The 5′ Binding MID Domain of Human Argonaute2 Tolerates Chemically Modified Nucleotide Analogues

Investigation of Strand-Selective Interaction of SNA-Modified siRNA with AGO2-MID

Small interfering RNA (siRNA) has been recognized as a powerful gene-silencing tool. For therapeutic application, chemical modification is often required to improve the properties of siRNA, including its nuclease resistance, activity, off-target effects, and tissue distribution. Careful siRNA guide strand selection in the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) is important to increase the RNA interference (RNAi) activity as well as to reduce off-target effects. The passenger strand-mediated off-target activity was previously reduced and on-target activity was enhanced by substitution with acyclic artificial nucleic acid, namely serinol nucleic acid (SNA). In the present study, the reduction of off-target activity caused by the passenger strand was investigated by modifying siRNAs with SNA. The interactions of SNA-substituted mononucleotides, dinucleotides, and (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidin-1-yl)oxyl (TEMPO)-labeled double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) with the MID domain of the Argonaute 2 (AGO2) protein, which plays a pivotal role in strand selection by accommodation of the 5’-terminus of siRNA, were comprehensively analyzed. The obtained nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) data revealed that AGO2-MID selectively bound to the guide strand of siRNA due to the inhibitory effect of the SNA backbone located at the 5’ end of the passenger strand.

RNA-induced initiation of transcriptional silencing (RITS) complex structure and function

Heterochromatic regions of the genome are epigenetically regulated to maintain a heritable '"silent state"'. In fission yeast and other organisms, epigenetic silencing is guided by nascent transcripts, which are targeted by the RNA interference pathway. The key effector complex of the RNA interference pathway consists of small interfering RNA molecules (siRNAs) associated with Argonaute, assembled into the RNA-induced transcriptional silencing (RITS) complex. This review focuses on our current understanding of how RITS promotes heterochromatin formation, and in particular on the role of Argonaute-containing complexes in many other functions such as quelling, release of RNA polymerases, cellular quiescence and genome defense.

Re-Engineering RNA Molecules into Therapeutic Agents

Efforts to chemically modify nucleic acids got underway merely a decade after the discovery of the DNA double helix and initially targeted nucleosides and nucleotides. The origins of three analogues that remain staples of modification strategies and figure prominently in FDA-approved nucleic acid therapeutics can be traced to the 1960s: 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-RNA (2'-F RNA), 2'- O-methyl-RNA (2'- OMe RNA), and the phosphorothioates (PS-DNA/RNA). Progress in nucleoside phosphoramidite-based solid phase oligonucleotide synthesis has gone hand in hand with the creation of second-generation (e.g., 2'- O-(2-methoxyethyl)-RNA, MOE-RNA) and third-generation (e.g., bicyclic nucleic acids, BNAs) analogues, giving rise to an expanding universe of modified nucleic acids. Thus, beyond site-specifically altered DNAs and RNAs with a modified base, sugar, and/or phosphate backbone moieties, nucleic acid chemists have created a host of conjugated oligonucleotides and artificial genetic polymers (XNAs). The search for oligonucleotides with therapeutic efficacy constitutes a significant driving force for these investigations. However, nanotechnology, diagnostics, synthetic biology and genetics, nucleic acid etiology, and basic research directed at the properties of native and artificial pairing systems have all stimulated the design of ever more diverse modifications. Modification of nucleic acids can affect pairing and chemical stability, conformation and interactions with a flurry of proteins and enzymes that play important roles in uptake, transport or processing of targets. Enhancement of metabolic stability is a central concern in the design of antisense, siRNA and aptamer oligonucleotides for therapeutic applications. In the antisense approach, uniformly modified oligonucleotides or so-called gapmers are used to target a specific RNA. The former may sterically block transcription or direct alternative splicing, whereas the latter feature a central PS window that elicits RNase H-mediated cleavage of the target. The key enzyme in RNA interference (RNAi) is Argonaute 2 (Ago2), a dynamic multidomain enzyme that binds multiple regions of the guide (antisense) and passenger (sense) siRNAs. The complexity of the individual interactions between Ago2 and the siRNA duplex provides significant challenges for chemical modification. Therefore, a uniform (the same modification throughout, e.g., antisense) or nearly uniform (e.g., aptamer) modification strategy is less useful in the pursuit of siRNA therapeutic leads. Instead, unique structural features and protein interactions of 5'-end (guide/Ago2MID domain), seed region, central region (cleavage site/Ago2 PIWI domain), and 3'-terminal nucleotides (guide/Ago2 PAZ domain) demand a more nuanced approach in the design of chemically modified siRNAs for therapeutic use. This Account summarizes current siRNA modification strategies with an emphasis on the regio-specific interactions between oligonucleotide and Ago2 and how these affect the choice of modification and optimization of siRNA efficacy. In addition to standard assays applied to measure the effects of modification on the stability of pairing and resistance against nuclease degradation, structural insights based on crystallographic data for modified RNAs alone and in complex with Ago2 from molecular modeling studies are a valuable guide in the design of siRNA therapeutics. Thus, this comprehensive approach is expected to result in accelerated generation of new siRNA-based therapies against various diseases, now that the first siRNA has obtained approval by the US FDA for treatment of hereditary hATTR amyloidosis.

Structural and Functional Characterization of Plant ARGONAUTE MID Domains

The interaction of small silencing RNA 5' nucleotides with the MID domain of ARGONAUTE (AGO) proteins provides an anchor point that contributes to strong binding between RNA and protein. The following protocols describe the necessary procedures to characterize the structure of AGO MID domains using X-ray crystallography as well as their interaction with nucleotides that mimic the 5' end of small silencing RNAs using two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy.

