective is to use the instrument to describe differences in complexity across disease groups in specific home care for advanced disease and/or at the end-of-life patients, both in general and as relates to each domain and subdomain. METHODS Cross-sectional study of home care was conducted in Catalonia. The instrument includes 6 domains of needs (clinical, psychological/emotional, social/family, spiritual, ethical, and death-related), 4 domains of resources (intrapersonal, interpersonal, transpersonal, and practical), and 3 levels of complexity (High (H), Moderate (M), and Low (L)). Interdisciplinary home care teams assessed and agreed on the level of complexity for each patient. RESULTS Forty-three teams participated (74.1% of those invited). A total of 832 patients were assessed, 61.4% of which were cancer patients. Moderate complexity was observed in 385 (47.0%) cases and high complexity in 347 (42.4%). The median complexity score was 51 for cancer patients and 23 for patients with dementia (p<0.001). We observed the highest level of complexity in the social/family domain. Patients/families most frequently used interpersonal resources (80.5%). CONCLUSIONS This study sheds light on the high-intensity work of support teams, the importance of the social/family domain and planning the place of death, substantial differences in needs and resources across disease groups, and the importance of relationship wellbeing at the end-of-life.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Xavier Busquet-Duran
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
- Multidisciplinary Research Group on Health and Society (GREMSAS), Barcelona, Spain
- Department of Nursing, University Foundation of Bages (FUB), University of Vic. Central University of Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Eva Maria Jiménez-Zafra
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Josep Maria Manresa-Domínguez
- Multidisciplinary Research Group on Health and Society (GREMSAS), Barcelona, Spain
- Metropolitan Nord Unit of Research Support, University Institute of Research in Primary Care (IDIAP) Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain
- Department of Nursing, Autonomous University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Magda Tura-Poma
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | | | - Anna Moragas-Roca
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Maria Concepción Galera Padilla
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Susana Martin Moreno
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Emilio Martínez-Losada
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | | | - Ana Isabel López-Garcia
- Home Care Program, Support Team, PADES Granollers, Vallès Oriental Primary Health Care Services, Catalan Institute of Health, Barcelona, Spain
| | - Pere Torán-Monserrat
- Multidisciplinary Research Group on Health and Society (GREMSAS), Barcelona, Spain
- Metropolitan Nord Unit of Research Support, University Institute of Research in Primary Care (IDIAP) Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain
| |
Collapse
|