Model to describe the degree of twitch potentiation during neuromuscular monitoring

Influence of tetanic stimulation on the staircase phenomenon and the acceleromyographic time-course of neuromuscular block: a randomized controlled trial

During neuromuscular monitoring, repeated electrical stimulation evokes muscle responses of increasing magnitude ('staircase phenomenon', SP). We aimed to evaluate whether SP affects time course and twitches' values of an acceleromyographic assessed neuromuscular block with or without previous tetanic stimulation. Fifty adult patients were randomized to receive a 50 Hz tetanic stimulus (S group) or not (C group) before monitor calibration. After 20 min of TOF ratio (TOFr) stimulation rocuronium was administered. Onset time of block (primary endpoint), recovery of T1 to 25%, TOFr to 0.9, and recovery index were compared. We also compared T1 and TOFr at baseline, post-stimulation, and during recovery from block. Moreover the correlation between T1 at maximum recovery and (a) baseline T1 and (b) post-stimulation T1 along with T1/TOFr ratio during recovery were evaluated. After stimulation median T1 increased (32%) in group C and decreased (16%) in group S (P = 0.0001). Onset time (Median [IQR] in seconds) was 90 (29-77) vs. 75 (28-60) in C and S group (P = 0.002). Time [Mean (SD) in minutes] to normalized TOFr 0.9 were 70.13 (14.9) vs. 62.1 (21.2) in C and S groups (P = 0.204). TOFr showed no differences between groups at any time point. T1 at maximum recovery showed a stronger correlation with post-stabilization T1 compared to baseline. (ρ = 0.80 and ρ = 0.85, for C and S groups.) Standard calibration does not ensure twitch baseline stabilization and prolongs onset time of neuromuscular block. TOF ratio is not influenced by SP.

Positive and negative staircase effect during single twitch and train-of-four stimulation: a laboratory study in dogs

A positive staircase effect is well documented during neuromuscular monitoring. However, the increase in twitch amplitude may not remain stable over time. We compared the staircase phenomenon and twitch stability during single twitch (ST) or train-of-four (TOF) stimulation in anesthetized dogs. Force of contraction was measured in ten dogs. Each thoracic limb was stimulated with ST 0.1 Hz or TOF q 12 s for 25 min (random order). No neuromuscular blockers were administered. Every 5 min, ST and T1 amplitudes were compared within and between groups. Stability of twitch amplitude (<5 % change in 5 min) was also evaluated. ST and T1 amplitude increased over time without significant differences between groups. After 10 min of ST stimulation, the average ST amplitude had increased significantly to 107 %, and remained unchanged thereafter. T1 amplitude was significantly greater than baseline only at 5 (111 %) and 10 min (109 %); a decline towards baseline occurred thereafter. Stability was reached after 15 min for all dogs in the ST group, however, three dogs continued to have changes >5 % with TOF. An initial increase in ST amplitude remained stable over the observation period, but the increase in T1 amplitude during TOF was frequently followed by a decay. A stable twitch amplitude (variation <5 % in 5 min) was observed in all dogs with ST after 15 min of stimulation, which was not the case during TOF stimulation. Therefore, it appears at least in dogs, that ST might offer some advantages over T1 for measuring twitch amplitude.

Twitch potentiation: a potential source of error during neuromuscular monitoring with acceleromyography in anesthetized dogs

OBJECTIVE

To measure twitch potentiation (the staircase phenomenon) in anesthetized dogs, and assess its relevance during neuromuscular monitoring with acceleromyography (AMG).

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized, prospective clinical trial.

ANIMALS

Sixteen dogs undergoing ovariohysterectomy.

METHODS

Under isoflurane anesthesia, neuromuscular function was monitored with train-of-four (TOF) stimuli every 15 seconds and quantified by AMG. Neuromuscular blockade (NMB) was produced with 0.15 mg kg(-1) atracurium IV. Dogs were randomly divided into two groups; a potentiation group (PG) in which TOF stimulation was applied for 20 minutes before atracurium was administered; and a control group (CG) where no such time was allowed. In both groups, the AMG was calibrated (at tCAL) just before atracurium was administered. TOF stimulation continued throughout the experiment in all dogs. The height of the first twitch (T(1)) (expressed as a fraction of T(1) at tCAL) and train-of-four ratio (TOFR) were recorded until TOFR returned to ≥90%.

