Developmentally regulated initiation of DNA synthesis by telomerase: evidence for factor-assisted de novo telomere formation

Programmed chromosome fragmentation in ciliated protozoa: multiple means to chromosome ends

SUMMARYCiliated protozoa undergo large-scale developmental rearrangement of their somatic genomes when forming a new transcriptionally active macronucleus during conjugation. This process includes the fragmentation of chromosomes derived from the germline, coupled with the efficient healing of the broken ends by de novo telomere addition. Here, we review what is known of developmental chromosome fragmentation in ciliates that have been well-studied at the molecular level (Tetrahymena, Paramecium, Euplotes, Stylonychia, and Oxytricha). These organisms differ substantially in the fidelity and precision of their fragmentation systems, as well as in the presence or absence of well-defined sequence elements that direct excision, suggesting that chromosome fragmentation systems have evolved multiple times and/or have been significantly altered during ciliate evolution. We propose a two-stage model for the evolution of the current ciliate systems, with both stages involving repetitive or transposable elements in the genome. The ancestral form of chromosome fragmentation is proposed to have been derived from the ciliate small RNA/chromatin modification process that removes transposons and other repetitive elements from the macronuclear genome during development. The evolution of this ancestral system is suggested to have potentiated its replacement in some ciliate lineages by subsequent fragmentation systems derived from mobile genetic elements.

RNA-template dependent de novo telomere addition

De novo addition of telomeric sequences can occur at broken chromosomes and must be well controlled, which is essential during programmed DNA reorganization processes. In ciliated protozoa an extreme form of DNA-reorganization is observed during macronuclear differentiation after sexual reproduction leading to the elimination of specific parts of the germline genome. Regulating these processes involves small noncoding RNAs, but in addition DNA-reordering, excision and amplification require RNA templates deriving from the parental macronucleus. We show that these putative RNA templates can carry telomeric repeats. Microinjection of RNA templates carrying modified telomeres into the developing macronucleus leads to modified telomeres in vegetative cells, providing strong evidence, that de novo addition of telomeres depends on a telomere-containing transcript from the parental macronucleus.

The MRT-1 nuclease is required for DNA crosslink repair and telomerase activity in vivo in Caenorhabditis elegans

The telomerase reverse transcriptase adds de novo DNA repeats to chromosome termini. Here we define Caenorhabditis elegans MRT-1 as a novel factor required for telomerase-mediated telomere replication and the DNA-damage response. MRT-1 is composed of an N-terminal domain homologous to the second OB-fold of POT1 telomere-binding proteins and a C-terminal SNM1 family nuclease domain, which confer single-strand DNA-binding and processive 3'-to-5' exonuclease activity, respectively. Furthermore, telomerase activity in vivo depends on a functional MRT-1 OB-fold. We show that MRT-1 acts in the same telomere replication pathway as telomerase and the 9-1-1 DNA-damage response complex. MRT-1 is dispensable for DNA double-strand break repair, but functions with the 9-1-1 complex to promote DNA interstrand cross-link (ICL) repair. Our data reveal MRT-1 as a dual-domain protein required for telomerase function and ICL repair, which raises the possibility that telomeres and ICL lesions may share a common feature that plays a critical role in de novo telomere repeat addition.

The structure and function of telomerase reverse transcriptase

The structure and integrity of telomeres are essential for genome stability. Telomere dysregulation can lead to cell death, cell senescence, or abnormal cell proliferation. The maintenance of telomere repeats in most eukaryotic organisms requires telomerase, which consists of a reverse transcriptase (RT) and an RNA template that dictates the synthesis of the G-rich strand of telomere terminal repeats. Structurally, telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) contains unique and variable N- and C-terminal extensions that flank a central RT-like domain. The enzymology of telomerase includes features that are both similar to and distinct from those characteristic of other RTs. Two distinguishing features of TERT are its stable association with the telomerase RNA and its ability to repetitively reverse transcribe the template segment of RNA. Here we discuss TERT structure and function; its regulation by RNA-DNA, TERT-DNA, TERT-RNA, TERT-TERT interactions, and TERT-associated proteins; and the relationship between telomerase enzymology and telomere maintenance.

High Telomerase RNA Expression Level Is an Adverse Prognostic Factor for Favorable-Histology Wilms' Tumor

Purpose

A primary objective of the fifth National Wilms Tumor Study (NWTS-5) was to identify prognostic indicators for patients with favorable-histology Wilms' tumor. The prognostic significance of telomerase expression level in primary tumor samples was assessed.

Patients and Methods

A case-cohort study was conducted involving 291 NWTS-5 registrants. Telomerase activity was measured using the telomeric repeat amplification protocol (TRAP). Expression levels of TERT mRNA (encoding the telomerase catalytic component) and TERC/hTR (the telomerase RNA template) were measured using quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction.

