Use of a direct fluorescent antibody test for detecting Chlamydia trachomatis cervical infection in women seeking routine gynecologic care

Diagnosis of Chlamydia trachomatis genital infections in the era of genomic medicine

PURPOSE

Chlamydial genital infections constitute significant sexually transmitted infections worldwide. The often asymptomatic status of C. trachomatis (CT) infections leads to an increased burden on human reproductive health, especially in middle- and low-income settings. Early detection and management of these infections could play a decisive role in controlling this public health burden. The objective of this review is to provide an insight into the evolution of diagnostic methods for CT infections through the development of new molecular technologies, emphasizing on -omics' technologies and their significance as diagnostic tools both for effective patient management and control of disease transmission.

METHODS

Narrative review of the diagnostic methodologies of CT infections and the impact of the introduction of -omics' technologies on their diagnosis by review of the literature.

RESULTS

Various methodologies are discussed with respect to working principles, required specifications, advantages, and disadvantages. Implementing the most accurate methods in diagnosis is highlighted as the cornerstone in managing CT infections.

CONCLUSION

Diagnostics based on -omics' technologies are considered to be the most pertinent modalities in CT testing when compared to other available methods. There is a need to modify these effective and accurate diagnostic tools in order to render them more available and feasible in all settings, especially aiming on turning them to rapid point-of-care tests for effective patient management and disease control.

Effect of endocervical-specimen adequacy on detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by the APTIMA COMBO 2 assay

Six hundred one endocervical specimens were analyzed for Chlamydia trachomatis by the APTIMA Combo 2 assay and evaluated for columnar epithelial cell adequacy by direct fluorescent-antibody staining. With 5.5% positive adequate and 7.8% positive inadequate specimens (P=0.27), the study suggested no difference in positivity rates due to specimen adequacy when this amplified technology was used.

Oral Chlamydia trachomatis in patients with established periodontitis

Periodontitis is considered a consequence of a pathogenic microbial infection at the periodontal site and host susceptibility factors. Periodontal research supports the association of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia, and Bacteroides forsythus, and periodontitis; however, causality has not been demonstrated. In pursuit of the etiology of periodontitis, we hypothesized that the intracellular bacteria Chlamydia trachomatis may play a role. As a first step, a cross-sectional study of dental school clinic patients with established periodontitis were assessed for the presence of C. trachomatis in the oral cavity, and in particular from the lining epithelium of periodontal sites. C. trachomatis was detected using a direct fluorescent monoclonal antibody (DFA) in oral specimens from 7% (6/87) of the patients. Four patients tested positive in specimens from the lining epithelium of diseased periodontal sites, one patient tested positive in healthy periodontal sites, and one patient tested positive in the general mucosal specimen. In conclusion, this study provides preliminary evidence of C. trachomatis in the periodontal sites. Planned studies include the use of a more precise periodontal epithelial cell collection device, the newer nucleic acid amplification techniques to detect C. trachomatis, and additional populations to determine the association of C. trachomatis and periodontitis.

An important proportion of genital samples submitted for Chlamydia trachomatis detection by PCR contain small amounts of cellular DNA as measured by beta-globin gene amplification

We assessed the quality of genital samples submitted for Chlamydia trachomatis detection by PCR by a second PCR assay for the presence of human beta-globin DNA. Endocervical and urethral samples were first tested by the COBAS AMPLICOR C. trachomatis assay (Roche Diagnostic Systems) with an internal control and were then amplified for the presence of beta-globin DNA with primers PC04 and GH20. Samples that contained inhibitors were retested after dilution 1:10. A total of 407 genital samples (311 endocervical swabs from 311 women and 96 urethral swabs from 95 men and 1 woman) collected over a 1-month period were evaluated. The internal control could not be amplified, despite dilution, from 3 of 23 samples that were retested after dilution because of inhibition, leaving 404 samples that could be analyzed by PCR. Eleven samples tested positive for C. trachomatis. Thirty (7.4%) of the 404 samples were negative for beta-globin. Twelve of the 23 undiluted samples that contained inhibitors tested positive for beta-globin DNA. Amplification of beta-globin DNA in samples submitted for C. trachomatis detection by the COBAS AMPLICOR C. trachomatis assay demonstrated that an important proportion of the samples did not contain cellular DNA. Assessment of the quality of the samples for PCR analysis by beta-globin amplification is feasible but cannot replace use of the internal control.

