Impacts of Whole-Genome Triplication on MIRNA Evolution in Brassica rapa

Evolution after Whole-Genome Duplication: Teleost MicroRNAs

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are important gene expression regulators implicated in many biological processes, but we lack a global understanding of how miRNA genes evolve and contribute to developmental canalization and phenotypic diversification. Whole-genome duplication events likely provide a substrate for species divergence and phenotypic change by increasing gene numbers and relaxing evolutionary pressures. To understand the consequences of genome duplication on miRNA evolution, we studied miRNA genes following the teleost genome duplication (TGD). Analysis of miRNA genes in four teleosts and in spotted gar, whose lineage diverged before the TGD, revealed that miRNA genes were retained in ohnologous pairs more frequently than protein-coding genes, and that gene losses occurred rapidly after the TGD. Genomic context influenced retention rates, with clustered miRNA genes retained more often than nonclustered miRNA genes and intergenic miRNA genes retained more frequently than intragenic miRNA genes, which often shared the evolutionary fate of their protein-coding host. Expression analyses revealed both conserved and divergent expression patterns across species in line with miRNA functions in phenotypic canalization and diversification, respectively. Finally, major strands of miRNA genes experienced stronger purifying selection, especially in their seeds and 3'-complementary regions, compared with minor strands, which nonetheless also displayed evolutionary features compatible with constrained function. This study provides the first genome-wide, multispecies analysis of the mechanisms influencing metazoan miRNA evolution after whole-genome duplication.

A prescient evolutionary model for genesis, duplication and differentiation of MIR160 homologs in Brassicaceae

MicroRNA160 is a class of nitrogen-starvation responsive genes which governs establishment of root system architecture by down-regulating AUXIN RESPONSE FACTOR genes (ARF10, ARF16 and ARF17) in plants. The high copy number of MIR160 variants discovered by us from land plants, especially polyploid crop Brassicas, posed questions regarding genesis, duplication, evolution and function. Absence of studies on impact of whole genome and segmental duplication on retention and evolution of MIR160 homologs in descendent plant lineages prompted us to undertake the current study. Herein, we describe ancestry and fate of MIR160 homologs in Brassicaceae in context of polyploidy driven genome re-organization, copy number and differentiation. Paralogy amongst Brassicaceae MIR160a, MIR160b and MIR160c was inferred using phylogenetic analysis of 468 MIR160 homologs from land plants. The evolutionarily distinct MIR160a was found to represent ancestral form and progenitor of MIR160b and MIR160c. Chronology of evolutionary events resulting in origin and diversification of genomic loci containing MIR160 homologs was delineated using derivatives of comparative synteny. A prescient model for causality of segmental duplications in establishment of paralogy in Brassicaceae MIR160, with whole genome duplication accentuating the copy number increase, is being posited in which post-segmental duplication events viz. differential gene fractionation, gene duplications and inversions are shown to drive divergence of chromosome segments. While mutations caused the diversification of MIR160a, MIR160b and MIR160c, duplicated segments containing these diversified genes suffered gene rearrangements via gene loss, duplications and inversions. Yet the topology of phylogenetic and phenetic trees were found congruent suggesting similar evolutionary trajectory. Over 80% of Brassicaceae genomes and subgenomes showed a preferential retention of single copy each of MIR160a, MIR160b and MIR160c suggesting functional relevance. Thus, our study provides a blue-print for reconstructing ancestry and phylogeny of MIRNA gene families at genomics level and analyzing the impact of polyploidy on organismal complexity. Such studies are critical for understanding the molecular basis of agronomic traits and deploying appropriate candidates for crop improvement.

