Sequence analysis of the thyrotropin (TSH) receptor gene in congenital primary hypothyroidism associated with TSH unresponsiveness

Imaging the thyroid in children

Color Doppler Ultrasounds (CDU) and Thyroid Scanning (TS) have much improved in recent years and offer a likely diagnosis of the disorder and its main subtypes. This especially applies when diagnosing permanent or transient causes of congenital hypothyroidism (CH), where dual imaging has proven to be more informative than single scanning. Though both isotopes have acceptable performances, the use of (123)I appears more advisable, since it more accurately identifies the various aetiologies of CH and probably has better dosimetric characteristics than (99m)Tc. Detailed dual imaging patterns are presented in connection with most of the underlying mechanisms explaining CH, thyroid dysgenesis (75%) and dyshormonogenesis (20%). Imaging of thyroid autoimmunity, of immunogenic thyrotoxicosis and of thyroid autonomy, is helped by CDU but most often requires a quantified (123)I-TS (molecular imaging). We finally show the interest of CDU to sort suspicious nodule and present the new TIRADS scoring system.

The molecular causes of thyroid dysgenesis: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is a frequent disease occurring with an incidence of about 1/2500 newborns/year. In 80-85% of the cases CH is caused by alterations in thyroid morphogenesis, generally indicated by the term "thyroid dysgenesis" (TD). TD is generally a sporadic disease, but in about 5% of the cases a genetic origin has been demonstrated. In these cases, mutations in genes playing a role during thyroid morphogenesis (NKX2-1, PAX8, FOXE1, NKX2-5, TSHR) have been reported.

AIM

This work reviews the main steps of thyroid morphogenesis and all the genetic alterations associated with TD and published in the literature.

Current loss-of-function mutations in the thyrotropin receptor gene: when to investigate, clinical effects, and treatment

Thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) loss-of-function (LOF) mutations lead to a wide spectrum of phenotypes, ranging from severe congenital hypothyroidism (CH) to mild euthyroid hyperthyrotropinemia. The degree of TSH resistance depends on the severity of the impairment of the receptor function caused by the mutation and on the number of mutated alleles In this review data about genotype-phenotype correlation and criteria for clinical work-up will be presented and discussed. Complete TSH resistance due to biallelic LOF TSHR mutations must be suspected in all patients with severe not syndromic CH and severe thyroid hypoplasia diagnosed at birth by neonatal screening. Partial forms of TSH resistance show a more heterogeneous hormonal and clinical pattern . In these cases TSH serum levels are above the upper limit of normal range for the age but with a very variable pattern, free thyroxine (T4) concentrations are within the normal range and thyroid size can be normal or hypoplastic at ultrasound scan. An early substitutive treatment with L-T4 must be mandatory in all patients with severe CH due to complete uncompensated TSH resistance diagnosed at birth by neonatal screening. The usefulness of substitutive treatment appears much more controversial inpatients with subclinical hypothyroidism due to partial TSH resistance in whom the increased TSH concentration should be able to compensate the mild functional impairment of the mutant receptor. Together with standard criteria we recommend also an accurate clinical work-up to select patients who are candidates for a LOF TSHR mutation.

Thyrotropin receptor gene mutations and TSH resistance: variable expressivity in the heterozygotes

OBJECTIVE

TSH resistance ranges from overt nonautoimmune hypothyroidism to subclinical hypothyroidism, defined as mild hyperthyrotrophinaemia but a euthyroid state clinically. To date, 23 inactivating mutations of the TSH receptor (TSHR) gene have been proven responsible for the clinical condition, but an absence of mutations in the TSHR gene has been reported for several cases of TSH resistance as well. In this paper, we aimed to investigate the actual role of the TSHR gene in the development of both subclinical and congenital hypothyroidism.

PATIENTS

14 hypothyroid newborns, 116 subclinical hypothyroid subjects and 120 healthy controls.

MEASUREMENTS

Through denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC), we screened for mutations the TSHR gene (the proximal promoter, the exons and their flanking regions), and evaluated the association between serum TSH and functionally characterized alleles identified.

RESULTS

In the hypothyroid patients, one patient was heterozygous for a new missense variation, E34K, whereas two others patients were either homozygous or heterozygous for the P162A substitution. In the subclinical hypothyroid subjects, we detected only heterozygous substitutions: they are mostly new (123-124insTGCA, P27T, R46P, 555-561delTATTCTT, D403N, W488R, M527T), while six correspond to already published mutations (P162A, R109Q, L252P and three C41S). We only focused on those mutations that had been functionally characterized in vitro, and in whom serum TSH was available from family members.