[Evaluation of parameters for laboratory diagnosis of genital female infection by Chlamydia trachomatis]

In order to evaluate the occurrence of Chlamydia trachomatis, we have examined samples of cervical swabs from 189 women (166 of which were symptomatic and the remaining 23 were asymptomatic with regard to chlamydial infection. Two specimens from the endocervical channel were collected and examined by immunofluorescent assay (DIF) and Chlamydia isolation. Detection of IgG and IgA antibodies specific to C. trachomatis was also effected by indirect immunofluorescent assay (IIF), in a cervical secretion sample. We succeeded in isolating chlamydia in 14 (8.4%) symptomatic and 3 (13%) asymptomatic women. The observation that the 152 symptomatic patients with negative results from chlamydia culture presented similar symptoms of disease, indicating that there is no specific symptom for genital infection caused by Chlamydia (p > 0.05). All the 13 (76.5%) positive endocervical specimens, as determined by cell culture and DIF reaction, presented more than 5 epithelial cells in the smears. These cells may represent an interference factor to the positivity of cell culture (p < 0.001). Antibodies of the IgG and/or IgA classes were detected in 11 (64.7%) out of 17 women with positive chlamydia culture, considering as positive the IIF titre of > or = 8. Consequently, this method can not be used as an alternative means of diagnosis, particularly in the earlier stages of chlamydial genital infections, since the presence of the antibodies depends on the phase of the infection and on the individual humoral immune response.

Rapid communication: Cervical Chlamydia trachomatis in women at low risk for infection

BACKGROUND

Evidence suggests that the bacterium Chlamydia trachomatis can cause asymptomatic genital infection in persons at risk for acquisition of the organism. We employed 2 independent molecular screening systems to assess such inapparent cervical chlamydial infections in low-risk female patients attending general (non-STD) clinics in 2 locations.

METHODS

Three hundred seventy-five cervical swab samples were obtained in duplicate from patients attending a general women's clinic (278 samples) and a colposcopy clinic (97 samples). One set of samples from the general clinic was screened by a highly-specific molecular hybridization system, using a probe targeting the chlamydial 16S ribosomal RNA; the other set was screened with the use of the Chlamydiazyme test. Samples from the colposcopy clinic were screened using a sensitive and specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay system targeting chlamydia; the duplicates were assayed by direct fluorescent antibody assay (DFA).

RESULTS

Of the 278 patients screened by RNA-directed hybridization, 6.5% were positive for C. trachomatis, in contrast to screening of duplicate samples via Chlamydiazyme, which indicated that 3.6% were infected. PCR-based screening of the additional 97 patients gave a positivity rate of 17.5% for the organism, whereas DFA on duplicate samples from this group showed only 7.5% positive.

CONCLUSIONS

These observations suggest that the level of asymptomatic cervical C. trachomatis infection is significant even in women who are at low risk for such infections; the data also indicate that results from standard laboratory screening for chlamydia should be viewed with caution.

How adequate is adequate for the collection of endocervical specimens for Chlamydia trachomatis testing?

BACKGROUND

Endocervical specimen adequacy has been assessed by subjective criteria that are based on arbitrarily chosen thresholds for the presence of target cells observed on microscopic slide examinations.

GOAL OF THIS STUDY

To assess the relationship of chlamydia test positivity to specimen adequacy with the use of a semi-quantitative cytologic staining method for assessing endocervical specimen collection cellularity.

