Factors affecting the efficiency of embryo cryopreservation and rederivation of rat and mouse models

Cryopreservation of Mouse Sperm for Genome Banking

Germplasm cryobanking of transgenic rodent models is a valuable tool for protecting important genotypes from genetic drift, genetic contamination, and loss of breeding colonies due to disease or catastrophic disasters to the housing facilities as well as avoiding stress associated with domestic and international live animal shipment. Furthermore, cryopreservation of germplasm enhances management efficiencies by saving animal room space, reducing workload for staff, reducing cost of maintaining live animals, reducing the number of animals used to maintain a breeding colony, and facilitating transportation of genetics by allowing distribution of frozen germplasm rather than live animals which also reduces the risk of transfer of pathogens between facilities. Thus, effective long-term preservation methods of mouse spermatozoa are critical for future reconstitution of scientifically important mouse strains used for biomedical research.

Successful re-establishment of a rabbit population from embryos vitrified 15 years ago: The importance of biobanks in livestock conservation

Genetic resource banks (GRB) are a valuable tool for maintaining genetic variability and preserving breeds from pathogens or catastrophe, enabling us to assess and correct breeding schemes, minimizing the impact of genetic drift and facilitating diffusion. This study tests their efficiency in re-establishing two extinct populations of a synthetic rabbit line selected for daily weight gain, using vitrified embryos from two generations (18th and 36th) separated by 15 years of genetic selection. The effect of long-term storage of vitrified embryos in liquid nitrogen was also evaluated. A total of 516 vitrified embryos using the same protocol were transferred into 54 recipients. The embryos had been maintained in liquid nitrogen during 2 different periods, (i) 1 year (301 embryos and 26 transfers, 36th generation) and (ii) 15 years (259 embryos and 28 transfers, 18th generation). A total of 80.0% (8/10 to 18th) and 60.0% (9/15 to 36th) of the foundational sire families were eventually re-established. Over approximately one year, animals within each population were crossed to produce the next generation and re-establish the original population size. Our study demonstrated that our GRB of embryos vitrified 15 years ago is a successful strategy to re-establish rabbit populations to continue the breeding programme.

Embryo vitrification in rabbits: Consequences for progeny growth

The objective of this research is to examine if there are any effects of the rederivation procedures on rabbit growth pattern and on weight of different organ in adults. For this purpose, three experiments were conducted on two different groups of animals (control group and vitrified-transferred group) to evaluate the possible effect of embryo manipulation (vitrification and transfer procedures) on future growth traits. The first experiment studies body weight from 1 to 9 weeks of age from the two groups. The second experiment describes the growth curve of progeny from experimental groups and analyzes their Gompertz curve parameters, including the estimation of adult body weight. The third experiment has been developed to study if there are any differences in different organ weight in adult males from the two experimental groups. In general, the results indicate that rederivation procedures had effect on the phenotypic expression of growth traits. The results showed that rabbit produced by vitrification and embryo transfer had higher body weight in the first four weeks of age than control progeny. Results from body weight (a parameter) and b parameter estimated by fitting the Gompertz growth curve did not show any difference between experimental groups. However, differences related with growth velocity (k parameter of the Gompertz curve) were observed among them, showing that the control group had higher growth velocity than the vitrified-transferred group. In addition, we found that liver weight at 40th week of age exhibits significant differences between the experimental groups. The liver weight was higher in the control males than in the VF males. Although the present results indicate that vitrification and transfer procedures might affect some traits related with growth in rabbits, further research is needed to assess the mechanisms involved in the appearance of these phenotypes and if these phenotypes could be transferred to the future progeny.