CONCLUSIONS

A single grossly mutated allele (such as C41S or 555-561del) invariably leads to a condition of subclinical hypothyroidism, whereas in case of heterozygous carriers of mutations partially affecting the receptor function (such as P162A or L252P), a remarkable variable expressivity was detected among individuals belonging to different generations.

Resistance to thyrotropin

Resistance to TSH is a syndrome of reduced sensitivity to a biologically active TSH molecule. Subjects have elevated TSH levels but no goiter. However, thyroid hormone concentration may vary from normal to very high, depending on the severity of the resistance. Individuals with very high TSH, low T4 and hypoplastic thyroid glands can be mistakenly diagnosed as having primary hypothyroidism due to a defective development of the thyroid gland. Those with normal or slightly decreased T4 can be misdiagnosed as having central hypothyroidism especially if their serum TSH concentration is only slightly elevated. Mutations in the TSH receptor (TSHr) gene have been reported in 16 families with homozygous or compound heterozygous inheritance. The mutant TSHrs show reduced or no function due to either altered ligand binding or defect in membrane targeting. Some individuals, heretozygous for a TSHr gene mutation can present mild resistance to TSH manifesting as euthyroidism with slight hyperthyrotropinemia. A larger proportion of families express the phenotype of resistance to TSH in the absence of a TSHr defect. In many the inheritance is dominant and the genetic cause has not been yet determined.

An outline of inherited disorders of the thyroid hormone generating system

To date, various genetic defects impairing the biosynthesis of thyroid hormone have been identified. These congenital heterogeneous disorders result from mutations of genes involved in many steps of thyroid hormone synthesis, storage, secretion, delivery, or utilization. In contrast to thyroid dyshormonogenesis, the elucidation of the underlying etiology of most cases of thyroid dysgenesis is much less understood. It is suggested that genetic factors might play a role in some cases of thyroid dysgenesis and the best candidate genes involved are those encoding transcription factors known to play a role in the embryonic development of the thyroid gland. Moreover, discordance for thyroid dysgenesis is the rule for monozygotic twins as recently reported and this may result from epigenetic phenomena, early somatic mutations, or postzygotic events. In the final part of this review the molecular defects involved in proteins that transport thyroid hormone in the circulation are described: thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG), transtiretin and albumin, that may be associated with altered thyroid function tests and other pathologic conditions such as amyloidotic polyneuropathy.

Novel inactivating missense mutations in the thyrotropin receptor gene in Japanese children with resistance to thyrotropin

We describe Japanese siblings with resistance to thyrotropin (TSH) who are compound heterozygotes for two novel mutations in the TSH receptor gene. The affected siblings had increased serum TSH, normal serum thyroid hormones, and normal positioned but slightly hypoplastic thyroid glands. The mutated paternal allele has the substitution of His (CAC) in place of Arg (CGC) at codon 450 (R450H) of the TSH receptor. The mutated maternal allele has the substitution of Ser (AGT) in place of Gly (GGT) at codon 498 (G498S) of the TSH receptor. COS-7 cells transfected with the R450H mutant exhibited a slightly decreased TSH binding and a slightly decreased cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) response to TSH, whereas cells transfected with the G498S mutant exhibited a markedly decreased TSH binding and a markedly decreased cAMP response to TSH. Flow immunocytofluorometry analysis demonstrated that the G498S mutant resulted in extremely low expression at the cell surface as compared with the wild type receptor and the R450H mutant, in spite of a normal intracellular synthesis. The present cases are the first Japanese patients with TSH resistance in whom mutations in the TSH receptor gene have been identified. These novel mutations may contribute to understanding of the struc-ture-function relationship of the TSH receptor.

Interpretation of thyroid function tests

The introduction of sensitive thyrotropin assays and free thyroid hormone measurements has simplified the interpretation of thyroid function tests. However, important pitfalls and difficult cases still exist. In this review, thyroid function test results are grouped into six different patterns. We propose that if assays for thyrotropin, free T3, and free T4 are all done, knowledge of these patterns coupled with clinical details and simple additional tests allow a diagnosis to be made in almost all cases.