STUDY DESIGN

Endocervical specimens for chlamydia testing (PACE 2, GenProbe, San Diego, CA) and for a slide cytologic examination (n = 3,500) were collected in parallel. A semi-quantitative cytologic examination to determine a specimen adequacy (SA) score was performed for every chlamydia-positive result (n = 163) and approximately every fifth negative result (n = 626). The Chi-square test for linear trends was used to assess the relationship between SA scores and chlamydia positivity. The median SA scores for chlamydia-positive and negative slides were compared.

RESULTS

The median SA scores for chlamydia-positive and -negative slides were 27 and 20, respectively (P < 0.001). Chlamydia positivity rates increased with increasing specimen adequacy scores (0-9, 2.7%; 10-19, 15.1%; 20-29, 24.8%; and 30-45, 31.3%; Chi-square for linear trend: P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate a linear relationship between the numbers of cells observed on an endocervical smear and chlamydia positivity rather than the threshold concept in practice. The semiquantitative cytologic technique offers an objective method for further evaluating specimen adequacy for Chlamydia trachomatis testing.

Influence of endocervical specimen adequacy on PCR and direct fluorescent-antibody staining for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis infections

The cellular quality of the endocervical swab specimen used for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis may dramatically impact the sensitivity of the diagnostic assay used. An evaluation of the adequacy of 319 endocervical swab specimens from women attending two inner-city sexually transmitted disease and family planning clinics, as well as five high school-based family planning clinics, was performed, and the resulting data were compared with the diagnostic results obtained by both Amplicor PCR and Microtrak direct fluorescent-antibody (DFA) staining. The swab from each patient was rolled across the open circular area of a DFA slide and then used to inoculate a transport tube for PCR (Roche), after which the swab was discarded. The slides were stained and examined by epifluorescence microscopy for the presence of C. trachomatis elementary bodies and for the presence and number of cell types to determine specimen adequacy. Cellular adequacy for a cervical swab specimen was defined as the presence of one or more columnar epithelial or metaplastic epithelial cells or the presence of more than 100 erythrocytes per high-power microscopic field. Of the 319 specimens read by DFA, 204 (63.9%) were determined to be adequate. There were 34 (10.7%) positive specimens by DFA and/or PCR. Twenty-nine (9.1%) specimens were positive by PCR, 20 (6.3%) specimens were DFA positive, and 15 (4.7%) were concordantly positive by both tests. The prevalence of chlamydia among adequate specimens was 14.2% (29/204), compared to 4.3% (5/115) for inadequate specimens (P < 0.0001). Variations in specimen quality and the sensitivity of the diagnostic assay used have a significant impact on determining the prevalence of C. trachomatis in a population.

Reliability of cytology to detect chlamydial infection in asymptomatic women

Chlamydia trachomatis is a frequent sexually transmitted disease. The diagnosis of C. trachomatis infection by cytology is controversial. We compared the ability of Papanicolaou (Pap) smears to detect C. trachomatis infection with antigen detection (enzyme immunoassay; EIA) and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). One hundred sixty-seven women attending a therapeutic abortion clinic were enrolled in the study. Endocervical samples were first collected for EIA and PCR, and then Pap smears were prepared for cytologic evaluation. Eight patients were excluded from the study due to the lack of an endocervical component. The criteria established by Gupta and associates (Diagn Cytopathol 1988;4:224-229; Acta Cytol 1979;23:315-320) were used in this study to assess the specificity and sensitivity of the Pap smear in recognizing C. trachomatis infection. After EIA testing, the remaining sample was subjected to phenol-chloroform extraction to purify the DNA and then tested by PCR. Positive PCR samples were subjected to repeat phenol-chloroform and retested to confirm the positive result. Using a confirmed PCR or a blocked EIA as the extended gold standard, the incidence of C. trachomatis infection was 9.4%. Fifteen of the 159 cases reviewed were positive by extended gold standard. Thirteen (86.7%) of those 15 cases were interpreted as negative by cytology (false-negatives), and two (13.3%) cases were positive. Of the remaining 144 cases, 14 cases (9.7%) were interpreted as positive by cytology (false-positives) but were not confirmed by the extended gold standard. Ten (66.7%) of the 15 cases confirmed by the extended gold standard were interpreted as negative by EIA (false-negatives), and five (33.3%) were positive. There were no false-positives by EIA. In this study, the sensitivity and the specificity for cytology were 13.3% and 90.3%, respectively. The positive predictive value was 12.5%, and the negative predictive value for cytology was 90.9%. The sensitivity and the specificity for EIA were 33.3% and 100%, respectively. The positive predictive value was 100%, and the negative predictive value for EIA was 93.5%. Both EIA and cytology are insensitive methods compared with PCR. Based on these data, cytology should not be used to diagnose C. trachomatis infection in an asymptomatic female population with a moderate risk of C. trachomatis infection.

