Comparison of different methods for the investigation of antisperm antibodies on spermatozoa, in seminal plasma and in serum

Male fertility during and after immune checkpoint inhibitor therapy: A cross-sectional pilot study

BACKGROUND

Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) are widely used and may induce long-term survival in various types of cancer. Yet, there is scarce evidence on potential effects on patient fertility and the necessity of cryopreservation before treatment onset. The aim of our study was to assess the prevalence of male infertility after initiation of ICI treatment.

METHODS

This is a monocenter, cross-sectional pilot study. Fertility was investigated by spermiogram, analysis of sexual hormones and questionnaires on sexual function and sexual activity. Male patients under the age of 60 years previously or currently treated with ICI for cutaneous malignancies or uveal melanoma were included.

RESULTS

Twenty-five patients were included, with a median age of 49 years. Eighteen of 22 (82%) available spermiograms showed no pathologies, all patients reported a normal sexual function and sexual activity. Of four patients with pathological spermiogram, three patients were diagnosed with azoospermia and one with oligoasthenoteratozoospermia. Three patients had significant confounding factors (previous inguinal radiotherapy, chemotherapy and chronic alcohol abuse, and bacterial orchitis). One patient with normal spermiogram before ICI treatment presented 1 year after initiation with azoospermia, showing an asymptomatic, inflammatory infiltrate with predominantly neutrophil granulocytes, macrophages and T-lymphocytes in the ejaculate. Infectious causes were ruled out; andrological examination was unremarkable. A second case with reduced sperm counts during treatment may be ICI-induced also.

CONCLUSIONS

Most patients had no restrictions in fertility, yet an inflammatory loss of spermatogenesis seems possible. Cryopreservation should be discussed with all patients with potential future desire for children before treatment.

Dominant Prostasome Immunogens for Sperm-Agglutinating Autoantibodies of Infertile Men

The presence of naturally occurring anti-sperm antibodies (ASA) is a well-known cause of infertility in men and women, but the antigens for these antibodies are poorly characterized. We have previously shown that prostasomes adhere to sperm cells and that prostasomes are major targets for ASA associated with infertility. These autoantigens have not been characterized. We used 2-dimensional electrophoresis, immunoblotting, and mass-spectrometry to identify the prostasome antigens for these autoantibodies. By these techniques, we revealed that prolactin-inducible protein (PIP) and clusterin were dominant prostasome immunogens for sperm-agglutinating autoantibodies of 20 patients with immunological infertility. PIP was identified by 19 of 20 (95%) patient sera and clusterin by 17 of 20 (85%). In addition, 10 sporadically occurring prostasomal antigens were identified in this context, viz alcohol dehydrogenase [NADP+], annexin I, annexin III, BRCA1-associated ring domain protein 1, heat shock 27-kd protein, isocitrate dehydrogenase, lactoylglutathione lyase, NG,NG-dimethylarginine dimethylaminohydrolase 1, peroxiredoxin 2, and syntenin 1.

Prostasome antigens as targets for sperm agglutinating antibodies demonstrated by 1-D gel electrophoresis and immunoblottings

Many immunoinfertile men have sperm agglutinating antibodies that are directed against prostasome-derived antigens, but these antigens have not been defined so far. We selected serum samples with high ELISA titres against prostasomes from a group of immunoinfertile patients with sperm agglutinating antibodies and used the sera for immunoblottings on 1-D SDS-PAGE of prostasomes and sperm cells. The immunoblottings with individual antiprostasome antisera on 1-D SDS-PAGE of prostasomes, revealed three to 10 bands for each serum. Eighty-five per cent of the serum samples contained bands in the 70-75 kDa region and 80% of the samples contained bands in the 50-55 kDa region. Immunoblottings of extracted sperm cells, revealed one to six bands in the molecular weight range 25-82 kDa and two of the samples recognized two bands with molecular weights (50 and 43 kDa) similar to immunoblottings of prostasomes. The prostasomal antigens recognized by the high titre-antisera of immunoinfertile men were generally different from the sperm antigens recognized by the same sera. This suggests that prostasomes offer a new set of antigens available for research on male immunoinfertility and immunocontraception.