Congenital hypothyroidism with impaired thyroid response to thyrotropin (TSH) and absent circulating thyroglobulin: evidence for a new inactivating mutation of the TSH receptor gene

Congenital hypothyroidism due to impaired thyroid response to TSH was originally described by Stanbury. A diagnosis of congenital hypothyroidism with thyroid unresponsiveness to TSH is accepted if the patient has congenital hypothyroidism, the thyroid gland is in the normal position in the neck, the size of the thyroid is either normal or atrophic, the serum TSH level is increased, the bioactivity of TSH is intact, and the response of the thyroid gland to TSH stimulation is decreased. In all originally described cases serum thyroglobulin was undetectable. We describe a 22-yr-old female patient who was severely hypothyroid and mentally retarded. Serum T4 and T3 concentrations were below the sensitivity of the methods, with elevated serum TSH levels. Serum thyroglobulin was undetectable. A normally shaped hypoplastic gland located in the appropriate anatomical position in the neck was found at scintiscan. The gland did not respond after administration of bovine TSH in terms of 131I uptake, serum thyroid hormones, and thyroglobulin secretion. A diagnosis of congenital hypothyroidism due to TSH unresponsiveness was formulated. Genetic analysis in the propositus showed a homozygous inactivating mutation of the TSH receptor that had not been previously described. The mutation consisted of the substitution of an isoleucine in place of a highly conserved threonine at position 477 in the first extracellular loop of the receptor (T477I). The brother, one sister of the father (whose DNA was not available), the mother of the propositus, one sister, and the brother were heterozygous for T477I. All the heterozygous persons were unaffected. After transfection in COS-7 cells, the mutant receptor displayed an extremely low expression at cell surface. At variance with cells transfected with the wild-type TSH receptor, cells transfected with the mutant T477I did not show constitutive activity for the adenylyl cyclase pathway. A dramatic reduction in the amount of cAMP accumulation after bovine TSH challenge was observed in cells transfected with the mutant T477I receptor. A structural defect in the mutant TSH receptor protein was probably responsible for the poor routing of the receptor to the cell membrane. This is the first time that a loss of function mutation of the TSH receptor is described in a patient with severe congenital hypothyroidism and absent circulating thyroglobulin due to TSH unresponsiveness and the first time that an inactivating mutation of the TSH receptor is described in the first extracellular loop.

Analysis of the genetic variability of the 1st (CCC/ACC, P52T) and the 10th exons (bp 1012-1704) of the TSH receptor gene in Graves' disease

We determined the genetic variability of the 1st (CCC/ACC, P52T polymorphic variant) and 10th exons (bp 1012-1704) of the TSH receptor (TSHR) gene in Graves' disease. A total of 101 Graves' patients and 163 control subjects were screened. The A253 mutant allele was carried by nine patients with Graves' disease (8.91%) and 13 control subjects (7.98%) in heterozygous genotype. No significant difference in the frequency of the mutant allele was found between Graves' patients and control subjects. These results provide evidence that the A253 polymorphism has no genetic relevance in Graves' disease. Moreover, the DNA nucleotide sequence of 693 bp of the 10th exon (bp 1012-1704) of the TSHR gene was determined in 15 Graves' patients. Six patients were homozygous for the wild-type allele and nine were heterozygous for the mutant allele at the 253rd nucleotide of the first exon. No polymorphism was found in the DNA sequences obtained from leukocytes of Graves' patients, similarly to the sequences obtained from the nine control subjects. None of the nine patients carrying the A253 polymorphism in the 1st exon of the TSHR had polymorphism in the examined part of the 10th exon, including two additional patients whose thyroid tissue was directly analysed. In all likelihood, the polymorphisms of the examined regions of either the 1st or the 10th exon of the THSR gene do not contribute to the genetic susceptibility to Graves' disease.

Linkage of familial euthyroid goiter to the multinodular goiter-1 locus and exclusion of the candidate genes thyroglobulin, thyroperoxidase, and Na+/I- symporter