Current methods of laboratory diagnosis of Chlamydia trachomatis infections

Infections caused by Chlamydia trachomatis are probably the most common sexually transmitted diseases in the United States. Commonly unrecognized and often inadequately treated, chlamydial infections can ascend the reproductive tract and cause pelvic inflammatory disease, which often results in the devastating consequences of infertility, ectopic pregnancy, or chronic pelvic pain. C. trachomatis infections are also known to increase the risk for human immunodeficiency virus infection. The obligate intracellular life cycle of C. trachomatis has traditionally required laboratory diagnostic tests that are technically demanding, labor-intensive, expensive, and difficult to access. In spite of these historical challenges, however, laboratory diagnosis of C. trachomatis has been a rapidly advancing area in which there is presently a wide array of commercial diagnostic technologies, costs, manufacturers. This review describes and compares the diagnostic methods for C. trachomatis infection that are currently approved for use in the United States, including the newest DNA amplification technologies which are yet to be licensed for commercial use. Issues to consider in selecting a test for purposes of screening versus diagnosis based on prevalence, performance, legal, social, and cost issues are also discussed.

Diff-Quik stain as a simplified alternative to Papanicolaou stain for determination of quality of endocervical specimens submitted for PCR detection of Chlamydia trachomatis

The simple, rapid, two-step Diff-Quik stain procedure (Baxter Diagnostics) was compared with the Papanicolaou stain for microscopic determination of endocervical specimen quality. Results from 230 (98.7%) of 233 specimens stained by both methods indicated agreement between the two staining methods for detection of the endocervical cells or erythrocytes indicating specimen adequacy. By using the Amplicor Chlamydia trachomatis Test (Roche Diagnostic Systems) to detect C.trachomatis and the Diff-Quik stain to assess specimen adequacy, PCR-positive results were obtained from 147 (9.1%) of 1,615 microscopically adequate specimens but from only 13 (2.2%) of the 583 inadequate specimens (P < 0.001).

Evidence of labile inhibitors in the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in cervical specimens by polymerase chain reaction

A total of 276 cervical swabs (241 from first visits and 35 from follow-up visits) from 241 women were tested for Chlamydia trachomatis by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and enzyme immunoassay (EIA). Sixty-one smears (53 from first visits and 8 from follow-up visits) from 53 women were stained by direct fluorescent antibody (DFA). Twenty-one (8.7%) women had positive swabs in at least two different tests. All follow-up swabs (collected between 3 days and 3 weeks after the first clinical visit) were positive in at least one test when the woman had been positive at the first visit and no antibiotic treatment had been initiated. Including swabs from follow-up visits and DFA results, the respective sensitivities and specificities of the assays were as follows: PCR, 75.9% and 100%; EIA, 69% and 98.4%. The seven swabs that were false negative by PCR (tested initially after thawing from -20 degrees C) were mailed nonrefrigerated to the assay manufacturer, where they tested true positive. These data point to labile inhibitors of the PCR, predominantly cervical mucus.