RESULTS

In PG, T(1) increased significantly (p = 0.0078) from a median of 102% (range, 95, 109) at baseline to 118% (100, 142) at 20 minutes. In PG, no difference was found between T(1) at tCAL (immediately before atracurium administration) and T(1) when neuromuscular transmission returned (p = 0.42). In the CG, T(1) increased significantly between tCAL and the time neuromuscular transmission returned (p = 0.027). TOFR did not increase during twitch potentiation (all p = 0.32).

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

T(1) increased significantly during 20 minutes of uninterrupted TOF stimulation in the absence of NMB, establishing that twitch potentiation occurs in anesthetized dogs. With no time for potentiation, T(1) increased during the course of recovery from NMB; this phenomenon introduces a bias in T(1) measurements and could affect studies reporting potency and duration of NMB based on T(1) or single twitches. TOFR was unaltered by potentiation emphasizing its clinical usefulness for excluding post-operative residual NMB.

Simultaneous versus sequential pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic population analysis using an Iterative Two-Stage Bayesian technique

A method for simultaneous pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) population analysis using an Iterative Two-Stage Bayesian (ITSB) algorithm was developed. The method was evaluated using clinical data and Monte Carlo simulations. Data from a clinical study with rocuronium in nine anesthetized patients and data generated by Monte Carlo simulation using a similar study design were analysed by sequential PK-PD analysis, PD analysis with nonparametric PK data and simultaneous PK-PD analysis. Both PK and PD data sets were 'rich' with respect to the number of measurements per individual. The accuracy and precision of the estimated population parameters were evaluated by comparing their mean error (ME) and root mean squared error (RMSE), respectively. The influence of PD model misspecification on the results was also investigated. The simultaneous PK-PD analysis resulted in slightly more precise population parameter estimates than the sequential PK-PD analysis and the nonparametric PK method. In the presence of PD model misspecification, however, simultaneous analysis resulted in poor PK parameter estimates, while sequential PK-PD analysis performed well. In conclusion, ITSB is a valuable technique for PK-PD population analysis of rich data sets. The sequential PK-PD method is better suited for the analysis of rich data than the simultaneous analysis.

Twitch potentiation influences the time course of twitch depression in muscle relaxant studies: a pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic explanation

The time course of twitch depression following neuromuscular blocking agent (NMBA) administration is influenced by the duration of control neuromuscular monitoring (twitch stabilization). The physiological mechanism for this interaction is not known. During twitch stabilization twitch response often increases to a plateau, this is known as twitch potentiation or the staircase phenomenon. Since twitch potentiation contributes to the observed twitch response it may also influence the time course of twitch depression following NMBA administration. Our objective was to estimate the degree that twitch potentiation influences the time course of twitch depression following NMBA administration under conditions typical for muscle relaxation studies. We used previousy described pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) and twitch potentiation models to simulate twitch data. Simulations consisted of twitch stabilization followed by a NMBA bolus dose and subsequent onset and recovery from muscle relaxation. Twitch data were analyzed for onset and recovery characteristics and the results compared to clinical muscle relaxation studies in existing literature. We found that twitch potentiation likely plays a minor role in shortened onset time and increased duration of twitch depression observed with long periods of twitch stabilization.

Normalization of acceleromyographic train-of-four ratio by baseline value for detecting residual neuromuscular block

BACKGROUND

This study was designed to recognize the importance of normalizing postoperative acceleromyographic train-of-four (TOF) ratio by the baseline TOF value obtained before neuromuscular block for ensuring adequate recovery of neuromuscular function.

METHODS

In 120 patients, TOF responses of the adductor pollicis to the ulnar nerve stimulation were monitored by acceleromyography (AMG) during anaesthesia using propofol, fentanyl and nitrous oxide. Control TOF stimuli were administered for 30 min. A TOF ratio measured at the end of control stimulation was regarded as a baseline value. Neuromuscular block was induced with vecuronium 0.1 mg kg(-1) and was allowed to recover spontaneously. Duration to a TOF ratio of 0.9 as calculated by AMG (DUR-raw 0.9) was compared with that of 0.9 as corrected by the baseline TOF ratio (i.e. 0.9 x baseline TOF ratio; DUR-real 0.9).

RESULTS

Baseline TOF ratios ranged from 0.95 to 1.47. The average TOF ratios observed every 5 min were constant throughout control stimulation from at time zero mean (SD) [range]; 1.11 (0.09) [0.94-1.42] to at 30 min 1.13 (0.11) [0.95-1.47]. The DUR-real 0.9 was 91.0 (18.0) [51.3-131.0] min and was significantly longer than the DUR-raw 0.9 (81.2 (16.3) [41.3-123.0] min).