Results

After excluding samples because of lack of viable tumor, RNA degradation, or insufficient clinical information, 244 patients remained for the final analysis (96 with relapse and 148 without relapse). Univariate analysis revealed a positive correlation between relative risk (RR) of relapse and levels of TERT mRNA and TERC expression. For each doubling in TERT mRNA and TERC level, the RR increased by a factor of 1.16 (95% CI, 1.04 to 1.29; P = .01) and 1.35 (95% CI, 1.11 to 1.64; P = .003), respectively. The one third of patients whose tumors had the highest TERC expression level had an RR of 2.06 (95% CI, 1.14 to 3.70; P = .02) compared with patients with the lowest level. TERC expression level remained a significant prognostic indicator in a multivariate analysis adjusting for TERT mRNA, tumor stage, and patient age. TRAP level did not correlate with RR of relapse. Telomerase expression levels were not predictive of overall survival.

Conclusion

Telomerase RNA expression level may provide a clinically useful adjunct to the current risk classification schema for favorable-histology Wilms' tumor.

The Euplotes telomerase subunit p43 stimulates enzymatic activity and processivity in vitro

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that synthesizes telomeric DNA repeats at the ends of eukaryotic chromosomes. Although it is minimally composed of a conserved catalytic protein subunit (TERT) and an RNA component, additional accessory factors present in the holoenzyme play crucial roles in the biogenesis and function of the enzyme complex. Telomerase from the ciliate Tetrahymena can be reconstituted in active form in vitro. Using this system, we show that p43, a telomerase-specific La-motif protein from the ciliate Euplotes, stimulates activity and increases repeat addition processivity of telomerase. Activity enhancement by p43 requires its incorporation into a TERT.RNA.p43 ternary complex but is independent of other dissociable protein factors functioning in telomerase complex assembly. Stimulation is enhanced at elevated temperatures, supporting a role for p43 in structural stabilization of a critical region of the RNA subunit. To our knowledge, this represents the first demonstration that an authentic telomerase accessory protein can directly affect the enzymatic activity of the core enzyme in vitro.

A human telomerase-associated nuclease

Ciliate and yeast telomerase possess a nucleolytic activity capable of removing DNA from the 3' end of a single-stranded oligonucleotide substrate. The nuclease activity is thought to assist in enzyme proofreading and/or processivity. Herein, we report a previously uncharacterized human telomerase-associated nuclease activity that shares several properties with ciliate and yeast telomerases. Partially purified human telomerase, either from cell extracts or recombinantly produced, demonstrated an ability to remove 3' nontelomeric nucleotides from a substrate containing 5' telomeric DNA, followed by extension of the newly exposed telomeric sequence. This cleavage/extension activity was apparent at more than one position within the telomeric DNA and was influenced by sequences 5' to the telomeric/nontelomeric boundary and by substitution with a methylphosphonate moiety at the telomeric/nontelomeric DNA boundary. Our data suggest that human telomerase is associated with an evolutionarily conserved nucleolytic activity and support a model in which telomerase-substrate interactions can occur distal from the 3' primer end.

Human telomerase catalyzes nucleolytic primer cleavage

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that uses an integral RNA molecule to add de novo G-rich repeats onto telomeric DNA, or onto nontelomeric DNA generated during chromosome fragmentation and breakage events. A telomerase-mediated DNA substrate cleavage activity has been reported in ciliates and yeasts. Nucleolytic cleavage may serve a proofreading function, enhance processivity or ensure that nontemplate telomerase RNA sequences are not copied into DNA. We identified and characterized a human telomerase-mediated nucleolytic cleavage activity using enzyme reconstituted in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate in vitro transcription/translation system and native enzyme extracted from cells. We found that telomerase catalyzed the removal of nucleotides from DNA substrates including those that can form a mismatch with the RNA template or that contain nontelomeric sequences located 3' to a telomeric sequence. Unlike Tetrahymena telomerase, human telomerase catalyzed the removal of more than one nucleotide (up to 13) from telomeric primers. DNA substrates predicted to align at the 3'-end of the RNA template were not cleaved, consistent with cleavage being dictated by the template 5'-end. We also found some differences in the nuclease activity between RRL-reconstituted human telomerase and native enzyme.

A conserved telomerase motif within the catalytic domain of telomerase reverse transcriptase is specifically required for repeat addition processivity

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase responsible for the maintenance of one strand of the telomere terminal repeats. The catalytic protein subunit of the telomerase complex, known as TERT, possesses a reverse transcriptase (RT) domain that mediates nucleotide addition. The RT domain of TERT is distinguishable from retroviral and retrotransposon RTs in having a sizable insertion between conserved motifs A and B', within the so-called fingers domain. Sequence analysis revealed the existence of conserved residues in this region, named IFD (insertion in fingers domain). Mutations of some of the conserved residues in Saccharomyces cerevisiae TERT (Est2p) abolished telomerase function in vivo, testifying to their importance. Significant effects of the mutations on telomerase activity in vitro were observed, with most of the mutants exhibiting a uniform reduction in activity regardless of primer sequence. Remarkably, one mutant manifested a primer-specific defect, being selectively impaired in extending primers that form short hybrids with telomerase RNA. This mutant also accumulated products that correspond to one complete round of repeat synthesis, implying an inability to effect the repositioning of the DNA product relative to the RNA template that is necessary for multiple repeat addition. Our results suggest that the ability to stabilize short RNA-DNA hybrids is crucial for telomerase function in vivo and that this ability is mediated in part by a more elaborate fingers domain structure.