Iodine deficiency is the most important etiological factor for euthyroid endemic goiter. However, family and twin pair studies also indicate a genetic predisposition for euthyroid simple goiter. In hypothyroid goiters several molecular defects in the thyroglobulin (TG), thyroperoxidase (TPO), and Na+/I- symporter (NIS) genes have been identified. The TSH receptor with its central role for thyroid function and growth is also a strong candidate gene. Therefore, we investigated a proposita with a relapsing euthyroid goiter and her family, in which several members underwent thyroidectomy for euthyroid goiter. Sequence analysis of the complementary DNA (cDNA) of the TPO and TSH receptor genes revealed several previously reported polymorphisms. As it is not possible to exclude a functional relevance for all polymorphisms, we opted for linkage analysis with microsatellite markers to investigate whether the candidate genes are involved in the pathogenesis of euthyroid goiter. The markers for the genes TG, TPO, and NIS gave two-point and multipoint logarithm of odds score analysis scores that were negative or below 1 for all assumed recombination fractions. As no significant evidence of linkage was found, we conclude that these candidate genes can be excluded as a major cause of the euthyroid goiters in this family. In contrast, we have found evidence for linkage of familial euthyroid goiter to the recently identified locus for familial multinodular nontoxic goiter (MNG-1) on chromosome 14q. The haplotype cosegregates clearly with familial euthyroid goiter. Our results provide the first confirmation for MNG-1 as a locus for nontoxic goiter.

Structural analysis of the thyrotropin receptor in four patients with congenital hypothyroidism due to thyroid hypoplasia

Sporadic congenital hypothyroidism is most commonly caused by developmental abnormalities of the thyroid gland. More rarely, it is due to defects in gene products involved in the regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid axis or thyroid hormone synthesis. Loss of function mutations in the thyrotropin (TSH) receptor have been shown to result in resistance to biologically active TSH. In complete resistance to TSH, the thyroid gland is hypoplastic and unable to synthesize and secrete sufficient amounts of thyroid hormones. In partial resistance, referred to as euthyroid hyperthyrotropinemia, the size of the gland and the thyroid hormone levels are normal at the expense of an elevated TSH. Four patients with sporadic congenital hypothyroidism and properly located hypoplastic thyroid glands were included in this study. Serum TSH concentrations were 150 mU/L or higher, serum thyroglobulin levels were within normal limits (6.1 to 8.2 ng/mL; normal range: 2.1 to 32 ng/mL), and thyroid autoantibodies were absent. The coding region of the TSHbeta subunit gene, the TSH receptor gene, and exons 8 and 9 of Gsalpha were analyzed by direct sequencing and found to be normal in all patients. One patient was heterozygous for a G to A transition in the TSHbeta gene resulting in a substitution of alanine by threonine at position -7 of the signal peptide. This substitution was also found in her euthyroid father. In addition, Southern analysis of the TSH receptor gene excluded major structural alterations. These findings support previous reports that indicate that TSH resistance is genetically heterogeneous. In addition to mutations in the TSH receptor or the Gsalpha genes, other genetic defects can lead to an identical phenotype. These observations also suggest that TSH receptor mutations might be a relatively rare cause of congenital thyroid hypoplasia.

Molecular genetics of congenital hypothyroidism

Congenital thyroid gland defects - resulting in reduced production of the hormones triiodothyronine (T3) and thyroxine (T4) - can be a consequence of either reduced or absent thyroid tissue (thyroid dysgenesis) or, less frequently, of impairment in the biochemical mechanisms responsible for hormone biosynthesis (thyroid dyshormonogenesis). Recent studies have revealed how mutations in the genes encoding either transcription factors or the thyroid stimulating hormone receptor cause, in humans or in mouse models, thyroid dysgenesis. This demonstrates, for the first time, the heritability of this condition. New genes responsible for thyroid dyshormonogenesis have also been discovered.

A conserved tyrosine residue (Y601) in transmembrane domain 5 of the human thyrotropin receptor serves as a molecular switch to determine G-protein coupling

In the human thyroid, the wild-type thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) couples to adenylyl cyclase and phospholipase C and constitutively increases intracellular cAMP levels. The first human TSHR sequence submitted differs from subsequently cloned wild-type receptors by an exchange of a conserved Y residue within transmembrane domain 5 (TM5) for an H residue. We did not detect the Y601H mutant in 263 European individuals, but confirmed the homozygous occurrence of TSHR-Y601. Expression of TSHR-Y601H in COS-7 cells revealed a loss of constitutive cAMP production and selective lack of TSH-induced phosphoinositide hydrolysis, whereas agonist-induced cAMP formation remained unaltered. Analysis of several mutant receptors (Y601A, Y601D, Y601F, Y601K, Y601P, Y601S, Y601W, Y601Delta) did not show restoration of constitutive activity and dual signaling, thus suggesting a functional role of a properly spaced hydroxyl group at position 601. Molecular modeling revealed that the formation of a hydrogen bond between the hydroxyl group of Y601 in TM5 and the carbonyl oxygen of A623 in the peptide backbone of TM6 is critical for the receptor to adopt active conformations that impart wild-type signaling properties. Our findings indicate that multiple active receptor states underlie coupling of a G-protein-coupled receptor to different G-proteins.