Case report: in situ hybridization for detection of inapparent infection with Chlamydia trachomatis in synovial tissue of a patient with Reiter's syndrome

The authors have shown that protein antigens, RNA, and DNA from Chlamydia trachomatis are present in synovial tissues of patients with Reiter's syndrome (RS). However, those studies gave no insight into the host cell type involved or the precise tissue location of the bacteria. To address such issues, the authors developed an in situ hybridization system to detect chlamydia, and they used that system to examine synovial biopsies from a patient with RS and a patient without RS. The in situ system uses a previously described digoxigenin-labeled DNA probe that hybridizes with chlamydial 16S rRNA sequences in paraformaldehyde-fixed samples. Control studies with chlamydia-infected and uninfected HeLa cells confirmed that the in situ system is as sensitive as is direct fluorescence cytology for detection of the organism. Morphology of host and chlamydia cells is preserved after hybridization. Studies using synovial tissue from an osteoarthritis patient produced no in situ hybridization signal, but similar hybridization to tissue from a culture-/direct fluorescence cytology- negative RS patient had a strong intracellular signal for chlamydia within a subsynovial cell layer. These in situ hybridization results confirm the extensive presence of chlamydia in synovia and extend the authors' earlier observation that chlamydia RNA is present in the synovia of patients with RS. The data also confirm their electron microscopy studies, indicating that chlamydia are intracellular in synovial tissue, and they further show that infected host cells are located beneath the synovial lining.

Improved PCR detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by using an altered method of specimen transport and high-quality endocervical specimens

Duplicate endocervical swabs were collected for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by PCR (Roche Diagnostics). One swab was swirled in Specimen Transport Medium (Roche) for PCR testing and discarded. A saline aliquot from the other specimen, sent as a dry swab to the laboratory, was Papanicolaou stained to determine specimen adequacy, and the remainder was PCR tested. Significantly more (24%) PCR-positive results (118 versus 95; P < 0.001) were obtained with the dry specimens than with the swirled specimens when first tested. In addition, PCR-positive results were obtained with 107 (10.6%) of 1,007 microscopically adequate specimens but with only 3 (0.9%) of 341 inadequate specimens (P < 0.001).

Chlamydia trachomatis species specific serology: ImmunoComb Chlamydia bivalent versus microimmunofluorescence (MIF)

The ImmunoComb Chlamydia Bivalent IgG/IgA (Orgenics, Israel) is a new quantitative serologic test that employs LPS extracted Chlamydia trachomatis L2 and LPS extracted Chlamydia pneumoniae elementary bodies on two separate antigenic spots. The Bivalent C. trachomatis specific test results were compared with microimmunofluorescence (MIF), the gold standard of chlamydial species specific serology. For C. trachomatis IgG the Bivalent was highly concordant with the MIF: the rate of positive titres (IgG > or = 1:8) was 10% vs. 11% in 100 blood donors, 18% vs. 16% in 111 obstetric patients (6% antigen prevalence), 26% vs. 22% in sterile women with open (n = 54) and 86% vs. 84% with occluded (n = 51) tubes, and 88% vs. 85% in 103 women with C. trachomatis positive cervical smears. Surprisingly, the Bivalent differed considerably from the MIF in IgA prevalence: in obstetric patients (8% vs. 4%), sterile women with open (13% vs. 6%) and occluded (71% vs. 20%) tubes, and women with positive cervical smears (78% vs. 24%). Bivalent IgA appeared to be more sensitive than MIF IgA and showed a stronger correlation with positive cervical smears in obstetric patients (sensitivity 67% vs. 0%, specificity 95% vs. 96%, positive prediction 44% vs. 0%, negative prediction 98% vs. 94%) and with tubal occlusion in sterile women (sensitivity 71% vs. 20%, specificity 87% vs. 94%, positive prediction 84% vs. 77%, negative prediction 76% vs. 55%). MIF IgM was of little diagnostic help. Supplemental to the often difficult C. trachomatis antigen detection, the easily performed Bivalent IgG/IgA appears to be of great value in routine diagnosis of genital chlamydial infections.