The C terminus of the human telomerase reverse transcriptase is a determinant of enzyme processivity

The catalytic subunit of telomerase (TERT) contains conserved reverse transcriptase-like motifs but N- and C-terminal regions unique to telomerases. Despite weak sequence conservation, the C terminus of TERTs from various organisms has been implicated in telomerase-specific functions, including telomerase activity, functional multimerization with other TERT molecules, enzyme processivity and telomere length maintenance. We studied hTERT proteins containing small C-terminal deletions or substitutions to identify and characterize hTERT domains mediating telomerase activity, hTERT multimerization and processivity. Using sequence alignment of five vertebrate TERTs and Arabidopsis thaliana TERT, we identified blocks of highly conserved amino acids that were required for human telomerase activity and functional hTERT complementation. We adapted the non-PCR-based telomerase elongation assay to characterize telomerase expressed and reconstituted in the in vitro transcription/translation rabbit reticulocyte lysate system. Using this assay, we found that the hTERT C terminus, like the C terminus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae TERT, contributes to successive nucleotide addition within a single 6-base telomeric repeat (type I processivity). Certain mutations in the hTERT C terminus also reduced the repetitive addition of multiple telomeric repeats (type II processivity). Our results suggest a functionally conserved role for the TERT C terminus in telomerase enzyme processivity.

Developmentally programmed gene elimination in Euplotes crassus facilitates a switch in the telomerase catalytic subunit

The primary function of telomerase is to maintain preexisting telomere tracts. In the ciliate Euplotes crassus, however, telomerase RNP structure and substrate recognition are altered during macronuclear development to facilitate de novo telomere addition. We found that E. crassus harbors three TERT genes encoding the telomerase catalytic subunit that not only vary in their nucleotide and predicted protein sequences, but also in their expression profiles. Expression of EcTERT-1 and -3 correlates with the requirement for telomere maintenance, while that of EcTERT-2 correlates with de novo telomere synthesis. All three genes appear to require ribosomal frameshifting for expression of catalytically active protein. The transcriptionally active form of EcTERT-2 exists only transiently in mated cells and is absent from the vegetative macronucleus. Thus, telomerase expression in Euplotes is controlled by unique regulatory mechanisms that culminate in a developmental switch to a different catalytic subunit with properties suited to de novo telomere addition.

Biochemical aspects of telomerase function

Arthur Kornberg "never met a dull enzyme" (For the Love of Enzymes: The Odyssey of a Biochemist, Harvard University Press, 1989) and telomerase is no exception. Telomerase is a remarkable polymerase that uses an internal RNA template to reverse-transcribe telomere DNA, one nucleotide at a time, onto telomeric, G-rich single-stranded DNA. In the 17 years since its discovery, the characterization of telomerase enzyme components has uncovered a highly conserved family of telomerase reverse transcriptases that, together with the telomerase RNA, appear to comprise the enzymatic core of telomerase. While not as comprehensively understood as yet, some telomerase-associated proteins also serve crucial roles in telomerase function in vivo, such as telomerase ribonudeoprotein (RNP) assembly, recruitment to the telomere, and the coordination of DNA replication at the telomere. A selected overview of the biochemical properties of this unique enzyme, in vitro and in vivo, will be presented.

Genome remodeling in ciliated protozoa

The germline genomes of ciliated protozoa are dynamic structures, undergoing massive DNA rearrangement during the formation of a functional macronucleus. Macronuclear development involves chromosome fragmentation coupled with de novo telomere synthesis, numerous DNA splicing events that remove internal segments of DNA, and, in some ciliates, the reordering of scrambled gene segments. Despite the fact that all ciliates share similar forms of DNA rearrangement, there appears to be great diversity in both the nature of the rearranged DNA and the molecular mechanisms involved. Epigenetic effects on rearrangement have also been observed, and recent work suggests that chromatin differentiation plays a role in specifying DNA segments either for rearrangement or for elimination.

Minimum length requirement of the alignment domain of human telomerase RNA to sustain catalytic activity in vitro

Telomeres are essential for genomic stability and cell viability. Telomerase, the enzyme responsible for telomere maintenance, is composed of a reverse transcriptase protein subunit and an integral RNA component which contains the templating domain. In human telomerase, the template region consists of 11 nt (3'-rCAAUCCCAAUC-5') and comprises an alignment domain (italicised) plus a template sequence encoding the telomeric repeat d(GGT TAG). In this study, the alignment domain of human telomerase was systematically reduced from the 3' end and the resultant recombinant enzyme activity was evaluated in vitro. Deletion or substitution of one or two residues from the 3' end of the alignment domain caused only a slight reduction in overall catalytic activity and did not alter the processivity of the enzyme. Deletion or substitution of three or more residues from the 3' end of the alignment domain resulted in total loss of catalytic activity. These results suggest that the two most 3' terminal RNA residues are relevant but not essential for overall activity and that the minimal length requirement of the alignment domain is 3 nt. Furthermore, base pairing between the 3' end of the primer substrate and the first two residues of the alignment domain is also not an absolute requirement for processive synthesis.

