Robust inference methods for meta-analysis involving influential outlying studies

Meta-analysis is an essential tool to comprehensively synthesize and quantitatively evaluate results of multiple clinical studies in evidence-based medicine. In many meta-analyses, the characteristics of some studies might markedly differ from those of the others, and these outlying studies can generate biases and potentially yield misleading results. In this article, we provide effective robust statistical inference methods using generalized likelihoods based on the density power divergence. The robust inference methods are designed to adjust the influences of outliers through the use of modified estimating equations based on a robust criterion, even when multiple and serious influential outliers are present. We provide the robust estimators, statistical tests, and confidence intervals via the generalized likelihoods for the fixed-effect and random-effects models of meta-analysis. We also assess the contribution rates of individual studies to the robust overall estimators that indicate how the influences of outlying studies are adjusted. Through simulations and applications to two recently published systematic reviews, we demonstrate that the overall conclusions and interpretations of meta-analyses can be markedly changed if the robust inference methods are applied and that only the conventional inference methods might produce misleading evidence. These methods would be recommended to be used at least as a sensitivity analysis method in the practice of meta-analysis. We have also developed an R package, robustmeta, that implements the robust inference methods.

Robust small area estimation for unit level model with density power divergence

Unit level model is one of the classical models in small area estimation, which plays an important role with unit information data. Empirical Bayesian(EB) estimation, as the optimal estimation under normal assumption, is the most commonly used parameter estimation method in unit level model. However, this kind of method is sensitive to outliers, and EB estimation will lead to considerable inflation of the mean square error(MSE) when there are outliers in the responses yij. In this study, we propose a robust estimation method for the unit-level model with outliers based on the minimum density power divergence. Firstly, by introducing the minimum density power divergence function, we give the estimation equation of the parameters of the unit level model, and obtain the asymptotic distribution of the robust parameters. Considering the existence of tuning parameters in the robust estimator, an optimal parameter selection algorithm is proposed. Secondly, empirical Bayesian predictors of unit and area mean in finite populations are given, and the MSE of the proposed robust estimators of small area means is given by bootstrap method. Finally, we verify the superior performance of our proposed method through simulation data and real data. Through comparison, our proposed method can can solve the outlier situation better.

On Default Priors for Robust Bayesian Estimation with Divergences

This paper presents objective priors for robust Bayesian estimation against outliers based on divergences. The minimum γ-divergence estimator is well-known to work well in estimation against heavy contamination. The robust Bayesian methods by using quasi-posterior distributions based on divergences have been also proposed in recent years. In the objective Bayesian framework, the selection of default prior distributions under such quasi-posterior distributions is an important problem. In this study, we provide some properties of reference and moment matching priors under the quasi-posterior distribution based on the γ-divergence. In particular, we show that the proposed priors are approximately robust under the condition on the contamination distribution without assuming any conditions on the contamination ratio. Some simulation studies are also presented.

Small area estimation with mixed models: a review

Small area estimation is recognized as an important tool for producing reliable estimates under limited sample information. This paper reviews techniques of small area estimation using mixed models, covering from basic to recently proposed advanced ones. We first introduce basic mixed models for small area estimation, and provide several methods for computing mean squared errors and confidence intervals which are important for measuring uncertainty of small area estimators. Then we provide reviews of recent development and techniques in small area estimation. This paper could be useful not only for researchers who are interested in details on the methodological research in small area estimation, but also for practitioners who might be interested in the application of the basic and new methods.