Ultrastructure of vitrified rabbit transgenic embryos

The aim of the study was to determine the viability of rabbit transgenic (enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-positive) embryos cultured in vitro and compare with gene-microinjected (Mi) non-transgenic (EGFP-negative) embryos following vitrification. Non-microinjected and non-vitrified embryos were used as the control. Morphological signs of injury to embryo organelles were determined at the ultrastructural level using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Morphometric evaluation was performed on cellular organelles using microphotographs obtained by TEM. Intact and Mi embryos recovered from in vivo fertilized eggs at 19-20 hours post coitum (hpc) were cultured for up to 72 hpc (morula stage), evaluated for the EGFP gene integration and then vitrified in 0.25 ml insemination straws in modified EFS (40% ethylene glycol + 18% Ficoll 70 + 0.3 M sucrose) vitrification solution. After 1-3 days the embryos were devitrified, a representative selection of embryos was analyzed by TEM and the remaining embryos were subjected to additional in vitro culture. Observations by TEM showed that the vitrified/warmed EGFP-positive and EGFP-negative embryos had a slight accumulation of cellular debris and lipid droplets compared with the control intact embryos. More severe changes were detected in the membrane structures of the treated embryos, mostly in the cytoplasmic envelope, trophoblastic microvilli, junctional contacts and mitochondria. We suggest that the higher proportion of deteriorated cell structures and organelles in the treated embryos may be due to the vitrification process rather than to mechanical violation (the gene-microinjection procedure), as a detailed inspection of ultrastructure revealed that most damage occurred in the cell membrane structures.

Genome resource banking of biomedically important laboratory animals

Genome resource banking is the systematic collection, storage, and redistribution of biomaterials in an organized, logistical, and secure manner. Genome cryobanks usually contain biomaterials and associated genomic information essential for progression of biomedicine, human health, and research. In that regard, appropriate genome cryobanks could provide essential biomaterials for both current and future research projects in the form of various cell types and tissues, including sperm, oocytes, embryos, embryonic or adult stem cells, induced pluripotent stem cells, and gonadal tissues. In addition to cryobanked germplasm, cryobanking of DNA, serum, blood products, and tissues from scientifically, economically, and ecologically important species has become a common practice. For revitalization of the whole organism, cryopreserved germplasm in conjunction with assisted reproductive technologies, offer a powerful approach for research model management, as well as assisting in animal production for agriculture, conservation, and human reproductive medicine. Recently, many developed and developing countries have allocated substantial resources to establish genome resources banks which are responsible for safeguarding scientifically, economically, and ecologically important wild type, mutant, and transgenic plants, fish, and local livestock breeds, as well as wildlife species. This review is dedicated to the memory of Dr. John K. Critser, who has made profound contributions to the science of cryobiology and establishment of genome research and resources centers for mice, rats, and swine. Emphasis will be given to application of genome resource banks to species with substantial contributions to the advancement of biomedicine and human health.

Pregnancy rates, prenatal and postnatal survival of offspring, and litter sizes after reciprocal embryo transfer in DBA/2JHd, C3H/HeNCrl and NMRI mice

Success of embryo transfer is often a limiting factor in transgenic procedures and rederivation efforts, and depends on the genetic background of the donor and recipient strains used. Here we show that embryo transfer to DBA/2J females is possible, and present data on pre- and postnatal success rates after reciprocal embryo transfer using the inbred DBA/2J and C3H/HeN, and outbred NMRI strains. The highest embryo yield was achieved in outbred NMRI females, but embryo yields were similar in DBA/2J and C3H/HeN mice following superovulation despite poor estrus cycle synchronization in DBA/2J females. In-strain transfer of DBA/2J blastocysts (transfer of embryos to recipients from the same strain) resulted in pregnancy rates (57.1%) similar to those obtained following in-strain transfer of C3H/HeN (60.0%) and NMRI mice (83.3%), although the prenatal survival rate of blastocysts was low. Moreover, from the pups born only half survived the postnatal period after transfer of DBA/2J and C3H/HeN blastocysts to DBA/2J recipients. These problems were not observed when transferring NMRI-blastocysts to C3H/HeN and DBA/2J mothers. The number of blastocysts transferred also had a positive effect on the success of embryo transfer. In conclusion, C3H/HeN and DBA/2J females can be used as recipients for embryo transfer procedures for certain donor strains like NMRI, as one major determinant seems to be the genetic background of the embryos transferred. We also recommend to increase the number of DBA/2J blastocysts transferred, and to foster the DBA/2J pups to other DBA/2J mothers postnatally for in-strain transfer of DBA/2J mice.