Oligomerization of the telomerase reverse transcriptase from Euplotes crassus

The telomerase ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase uses its RNA subunit as a template to synthesize telomeric repeats and maintain telomere tracts on chromosome ends. In the ciliate Euplotes crassus, the core telomerase ribonucleoprotein particle undergoes a developmentally programmed assembly into three higher order complexes after mating. Here, we provide evidence using oligonucleotide-directed affinity purification that all of the E.crassus telomerase complexes contain at least two enzyme active sites. Furthermore, we show using co-immunoprecipitation experiments that EcTERT, the telomerase catalytic subunit, undergoes multimerization in vitro. Two independent interaction domains were identified in EcTERT, one at the N-terminus that spans amino acids 186-354 and one at the C-terminus that spans amino acids 755-857. Unexpectedly, we found that TERT can form head-to-head, tail-to-tail and head-to-tail oligomers in vitro, implying that E.crassus telomerase has the potential to assume different conformations in vivo. Together, these data indicate that oligomerization is a conserved feature of telomerase and that the minimal functional unit of the enzyme is a dimer.

Telomere formation on macronuclear chromosomes of Oxytricha trifallax and O. fallax: alternatively processed regions have multiple telomere addition sites

BACKGROUND

Ciliates employ massive chromatid breakage and de novo telomere formation during generation of the somatic macronucleus. Positions flanking the 81-MAC locus are reproducibly cut. But those flanking the Common Region are proposed to often escape cutting, generating three nested macronuclear chromosomes, two retaining "arms" still appended to the Common Region. Arm-distal positions must differ (in cis) from the Common Region flanks.

RESULTS

The Common-Region-flanking positions also differ from the arm-distal positions in that they are "multi-TAS" regions: anchored PCR shows heterogeneous patterns of telomere addition sites, but arm-distal sites do not. The multi-TAS patterns are reproducible, but are sensitive to the sequence of the allele being processed. Thus, random degradation following chromatid cutting does not create this heterogeneity; these telomere addition sites also must be dictated by cis-acting sequences.

CONCLUSIONS

Most ciliates show such micro-heterogeneity in the precise positions of telomere addition sites. Telomerase is believed to be tightly associated with, and act in concert with, the chromatid-cutting nuclease: heterogeneity must be the result of intervening erosion activity. Our "weak-sites" hypothesis explains the correlation between alternative chromatid cutting at the Common Region boundaries and their multi-TAS character: when the chromatid-breakage machine encounters either a weak binding site or a weak cut site at these regions, then telomerase dissociates prematurely, leaving the new end subject to erosion by an exonuclease, which pauses at cis-acting sequences; telomerase eventually heals these resected termini. Finally, we observe TAS positioning influenced by trans-allelic interactions, reminiscent of transvection.

Interactions between telomerase and primase physically link the telomere and chromosome replication machinery

In the ciliate Euplotes crassus, millions of new telomeres are synthesized by telomerase and polymerase alpha-primase during macronuclear development in mated cells. Concomitant with de novo telomere formation, telomerase assembles into higher-order complexes of 550 kDa, 1,600 kDa, and 5 MDa. We show here that telomerase is physically associated with the lagging-strand replication machinery in these complexes. Antibodies against DNA primase precipitated telomerase activity from all three complexes from mated cells but not the 280-kDa telomerase complex from vegetatively growing cells. Moreover, when telomerase was affinity purified, primase copurified with enzyme from mated cells but not with the 280-kDa vegetative complex. Thus, the association of telomerase and primase is developmentally regulated. Intriguingly, PCNA (proliferating cell nuclear antigen) was also found in the 5-MDa complex from mated cells. We therefore speculate that this complex is a complete telomere synthesis machine, while the smaller complexes are assembly intermediates. The physical association of telomerase and primase explains the coordinate regulation of telomeric G- and C-strand synthesis and the efficiency of telomere addition in E. crassus.

Rapid upregulation of telomerase activity in human leukemia HL-60 cells treated with clinical doses of the DNA-damaging drug etoposide

The enzyme telomerase is implicated in cellular resistance to apoptosis, but the mechanism for this resistance remains to be elucidated. The ability of telomerase to synthesize new DNA at telomeres suggests that this enzyme might function in the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks. To distinguish the effects of double-stranded DNA break damage and apoptosis on human telomerase activity, we treated the HL-60 human hematopoietic cancer cell line with clinical doses of the chemotherapeutic drug etoposide (0.5 to 5 microM), which allowed us to distinguish between events associated with DNA damage-induced cell cycle arrest, and events associated with apoptosis. Large (three- to seven-fold) upregulation of telomerase activity occurred soon after etoposide treatment (3 h) in S/G2/M-arresting populations; this upregulation was abolished at onset of apoptotic cell death. No upregulation of telomerase activity was observed in cells treated with a larger dose of etoposide (5 microM) that caused cells to undergo rapid apoptosis without intervening cell cycle arrests. These observations are consistent with a possible role for telomerase upregulation during the DNA damage response.