Gene duplication and stress genomics in Brassicas: Current understanding and future prospects

Polyploidy or whole genome duplication (WGD) is an evolutionary phenomenon that happened in all angiosperms multiple times over millions of years. Extensive studies on the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana genome have revealed that it has undergone five rounds of WGDs followed, in the Brassicaceae tribe, by a characteristic whole genome triplication (WGT). In addition, small-scale events such as tandem or segmental duplications and retrotransposition also enable plants to reshape their genomes. Over the decades, extensive research efforts have been undertaken to understand the evolutionary significance of polyploidy. On the other hand, much less attention has been paid to understanding the impact of gene duplication on the diversification of important stress response genes. The main objective of this review is to discuss key aspects of gene and genome duplications with a focus on genes primarily regulated by osmotic stresses. The focal family is the Brassicaceae, since it (i) underwent multiple rounds of WGDs plus WGTs, (ii) hosts many economically important crops and wild relatives that are tolerant to a range of stresses, and (iii) comprises many species that have already been sequenced. Diverse molecular mechanisms that lead to structural and regulatory alterations of duplicated genes are discussed. Examples are drawn from recent literature to elucidate expanded, stress responsive gene families identified from different Brassica crops. A combined bioinformatic and transcriptomic method has been proposed and tested on a known stress-responsive gene pair to prove that stress-responsive duplicated allelic variants can be identified by this method. Finally, future prospects for engineering these genes into crops to enhance stress tolerance are discussed, and important resources for Brassica genome research are provided.

Evolution of MIR159/319 genes in Brassica campestris and their function in pollen development

MIR159/319 have conserved evolution and diversified function after WGT in Brassica campestris, both of them can lead pollen vitality and germination abnormality, Bra-MIR319c also can function in flower development. MiR159 and miR319 are extensively studied highly conserved microRNAs which play roles in vegetative development, reproduction, and hormone regulation. In this study, the effects of whole-genome triplication (WGT) on the evolution of the MIR159/319 family and the functional diversification of the genes were comprehensively investigated in Brassica campestris. We identified 11 MIR159/319 genes in B. campestris, which produced five mature sequences. After analyzing the precursor sequences and phylogenetic tree, we found that Bra-MIR159/319 have evolutionary conservatism. Furthermore, Bra-MIR159/319 show functional diversification after WGT, as indicated by their expression patterns and the cis-element in their promoter. GUS signal showed that Bra-MIR159a and Bra-MIR319c can be expressed in anther but in different development stages. In B. campestris, overexpressed MIR159a and MIR319c contribute to late anther development and promote pollen abortion. Moreover, Bra-MIR319c can partially assume the function of MIR319a in flower development.

Functional Similarity and Difference among Bra-MIR319 Family in Plant Development

miR319 was the first plant miRNA discovered via forward genetic mutation screening. In this study, we found that miR319 family members had similar sequences but different expression patterns in Brassica campestris and Arabidopsis thaliana. RT-PCR analysis revealed that Bra-MIR319a and Bra-MIR319c had similar expression patterns and were widely expressed in plant development, whereas Bra-MIR319b could only be detected in stems. The overexpression of each Bra-MIR319 family member in Arabidopsis could inhibit cell division and function in leaf and petal morphogenesis. Bra-miR319a formed a new regulatory relationship after whole genome triplication, and Bra-MIR319a overexpressing in Arabidopsis led to the degradation of pollen content and affected the formation of intine, thereby causing pollen abortion. Our results suggest that Bra-MIR319 family members have functional similarity and difference in plant development.

Fine-Tuning the Expression of Duplicate Genes by Translational Regulation in Arabidopsis and Maize