Effect of human beta-globin bacterial artificial chromosome transgenesis on embryo cryopreservation in mouse models

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the efficiency of embryo cryopreservation for four transgenic (TG) thalassaemic mouse strains, which is a key element of the ongoing gene banking efforts for these high-value animals. Heterozygous TG embryos were produced by breeding four lines of TG males to wild-type (WT) females (C57BL/6J). Intact two-cell embryos were cryopreserved by vitrification in straws using 35% ethylene glycol. Survival rates of cryopreserved embryos ranged between 91.1% (102/112) and 93.6% (176/188) without significant differences between the lines. In contrast, the paternal line had a significant effect on the development of these embryos to the blastocyst stage, which ranged from 50.6% (92/182) to 77.5% (79/102). This effect was also noted following embryo transfers, with implantation rates varying from 17.3% (19/110) to 78.1% (35/45). The results demonstrate that the in vivo developmental potential is significantly influenced by TG line and reveal a specific line effect on cryosurvival. All bacterial artificial chromosome transgenic fetuses developed from vitrified-warmed embryos showed expression of the human beta-globin transgene. In conclusion, the present study shows a strong TG line effect on developmental competence following cryopreservation and the vitrification method was successful to bank the human beta-globin TG-expressing mouse strains.

Emergency prevention of extinction of a transgenic allele in a less-fertile transgenic mouse line by crossing with an inbred or outbred mouse strain coupled with assisted reproductive technologies

Certain transgenic mouse lines are difficult to breed or archive and, consequently, their transgenes become lost. We examined a C57BL/6 mouse line (B6-tg), transgenic for green fluorescent protein (GFP) with low fertility, and its crosses with the more prolific inbred C3HeB/FeJ (C3) and outbred Swiss (SW) strains in order to assess the possibility of emergency prevention of extinction of a transgenic allele by using assisted reproductive technologies (ART). Out-crossing was performed by natural mating or in vitro fertilisation (IVF) with heterozygous mice. Most of the crossing combinations resulted in improved archiving and rederivation efficiencies of the transgenic allele. Natural crossing increased both mean litter size by two to three pups and the superovulatory rate from 69% for B6-tg to 70-90% for females from the out-crosses. Each plug-positive B6-tg female yielded an average of 4.6 two-cell embryos, whereas females from the out-crosses produced three- to fivefold that amount. After thawing, 13% of B6-tg embryos and 6-12% of out-crossed embryos developed into transgenic pups after transfer into recipients. After IVF with cryopreserved spermatozoa, cleavage rates were 4% for B6-tg, 22-37% for B6-tg oocytes out-crossed with C3 and SW spermatozoa, 9-49% for gametes from out-crossed mice and 28-44% for back-crosses with B6 oocytes. Transgenic pups were not derived from IVF with B6-tg gametes when either fresh or cryopreserved spermatozoa were used. Rederivation efficiencies were 7% and 4% from out-crosses of B6-tg oocytes with C3 and SW spermatozoa, respectively, 6-22% for gametes from out-crossed mice and 4-10% for the back-crosses. Although out-crossing changes the original genetic background, the strategy of crossing coupled with ART prevents the extinction of an allele of interest, especially where archiving and rederivation of the transgenic line fail.

Cryopreservation of the Germplasm of Animals Used in Biological and Medical Research: Importance, Impact, Status, and Future Directions

Molecular genetics and developmental biology have created thousands of new strains of laboratory animals, including rodents, Drosophila, and zebrafish. This process will accelerate. A decreasing fraction can be maintained as breeding colonies; hence, the others will be lost irretrievably unless their germplasm can be cryopreserved. Because of the increasingly critical role of cryopreservation, and because of wide differences in the success with which various forms of germplasm can be cryopreserved in various species, the National Institutes of Health National Center for Research Resources held a workshop on April 10-11, 2007, titled "Achieving High-Throughput Repositories for Biomedical Germplasm Preservation." The species of concern were mouse, rat, domestic swine, rhesus monkey, and zebrafish. Our review/commentary has several purposes. The first is to summarize the status of the cryopreservation of germplasm from these species as assessed in the workshop. The second is to discuss the nature of the major underlying problems when survivals are poor or highly variable and possible ways of addressing them. Third is to emphasize the importance of a balance between fundamental and applied research in the process. Finally, we assess and comment on the factors to be considered in transferring from a base of scientific information to maximally cost-effective processes for the preservation of this germplasm in repositories. With respect to the first purpose, we discuss the three methods of preservation in use: slow equilibrium freezing, rapid nonequilibrium vitrification, and the use of intracytoplasmic sperm injection to achieve fertilization with sperm rendered nonviable by other preservation treatments. With respect to the last purpose, we comment on and concur with the workshop's recommendations that cryopreservation largely be conducted by large, centralized repositories, and that both sperm (low front-end but high rederivation costs) and embryos (high front-end but modest rederivation costs) be preserved.