De novo telomere addition to spacer sequences prior to their developmental degradation in Euplotes crassus

During sexual reproduction, Euplotes crassus precisely fragments its micronuclear chromosomes and synthesizes new telomeres onto the resulting DNA ends to generate functional macronuclear minichromosomes. In the micronuclear chromosomes, the macronuclear-destined sequences are typically separated from each other by spacer DNA segments, which are eliminated following chromosome fragmentation. Recently, in vivo chromosome fragmentation intermediates that had not yet undergone telomere addition have been characterized. The ends of both the macronuclear-destined and eliminated spacers were found to consist of six-base, 3' overhangs. As this terminal structure on the macronuclear-destined sequences serves as the substrate for de novo telomere addition, we sought to determine if the spacer DNAs might also undergo telomere addition prior to their elimination. Using a polymerase chain reaction approach, we found that at least some spacer DNAs undergo de novo telomere addition. In contrast to macronuclear-destined sequences, heterogeneity could be observed in the position of telomeric repeat addition. The observation of spacer DNAs with telomeric repeats makes it unlikely that differential telomere addition is responsible for differentiating between retained and eliminated DNA. The heterogeneity in telomere addition sites for spacer DNA also resembles the situation found for telomeric repeat addition to macronuclear-destined sequences in other ciliate species.

Repair of chromosome ends after telomere loss in Saccharomyces

Removal of a telomere from yeast chromosome VII in a strain having two copies of this chromosome often results in its loss. Here we show that there are three pathways that can stabilize this broken chromosome: homologous recombination, nonhomologous end joining, and de novo telomere addition. Both in a wild-type and a recombination deficient rad52 strain, most stabilization events were due to homologous recombination, whereas nonhomologous end joining was exceptionally rare. De novo telomere addition was relatively rare, stabilizing <0.1% of broken chromosomes. Telomere addition took place at a very limited number of sites on chromosome VII, most occurring close to a 35-base pair stretch of telomere-like DNA that is normally approximately 50 kb from the left telomere of chromosome VII. In the absence of the Pif1p DNA helicase, telomere addition events were much more frequent and were not concentrated near the 35-base pair tract of telomere-like DNA. We propose that internal tracts of telomere-like sequence recruit telomerase by binding its anchor site and that Pif1p inhibits telomerase by dissociating DNA primer-telomerase RNA interactions. These data also show that telomeric DNA is essential for the stable maintenance of linear chromosomes in yeast.

Different modes of de novo telomere formation by plant telomerases

The telomerase reverse transcriptase can recognize broken chromosome ends and add new telomeres de novo in a reaction termed "chromosome healing". Here we investigate new telomere formation in vitro by telomerases from a variety of flowering plant species. Comparing the electrophoretic mobilities and nucleotide sequences of the products, we uncovered three different modes of new telomere formation. The soybean telomerase, designated a Class I enzyme, only elongated DNA primers ending in telomeric nucleotides. Arabidopsis and maize telomerases, designated Class II enzymes, efficiently extended completely non-telomeric sequences by positioning the 3' terminus at a preferred site on the RNA template. Silene latifolia and sorghum telomerases constituted class III enzymes that elongated non-telomeric DNA primers by annealing them at alternative sites on the RNA template. For all enzymes, errors were prevalent during synthesis of the first two repeats, likely reflecting lateral instability of the primer 3' terminus on the template during the initial rounds of elongation. Class III telomerases, however, were five- to 13-fold more error prone than class II, generating more mistakes in distal repeats added to the primers. This remarkable variability in enzyme-DNA interactions among plant telomerases does not reflect phylogenetic relationships, and therefore implies that the telomerase active site can evolve rapidly.

Ciliate telomerase biochemistry

Telomerase is a cellular reverse transcriptase specialized for use of a template carried within the RNA component of the enzyme ribonucleoprotein complex. Substrates for telomerase are single-stranded oligonucleotides in vitro and chromosome ends in vivo. In vitro, a bound substrate is extended by an initial round of DNA synthesis on the internal RNA template and in some cases by multiple rounds of template copying before product dissociation. In vivo, de novo synthesis of one strand of a telomeric repeat sequence by telomerase balances the sequence loss resulting from incomplete replication of linear chromosome ends by RNA primer-requiring DNA polymerases. Telomerase biochemistry has been studied extensively by using partially purified cell extracts. Telomerase components are being identified and beginning to be produced in recombinant form. This review focuses on the enzyme mechanism of telomerases from ciliate species, thus far the most intensively studied systems.

Interference footprinting analysis of telomerase elongation complexes

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that adds single-stranded telomeric repeats to the ends of linear eukaryotic chromosomes. It consists of an RNA molecule including a template sequence, a protein subunit containing reverse transcriptase motifs, and auxiliary proteins. We have carried out an interference footprinting analysis of the Tetrahymena telomerase elongation complexes. In this study, single-stranded oligonucleotide primers containing telomeric sequences were modified with base-specific chemical reagents and extended with the telomerase by a single (32)P-labeled dGMP or dTMP. Base modifications that interfered with the primer extension reactions were mapped by footprinting. Major functional interactions were detected between the telomerase and the six or seven 3'-terminal residues of the primers. These interactions occurred not only with the RNA template region, but also with another region in the enzyme ribonucleoprotein complex designated the telomerase DNA interacting surface (TDIS). This was indicated by footprints generated with dimethyl sulfate (that did not affect Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding) and by footprinting assays performed with mutant primers. In primers aligned at a distance of 2 nucleotides along the RNA template region, the footprints of the six or seven 3'-terminal residues were shifted by 2 nucleotides. This shift indicated that during the elongation reaction, TDIS moved in concert with the 3' ends of the primers relative to the template region. Weak interactions occurred between the telomerase and residues located upstream of the seventh nucleotide. These interactions were stronger in primers that were impaired in the ability to align with the template.