Plant genomes are extensively shaped by various types of gene duplication. However, in this active area of investigation, the vast majority of studies focus on the sequence and transcription of duplicate genes, leaving open the question of how translational regulation impacts the expression and evolution of duplicate genes. We explored this issue by analyzing the ribo- and mRNA-seq data sets across six tissue types and stress conditions in Arabidopsis thaliana and maize (Zea mays). We dissected the relative contributions of transcriptional and translational regulation to the divergence in the abundance of ribosome footprint (RF) for different types of duplicate genes. We found that the divergence in RF abundance was largely programmed at the transcription level and that translational regulation plays more of a modulatory role. Intriguingly, translational regulation is characterized by its strong directionality, with the divergence in translational efficiency (TE) globally counteracting the divergence in mRNA abundance, indicating partial buffering of the transcriptional divergence between paralogs by translational regulation. Divergence in TE was associated with several sequence features. The faster-evolving copy in a duplicate pair was more likely to show lower RF abundance, which possibly results from relaxed purifying selection compared with its paralog. A considerable proportion of duplicates displayed differential TE across tissue types and stress conditions, most of which were enriched in photosynthesis, energy production, and translation-related processes. Additionally, we constructed a database TDPDG-DB (http://www.plantdupribo.tk), providing an online platform for data exploration. Overall, our study illustrates the roles of translational regulation in fine-tuning duplicate gene expression in plants.

Microsynteny analysis to understand evolution and impact of polyploidization on MIR319 family within Brassicaceae

The availability of a large number of whole-genome sequences allows comparative genomic analysis to reveal and understand evolution of regulatory regions and elements. The role played by events such as whole-genome and segmental duplications followed by genome fractionation in shaping genomic landscape and in expansion of gene families is crucial toward developing insights into evolutionary trends and consequences such as sequence and functional diversification. Members of Brassicaceae are known to have experienced several rounds of whole-genome duplication (WGD) that have been termed as paleopolyploidy, mesopolyploidy, and neopolyploidy. Such repeated events led to the creation and expansion of a large number of gene families. MIR319 is reported to be one of the most ancient and conserved plant MIRNA families and plays a role in growth and development including leaf development, seedling development, and embryo patterning. We have previously reported functional diversification of members of miR319 in Brassica oleracea affecting leaf architecture; however, the evolutionary history of the MIR319 gene family across Brassicaceae remains unknown and requires investigation. We therefore identified homologous and homeologous segments of ca. 100 kb, with or without MIR319, performed comparative synteny analysis and genome fractionation studies. We detected variable rates of gene retention across members of Brassicaceae when genomic blocks of MIR319a, MIR319b, and MIR319c were compared either between themselves or against Arabidopsis thaliana genome which was taken as the base genome. The highest levels of shared genes were found between A. thaliana and Capsella rubella in both MIR319b- and MIR319c-containing genomic segments, and with the closest species of A. thaliana, A. lyrata, only in MIR319a-containing segment. Synteny analysis across 12 genomes (with 30 sub-genomes) revealed MIR319c to be the most conserved MIRNA loci (present in 27 genomes/sub-genomes) followed by MIR319a (present in 23 genomes/sub-genomes); MIR319b was found to be frequently lost (present in 20 genomes/sub-genomes) and thus is under least selection pressure for retention. Genome fractionation revealed extensive and differential loss of MIRNA homeologous loci and flanking genes from various sub-genomes of Brassica species that is in accordance with their older history of polyploidy when compared to Camelina sativa, a recent neopolyploid, where the effect of genome fractionation was least. Finally, estimation of phylogenetic relationship using precursor sequences of MIR319 reveals MIR319a and MIR319b form sister clades, with MIR319c forming a separate clade. An intra-species synteny analysis between MIR319a-, MIR319b-, and MIR319c-containing genomic segments suggests segmental duplications at the base of Brassicaceae to be responsible for the origin of MIR319a and MIR319b.

