Mechanism of gene repair open for discussion

Genome-wide Mapping of Off-Target Events in Single-Stranded Oligodeoxynucleotide-Mediated Gene Repair Experiments

Short single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides are versatile molecular tools used in different applications. They enable gene repair and genome editing, and they are central to the antisense technology. Because the usability of single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides depends on their efficiencies, as well as their specificities, analyzing their genotoxic off-target activities is important. Thus, we have developed a protocol that follows the fate of a biotin-labeled single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotide in human cells based on its physical incorporation into the targeted genome. Affected chromosomal fragments are enriched and preferably sequenced by nanopore sequencing. This protocol was validated in gene repair experiments without intentionally inducing a DNA double-strand break. For a 21-nucleotide-long phosphorothioate-modified oligodeoxynucleotide, we compiled a broad array of error-free incorporations, point mutations, indels, and structural rearrangements from actively dividing HEK293-derived cells. Additionally, we demonstrated the usefulness of this approach for primary cells by treating human CD34⁺ hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells with a 100-nucleotide-long unmodified oligodeoxynucleotide directed against the endogenous CYBB locus. This work should pave the way for future genotoxicity analyses. Concerning genome engineering approaches based on nuclease-induced DNA double-strand breaks, this protocol could aid in detecting the unwanted effects caused by the donor fragments themselves.

Emerging gene editing strategies for Duchenne muscular dystrophy targeting stem cells

The progressive loss of muscle mass characteristic of many muscular dystrophies impairs the efficacy of most of the gene and molecular therapies currently being pursued for the treatment of those disorders. It is becoming increasingly evident that a therapeutic application, to be effective, needs to target not only mature myofibers, but also muscle progenitors cells or muscle stem cells able to form new muscle tissue and to restore myofibers lost as the result of the diseases or during normal homeostasis so as to guarantee effective and lost lasting effects. Correction of the genetic defect using oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) or engineered nucleases holds great potential for the treatment of many of the musculoskeletal disorders. The encouraging results obtained by studying in vitro systems and model organisms have set the groundwork for what is likely to become an emerging field in the area of molecular and regenerative medicine. Furthermore, the ability to isolate and expand from patients various types of muscle progenitor cells capable of committing to the myogenic lineage provides the opportunity to establish cell lines that can be used for transplantation following ex vivo manipulation and expansion. The purpose of this article is to provide a perspective on approaches aimed at correcting the genetic defect using gene editing strategies and currently under development for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), the most sever of the neuromuscular disorders. Emphasis will be placed on describing the potential of using the patient own stem cell as source of transplantation and the challenges that gene editing technologies face in the field of regenerative biology.

Oligonucleotide-directed gene-editing technology: mechanisms and future prospects

INTRODUCTION

Gene editing, as defined here, uses short synthetic oligonucleotides to introduce small, site-specific changes into mammalian genomes, including repair of genetic point mutations. Early RNA-DNA oligonucleotides (chimeraplasts) were problematic, but application of single-stranded all-DNA molecules (ssODNs) has matured the technology into a reproducible tool with therapeutic potential.

AREAS COVERED

The review illustrates how gene-editing mechanisms are linked to DNA repair systems and DNA replication, and explains that while homologous recombination (HR) and nucleotide excision repair (NER) are implicated, the mismatch repair (MMR) system is inhibitory. Although edited cells often arrest in late S-phase or G2-phase, alternative ssODN chemistries can improve editing efficiency and cell viability. The final section focuses on the exciting tandem use of ssODNs with zinc finger nucleases to achieve high frequency genome editing.

EXPERT OPINION

For a decade, changing the genetic code of cells via ssODNs was largely done in reporter gene systems to optimize methods and as proof-of-principle. Today, editing endogenous genes is advancing, driven by a clearer understanding of mechanisms, by effective ssODN designs and by combination with engineered endonuclease technologies. Success is becoming routine in vitro and ex vivo, which includes editing embryonic stem (ES) and induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells, suggesting that in vivo organ gene editing is a future option.

Genetic modification through oligonucleotide-mediated mutagenesis. A GMO regulatory challenge?

In the European Union, the definition of a GMO is technology-based. This means that a novel organism will be regulated under the GMO regulatory framework only if it has been developed with the use of defined techniques. This approach is now challenged with the emergence of new techniques. In this paper, we describe regulatory and safety issues associated with the use of oligonucleotide-mediated mutagenesis to develop novel organisms. We present scientific arguments for not having organisms developed through this technique fall within the scope of the EU regulation on GMOs. We conclude that any political decision on this issue should be taken on the basis of a broad reflection at EU level, while avoiding discrepancies at international level.