Chromatin diminution in the parasitic nematodes ascaris suum and parascaris univalens

Chromatin diminution in Parascaris univalens and Ascaris suum undoubtedly represents an interesting case of developmentally programmed DNA rearrangement in higher eukaryotes. It is a complex mechanism involving chromosomal breakage, new telomere addition and DNA degradation, and occurs in all presomatic cells. The process is rather specific with respect to its developmental timing and the chromosomal regions that are eliminated. The functional significance of chromatin diminution still remains an enigma. The fact, however, that single-copy, protein-coding genes are contained in the eliminated DNA demonstrates that in P. univalens and A. suum, there is a qualitative difference between germ-line and somatic genomes, and suggests that chromatin diminution may be used as a "throw-away" approach to gene regulation. We present a hypothesis as to how, during evolution, a partial genome duplication might have been linked to the process of chromatin diminution, in order to provide a selective advantage to parasitic DNA-eliminating nematodes.

Characterization of in vivo developmental chromosome fragmentation intermediates in E. crassus

Ligation-mediated PCR was used to characterize intermediates in the fragmentation/de novo telomere addition process that occurs during sexual reproduction in the ciliate E. crassus. Fragmentation generates ends with 6-base, 3' overhangs that have 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl groups. These intermediates are detected only during the period of chromosome fragmentation. Fragmentation always occurs at a precise distance from a conserved sequence, the E-Cbs, indicating that it is a key cis-acting element in the process. The results also serve to identify the natural substrate for de novo telomere addition and indicate that telomerase recognizes, and compensates for, partial telomeric repeats at the ends of fragmentation intermediates. Similarities of the Euplotes fragmentation/telomere addition process to the movement of some non-long terminal repeat retrotransposons are discussed.

Assembly and regulation of telomerase

Recent studies on the telomerase reverse transcriptase have benefited from the identification of the catalytic core subunits. Cellular factors that participate in the assembly of the core enzyme have been identified and regulatory mechanisms that control telomerase activity are beginning to be elucidated.

Telomerase activity in ductal carcinoma in situ and invasive breast cancer

The increasing number of breast carcinoma in situ detected by screening procedures makes it imperative to develop improved markers to stratify the risk of invasive cancer. Telomerase is detectable in invasive cancer, but not in normal tissues. We have microdissected frozen tissue blocks containing both DCIS and invasive cancer to assay the telomerase activity of these two lesions. The 46 available cases of concurrent DCIS and invasive breast cancer resulted in 43 DCIS samples and 38 invasive cancer samples adequate for analysis. Seventy per cent of the DCIS and all invasive cancer samples tested had detectable telomerase activity. In addition, we analysed telomerase activity in ten cases of DCIS that were not associated with invasive cancer, and detected telomerase activity in seven (70%). Mixing experiments showed no evidence of telomerase inhibitors in telomerase negative samples. Furthermore, periductal inflammatory infiltrates were shown to be a potential confounding source of telomerase activity. Since DCIS lesions appear to be heterogeneous with respect to telomerase activity, and telomerase activation appears to precede the development of invasive cancer, telomerase activity may be a useful adjunct in stratifying the risk of developing invasive breast cancer in patients with DCIS.

Developmentally regulated telomerase activity is correlated with chromosomal healing during chromatin diminution in Ascaris suum

Telomerase is the ribonucleoprotein complex responsible for the maintenance of the physical ends, or telomeres, of most eukaryotic chromosomes. In this study, telomerase activity has been identified in cell extracts from the nematode Ascaris suum. This parasitic nematode is particularly suited as a model system for the study of telomerase, because it shows the phenomenon of chromatin diminution, consisting of developmentally programmed chromosomal breakage, DNA elimination, and new telomere formation. In vitro, the A. suum telomerase is capable of efficiently recognizing and elongating nontelomeric primers with nematode-specific telomere repeats by using limited homology at the 3' end of the DNA to anneal with the putative telomerase RNA template. The activity of this enzyme is developmentally regulated, and it correlates temporally with the phenomenon of chromatin diminution. It is up-regulated during the first two rounds of embryonic cell divisions, to reach a peak in 4-cell-stage embryos, when three presomatic blastomeres prepare for chromatin diminution. The activity remains high until the beginning of gastrulation, when the last of the presomatic cells undergoes chromatin diminution, and then constantly decreases during further development. In summary, our data strongly argue for a role of this enzyme in chromosome healing during the process of chromatin diminution.

