Comparison of the early haemodynamics of stented pericardial and porcine aortic valves

Functional performance of eight small surgical aortic valve bioprostheses: An in vitro study

OBJECTIVES

Selection of a surgical aortic valve bioprosthesis (SAV) model for treatment of aortic valve disease remains controversial. The aim of this study was to characterize the functional performance of eight SAV models in a standardized in vitro setting.

METHODS

The hydrodynamic performance of eight SAVs with labelled size 21 mm (Avalus™, Hancock® II, Mosaic® UltraTM, Perimount®, Perimount® Magna Ease, EpicTM Supra, Trifecta™ GT; Freestyle®) was investigated in a pulse duplicator. Transvalvular pressure gradients and effective orifice area (EOA) were recorded. The geometrical orifice area (GOA) and physical dimensions of the valves were determined, and new functional dimensions were introduced.

RESULTS

Mean pressure gradient (MPG) and EOA differed significantly between the analyzed SAVs. The Epic presented with the lowest EOA and highest MPG, while the Trifecta showed the highest EOA and the lowest MPG. We introduce a useful way to determine the minimal internal diameter and a new measure termed 'relative orifice area' to characterize a valve's performance.

CONCLUSIONS

SAVs showed significant differences in their hydrodynamic performance despite the same label size. This finding was related to the construction of the valves. We introduce a new measure that characterizes the functional performance of a valve model and size for treatment of an aortic annulus of a specific size. Our data emphasize that SAV selection should carefully be done using an individual patient approach and that future research is necessary to improve the current generation of SAVs.

Glutaraldehyde and 2,3-butanediol treatment of bovine pericardium for aortic valve bioprosthesis in sheep: a preliminary study

Background

Bovine pericardium can be used for cardiovascular repair surgeries, but challenges involving biocompatibility and durability remain. This study aimed to carry out pre-clinical testing of aortic valve replacement using an aortic valve prosthesis made of bovine pericardium modified with glutaraldehyde (GA) and 2,3-butanediol (BD).

Methods

The mechanical, plasma protein adsorption, platelet adhesion, collagenase digestion, and ninhydrin properties of the material (control vs. GA vs. GA + BD) were tested. All 3 tissues were implanted in rats and observed after 8 weeks under microscopy with alizarin red staining for calcification. Aortic valves made from the fully-treated material were implanted in sheep. A commercial bioprosthesis was used as control. Effectiveness and safety indicators were observed at 180 days after implantation.

Results

Compared with the control group, the GA + BD material showed higher elongation at breaking and tensile load (both P<0.05), lower plasma protein adsorption, lower platelet adhesion, lower collagenase digestion, lower ninhydrin value, and higher cross-linking (all P<0.05). After implantation in rat models, the GA + BD material showed little or no dissolution; there was no obvious calcification; and it was surrounded by a small amount of fibrosis, with peripheral capillary proliferation. After implantation in sheep models, the aortic valve leaflets of the experimental animals freely opened and closed, their surface was smooth, and no abnormal echo was observed. The echocardiographic results and hemodynamic were comparable between the two groups. All safety parameters were normal.

Conclusions

Modification of bovine pericardium with GA and BD results in a biomaterial with favorable properties for use as an aortic valve prosthesis.

Perioperative evaluation of regional aortic wall shear stress patterns in patients undergoing aortic valve and/or proximal thoracic aortic replacement

OBJECTIVES

To assess in patients with aortopathy perioperative changes in thoracic aortic wall shear stress (WSS), which is known to affect arterial remodeling, and the effects of specific surgical interventions.

METHODS

Presurgical and postsurgical aortic 4D flow MRI were performed in 33 patients with aortopathy (54 ± 14 years; 5 women; sinus of Valsalva (d_SOV)/midascending aortic (d_MAA) diameters = 44 ± 5/45 ± 6 mm) scheduled for aortic valve (AVR) and/or root (ARR) replacement. Control patients with aortopathy who did not have surgery were matched for age, sex, body size, and d_MAA (n = 20: 52 ± 14 years; 3 women; d_SOV/d_MAA = 42 ± 4/42 ± 4 mm). Regional aortic 3D systolic peak WSS was calculated. An atlas of WSS normal values was used to quantify the percentage of at-risk tissue area with abnormally high WSS, excluding the area to be resected/graft.

RESULTS

Peak WSS and at-risk area showed low interobserver variability (≤0.09 [-0.3; 0.5] Pa and 1.1% [-7%; 9%], respectively). In control patients, WSS was stable over time (follow-up-baseline differences ≤0.02 Pa and 0.0%, respectively). Proximal aortic WSS decreased after AVR (n = 5; peak WSS difference ≤-0.41 Pa and at-risk area ≤-10%, P < .05 vs controls). WSS was increased after ARR in regions distal to the graft (peak WSS difference ≥0.16 Pa and at-risk area ≥4%, P < .05 vs AVR). Follow-up duration had no significant effects on these WSS changes, except when comparing ascending aortic peak WSS between ARR and AVR (P = .006).

CONCLUSIONS

Serial perioperative 4D flow MRI investigations showed distinct patterns of postsurgical changes in aortic WSS, which included both reductions and translocations. Larger longitudinal studies are warranted to validate these findings with clinical outcomes and prediction of risk of future aortic events.