A new test for immunological infertility: an ELISA based on prostasomes

Antisperm antibodies (ASA) are present in patients with immunological infertility, but the antigens are poorly characterized. Prostasomes adhere to sperm cells and are recognized as antigens for ASA. This investigation aimed to study the prevalence of antiprostasome antibodies in ASA-classified sera. We studied the reactivity of ASA-positive sera from 116 immunoinfertile patients. Ninety-seven per cent (113 of 116) of the patients' sera contained IgG antibodies against seminal prostasomes. Accordingly, prostasomes are one of the major targets for ASA. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay based on prostasomes is simpler to perform than ASA tests presently in use. It is also easier to achieve reproducible and standardized results.

Basis, diagnosis and treatment of immunological infertility in men

Sperm-reactive antibodies (SpAb) are found attached to sperm, or present in serum or seminal fluid, in approximately 6% of men presenting with infertility. Data supports their pathophysiological role in some cases by the interference with sperm motility and/or sperm-egg interaction. The occurrence of SpAbs may follow disruption of either the cellular barrier separating sperm antigens from the immune system (e.g. testis trauma or obstruction to sperm outflow), or to dysregulation of normal immunosuppressive activities within the male reproductive tract. The epididymis is likely to be the key site of antibody generation, especially in the setting of obstruction. Detection methods are all based on the detection of Ig isotypes rather than specific antibody-antigen interactions, which limits their usefulness. Treatment options in the past (immunosuppression, intrauterine insemination, conventional in vitro fertilization) have been superceded by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) which appears to circumvent all adverse effects of male SpAbs.

Seminal antibodies to human 60kd heat shock protein (HSP 60) in male partners of subfertile couples

BACKGROUND

Heat shock proteins (HSP) are essential mammalian and bacterial stress proteins. At the cellular level, they act as chaperones, have important regulatory functions, and are considered to be an essential factor for reproduction. Scarce information exists on the role of sensitization to HSP and the potential role in the aetiology of male infertility.

METHODS

The potential association of immunoglobulin (Ig)A antibodies (Ab) to the human 60 kDa heat shock protein (HSP 60) with several parameters of subclinical male genital tract infection/inflammation and with semen quality and sperm fertilizing capacity was analysed in a prospective study. IgA Ab to human HSP 60 were determined in seminal plasma of 202 randomly chosen male partners of subfertile couples with a median duration of infertility of 4 years (range 1-15 years), who were asymptomatic for genital tract infection. After medical history and clinical examination, a comprehensive evaluation of semen quality, in aliquots of the same ejaculates used for HSP Ab determination, included: sperm analysis; local antisperm antibody (ASA) screening; standardized sperm-cervical mucus (CM) penetration testing; immunocytochemical round cell differentiation to determine seminal leukocyte counts; evaluation of complement fraction C(3) and of some pro-inflammatory cytokines; and microbial screening. Subsequent fertility was recorded after 6 months.

RESULTS

The presence of HSP 60 IgA Ab in seminal fluid (total positive 6.9%) was significantly associated with leukocytospermia, the presence of C(3), and also with high interleukin (IL) levels in seminal plasma. HSP 60 Ab were not related to the bacterial colonization of ejaculates. There was no association of seminal IgA Ab to human HSP 60 with semen quality, determined with microscopical semen analysis, nor with local IgG- or IgA-class ASA. There was no relationship with sperm intrinsic motility and duration of motility in the sperm CM-penetration test, nor with sperm fertilizing capacity.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined presence of IgA Ab to human 60 kDa HSP, leukocytes and other established infection/inflammation markers in semen might suggest a potential role of the immune response to heat shock proteins (HSP) in cases of silent male genital tract infection, but the results do not indicate a marked relationship of HSP 60 Ab in seminal fluid with standard parameters of semen quality.

Antisperm antibodies associated with infertility: properties and encoding genes of target antigens

Infertility among couples of reproductive age is a perplexing condition when the cause is indeterminate. These cases are classified as unexplained infertility. In a subset of subjects, antisperm antibodies with sperm agglutinating and/or immobilizing activities have been detected in the blood or fluids of the reproductive tract. These cases are designated as immunologic infertility although a cause and effect relationship of the antibodies to infertility has not been established. In this review, seven target sperm antigens to antibodies associated with infertility and their encoding genes are described. The antisperm antibodies (ASAs) examined were obtained from infertile women or were monoclonal antibodies (mAb) raised against human sperm proteins. All the ASAs studied possessed potent sperm agglutinating and/or immobilizing activities. The target antigens were isolated from human and other mammalian sperm, and the encoding genes identified. The seven antigens are YWK-II, BE-20, rSMP-B, BS-63 (nucleoporin-related), BS-17 (calpastatin), HED-2 (zyxin), and 75- kDa. Each antigen is a distinct and separate entity and is produced by different cells of the reproductive tract, (e.g., germ cells, epididymal epithelial cells, and Sertoli cells). No single predominant target component has been found to interact with the ASAs. It is proposed that immunologic infertility is the consequence of the combined actions of multiple ASAs in immobilizing and/or agglutinating spermatozoa, blocking spermegg interaction, preventing implantation, and/or arresting embryo development.