Telomerase in kinetoplastid parasitic protozoa

We have identified telomerase activity in extracts of three evolutionarily diverse kinetoplastid species: Trypanosoma brucei, Leishmania major, and Leishmania tarentolae. Telomerase activity was initially detected in extracts from insect form cells of all three kinetoplastid species by using a modification of the one-tube telomere repeat amplification protocol [Kim, N., et al. (1994) Science 266, 2011-2015], although better results were subsequently achieved with the two-tube telomere repeat amplification protocol [Autexier, C., Pruzan, R., Funk, W. & Greider, C. (1996) EMBO J. 15, 5928-5935]. The activity in T. brucei extracts was sufficiently robust to enable its detection in a direct assay of telomerase; enzyme processivity was found to be relatively low. The in vitro properties of telomerase suggest a possible templating domain sequence for the telomerase RNA of T. brucei. Telomerase activity is likely to contribute to telomere maintenance in these parasitic organisms and provides a new target for chemotherapeutic intervention.

Conserved DNA sequences adjacent to chromosome fragmentation and telomere addition sites in Euplotes crassus

During the formation of a new macronucleus in the ciliate Euplotes crassus, micronuclear chromosomes are reproducibly broken at approximately 10 000 sites. This chromosome fragmentation process is tightly coupled with de novo telomere synthesis by the telomerase ribonucleoprotein complex, generating short linear macronuclear DNA molecules. In this study, the sequences of 58 macronuclear DNA termini and eight regions of the micronuclear genome containing chromosome fragmentation/telomere addition sites were determined. Through a statistically based analysis of these data, along with previously published sequences, we have defined a 10 bp conserved sequence element (E-Cbs, 5'-HATTGAAaHH-3', H = A, C or T) near chromosome fragmentation sites. The E-Cbs typically resides within the DNA destined to form a macronuclear DNA molecule, but can also reside within flanking micronuclear DNA that is eliminated during macronuclear development. The location of the E-Cbs in macronuclear-destined versus flanking micronuclear DNA leads us to propose a model of chromosome fragmentation that involves a 6 bp staggered cut in the chromosome. The identification of adjacent macronuclear-destined sequences that overlap by 6 bp provides support for the model. Finally, our data provide evidence that telomerase is able to differentiate between newly generated ends that contain partial telomeric repeats and those that do not in vivo.

Developmentally programmed assembly of higher order telomerase complexes with distinct biochemical and structural properties

In Euplotes crassus, telomerase is responsible for telomere maintenance during vegetative growth and de novo telomere synthesis during macronuclear development. Here we show that telomerase in the vegetative stage of the life cycle exists as a 280-kD complex that can add telomeric repeats only onto telomeric DNA primers. Following the initiation of macronuclear development, telomerase assembles into larger complexes of 550 kD, 1600 kD, and 5 MD. In the 1600-kDa and 5-MDa complexes, telomerase is more processive than in the two smaller complexes and can add telomeres de novo onto nontelomeric 3' ends. Assembly of higher order telomerase complexes is accompanied by an extended region of RNase V1 and RNase T1 protection in the telomerase RNA subunit that is not observed with telomerase from vegetatively growing cells. The protected residues encompass a highly conserved region previously proposed to serve as a platform for formation of higher order structures. These findings provide the first direct demonstration of developmentally regulated higher order telomerase complexes with unique biochemical and structural properties.

Reiterative dG addition by Euplotes crassus telomerase during extension of non-telomeric DNA

Telomerase from the ciliate Euplotes crassus incorporates G4T4telomeric repeats onto both telomeric and non-telomeric single-stranded DNA 3'-ends via reverse transcription of a templating domain in its RNA subunit. Here we describe an unusual mode of template copying that is characteristic of DNA synthesis onto non-telomeric 3'-ends in vitro . When dTTP was eliminated from telomerase reactions, telomeric primers or DNA products generated from the telomerase endonuclease were extended by precise copying of the RNA template. In contrast, telomerase catalyzed the addition of up to 13 dG residues onto primers with non-telomeric 3'-ends under the same reaction conditions. Introducing mismatches in the 3'-terminus of telomeric primers that reduced primer complementarity to the RNA template induced reiterative dG incorporation, indicating that the reaction is influenced by Watson-Crick base pair formation between the primer and the RNA template. Unexpectedly, the reiterative dG addition mode was confined to telomerase derived from developing cells that undergo new telomere formation. This reaction was not observed in vegetatively growing cells. We postulate that indiscriminate dG addition by telomerase occurs by reiterative copying of C residues in the telomerase RNA templating domain and reflects lateral instability of the primer-template interaction during de novo telomere formation.

Flexible positioning of the telomerase-associated nuclease leads to preferential elimination of nontelomeric DNA

In addition to a reverse transcriptase activity, telomerase is associated with a DNA endonuclease that removes nucleotides from a primer 3' terminus prior to telomere repeat addition. Here we examine the DNA specificity of the primer cleavage-elongation reaction carried out by the Euplotes crassus telomerase. We show that the primer cleavage activity copurified with the E. crassus telomerase polymerase, indicating that it either is an intrinsic property of telomerase or is catalyzed by a tightly associated factor. Using chimeric primers containing stretches of telomeric DNA that could be precisely positioned on the RNA template, we found that the cleavage site is more flexible than originally proposed. Primers harboring mismatches in dT tracts that aligned opposite nucleotides 37 to 40 in the RNA template were cleaved to eliminate the mismatched residues along with the adjacent 3' sequence. The cleaved product was then elongated to generate perfect telomeric repeats. Mismatches in dG tracts were not removed, implying that the nuclease does not track coordinately with the polymerase active site. Our data indicate that the telomerase-associated nuclease could provide a rudimentary proofreading function in telomere synthesis by eliminating mismatches between the DNA primer and the 5' region of the telomerase RNA template.

