Assessing Upper and Lower Extremities Via Tissue Dielectric Constant: Suitability of Single Versus Multiple Measurements Averaged

Breast Cancer-Related Lymphedema Assessed via Tissue Dielectric Constant Measurements

This review describes the use of tissue dielectric constant (TDC) measurements mainly in the assessment of breast cancer-related lymphedema (BCRL). PubMed, Web of Science, and EMBASE databases were initially searched using criteria that included the terms "dielectric" and "lymphedema." The initial search yielded a total of 131 titles. After removing studies not focused on upper extremity lymphedema, 56 articles remained. These articles, together with relevant articles from their bibliographies, formed the basis of the review. The findings show the potential utility and applications of TDC measurements to help detect and track BCRL, whether present in limbs, breasts, or trunks. It is reported as a non-invasive, simple-to-use method, with each measurement requiring less than 10 seconds, suggesting its practicality and useability as an in-office or in-clinic screening and tracking method. Although there are various ways to quantitatively evaluate lymphedema, most, if not all, are restricted to measurements on limbs. Thus, one significant advantage of the TDC approach is that almost any local region of interest can be effectively measured and tracked, which, for BCRL, could include specific regions of arms or hands, breasts, and truncal areas.

Medical Applications of Skin Tissue Dielectric Constant Measurements

Tissue dielectric constant (TDC) values assess certain skin properties that are dependent on multiple factors but mainly on the relative amount of water content within a locally measured tissue volume. Because of the non-invasive nature of these measurements and their ease of use, the method has been widely used in various medically related applications. The goal of this paper was to review and describe the uses and findings of such TDC measurements, considering and including the wide array of medical applications. The review is in part based on information derived from an analysis of published material obtained via literature searches of four major electronic databases and, in part, based on the author's experience with the TDC measurement methods and their various applications and his professional experiences. The databases searched were PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, and CINAHL Complete. Based on the initial search criteria, a total of 1257 titles were identified. After removing duplicates and filtering according to relevancy, 160 remained for detailed further review. In some cases, the bibliography of these retrieved articles provided additional sources. The findings demonstrate multiple research and medical uses and applications of TDC measurements, focusing on detecting and quantifying localized edema and lymphedema in multiple target sites. These include the upper and lower extremities, breasts, and trunk as regions involved in medical conditions causing lymphedema. In addition, the findings suggest that TDC evaluations are a convenient, non-invasive method to study and evaluate other conditions impacting skin, including diabetes mellitus and skin wounds or ulcers. Its ability to detect aspects of tissue changes simply and rapidly at almost any anatomical location makes it a useful tool for investigating multiple dermatological conditions and their treatment as future applications of this method.

Tissue Dielectric Constant and Skin Stiffness Relationships in Lower Extremity Lymphedema

Background: Lower extremity lymphedema or edema (LELE) may progressively transition from a state of excess tissue fluid to increased fat accumulation and collagen deposition, with tissue fibrosis and hardening. Such changes may lead to altered tissue water holding and thereby impact tissue dielectric constant (TDC). This study seeks to evaluate the relationship between TDC and tissue indentation force (TIF) in patients with LELE and assess the utility of the leg/arm TDC ratio (LAR) as an indicator of LELE. Methods and Results: Thirty females (49-91 years) with previously diagnosed LELE were evaluated during a scheduled session. TDC and TIF were measured 8 cm proximal to the medial malleolus on the medial and lateral aspects of both legs and on one forearm 8 cm distal to the antecubital fossa. The TDC-TIC relationship and the LAR were subsequently determined. Main results showed an absence of a significant correlation between TDC and TIF on medial or lateral leg sites but a positive correlation on the normal forearm site. Further, LAR values exceeded the published proposed threshold of 1.35 for 29/30 patients when using medial-side TDC values and 28/30 patients when using lateral-side TDC values. Conclusions: Findings suggest that for patients with LELE, TDC values are significantly elevated on medial and lateral standardized sites. The LAR determined using either medial or lateral sites that are similar to each other and have values consistent with a lymphedema threshold of 1.35. In edematous legs of the type evaluated herein, there is no apparent relationship between TDC values and indentation force.