Virtues and limitations of the preimplantation mouse embryo as a model system

The mouse is the most widely used model of preimplantation embryo development, but is it a good model? Its small size, prolificacy and ease of handling make the mouse a relatively low cost, readily available and attractive alternative when embryos from other species are difficult or expensive to obtain. However, the real power of the mouse as a model lies in mouse genetics. The development of inbred mouse strains facilitated gene discovery as well as our understanding of gene function and regulation while the development of tools to introduce precise genetic modifications uniquely positioned the mouse as a powerful model system for uncovering gene function. However, all models have limitations; the small size of the mouse limits tissue availability and manipulations that can be performed and differences in physiology among species may make it inappropriate to extrapolate from the mouse to other species. Thus, rather than extrapolating directly from the mouse to other species, it may be more useful to use the mouse as a model system for developing and refining hypotheses to be tested directly in species of interest. In this brief review, the value of the preimplantation mouse embryo as a model is considered, both as a model for other species and as a model for the mouse, as understanding the virtues and limitations of the mouse as a model system is essential to its appropriate use.

The effectiveness of the stereomicroscopic evaluation of embryo quality in vitrified-warmed porcine blastocysts: an ultrastructural and cell death study

The objective of this study was to analyze the validity of the stereomicroscopic evaluation of vitrified-warmed (V-W) porcine blastocysts. Unhatched blastocysts were obtained from Large-white gilts (n=10). Blastocysts (n=156) were vitrified using the Open Pulled Straw technology. After warming, V-W blastocysts were cultured for 24h (V24). Then, their developmental progression was morphologically assessed by stereomicroscopy and classified as: V24 viable re-expanded blastocysts; V24 viable hatched blastocysts or V24 degenerated. Blastocysts which re-expanded or hatched after warming were considered viable. Some fresh blastocysts were not vitrified and were evaluated after 24h in culture (F24). By stereomicroscopic analysis all the fresh blastocysts were considered viable. Some F24, V24 re-expanded viable, V24 hatched viable and V24 degenerated blastocysts were processed for transmission electron microscopy (n=13, 19, 9 and 9, respectively) or assessed by TUNEL for cell-death evaluation (n=16, 21, 11 and 21, respectively). All V24 hatched blastocysts showed similar ultrastructure to fresh blastocysts. However, some V24 re-expanded blastocysts considered viable (6/19) revealed ultrastructural alterations. Degenerated V24 blastocysts showed ultrastructural disintegration. Hatched V24 blastocysts did not differ (p>0.05) from F24 hatched blastocysts with regard to the ratio of dead cells (2.8+/-0.5% versus 1.9+/-0.3%, respectively). However, V24 expanded blastocysts had higher (p<0.01) cell death levels (4.3+/-3.4%) than those observed in the F24 expanded blastocysts (1.1+/-0.3%). The degenerated blastocysts showed the highest cell-death index (19.4+/-6.3%). In summary, V-W blastocyst hatching during in vitro culture appears to coincide with good ultrastructure and low cell-death index, suggesting that the hatching rate assessed by stereomicroscopy is more appropriate than embryo re-expansion for an evaluation of V-W blastocyst quality.

Applications of emerging technologies to the study and conservation of threatened and endangered species

Sustaining viable populations of all wildlife species requires the maintenance of habitat, as well as an understanding of the behaviour and physiology of individual species. Despite substantial efforts, there are thousands of species threatened by extinction, often because of complex factors related to politics, social and environmental conditions and economic needs. When species become critically endangered, ex situ recovery programmes that include reproductive scientists are the usual first line of defence. Despite the potential of reproductive technologies for rapidly increasing numbers in such small populations, there are few examples of success. This is not the result of a failure on the part of the technologies per se, but rather is due to a lack of knowledge about the fundamental biology of the species in question, information essential for allowing reproductive technologies to be effective in the production of offspring. In addition, modern conservation concepts correctly emphasise the importance of maintaining heterozygosity to sustain genetic vigour, thereby limiting the practical usefulness of some procedures (such as nuclear transfer). However, because of the goal of maintaining all extant gene diversity and because, inevitably, many species are (or will become) 'critically endangered', it is necessary to explore every avenue for a potential contributory role. There are many 'emerging technologies' emanating from the study of livestock and laboratory animals. We predict that a subset of these may have application to the rescue of valuable genes from individual endangered species and eventually to the genetic management of entire populations or species. The present paper reviews the potential candidate techniques and their potential value (and limitations) to the study and conservation of rare wildlife species.

