Adaptive mutation and slow-growing revertants of an Escherichia coli lacZ amber mutant

The transcription elongation factor NusA is required for stress-induced mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Stress-induced mutagenesis describes the accumulation of mutations that occur in nongrowing cells, in contrast to mutagenesis that occurs in actively dividing populations, and has been referred to as stationary-phase or adaptive mutagenesis. The most widely studied system for stress-induced mutagenesis involves monitoring the appearance of Lac(+) revertants of the strain FC40 under starvation conditions in Escherichia coli. The SOS-inducible translesion DNA polymerase DinB plays an important role in this phenomenon. Loss of DinB (DNA pol IV) function results in a severe reduction of Lac(+) revertants. We previously reported that NusA, an essential component of elongating RNA polymerases, interacts with DinB. Here we report our unexpected observation that wild-type NusA function is required for stress-induced mutagenesis. We present evidence that this effect is unlikely to be due to defects in transcription of lac genes but rather is due to an inability to adapt and mutate in response to environmental stress. Furthermore, we extended our analysis to the formation of stress-induced mutants in response to antibiotic treatment, observing the same striking abolition of mutagenesis under entirely different conditions. Our results are the first to implicate NusA as a crucial participant in the phenomenon of stress-induced mutagenesis.

Adaptive mutations in Salmonella typhimurium phenotypic of purR super-repression

Under non-lethal selective conditions, a non-dividing or very slowly dividing microbial population gives rise to mutations that relieve selective pressures. This process is described as adaptive mutation. Salmonella typhimurium strain 5-28 has been used as a system for studying adaptive mutations in the chromosomal regulatory gene purR and its target, the purD operator. When this strain is plated on a minimal lactose medium, no apparent growth of parent lawn is observed, yet the revertant colonies accumulate over a period of time. Analysis of the purR mutational spectra showed that the frequencies of transitions and transversions were not significantly different among the growth-dependent and adaptive mutations. But the frequencies for five kinds of -1 frameshifts were significantly different between the growth-dependent and adaptive types. Among the growth-dependent mutations, most one-base deletions occurred in non-iterated bases and were distributed randomly. Among adaptive mutations, the frequency of one-base deletions in small mononucleotide repeats was higher and mutations were concentrated at three hotspots. One-base deletion in small mononucleotide repeats are generally believed to result from DNA polymerase slippage errors, which are not corrected by DNA repair machinery. We further investigated the role of DNA repair on adaptive mutation. Our results showed that the mismatch repair (MMR) might function less efficiently during adaptive mutation. However, DNA oxidative damage repair seemed no less effective in correcting errors under selective pressures than during non-selective growth.

Stress responses and genetic variation in bacteria

Under stressful conditions mechanisms that increase genetic variation can bestow a selective advantage. Bacteria have several stress responses that provide ways in which mutation rates can be increased. These include the SOS response, the general stress response, the heat-shock response, and the stringent response, all of which impact the regulation of error-prone polymerases. Adaptive mutation appears to be process by which cells can respond to selective pressure specifically by producing mutations. In Escherichia coli strain FC40 adaptive mutation involves the following inducible components: (i) a recombination pathway that generates mutations; (ii) a DNA polymerase that synthesizes error-containing DNA; and (iii) stress responses that regulate cellular processes. In addition, a subpopulation of cells enters into a state of hypermutation, giving rise to about 10% of the single mutants and virtually all of the mutants with multiple mutations. These bacterial responses have implications for the development of cancer and other genetic disorders in higher organisms.

Adaptive changes in bacteria: a consequence of nonlinear transitions in chromosome topology?

Adaptive changes in bacteria are generally considered to result from random mutations selected by the environment. This interpretation is challenged by the non-randomness of genomic changes observed following ageing or starvation in bacterial colonies. A theory of adaptive targeting of sequences for enzymes involved in DNA transactions is proposed here. It is assumed that the sudden leakage of cAMP consecutive to starvation induces a rapid drop in the ATP/ADP ratio that inactivates the homeostasis in control of the level of DNA supercoiling. This phase change enables the emergence of local modifications in chromosome topology in relation to the missing metabolites, a first stage in expression of an adaptive status in which DNA transactions are induced. The nonlinear perspective proposed here is homologous to that already suggested for adaptation of pluricellular organisms during their development. In both cases, phases of robustness in regulation networks for genetic expression are interspaced by critical periods of breakdown of the homeostatic regulations during which, through isolation of nodes from a whole network, specific changes with adaptive value may locally occur.