Antisperm antibodies: etiology, pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment

OBJECTIVE

To critically review the English-language literature and describe the current diagnosis, prevalence, etiology, and treatment of antisperm antibodies (ASA).

DESIGN

A comprehensive literature search of the English-language literature published between 1966 and December 1997 was performed on MEDLINE. Articles were also located via bibliographies of published works.

RESULT(S)

Data were excerpted from articles identified by MEDLINE search. The diagnosis, prevalence, etiology, and treatment of ASA are described.

CONCLUSION(S)

There is sufficient evidence that ASA impair fertility in couples with unexplained infertility. A number of different methodologies are available, which may be used in their detection. However, in many cases, test interpretation is subjective. Although there is not enough evidence to support systemic treatment for ASA, application of a variety of assisted reproductive technologies improves outcome.

The clinical and biologic significance of serum inhibins in subfertile men

Inhibin B is a marker of spermatogenesis and Sertoli cell function. The objective of this study was to evaluate the biologic significance of inhibins in subfertile men and the usefulness of inhibin B for the detection of male reproductive dysfunction. Forty-seven subfertile men were evaluated by semen analysis and clinical examination. In addition to semen analysis and hormone determinations, inhibins A and B (Serotec) in all 47 and inhibin A in 25 of these samples using another kit (Biosource) were measured. Higher inhibin B (median, range: 160.3, 81.8-328.5 pg/mL vs. 94.9, 15.6-389.7 pg/mL, P = 0.024) and lower FSH (P = 0.001) were detected in men with sperm concentrations > or =20 million/mL (n = 9), compared to oligozoospermia (sperm concentration <20 million/mL, n = 38). Inhibin B correlated significantly negatively with FSH, LH, and E2, and patient's age and positively with sperm concentration, testicular volume, and TSH. Multiple regression analysis indicated FSH, LH, E2, TSH, and age as the independent variables for inhibin B with a coefficient of determination (R) of 0.53. Simultaneous measurement of both FSH and inhibin B identified more cases with oligozoospermia than either hormone alone. Taking into account the body mass index, the age of the patient, and the indirect mixed antiglobin reaction (MAR) test result in addition to FSH and inhibin B led to the correct semen classification in 45 out of 47 cases. The simultaneous measurement of FSH and inhibin B, taking into account age, body mass index, and the indirect MAR test result appears accurate in identifying subfertility. Inhibin A is detectable in some subfertile men but its significance is not clear.

Antisperm antibodies and microorganisms in genital secretions--a clinically significant relationship?

In asymptomatic infertility patients, no significant relationship was found between the presence of antisperm antibodies (ASA) in serum and in semen samples (IgG and/or IgA ASA), differentiated with the mixed antiglobulin reaction (MAR), and the microbial colonization of ejaculates covering a broad spectrum of microorganisms. Likewise, there was no significant association of ASA with microbial findings in patients' female partners, who also presented without symptoms of genital tract infection and were screened at the same time. Furthermore, ASA in semen (IgG and IgA) were not significantly related to several potential markers of subclinical male sexual gland infection or inflammation (leukocytes, PMN elastase, albumin, C3c) evaluated in aliquots of the same ejaculates used for immunological testing.

Clinical and biological aspects of male immune infertility: a case-controlled study of 86 cases

A case-control study of clinical, endocrine and seminal characteristics in 86 infertile men and a prospective study of conception rates during 804 follow-up cycles among 75 infertile couples with male immune infertility were performed. Genito-urethral infections or surgery, and palpable epididymal abnormalities were more common among the immunological cases than among the non-immunological infertile controls (n = 180), but sperm concentration, motility and morphology were similar. The spontaneous conception rate in 70 cases was 1.7% per cycle. Treatment by intra-uterine insemination (IUI) resulted in 8.6% pregnancies per cycle, conventional in vitro fertilization (IVF) had a 18.4% success rate per attempt, and two out of three couples treated by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) attained pregnancy. Minimal sperm quality required for successful IUI was not lower than that recorded in couples with spontaneous conception. It is concluded that immunological infertility, as diagnosed by a positive mixed antiglobulin reaction (MAR) test, is associated with a low spontaneous conception rate. Techniques of assisted reproduction are useful in the management of couples with infertility resulting from this pathology, but sperm characteristics required for successful IUI are much higher than those needed for successful IVF. A strategy for the logical management of this pathology is proposed.