Improved Brassica rapa reference genome by single-molecule sequencing and chromosome conformation capture technologies

Brassica rapa comprises several important cultivated vegetables and oil crops. Current reference genome assemblies of Brassica rapa are quite fragmented and not highly contiguous, thereby limiting extensive genetic and genomic analyses. Here, we report an improved assembly of the B. rapa genome (v3.0) using single-molecule sequencing, optical mapping, and chromosome conformation capture technologies (Hi-C). Relative to the previous reference genomes, our assembly features a contig N50 size of 1.45 Mb, representing a ~30-fold improvement. We also identified a new event that occurred in the B. rapa genome ~1.2 million years ago, when a long terminal repeat retrotransposon (LTR-RT) expanded. Further analysis refined the relationship of genome blocks and accurately located the centromeres in the B. rapa genome. The B. rapa genome v3.0 will serve as an important community resource for future genetic and genomic studies in B. rapa. This resource will facilitate breeding efforts in B. rapa, as well as comparative genomic analysis with other Brassica species.

Highly preserved roles of Brassica MIR172 in polyploid Brassicas: ectopic expression of variants of Brassica MIR172 accelerates floral transition

Functional characterization of regulatory genes governing flowering time is a research priority for breeding earliness in crop Brassicas. Highly polyploid genomes of Brassicas pose challenges in unraveling homeolog gene function. In Arabidopsis, five MIR172 paralogs control flowering time and floral organ identity by down-regulating AP2 and AP2-like genes. The impact of homeolog diversification on MIR172 loci, however, needs to be examined in morphologically diverse Brassicas. Herein, we analyze fractionation status and phylogeny of MIR172 and target AP2 from Brassicas and compare functionality of MIR172 variants representing distinct sub-genomes and progenitor genomes. Copy number analysis revealed higher retention of MIR172 loci relative to AP2 in diploid and amphi-diploid Brassica species. Dendrogram of 87 MIR172 sequences from Brassicaceae showed five major clusters corresponding to MIR172a-MIR172e which further separated into sub-genome and progenitor genome specific clades. Similar groupings were observed in the phylogeny of 11 Brassica AP2 and AP2-like genes. Over-expression of a pair of natural variants for each of MIR172b, MIR172d and MIR172e representing sub-genomes, progenitor genomes and species of Brassicas displayed floral acceleration in all transgenic lines indicating a strong selection pressure on MIR172. All gain-of-function lines, except 35S::MIR172e and 35S::MIR172e' displayed floral organ defects implying altered target spectrum of MIR172e relative to MIR172b and MIR172d. Expression of MIR172e caused marginal earliness in flowering time in B. juncea. In conclusion, this study demonstrates tightly preserved role of homeologs and natural variants of MIR172 family in mediating flowering in Brassicas and suggests their deployment for introgression of early flowering trait.

Genome-wide identification, putative functionality and interactions between lncRNAs and miRNAs in Brassica species

Non-coding RNA (ncRNA) is abundant in plant genomes, but is poorly described with unknown functionality in most species. Using whole genome RNA sequencing, we identified 1885, 1910 and 1299 lncRNAs and 186, 157 and 161 miRNAs at the whole genome level in the three Brassica species B. napus, B. oleracea and B. rapa, respectively. The lncRNA sequences were divergent between the three Brassica species. One quarter of lncRNAs were located in tandem repeat (TR) region. The expression of both lncRNAs and miRNAs was strongly biased towards the A rather than the C subgenome in B. napus, unlike mRNA expression. miRNAs in genic regions had higher average expression than miRNAs in non-genic regions in B. napus and B. oleracea. We provide a comprehensive reference for the distribution, functionality and interactions of lncRNAs and miRNAs in Brassica.

misMM: An Integrated Pipeline for Misassembly Detection Using Genotyping-by-Sequencing and Its Validation with BAC End Library Sequences and Gene Synteny

As next-generation sequencing technologies have advanced, enormous amounts of whole-genome sequence information in various species have been released. However, it is still difficult to assemble the whole genome precisely, due to inherent limitations of short-read sequencing technologies. In particular, the complexities of plants are incomparable to those of microorganisms or animals because of whole-genome duplications, repeat insertions, and Numt insertions, etc. In this study, we describe a new method for detecting misassembly sequence regions of Brassica rapa with genotyping-by-sequencing, followed by MadMapper clustering. The misassembly candidate regions were cross-checked with BAC clone paired-ends library sequences that have been mapped to the reference genome. The results were further verified with gene synteny relations between Brassica rapa and Arabidopsis thaliana. We conclude that this method will help detect misassembly regions and be applicable to incompletely assembled reference genomes from a variety of species.