Adaptive, or stationary-phase, mutagenesis, a component of bacterial differentiation in Bacillus subtilis

Adaptive (stationary-phase) mutagenesis occurs in the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis. Furthermore, taking advantage of B. subtilis as a paradigm for the study of prokaryotic differentiation and development, we have shown that this type of mutagenesis is subject to regulation involving at least two of the genes that are involved in the regulation of post-exponential phase prokaryotic differentiation, i.e., comA and comK. On the other hand, a functional RecA protein was not required for this type of mutagenesis. The results seem to suggest that a small subpopulation(s) of the culture is involved in adaptive mutagenesis and that this subpopulation(s) is hypermutable. The existence of such a hypermutable subpopulation(s) raises important considerations with respect to evolution, the development of specific mutations, the nature of bacterial populations, and the level of communication among bacteria in an ecological niche.

Evolving responsively: adaptive mutation

A basic principle of genetics is that the likelihood that a particular mutation occurs is independent of its phenotypic consequences. The concept of adaptive mutation seemed to challenge this principle with the discoveries of mutations stimulated by stress, some of which allow adaptation to the stress. The emerging mechanisms of adaptive genetic change cast evolution, development and heredity into a new perspective, indicating new models for the genetic changes that fuel these processes.

Effect of drug concentration on emergence of macrolide resistance in Mycobacterium avium

The emergence of antibiotic resistance in mycobacteria involves the selection of mutant variants within a susceptible bacterial population. However, it is unclear whether antimycobacterial drugs act just as selective agents or can influence the rate of appearance of resistant mutants. The present study was initiated to address this issue by monitoring the effects of antimicrobial agents on the appearance and growth of clarithromycin (CLR)-resistant (CLR(r)) bacilli in broth cultures of Mycobacterium avium. Preexposure of M. avium to CLR had a significant dose effect on the emergence of resistance, with concentrations of 4 to 8 microg/ml resulting in a maximal (approximately 10(4)-fold) increase in the number of CLR(r) bacilli after a 4-day incubation. In addition, a dose effect was found with azithromycin. The use of combinations of CLR with either ethambutol (EMB) or rifabutin (RFB) resulted in fewer resistant bacilli compared to the use of CLR alone. The lowest active concentration of EMB (4 microg/ml) was equivalent to the EMB MIC (4 to 8 microg/ml) for the parental CLR(s) strain and the emergent CLR(r) variants, and thus, the antiresistance effect was probably the result of the bacteriostatic effect of EMB on CLR(r) bacilli. However, RFB was an order of magnitude more active (0.05 microg/ml) at reducing resistance than suggested by the MIC of this agent (0.5 to 1 microg/ml). These results indicate that the emergence of resistance was not simply the selection of a preexisting subpopulation of resistant bacilli. Further analysis suggested that early events in the emergence of resistance involved organisms (progenitors) that acquired a resistance phenotype. In addition, the progenitors appeared to be in a transient state, able to develop into a stable resistant lineage in the presence of CLR, or able to revert to the wild type in nonselective conditions.

Hypermutation in bacteria and other cellular systems

A temporary state of hypermutation can in principle arise through an increase in the rate of polymerase errors (which may or may not be triggered by template damage) and/or through abrogation of fidelity mechanisms such as proofreading and mismatch correction. In bacteria there are numerous examples of transient mutator states, often occurring as a consequence of stress. They may be targeted to certain regions of the DNA, for example by transcription or by recombination. The initial errors are made by various DNA polymerases which vary in their error-proneness: several are inducible and are under the control of the SOS system. There are several structurally related polymerases in mammals that have recently come to light and that have unusual properties, such as the ability to carry out 'accurate' translesion synthesis opposite sites of template damage or the possession of exceedingly high misincorporation rates. In bacteria the initial errors may be genuinely spontaneous polymerase errors or they may be triggered by damage to the template strand, for example as a result of attack by active oxidative species such as singlet oxygen. In mammalian cells, hypermutable states persisting for many generations have been shown to be induced by various agents, not all of them DNA damaging agents. A hypermutable state induced by ionizing radiation in male germ cells in the mouse results in a high rate of sequence errors in certain unstable minisatellite loci; the mechanism is unclear but believed to be associated with recombination events.

Adaptive amplification: an inducible chromosomal instability mechanism

Adaptive mutation is an induced response to environmental stress in which mutation rates rise, producing permanent genetic changes that can adapt cells to stress. This contrasts with neo-Darwinian views of genetic change rates blind to environmental conditions. DNA amplification is a flexible, reversible genomic change that has long been postulated to be adaptive. We report the discovery of adaptive amplification at the lac operon in Escherichia coli. Additionally, we find that adaptive amplification is separate from, and does not lead to, adaptive point mutation. This contradicts a prevailing alternative hypothesis whereby adaptive mutation is normal mutability in amplified DNA. Instead, adaptive mutation and amplification are parallel routes of inducible genetic instability allowing rapid evolution under stress, and escape from growth inhibition.