Osmotic tolerance of mouse spermatozoa from various genetic backgrounds: acrosome integrity, membrane integrity, and maintenance of motility

All cells have an intrinsic biophysical property related to their ability to undergo osmotically driven volume changes. This project is of fundamental importance to our understanding of the basic cryobiology of mouse spermatozoa. The objectives of this study were to determine the osmotic tolerance limits for (1) motility, (2) acrosome integrity, and (3) membrane integrity of mouse spermatozoa from multiple genetic backgrounds including: C57BL/6, BALB/c, FVB, C3H, 129/SVS2 hsd B6C3F1, CB6F1, and ICR. The maintenance of acrosomal and plasma membrane integrity was not affected by genetic background (p=0.13), however, there was an interaction between genetic background and osmolality. In addition, acrosome and plasma membrane integrity was highly correlated within each strain (p<0.01). In contrast to acrosome and plasma membrane integrity, the motility of spermatozoa from different genetic backgrounds fell sharply on both sides of isosmolality, both with and without return to isosmotic conditions. Exposure to hyposmotic conditions caused morphological changes in the spermatozoa, which inhibited motility. However, this morphological change was not reversible in all cases when returned to isosmotic conditions. The ability to maintain motility in an anisosmotic media was affected by genetic background, osmolality as well as the interaction between genetic background and osmolality (p<0.05). In conclusion, mice with different genetic backgrounds appear to have similar tolerance to osmotic changes in terms of sperm acrosome and plasma membrane integrity; however, the ability to maintain motility differs between genetic backgrounds.

Birth of offspring after transfer of Mongolian gerbil (Meriones unguiculatus) embryos cryopreserved by vitrification

The Mongolian gerbil (Meriones unguiculatus) has been used as a laboratory species in many fields of research, including neurology, oncology, and parasitology. Although the cryopreservation of embryos has become a useful means to protect valuable genetic resources, its application to the Mongolian gerbil has not yet been reported. In this study, we investigated the in vitro and in vivo developmental competence of Mongolian gerbil embryos cryopreserved by vitrification. In vivo-fertilized embryos were vitrified on the day of collection using the ethylene glycol (EG)-based solutions EFS20 and EFS40, which contained 20% and 40% EG, respectively, in PB1 containing 30% (w/v) Ficoll 70 and 0.5 M sucrose. First, we compared one-step and two-step vitrification protocols. In the one-step method, the embryos were directly transferred into the vitrification solution (EFS40), whereas in the two-step method, the embryos were exposed serially to EFS20 and EFS40 and then vitrified. After liquefying (thawing), late two-cell embryos (collected on day 3) vitrified by the two-step method showed significantly better rates of in vitro development to the morula stage compared to those vitrified by the one-step method (65% vs. 5%, P < 0.0001). We then examined whether the same two-step method could be applied to early two-cell embryos (collected on day 2), four-cell embryos (day 4), morulae (day 5), and blastocysts (day 6). After liquefying, 87%-100% of the embryos were morphologically normal in all groups, and 23% and 96% developed to the compacted morula stage from early two- and four-cell embryos, respectively. After transfer into recipient females, 3% (4/123), 1% (1/102), 5% (4/73), and 10% (15/155) developed to full-term offspring from vitrified and liquefied early two-cell embryos, late two-cell embryos, morulae, and blastocysts, respectively. This demonstrates that Mongolian gerbil embryos can be safely cryopreserved using EG-based vitrification solutions.

Pregnancy outcomes for mouse preimplantation embryos exposed in vitro to the estrogenic pesticide o,p′-DDT

Pregnancy outcomes were evaluated following uterine transfer of murine preimplantation embryos exposed in vitro to the estrogenic pesticide o,p'-dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (o,p'-DDT). Single-cell embryos were incubated 72 h in medium droplets containing 0.1% ethanol (control) or 0.1 microg/ml o,p'-DDT (pesticide). Morula and preblastocyst embryos were transferred in groups of eight to right uterine horns of pseudopregnant mice (n=111) and pups (n=132) were evaluated at Caesarean-section (C-section). In vitro exposure to o,p'-DDT reduced development to morula (P<0.001) and modestly increased blastomere apoptosis (P=0.05). However, treatment differences were not detected for implantation rates (35% versus 39%; P=0.64), pup numbers per dam (2.3 versus 1.9; P=0.36), transfer efficiencies (16% versus 14%; P=0.53), fetal weights (1.56 g versus 1.57 g; P=0.91), skeletal abnormalities (55% versus 66%; P=0.47), or male ratios (54.8% versus 53.8%; P=1.0). In vitro exposure of preimplantation embryos to 0.1 microg/ml o,p'-DDT for 72 h resulted in no measurable effects on subsequent implantation or pup characteristics at C-section.