Comparison of partially and fully chemically-modified siRNA in conjugate-mediated delivery in vivo

Small interfering RNA (siRNA)-based drugs require chemical modifications or formulation to promote stability, minimize innate immunity, and enable delivery to target tissues. Partially modified siRNAs (up to 70% of the nucleotides) provide significant stabilization in vitro and are commercially available; thus are commonly used to evaluate efficacy of bio-conjugates for in vivo delivery. In contrast, most clinically-advanced non-formulated compounds, using conjugation as a delivery strategy, are fully chemically modified (100% of nucleotides). Here, we compare partially and fully chemically modified siRNAs in conjugate mediated delivery. We show that fully modified siRNAs are retained at 100x greater levels in various tissues, independently of the nature of the conjugate or siRNA sequence, and support productive mRNA silencing. Thus, fully chemically stabilized siRNAs may provide a better platform to identify novel moieties (peptides, aptamers, small molecules) for targeted RNAi delivery.

Modulation of the RNA Interference Activity Using Central Mismatched siRNAs and Acyclic Threoninol Nucleic Acids (aTNA) Units

The understanding of the mechanisms behind nucleotide recognition by Argonaute 2, core protein of the RNA-induced silencing complex, is a key aspect in the optimization of small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) activity. To date, great efforts have been focused on the modification of certain regions of siRNA, such as the 3'/5'-termini and the seed region. Only a few reports have described the roles of central positions flanking the cleavage site during the silence process. In this study, we investigate the potential correlations between the thermodynamic and silencing properties of siRNA molecules carrying, at internal positions, an acyclic L-threoninol nucleic acid (aTNA) modification. Depending on position, the silencing is weakened or impaired. Furthermore, we evaluate the contribution of mismatches facing either a natural nucleotide or an aTNA modification to the siRNA potency. The position 11 of the antisense strand is more permissive to mismatches and aTNA modification, in respect to the position 10. Additionally, comparing the ON-/OFF-target silencing of central mismatched siRNAs with 5'-terminal modified siRNA, we concluded: (i) central perturbation of duplex pairing features weights more on potency rather than silencing asymmetry; (ii) complete bias for the ON-target silencing can be achieved with single L-threoninol modification near the 5'-end of the sense strand.

Mammalian Argonaute-DNA binding?

When a field shares the consensus that a particular phenomenon does NOT occur, this may reflect extensive experimental investigations with negative outcomes, or may represent the “common sense” position based on current knowledge and established ways of thinking. The current consensus of the RNA field is that eukaryotic Argonaute (Ago) proteins employ RNA guides and target other RNAs. The alternative -- that eukaryotic Ago has biologically important interactions with DNA in vivo – has not been seriously considered, in part because the only role contemplated for DNA was as a guide strand, and in part because it did not seem plausible that any natural source of suitable DNAs exists in eukaryotic cells. However, eukaryotic Argonaute domains bind DNA in the test tube, and several articles report that small inhibitory double-stranded DNAs do have the ability to silence target RNAs in a sequence-dependent (though poorly characterized) manner. A search of the literature identified potential DNA binding partners for Ago, including (among others) single-stranded DNAs residing in extracellular vesicles, and cytoplasmic satellite-repeat DNA fragments that are associated with the plasma membrane and transcribed by Pol II. It is interesting to note that both cytoplasmic and extracellular vesicle DNA are expressed at greatly elevated levels in cancer cells relative to normal cells. In such a pathological scenario, if not under normal conditions, there may be appreciable binding of Ago to DNA despite its lower affinity compared to RNA. If so, DNA might displace Ago from binding to its normal partners (miRNAs, siRNAs and other short ncRNAs), disrupting tightly controlled post-transcriptional gene silencing processes that are vital to correct functioning of a normal cell. The possible contribution to cancer pathogenesis is a strong motivator for further investigation of Ago-DNA binding. More generally, this case underscores the need for better informatics tools to allow investigators to analyze the state of a given scientific question at a high-level and to identify possible new research directions.

Reviewers: This article was reviewed by Eugene Koonin, Kira S. Makarova, Alexander Maxwell Burroughs (nominated by L Aravind), and Isidore Rigoutsos.

Open peer review: Reviewed by Eugene Koonin, Kira S. Makarova, Alexander Maxwell Burroughs (nominated by L Aravind), and Isidore Rigoutsos. For the full reviews, please go to the Reviewers’ comments section.

Arabinonucleic acids: 2'-stereoisomeric modulators of siRNA activity

We have investigated, for the first time, short interfering duplexes containing arabinonucleotides (ANA; the 2'-stereoisomer of RNA), as well as combinations of ANA with RNA, and their 2'-fluorinated derivatives 2F-ANA and/or 2'F-RNA. The results show that ANA is especially well accommodated in the sense strand of small interfering RNA (siRNA) duplexes, which can be extensively modified with little effect on potency. Furthermore, combining ANA with RNA and 2'F-ANA in siRNA passenger strands, particularly in patterns that bias duplex thermal stability, produces duplexes with similar (and sometimes enhanced) potency compared with native siRNA. Effective patterns of modification were identified against firefly luciferase screens in HeLa cells and then applied to knockdown of down-regulated in renal cell carcinoma (DRR), a novel and clinically tractable target for the treatment of glioblastoma.