Higher efficiency of thymine-adenine clamp-modified single-stranded oligonucleotides in targeted nucleotide sequence correction is not correlated with lower intracellular degradation

Specific single-stranded oligonucleotides can induce targeted nucleotide sequence correction in eukaryotic genes in vitro and in vivo. Our model for investigating the reasons for the low correction rates achieved by this method is the correction of a point mutation in the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase gene (hprt) in the cell line V79-151. Using single-stranded phosphorothioate-modified oligonucleotides, the correction rates of this hprt mutation were low but always reproducible. One reason for low exchange rates may be fast intracellular degradation of the oligonucleotides. Therefore we compared the exchange rates of different 3' and 5' end-modified oligonucleotides with their degradation rates. Thymine-adenine (TA) repeat (clamp)-modified oligonucleotides showed higher correction rates than those with a guanine-cytosine (GC) clamp and 5' clamps induced higher correction rates than clamps at the 3' end. Experiments on the stability of the most effective 5'-TA and 3'-TA clamp-modified oligonucleotide indicated rapid cleavage and the occurrence of shortened oligonucleotides in the presence of cytoplasmic and nuclear extracts. The phosphorothioate-modified oligonucleotides were more stable, but their correction rates were lower. We suggest that there is no direct correlation between the biological stability of the full-length oligonucleotides and the exchange rates achieved.

RecA-mediated strand invasion of DNA by oligonucleotides substituted with 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine

Sequence-specific recognition of DNA is a critical step in gene targeting. Here we describe unique oligonucleotide (ON) hybrids that can stably pair to both strands of a linear DNA target in a RecA-dependent reaction with ATP or ATPγS. One strand of the hybrids is a 30-mer DNA ON that contains a 15-nt-long A/T-rich central core. The core sequence, which is substituted with 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine, is weakly hybridized to complementary locked nucleic acid or 2′-OMe RNA ONs that are also substituted with the same base analogs. Robust targeting reactions took place in the presence of ATPγS and generated metastable double D-loop joints. Since the hybrids had pseudocomplementary character, the component ONs hybridized less strongly to each other than to complementary target DNA sequences composed of regular bases. This difference in pairing strength promoted the formation of joints capable of accommodating a single mismatch. If similar joints can form in vivo, virtually any A/T-rich site in genomic DNA could be selectively targeted. By designing the constructs so that the DNA ON is mismatched to its complementary sequence in DNA, joint formation might allow the ON to function as a template for targeted point mutation and gene correction.

Oligonucleotide-mediated gene targeting in human hepatocytes: implications of mismatch repair

Gene therapy using viral vectors for liver diseases, particularly congenital disorders, is besought with difficulties, particularly immunologic reactions to viral antigens. As a result, nonviral methods for gene transfer in hepatocytes have also been explored. Gene repair by small synthetic single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) produces targeted alterations in the genome of mammalian cells and represents a great potential for nonviral gene therapy. To test the feasibility of ODN-mediated gene repair within chromosomal DNA in human hepatocytes, two new cell lines with stably integrated mutant reporter genes, namely neomycin and enhanced green fluorescent protein were established. Targeting theses cells with ODNs specifically designed for repair resulted in site-directed and permanent gene conversion of the single-point mutation of the reporter genes. Moreover, the frequency of gene alteration was highly dependent on the mitotic activity of the cells, indicating that the proliferative status is an important factor for successful targeting in human hepatocytes. cDNA array expression profiling of DNA repair genes under different cell culture conditions combined with RNA interference assay showed that mismatch repair (MMR) in actively growing hepatocytes imposes a strong barrier to efficient gene repair mediated by ODNs. Suppression of MSH2 activity in hepatocytes transduced with short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) targeted to MSH2 mRNA resulted in 25- to 30-fold increase in gene repair rate, suggesting a negative effect of MMR on ODN-mediated gene repair. Taken together, these data suggest that under appropriate conditions nonviral chromosomal targeting may represent a feasible approach to gene therapy in liver disease.