Conception rates and assisted reproduction in subfertility due to unilateral cryptorchidism

During 774 spontaneous cycles and 87 cycles of assisted reproduction, the conception rates were evaluated in 48 infertile couples in whom unilateral cryptorchidism was the causal factor. In spite of adjuvant therapy of the male partner, the spontaneous conception rate was very low (1% per cycle). Intra-uterine insemination (IUI) and conventional in vitro fertilization (IVF) resulted in similar success rates of 6.1 and 8.7% per cycle/attempt respectively. After intra-cyto-plasmic sperm injection (ICSI), 46.7% pregnancies were obtained per attempt, and sperm requirements for the latter treatment to be successful were lower than for IUI. It is concluded that subfertility in men with unilateral cryptorchidism is severe, conventional IVF has little advantage, but ICSI is highly successful.

Seminal fluid antisperm antibodies measured by direct flow cytometry do not correlate with those measured by indirect flow cytometry, the indirect immunobead test, and the indirect mixed antiglobulin reaction

OBJECTIVE

To compare the direct flow cytometric (FCM) measurement of sperm-bound antibodies with the indirect FCM measurement of unbound antisperm antibodies in seminal plasma of the same ejaculates. To compare the FCM measurements with the indirect mixed antiglobulin reaction (MAR) and the indirect immunobead test (IBT) performed on the same seminal plasmas.

SETTING

University hospital-based infertility service.

PATIENTS

Eleven infertile men with a positive immunoglobulin (Ig) G direct MAR test and antibody positivity on the direct FCM measurements. Four control patients with a negative IgG-direct MAR test.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The proportion of spermatozoa positive for IgG and IgA antibodies as measured by various tests.

RESULTS

The direct and indirect FCM measurements for sperm-bound antibodies from seminal plasma did not correlate with each other. In general, IgG antibodies were not detectable by indirect FCM whereas IgA were detected in lower proportions than by direct FCM measurements. Weak correlation was observed between the indirect FCM, indirect MAR, and indirect IBT measurements.

CONCLUSION

Nearly all of the IgG and some of the IgA antisperm antibodies in seminal fluid bind to spermatozoa. Thus, indirect tests to measure antisperm antibodies from seminal plasma are likely to miss the presence of antisperm IgG antibodies while detecting some cases of IgA antibodies.

Study of antisperm antibodies bound to the sperm cell surface and their relationship to circulating ASA

PROBLEM

Direct and indirect tests for antisperm antibody (ASA) detection are commonly used in laboratories for the diagnosis of male immunological infertility. Even though the two kinds of tests study the same immunological phenomena, frequently no perfect correlation is found even on large series of patients and with precise statistical models. The aim of the present investigation was to try to establish whether biological models can explain the antibody test results and if a predictive threshold can be established for expected positivity/negativity.

METHOD

The data relate to 667 patients, who were screened using the Direct Immunobead test (d-IBT) for ASA bound to the sperm surface and with the gelatin and tray agglutination test (GAT and TAT) in sera for circulating ASA. Correlation were studied and cases of no correlation were further analyzed.

RESULTS

The number of patients with a clinically significant positivity to d-IBT (binding percentage > or = 20%) was 134 (20.1% of total patients). The analysis of the results of direct and indirect tests shows that the discordances are due to differences in the Ig class of immunization or to the site of epitopes involved. In fact, as far the Ig class is concerned, if d-IBT shows a prevalent or exclusive IgG or IgA positivity, this results in a poor correlation between binding percentage to d-IBT and GAT-TAT titers. If both the Ig classes are involved, the level of positivity of the two kinds of test are strictly related. As far as the site of Ag-Ab reaction on the sperm surface is concerned, the wide immunization involving all the surface sperm antigens (mixed), shown by d-IBT, is related to higher indirect test titers.

CONCLUSION

Local and systemic antisperm immunizations are strictly related and a predictive threshold of expectation can be established to explain even apparently discordant direct and indirect results.