CONCLUSIONS

Baseline TOF ratios measured by AMG are usually more than 1.0 and vary widely among patients. Therefore a TOF ratio of 0.9 displayed postoperatively on AMG does not always represent adequate recovery of neuromuscular function and should be normalized by baseline value to reliably detect residual paralysis.

The staircase phenomenon at the corrugator supercilii muscle in comparison with the hand muscles

BACKGROUND

Phonomyography (PMG) is a novel method to monitor neuromuscular block. It is non-invasive and can be applied to any muscle. It can be used interchangeably with mechanomyography (MMG). The staircase phenomenon has not been investigated for this method or at the corrugator supercilii muscle. The purpose of this work was to determine the staircase effect at three different muscles using two different methods.

METHODS

In 10 patients undergoing general anaesthesia with sevoflurane, using a laryngeal mask airway without the aid of neuromuscular block, one piezo-electric microphone each was applied to the corrugator supercilii muscle and the first dorsal interosseus muscle. In addition, a force transducer was attached to the tip of the thumb to determine the force of the adductor pollicis muscle. Supramaximal stimulation at 1 Hz was used at the ulnar and the facial nerve. All signals were simultaneously recorded for 30 min. Data are presented as means (SD).

RESULTS

The staircase effect was significantly positive for the first dorsal interosseus muscle and the adductor pollicis muscle. The signal potentiation was not significantly different between the first dorsal interosseus muscle with a maximum increase at 148 (19)% using PMG, and the adductor pollicis muscle at 154 (22)% using MMG. The evoked signals reached a plateau after 15-18 min at both muscles. There was only a small initial increase in signal height at the corrugator supercilii to a maximum of 117 (20)% at 7 min, after which the signals decreased to reach a plateau at 25 min. In comparison with the signal height of 105 (25)% at 30 min, there was no significant difference of signal heights throughout the observation period.

CONCLUSIONS

A positive staircase phenomenon is found equally at the first dorsal interosseus muscle and the adductor pollicis muscle. There is no significant staircase effect at the corrugator supercilii muscle.

Improving Pharmacokinetic–Pharmacodynamic Models of Muscle Relaxants Using Potentiation Modelling

Repeated motor nerve stimulation performed during neuromuscular monitoring enhances the evoked mechanical response of the corresponding muscle resulting in an increased twitch response. This is known as twitch potentiation or the staircase phenomenon. For neuromuscular modelling research twitch stabilisation techniques are often used to reduce the visible effect of potentiation, but such techniques are not always effective. Our objective was to model pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) and twitch potentiation and to estimate neuromuscular block (NMB) in the presence of twitch potentiation. We combined a standard PK-PD model with a model describing the degree of twitch potentiation. The combined model was used to predict mechanomyographic twitch measurements and estimate NMB and twitch potentiation during muscle relaxation monitoring. Model parameters and prediction accuracy were compared to the standard PK-PD model with and without linear baseline correction. The PK-PD-potentiation model allows NMB to be estimated in the presence of twitch potentiation. It also accurately predicts data from twitch stabilisation, which is ignored with the standard PK-PD model. Compared to the standard PK-PD model, estimated PD parameters ec50 and gamma were found to be higher using the PK-PD-potentiation model. Compared to linear baseline correction, estimated PD parameters ke0 and ec50 were found to be higher. A PK-PD-potentiation model can estimate the degree of twitch potentiation and the degree of NMB during neuromuscular monitoring. This model leads to different PD parameter estimations than the standard PK-PD model however the differences are small enough to be unlikely to cause great concern among researchers.

Proteomic studies of human and other vertebrate muscle proteins

This review summarizes results of some systemic studies of muscle proteins of humans and some other vertebrates. The studies, started after introduction of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of O'Farrell, were significantly extended during development of proteomics, a special branch of functional genomics. Special attention is paid to analysis of characteristic features of strategy for practical realization of the systemic approach during three main stages of these studies: pre-genomic, genomic (with organizational registration of proteomics), and post-genomic characterized by active use of structural genomics data. Proteomic technologies play an important role in detection of changes in isoforms of various muscle proteins (myosins, troponins, etc.). These changes possibly reflecting tissue specificity of gene expression may underline functional state of muscle tissues under normal and pathological conditions, and such proteomic analysis is now used in various fields of medicine.