A novel specificity for the primer-template pairing requirement in Tetrahymena telomerase

Telomerase is a specialized reverse transcriptase with a built-in RNA template. Base pairing between the templating domain of telomerase RNA and a telomeric DNA primer is normally a characteristic of elongation of telomeric DNA. Here we demonstrate the mechanism by which Tetrahymena telomerase bypasses a requirement for template-primer pairing in order to add telomeric DNA de novo to completely non-telomeric DNA primers. We show that this reaction initiates by copying the template residue at the 3' boundary of the telomerase RNA template sequence. Unexpectedly, as the RNA template moves through the telomerase catalytic center, the number of required potential Watson-Crick base pairs between RNA template and DNA primer increases from zero to five. We propose that this unprecedented position specificity of a base pairing potential requirement in a polymerase underlies the chromosome healing mechanism of telomerase, and reflects constraints inherent in an internal template.

Plasmodium falciparum telomerase: de novo telomere addition to telomeric and nontelomeric sequences and role in chromosome healing

Telomerase, a specialized cellular reverse transcriptase, compensates for chromosome shortening during the proliferation of most eucaryotic cells and contributes to cellular immortalization. The mechanism used by the single-celled protozoan malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum to complete the replication of its linear chromosomes is currently unknown. In this study, telomerase activity has for the first time been identified in cell extracts of P. falciparum. The de novo synthesis of highly variable telomere repeats to the 3' end of DNA oligonucleotide primers by plasmodial telomerase is demonstrated. Permutated telomeric DNA primers are extended by the addition of the next correct base. In addition to elongating preexisting telomere sequences, P. falciparum telomerase can also add telomere repeats onto nontelomeric 3' ends. The sequence GGGTT was the predominant initial DNA sequence added to the nontelomeric 3' ends in vitro. Poly(C) at the 3' end of the oligonucleotide significantly alters the precision of the new telomerase added repeats. The efficiency of nontelomeric primer elongation was dependent on the presence of a G-rich cassette upstream of the 3' terminus. Oligonucleotide primers based on natural P. falciparum chromosome breakpoints are efficiently used as telomerase substrates. These results imply that P. falciparum telomerase contributes to chromosome maintenance and to de novo telomere formation on broken chromosomes. Reverse transcriptase inhibitors such as dideoxy GTP efficiently inhibit P. falciparum telomerase activity in vitro. These data point to malaria telomerase as a new target for the development of drugs that could induce parasite cell senescence.

Coordinate regulation of G- and C strand length during new telomere synthesis

We have used the ciliate Euplotes to study the role of DNA polymerase in telomeric C strand synthesis. Euplotes provides a unique opportunity to study C strand synthesis without the complication of simultaneous DNA replication because millions of new telomeres are made at a stage in the life cycle when no general DNA replication takes place. Previously we showed that the C-strands of newly synthesized telomeres have a precisely controlled length while the G-strands are more heterogeneous. This finding suggested that, although synthesis of the G-strand (by telomerase) is the first step in telomere addition, a major regulatory step occurs during subsequent C strand synthesis. We have now examined whether G- and C strand synthesis might be regulated coordinately rather than by two independent mechanisms. We accomplished this by determining what happens to G- and C strand length if C strand synthesis is partially inhibited by aphidicolin. Aphidicolin treatment caused a general lengthening of the G-strands and a large increase in C strand heterogeneity. This concomitant change in both the G- and C strand length indicates that synthesis of the two strands is coordinated. Since aphidicolin is a very specific inhibitor of DNA pol alpha and pol delta, our results suggest that this coordinate length regulation is mediated by DNA polymerase.

dGTP-dependent processivity and possible template switching of euplotes telomerase

We have measured the processivity of telomeric DNA extension by Euplotes aediculatus telomerase at various concentrations of the nucleotide substrates dGTP and dTTP. The maximum processivity (approximately 3 repeats) was observed at approximately 100 microM of each dNTP. Processivity decreased as the dNTP concentrations were reduced and, surprisingly, as the concentration of dGTP was increased. Also, the characteristic banding pattern generated by telomerase extension of DNA primers shifted in response to changes in dGTP concentration. One pattern with 8 nt periodicity was predominant at dGTP concentrations </=16 microM, while at >/= 250 microM an 8 nt repeat pattern out-of-phase with the first was observed; at intermediate concentrations the two patterns coexisted. We propose that two different segments of the RNA subunit can serve as the template for repeat synthesis; nt 42-49 at low dGTP concentrations and nt 36-43 at high dGTP concentrations. An alternative model for the low dGTP pattern involves an internal pause site but no pause at the end of the template and is, therefore, considered less likely. Because the effects of dGTP on processivity and banding pattern appear to be distinct from nucleotide binding in the polymerase active site, we propose a second dGTP binding site involved in template selection and processivity.