Site-specific gene modification by oligodeoxynucleotides in mouse bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells

Synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) had been employed in gene modification and represent an alternative approach to 'cure' genetic disorders caused by mutations. To test the ability of ODN-mediated gene repair in bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), we established MSCs cell lines with stably integrated mutant neomycin resistance and enhanced green fluorescent protein reporter genes. The established cultures showed morphologically homogenous population with phenotypic and functional features of mesenchymal progenitors. Transfection with gene-specific ODNs successfully repaired targeted cells resulting in the expression of functional proteins at relatively high frequency approaching 0.2%. Direct DNA sequencing confirmed that phenotype change resulted from the designated nucleotide correction at the target site. The position of the mismatch-forming nucleotide was shown to be important structural feature for ODN repair activity. The genetically corrected MSCs were healthy and maintained an undifferentiated state. Furthermore, the genetically modified MSCs were able to engraft into many tissues of unconditioned transgenic mice making them an attractive therapeutic tool in a wide range of clinical applications.

Simultaneous targeted exchange of two nucleotides by single-stranded oligonucleotides clusters within a region of about fourteen nucleotides

Background

Transfection of cells with gene-specific, single-stranded oligonucleotides can induce the targeted exchange of one or two nucleotides in the targeted gene. To characterize the features of the DNA-repair mechanisms involved, we examined the maximal distance for the simultaneous exchange of two nucleotides by a single-stranded oligonucleotide. The chosen experimental system was the correction of a hprt-point mutation in a hamster cell line, the generation of an additional nucleotide exchange at a variable distance from the first exchange position and the investigation of the rate of simultaneous nucleotide exchanges.

Results

The smaller the distance between the two exchange positions, the higher was the probability of a simultaneous exchange. The detected simultaneous nucleotide exchanges were found to cluster in a region of about fourteen nucleotides upstream and downstream from the first exchange position.

Conclusion

We suggest that the mechanism involved in the repair of the targeted DNA strand utilizes only a short sequence of the single-stranded oligonucleotide, which may be physically incorporated into the DNA or be used as a matrix for a repair process.

Recovery of cell cycle delay following targeted gene repair by oligonucleotides

We have previously shown that activation of the homologous recombinational repair pathway leads to a block of cell division in corrected cells, possibly through the activity of checkpoint proteins Chk1 and Chk2. In this study, we examine the long-term impact of this stalling on the growth of cells that have enabled gene repair events. Using a mutated eGFP gene as an episomal reporter, we show that corrected (eGFP-positive) cells contain only a few active replication templates 2 weeks after electroporation, yet do not display an apoptotic or senescent phenotype. By 6 weeks after electroporation, cells resume active replication with a cell cycle profile that is comparable to that of the non-corrected (eGFP-negative) population. These results indicate that the initial stalling is transient and eGFP-positive cells eventually resume a normal phenotypic growth pattern, allowing for passaging and expansion in vitro.

Targeted chromosomal gene modification in human cells by single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides in the presence of a DNA double-strand break

A DNA double-strand break (DSB) cannot be tolerated by a cell and is dealt with by several pathways. Here, it was hypothesized that DSB induction close to a targeted mutation in the genome of a mammalian cell might attract oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN)-directed gene repair. A HEK-293-derived cell line had been engineered harboring a single target locus with open reading frames encoding the living-cell reporter proteins LacZ and EGFP, the latter translationally decoupled by a DNA spacer with a unique I-SceI recognition site for defined DSB induction. To enable expression of a fluorescent LacZ-EGFP fusion protein, single-stranded (ss) ODNs (80 or 96 nucleotides long) spanning the DSB were designed to fuse both reading frames by altering a few base-pair positions, deleting 59 bp or introducing a 10-bp fragment. The ssODNs alone generated few EGFP-positive cells. With I-SceI transiently expressed, more than 0.3% of cells revealed EGFP expression 7 days after transfection, with up to 96% of the loci faithfully corrected, depending on the ssODN used. During these correction events, the ssODN did not become physically incorporated into the chromosome, but served only as information template. Unwanted insertional mutagenesis also occurred. Both observations have important implications for gene therapy.

Differential cellular responses to exogenous DNA in mammalian cells and its effect on oligonucleotide-directed gene modification

Transient transfection has been widely used in many biological applications including gene regulation and DNA repair, but, so far, little attention has been paid to cellular responses induced by the transfected DNA. Here, we report that double-stranded (ds) DNA introduced into mammalian cells induced expression of a variety of genes involved in DNA damage signaling and DNA repair. The expression profile of the induced genes was highly dependent on the cell type, suggesting interactions between exogenous dsDNA and cellular proteins. Moreover, each cell line elicited a markedly different level of intrinsic cellular responses to the introduced dsDNA. Furthermore, the presence of single-stranded oligonucleotides or short duplexes consisting of two complementary oligonucleotides did not affect cellular response, indicating that the induction was highly dependent on the structure and length of exogenous DNA. The extent of induction of DNA damage, signaling and DNA repair activities correlated to episomal and chromosomal gene correction frequencies. In addition, the presented data indicate that the presence of exogenous dsDNA triggered a DNA damage response by activation of ATR (ataxia telangiectasia-Rad3-related) but not ATM (ataxia telangiectasia mutated) pathway.