Variation in Leg Tissue Dielectric Constant Values of Healthy Young Adult Females With and Without Compression Bandaging

Background The clinical efficacy of a compression application has been often limited to the assessment of the change in limb volume, change in clinical symptoms (i.e., wound size, pain, range of motion, incidence of cellulitis), or vascular hemodynamics of the whole limb. Assessing compression-related biophysical changes of a localized area, such as around a wound, or in an area outside of an extremity cannot be objectively assessed by these measurements. Tissue dielectric constant (TDC) values, which provide a measure of the local tissue water (LTW) content, offer an alternative method to document variation in the LTW content of the skin in a specific location. The goals of the present research were (1) to characterize TDC values, expressed as percentage tissue water, from multiple areas along the medial aspect of the lower leg of healthy volunteers and (2) to explore the potential utilization of the TDC values to assess change in tissue water content in a localized area following compression applications. Methods TDC was measured at 10, 20, 30, and 40 cm proximal to the medial malleolus on the medial aspect of the right leg of 18 young adult healthy women with an age range of 18-23 years and a body mass index of 18.7 to 30.7kg/m^2.. TDC was measured at baseline and after 10 minutes of exercise with compression in place on three separate days during which three different compression applications were assessed: a longitudinal elastic stockinette, a two-layer cohesive compression kit, and a combination of the two. Leg circumferences and compression-related interface pressures were also measured. Results Test-Retest Reliability of circumferential measurements and TDC values evaluated using Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC _3,1) revealed excellent and moderate-to-good reliability, respectively. Analysis of TDC values along the length of the limb using Friedman's test, revealed a small but statistically significant overall difference among baseline TDC values attributable to a smaller value at 40 cm. The largest difference in cumulative average was 7.7% which occurred between 20 and 40 cm, with all other differences between locations less than 1%. No significant differences between the compression applications were observed. Conclusion  The present findings demonstrate the utility of TDC measurements as a modality to assess compression-related changes in the legs of healthy women as a foundation for their potential use in assessing outcomes of compression treatments for persons with lower extremity edema or lymphedema. The absence of a significant change in TDC values in these healthy non-edematous conditions and the demonstrated reliability of the TDC measurements on three different days provides further support for the utility of such applications of TDC measurements. The extension to patients with lower extremity edema or lymphedema needs to be evaluated.

Impedance of Extracellular Fluid, Volume, and Local Tissue Water Can Be Reliably Measured in People With Lower Limb Lymphedema

OBJECTIVE

Lower limb lymphedema (LLL) is a chronic condition. To be able to evaluate changes of LLL over time and effects of interventions, reliable measurement methods are important. Currently, there is limited knowledge of the reliability of commonly used measurement methods in LLL. The study objective was to evaluate the test-retest (intrarater) reliability of impedance of extracellular fluid, volume, and local tissue water measurements in people with unilateral or bilateral LLL and measurement errors both for a group of people and for a single individual.

METHODS

Forty-two people with mild to moderate unilateral or bilateral, primary or secondary LLL were measured twice, 2 weeks apart. Impedance of extracellular fluid was measured by bioimpedance spectroscopy and calculated as arm-to-leg ratio, volume with circumference measurements every 4 cm, and local tissue water with tissue dielectric constant at 14 points. Test-retest reliability was evaluated using the intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC(2,1)], changes in the mean, SE of measurement in relative terms (SEM%), and the smallest real difference in relative terms (SRD%).

RESULTS

For the impedance ratio, the reliability was high [ICC(2,1) = 0.79-0.90] and the measurement errors were acceptable (SEM% = 5.0%-5.2%; SRD% = 14.0%-14.4%). For volume, the reliability was high (ICC = 0.99) and the measurement errors were low (SEM% = 1.1%-1.7%; SRD% = 3.1%-4.6%). For the tissue dielectric constant, the reliability was fair to excellent [ICC(2,1) = 0.68-0.96] and the measurement errors were acceptable (SEM% = 4.2%-9.7%; SRD% = 11.7%-26.8%).

CONCLUSIONS

Measurements of impedance of extracellular fluid, volume, and local tissue water are reliable in people with mild to moderate LLL. The measurement errors were acceptable in all 3 methods indicating that real, clinical changes in lymphedema can be measured both for a group of people and a single individual.

IMPACT

The results from this test-retest reliability study can help clinicians and researchers to interpret if real clinical changes in lymphedema occur over time or after an intervention in people with mild to moderate LLL.

Anatomical variability of sub-epidermal moisture and its clinical implications

BACKGROUND

Technologies have been developed to monitor changes in dermal oedema, indicative of the early signs of pressure ulcers. However, there is limited information on the effects of regional differences in tissue morphology on these sub-epidermal moisture (SEM) parameters. This study was designed to investigate the absolute SEM readings across different anatomical sites using a commercial device.

METHODS

Twenty-four healthy participants were recruited to evaluate basal SEM values at different bony prominences, sampled by an experienced operator.

RESULTS

Distinct differences were observed in unloaded SEM values across different anatomical sites, notably between the upper and lower extremities. A high degree of variability was observed in particular sites, such as the heels. Moreover, SEM values at certain locations revealed significant relationships with age, BMI and gender (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The study revealed a high level of variability between and within anatomical sites in a healthy cohort of participants. Determining the changes in local skin and sub-dermal tissue status using SEM may require consideration of both site specific and individual demographic factors, with further research needed in cohorts at risk of pressure ulcers.