Ultrastructure and cell death of in vivo derived and vitrified porcine blastocysts

Morphological and molecular signs of injury and cell death and subsequent regeneration following vitrification of porcine blastocysts were evaluated by light (LM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) as well as TUNEL/propidium iodide (PI) nuclear staining followed by confocal microscopy (CSM). In vivo derived blastocysts were assigned to one of the following four groups: Controls-(1) fixed immediately after collection (C0h) and (2) after 24 hr culture in vitro (C24h) and vitrified embryos-(3) fixed immediately after vitrification and warming (V0h), and (4) after 24 hr of culture upon warming after vitrification (V24h). Observation by LM and TEM showed that the V0h embryos displayed collapse of the blastocoele cavity (BC) and cell swelling, a general distension or shrinkage of mitochondria and massive increase in the amount of vesicles, vacuoles, and secondary lysosomes (SLs). Approximately 2/3 of the V24h embryos had recovered, whereas the remaining 1/3 were degenerated. Recovered embryos displayed almost normal blastocyst morphology, except for a widening of the perivitelline space, accumulation of debris and partial distension of mitochondria, whereas degenerated embryos were disintegrated into a poorly defined mass of cells and debris including cells with abundant degeneration of mitochondria and other organelles. Both recovered and degenerated embryos displayed a persistent abundance of presence of small membrane bounded vesicles, vacuoles, and SLs. Evaluation of TUNEL/PI stained embryos showed only occasional appearance of TUNEL positive nuclei with typical apoptotic morphology in controls (C0h 0.67%, C24h 1.22%) and in the V0h embryos (0.93%). The percentage of apoptotic nuclei in embryos at V24h was significantly higher than in all other groups (2.64%). Vitrified embryos showed significantly increased appearance of DNA fragmented nuclei without typical morphological features of apoptosis (V0h 1.43%, V24h 4.30%) compared with controls (C0h 0.26%, C24h 0.45%). The observed morphological changes and increased DNA fragmentation observed immediately after vitrification and warming probably reflects a direct damaging effect of vitrification. During 24 hr of culture a portion of the embryos was able to regenerate and along with the regenerative process, apoptosis--a possible pathway for elimination of damaged cells--became evident.

Expanding the three Rs to meet new challenges in humane animal experimentation

The Three Rs are the main principles used by Animal Ethics Committees in the governance of animal experimentation, but they appear not to cover some ethical issues that arise today. These include: a) claims that certain species should be exempted on principle from harmful research; b) increased emphasis on enhancing quality of life of research animals; c) research involving genetically modified (GM) animals; and d) animals bred as models of disease. In some cases, the Three Rs can be extended to cover these developments. The burgeoning use of GM animals in science calls for new forms of reduction through improved genetic modification technology, plus continued attention to alternative approaches and cost-benefit analyses that include the large numbers of animals involved indirectly. The adoption of more expanded definitions of refinement that go beyond minimising distress will capture concerns for enhancing the quality of life of animals through improved husbandry and handling. Targeting refinement to the unpredictable effects of gene modification may be difficult; in these cases, careful attention to monitoring and endpoints are the obvious options. Refinement can also include sharing data about the welfare impacts of gene modifications, and modelling earlier stages of disease, in order to reduce the potential suffering caused to disease models. Other issues may require a move beyond the Three Rs. Certain levels of harm, or numbers and use of certain species, may be unacceptable, regardless of potential benefits. This can be addressed by supplementing the utilitarian basis of the Three Rs with principles based on deontological and relational ethics. The Three Rs remain very useful, but they require thoughtful interpretation and expansion in order for Animal Ethics Committees to address the full range of issues in animal-based research.