Apparent congenital athyreosis contrasting with normal plasma thyroglobulin levels and associated with inactivating mutations in the thyrotropin receptor gene: are athyreosis and ectopic thyroid distinct entities?

Loss-of-function mutations in the TSH receptor gene (TSH-R), usually leading to asymptomatic hyperthyrotropinemia, have been reported since 1995 in a total of eight pedigrees, with a pattern of transmission suggesting autosomal recessive inheritance. Although normal TSH secretion and action are not necessary for normal migration of the thyroid analage, they are essential for normal thyroid growth and function. In keeping with this concept, we report a severely hypothyroid boy with a normally located but very hypoplastic and hypofunctional thyroid caused by TSH-R loss-of-function mutations. The propositus' maternal great aunt also had apparent athyreosis. The propositus had undetectable uptake on 99mpertechnetate scintigraphy but normal plasma thyroglobulin at 15 days of age. He was found to be a compound heterozygote for TSH-R mutations, with the maternal allele carrying a splicing mutation (G to C transversion at position +3 of the donor site of intron 6) and the other allele a deletion of two nucleotides (2 bases of codon 655 in exon 10). The great aunt's TSH-R was normal. We also report the sex ratio of hypothyroid newborns referred to our center since 1989 with apparent athyreosis (5 girls, 7 boys) and with ectopic thyroid tissue (41 girls, 15 boys). We conclude that different genetic and nongenetic mechanisms for athyreosis and ectopic thyroid are likely, and that these two distinct entities are themselves heterogeneous. Our results further show that inactivating mutations in TSH-R may account for some cases of apparent congenital athyreosis and should be suspected, especially if plasma thyroglobulin levels are normal.

Analysis of the promoter of the thyrotropin receptor gene and the entire genomic sequence of thyroid transcription factor-1 in familial congenital hypothyroidism due to thyrotropin unresponsiveness

We previously reported that our patients with congenital primary hypothyroidism associated with thyrotropin (TSH) unresponsiveness through an autosomal recessive pattern of inheritance did not have mutations in the coding region of the TSH receptor gene. In the current study, we analyzed the promoter of the TSH receptor gene and the entire region of the thyroid transcription factor-1 (TTF-1) gene, including promoter, two exons, and one intron, because expression of the rat TSH receptor gene is reported to be stimulated by the interaction of the promoter of the TSH receptor gene with TTF-1. Screening for mutations was performed by RNase cleavage assay, and the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products were subsequently sequenced by the automatic sequencer. In the promoter of the TSH receptor gene, a duplication of nucleotides -346 to -330 was detected in one allele, but haplotype analysis of the family demonstrated lack of linkage between the duplication and the TSH unresponsiveness. The same duplication was also observed in some normal subjects. In the TTF-1 gene, we detected a transition (guanine to adenine) in the intron at the minus four position of cryptic 3' splice site in one allele, but absence of linkage suggested that the transition was not responsible for the TSH unresponsiveness. The same transition also was found in some normal subjects. These results suggest that TSH unresponsiveness in our patients is unlikely to be caused by mutations either in the promoter of the TSH receptor gene or in the TTF-1 gene.

Familial congenital hypothyroidism due to inactivating mutation of the thyrotropin receptor causing profound hypoplasia of the thyroid gland

Thyroid gland agenesis is the most common cause of congenital hypothyroidism and is usually sporadic. We investigated a brother and sister from consanguineous parents, ascertained through systematic newborn screening, and initially diagnosed with thyroid agenesis. Careful cervical ultrasonography in both patients revealed a very hypoplastic thyroid gland. By direct sequencing of the thyrotropin receptor gene, we identified the substitution of threonine in place of a highly conserved alanine at position 553, in the fourth predicted transmembrane domain. The mutation was found homozygous in the affected siblings, and heterozygous in both parents and two unaffected siblings. Functional analysis in transfected COS-7 cells showed that it resulted in extremely low expression at the cell surface as compared with the wild-type receptor, in spite of an apparently normal intracellular synthesis. The small amount of mutated receptor expressed at the surface of transfected cells bound thyrotropin with normal affinity and responded in terms of cAMP production, but the in vivo significance of these data from overexpressed receptor in transfected cells is unclear. Of note, blood thyroglobulin was unexpectedly elevated in the patients at the time of diagnosis, a finding that might prove useful in refining etiologies of congenital hypothyroidism.