Involvement of ERCC1/XPF and XPG in oligodeoxynucleotide-directed gene modification

Oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN)-mediated gene alteration was postulated to occur in two steps, DNA strand pairing and DNA repair. Once alignment has occurred through homologous strand pairing, a single mismatch is formed between an oligonucleotide and one of the target strands. Because of this mismatch, it has been suggested that proteins involved in a mismatch repair pathway (MMR) participate in the process. We proposed an alternative model, in which a transient assimilation of ODN to the target DNA can interrupt the trafficking of RNA polymerase, and the stalled RNA polymerase may signal for recruitment of DNA repair proteins, including transcription-coupled (TCR) DNA repair and nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathways. Recently, we found that transcription of many genes participating in NER and MMR was induced by the presence of plasmid DNA, and the extent of induction correlated with episomal gene repair rates. To investigate whether an increased level of induction of genes involved in specific DNA repair pathways has a functional role in ODN-directed gene repair, we performed episomal targeting in several cell lines with a specific defective gene in NER and MMR pathways. Comparison among several genetically related cell lines harboring a specific defective gene and complementation of missing activities showed that a primary pathway for gene correction involves some of the proteins participating in NER, primarily two endonucleases processing a DNA lesion, but not MMR.

Physical incorporation of a single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotide during targeted repair of a human chromosomal locus

BACKGROUND

Targeted gene repair is an attractive method to correct point-mutated genes at their natural chromosomal sites, but it is still rather inefficient. As revealed by earlier studies, successful gene correction requires a productive interaction of the repair molecule with the target locus. The work here set out to investigate whether DNA repair, e.g., mismatch repair, or a direct incorporation of the correction molecule follows as the step upon the initial interaction.

METHODS

Single-stranded 21mer oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) of sense orientation were directed towards point-mutated enhanced green fluorescence protein transgene loci in HEK-293-derived cell clones. First gene repair assays compared ODNs carrying the canonical termini 5'-phosphate and 3'-OH with their respective variants harbouring non-canonical termini (5'-OH, 3'-H). Second, a protocol was established to allow efficient recovery of integrated short biotin-labelled ODNs from the genomes of gene-corrected cells using streptavidin-coated beads in order to test directly whether transfected ODNs become bona fide parts of the target locus DNA.

RESULTS

Oligodeoxynucleotides with canonical termini were about 34-fold more efficient than their counterparts carrying non-canonical termini in a phosphorothioate-modified backbone. Furthermore, biotinylated fragments were successfully recovered from genomic DNAs of gene-corrected cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The experiment showed that ODNs are incorporated into a mammalian genome. This unravels one early repair step and also sets an unexpected example of genome dynamics possibly relevant to other ODN-based cell techniques.

Oligonucleotide-mediated gene modification and its promise for animal agriculture

One of the great aspirations in modern biology is the ability to utilise the expanding knowledge of the genetic basis of phenotypic diversity through the purposeful tailoring of the mammalian genome. A number of technologies are emerging which have the capacity to modify genes in their chromosomal context. Not surprisingly, the major thrust in this area has come from the evaluation of gene therapy applications to correct mutations implicated in human genetic diseases. The recent development of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) provides access to these technologies for the purposeful modification of livestock animals. The enormous phenotypic variety existent in contemporary livestock animals has in many cases been linked to quantitative trait loci (QTL) and their underlying point mutations, often referred to as single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Thus, the ability for the targeted genetic modification of livestock animals constitutes an attractive opportunity for future agricultural applications. In this review, we will summarize attempts and approaches for oligonucleotide-mediated gene modification (OGM) strategies for the site-specific modification of the genome, with an emphasis on chimeric RNA-DNA oligonucleotides (RDOs) and single-stranded oligonucletides (ssODNs). The potential of this approach for the directed genetic improvement of livestock animals is illustrated through examples, outlining the effects of point mutations on important traits, including meat and milk production, reproductive performance, disease resistance and superior models of human diseases. Current technological hurdles and potential strategies that might remove these barriers in the future are discussed.