Improving post-thaw survival of cryopreserved mouse blastocysts by hydrostatic pressure challenge

The purpose of the experiments was to study the effect of high hydrostatic pressure treatment prior to vitrification to the survival of expanded mouse blastocysts. High hydrostatic pressure has been reported to induce the production of "shock proteins" in bacteria, which can provide a possibility of cross-protection to other environmental stresses. The possible beneficial effects of this alleged principle was examined on embryo vitrification. First, the behaviour of blastocysts was studied at altered pressure conditions. In the second part of the study, pressure treatment was combined with a cryopreservation protocol. Our results indicate that the survival of pressurized mouse embryos depends on the magnitude and the duration of pressure applied. We demonstrated that a preceding pressure treatment strikingly increases the survival of the frozen blastocysts as well as the speed of resumption of the development, and hatching rate.

Survival of mouse blastocysts after low-temperature preservation under high pressure

Cryoinjuries are almost inevitable during the freezing of embryos. The present study examines the possibility of using high hydrostatic pressure to reduce substantially the freezing point of the embryo-holding solution, in order to preserve embryos at subzero temperatures, thus avoiding all the disadvantages of freezing. The pressure of 210 MPa lowers the phase transition temperature of water to -21 degrees C. According to the results of this study, embryos can survive in high hydrostatic pressure environment at room temperature; the time embryos spend under pressure without significant loss in their survival could be lengthened by gradual decompression. Pressurisation at 0 degrees C significantly reduced the survival capacity of the embryos; gradual decompression had no beneficial effect on survival at that stage. Based on the findings, the use of the phenomena is not applicable in this form, since pressure and low temperature together proved to be lethal to the embryos in these experiments. The application of hydrostatic pressure in embryo cryopreservation requires more detailed research, although the experience gained in this study can be applied usefully in different circumstances.

Vitrification of rat embryos at various developmental stages

The effect of developmental stage on the survival of cryopreserved rat embryos was examined. Wistar rat embryos at various developmental stages were vitrified by a 1-step method with EFS40, an ethylene glycol-based solution, or by a 2-step method with EFS20 and EFS40. After warming, the survival of the embryos was assessed by their morphology, their ability to develop to blastocysts (or expanded blastocysts for blastocysts) in culture, or their ability to develop to term after transfer. Most (91-100%) of the embryos recovered after vitrification were morphologically normal in all developmental stages. However, the developmental ability of 1-cell embryos was quite low; exposing them to EFS40 for just 0.5 min decreased the in vitro survival rate from 76 to 9%. The survival rates of 2-cell embryos and blastocysts, both in vitro and in vivo, were significantly higher with a 2-step vitrification process than with a 1-step vitrification process. Very high in vitro survival rates (94-100%) were obtained in 4- to 8-cell embryos and morulae in the 1-step method. Although survival rates in vivo of 4-cell (40%) and 8-cell (4%) embryos vitrified by the 1-step method were comparatively low, the values were similar to those obtained in non-vitrified fresh embryos. When morulae vitrified by the 1-step method were transferred to recipients, the in vivo survival rate (61%) was high, and not significantly different from that of fresh embryos (70%). These results show that rat embryos at the 2-cell to blastocyst stages can be vitrified with EFS40, and that the morula stage is the most feasible stage for embryo cryopreservation in this species.

Welfare issues of genetically modified animals

Genetically engineered animals have opened new frontiers in the study of physiology and disease processes. Mutant animals offer more accurate disease models and increased precision for pathogenesis and treatment studies. Their use offers hope for improved therapy to patients with conditions that currently have poor or ineffective treatments. These advantages have fostered an increase in studies using mice in recent years, a development viewed with alarm by those who oppose the use of animals in research. Scientists point out that the mice are replacing more sentient species, such as nonhuman primates, and are increasing the quality of research being conducted. They assert that study of genetically engineered animals will eventually permit decreases in numbers of animals used in research. Nevertheless, the increase in use of genetically altered animals presents many challenges in reviewing protocols and providing care. Identification and resolution of any welfare problems is a responsibility that is shared by institutional animal care and use committee, veterinary, animal care, and research staffs. To identify potential welfare concerns, a database such as TBASE (<http://tbase.jax.org>) can be searched to learn what has been reported for established mutant lines. In addition, newly created lines should be monitored by a surveillance system and have phenotype assessment to identify the effects of altering the genome. Methods of ensuring welfare can include treatment of conditions produced, restriction of gene expression to tissues of interest or to certain time periods, and establishment of endpoints for removing animals from a study before problems appear.