The evolution of microRNAs in plants

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are a central player in post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression and are involved in numerous biological processes in eukaryotes. Knowledge of the origins and divergence of miRNAs paves the way for a better understanding of the complexity of the regulatory networks that they participate in. The biogenesis, degradation, and regulatory activities of miRNAs are relatively better understood, but the evolutionary history of miRNAs still needs more exploration. Inverted duplication of target genes, random hairpin sequences and small transposable elements constitute three main models that explain the origination of miRNA genes (MIR). Both inter-species and intra-species divergence of miRNAs exhibits functional adaptation and adaptation to changing environments in evolution. Here we summarize recent progress in studies on the evolution of MIR and related genes.

The evolution of plant microRNAs: insights from a basal eudicot sacred lotus

microRNAs (miRNAs) are important noncoding small RNAs that regulate mRNAs in eukaryotes. However, under which circumstances different miRNAs/miRNA families exhibit different evolutionary trajectories in plants remains unclear. In this study, we sequenced the small RNAs and degradome from a basal eudicot, sacred lotus (Nelumbo nucifera or lotus), to identify miRNAs and their targets. Combining with public miRNAs, we predicted 57 pre-eudicot miRNA families from different evolutionary stages. We found that miRNA families featuring older age, higher copy and target number tend to show lower propensity for miRNA family loss (PGL) and stronger signature of purifying selection during divergence of temperate and tropical lotus. Further analyses of lotus genome revealed that there is an association between loss of miRNA families in descendent plants and in duplicated genomes. Gene dosage balance is crucial in maintaining those preferentially retained MIRNA duplicates by imposing stronger purifying selection. However, these factors and selection influencing miRNA family evolution are not applicable to the putative MIRNA-likes. Additionally, the MIRNAs participating in lotus pollen-pistil interaction, a conserved process in angiosperms, also have a strong signature of purifying selection. Functionally, sequence divergence in MIRNAs escalates expression divergence of their target genes between temperate and tropical lotus during rhizome and leaf growth. Overall, our study unravels several important factors and selection that determine the miRNA family distribution in plants and duplicated genomes, and provides evidence for functional impact of MIRNA sequence evolution.

Transcriptome Analysis of Leaves, Flowers and Fruits Perisperm of Coffea arabica L. Reveals the Differential Expression of Genes Involved in Raffinose Biosynthesis

Coffea arabica L. is an important crop in several developing countries. Despite its economic importance, minimal transcriptome data are available for fruit tissues, especially during fruit development where several compounds related to coffee quality are produced. To understand the molecular aspects related to coffee fruit and grain development, we report a large-scale transcriptome analysis of leaf, flower and perisperm fruit tissue development. Illumina sequencing yielded 41,881,572 high-quality filtered reads. De novo assembly generated 65,364 unigenes with an average length of 1,264 bp. A total of 24,548 unigenes were annotated as protein coding genes, including 12,560 full-length sequences. In the annotation process, we identified nine candidate genes related to the biosynthesis of raffinose family oligossacarides (RFOs). These sugars confer osmoprotection and are accumulated during initial fruit development. Four genes from this pathway had their transcriptional pattern validated by quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR). Furthermore, we identified ~24,000 putative target sites for microRNAs (miRNAs) and 134 putative transcriptionally active transposable elements (TE) sequences in our dataset. This C. arabica transcriptomic atlas provides an important step for identifying candidate genes related to several coffee metabolic pathways, especially those related to fruit chemical composition and therefore beverage quality. Our results are the starting point for enhancing our knowledge about the coffee genes that are transcribed during the flowering and initial fruit development stages.