A quantum mechanical model of adaptive mutation

The principle that mutations occur randomly with respect to the direction of evolutionary change has been challenged by the phenomenon of adaptive mutations. There is currently no entirely satisfactory theory to account for how a cell can selectively mutate certain genes in response to environmental signals. However, spontaneous mutations are initiated by quantum events such as the shift of a single proton (hydrogen atom) from one site to an adjacent one. We consider here the wave function describing the quantum state of the genome as being in a coherent linear superposition of states describing both the shifted and unshifted protons. Quantum coherence will be destroyed by the process of decoherence in which the quantum state of the genome becomes correlated (entangled) with its surroundings. Using a very simple model we estimate the decoherence times for protons within DNA and demonstrate that quantum coherence may be maintained for biological time-scales. Interaction of the coherent genome wave function with environments containing utilisable substrate will induce rapid decoherence and thereby destroy the superposition of mutant and non-mutant states. We show that this accelerated rate of decoherence may significantly increase the rate of production of the mutated state.

Mechanisms of stationary phase mutation: a decade of adaptive mutation

A decade of research on adaptive mutation has revealed a plethora of mutagenic mechanisms that may be important in evolution. The DNA synthesis associated with recombination could be an important source of spontaneous mutation in cells that are not proliferating. The movement of insertion elements can be responsive to environmental conditions. Insertion elements not only activate and inactivate genes, they also provide sequence homology that allows large-scale genomic rearrangements. Some conjugative plasmids can recombine with their host's chromosome, and may acquire chromosomal genes that could then spread through the population and even to other species. Finally, a subpopulation of transient hypermutators could be a source of multiple variant alleles, providing a mechanism for rapid evolution under adverse conditions.

Reversion of the tyrosine ochre strain Escherichia coli WU3610 under starvation conditions depends on a new gene tas

When 3 x 10(8) bacteria of the Escherichia coli tyrA14(oc) leu308(am) strain WU3610 are plated on glucose salts agar supplemented with leucine only, colonies of slow-growing Tyr+ suppressor mutants begin to appear after about a week and increase in numbers roughly linearly with time thereafter (stationary phase or starvation-associated mutation). From a library constructed from two of these mutants, a clone was obtained that suppressed the tyrosine requirement of WU3610 when present on a multicopy plasmid. The activity was identified to an open reading frame we call tas, the sequence for which has homology with a variety of known genes with aldo-keto reductase activity. The activity of tas complements the prephenate dehydrogenase dysfunction of tyrA14 (the chorismate mutase activity of tyrA possibly being still functional). A strain deleted for tas showed no spontaneous mutation under starvation conditions. Whereas neither tas+ nor tas bacteria showed any increase in viable or total count when plated under conditions of tyrosine starvation at 3 x 10(8) cells per plate, at lower density (approximately 10(7) per plate) tas+ but not tas bacteria showed considerable residual growth. We suggest that the single copy of tas present in WU3610 allows cryptic cell or DNA turnover under conditions of tyrosine starvation and that this is an essential prerequisite for starvation-associated mutation in this system. The target gene for mutation is not tas, although an increase in the expression of this gene, for example, resulting from a suppressor mutation affecting supercoiling, could be responsible for the slow-growing Tyr+ phenotype.

Mutation for survival

Adaptive mutations appear in response to selection. In the best-studied system, the two most controversial issues were resolved this year. The mutations are neither Lamarckian nor a peculiarity of bacterial sex, as had been suggested. They occur genome-wide in a hypermutable subpopulation of stressed cells. Genomic 'hot' and 'cold' regions may explain previous failures to detect similar mutations in other systems and at other sites. Stationary phase specific limitation of mismatch repair has also been discovered.

A genetic strategy to demonstrate the occurrence of spontaneous mutations in nondividing cells within colonies of Escherichia coli

A genetic strategy was designed to examine the occurrence of mutations in stationary-phase populations. In this strategy, a parental population of cells is able to survive under both permissive and restrictive conditions whereas mutants at a particular target locus exhibit a conditional-lethal phenotype. Thus, by growing the population to stationary phase under restrictive conditions and then shifting it to permissive conditions, mutations that had arisen in stationary phase can be studied without confounding effects caused by the occurrence of similar mutations during growth of the population. In two different applications of this strategy, we have studied the reversion to Lac+ in stationary phase of several Lac- mutations in Escherichia coli. Our results indicate that a variety of spontaneous point mutations and deletions, particularly those that are sensitive to the mechanisms of replication slippage (for their generation) and methyl-directed mismatch repair (for their correction), can arise in nondividing populations of cells within a colony. The frequency of their occurrence was also elevated in mutS strains, which are defective in such mismatch repair. These data have relevance to the ongoing debate on adaptive or directed mutations in bacteria.