Direct fluorescent-antibody confirmation of chlamydial antigen below the detection threshold of the chlamydiazyme enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

Of 4,000 endocervical specimens tested with the Chlamydiazyme enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Abbott Laboratories), 233 (5.8%) gave positive results (A492 above the cutoff), which were confirmed with a blocking reagent (Abbott). An additional 34 specimens (14.6%) with chlamydial antigen were detected and confirmed with the direct fluorescent-antibody test (Syva) from among those 66 Chlamydiazyme-negative specimens which had A492s that ranged from 0.030 to the cutoff and that could be blocked by > or = 50% with the blocking reagent.

Improved isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis from a low-prevalence population by using polyethylene glycol

The effect of polyethylene glycol (PEG) on the isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis was evaluated in our laboratory. Initial range-finding experiments demonstrated that the number of chlamydial inclusion bodies increased with increasing PEG concentrations. However, PEG concentrations above 10.5% became progressively more toxic to the McCoy cell monolayers. When 50 frozen clinical Chlamydia isolates were inoculated onto McCoy cell cultures with and without 7% PEG, the PEG-treated cultures produced three- to fivefold more chlamydial inclusions than cultures without PEG. This enhancement was also observed when 1,144 fresh clinical specimens from a low-prevalence population were tested. With fresh clinical specimens, PEG-treated cultures produced two- to sixfold more inclusions than standard cultures. The addition of 7% PEG to the chlamydial overlay medium significantly increased the number of inclusions in each culture, improved the sensitivity of the culture, and decreased the probability of missing a weakly positive specimen.

Performance of the syva direct fluorescent antibody assay for Chlamydia in a low-prevalence population

Chlamydia trachomatis is the most common reportable sexually transmitted disease (STD) in the United States. In the 1980s, rapid diagnostic tests for chlamydia began to replace more cumbersome tissue culture methods. Current data on rapid antigen detection assays demonstrate acceptable sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values in populations with a high prevalence of chlamydia. Few studies report the performance of these assays in a low-prevalence obstetric and gynecologic (Ob/Gyn) population, This study compares the most commonly used direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) assay (Syva Microtrak) with tissue culture (TC) in a low-prevalence population. Endocervical specimens (775) were tested from women at risk for chlamydia infection, and the prevalence was found to be 7.7%. The DFA assay demonstrated a sensitivity of 80% and a specificity of 97% compared with TC. The positive and negative predictive values were 72% and 98%, respectively. The results of this study indicate that the Syva DFA assay lacks the sensitivity and positive predictive value for routine use in Ob/Gyn populations with a lowprevalence of C. trachomatis.

Comparison of cytobrushes with swabs for recovery of endocervical cells and for Chlamydiazyme detection of Chlamydia trachomatis

Endocervical swab and cytobrush specimens from 1,301 symptomatic women were microscopically analyzed for adequacy and tested using Chlamydiazyme (CZ) (Abbott Laboratories). When the swab specimen was collected first, blocking antibody-confirmed CZ-positive results were obtained from 48 (8.0%) of 599 patients, 42 (87.5%) from swabs and 46 (95.8%) from cytobrushes (not significant). When the swab specimen was collected second, confirmed CZ-positive results were obtained from 46 (6.6%) of 702 patients, 44 (95.6%) from swabs and 41 (89.1%) from cytobrushes (not significant). Cytobrushes offered no significant advantage over swabs for CZ detection of Chlamydia trachomatis.

Detection of Chlamydia trachomatis antigens in first-void urine to identify asymptomatic male carriers

Early morning first-void urine collected from 279 sexually active Swedish male recruits (mean age 19.5 years) was tested by two commercial enzyme immunoassay (EIA) kits, MicroTrak and IDEIA III, and by MicroTrak direct fluorescence assay (DFA), to detect Chlamydia trachomatis antigens. A result was assumed to be true-positive when any of the two non-culture tests were positive for the same specimen. In one case where only DFA was positive, confirmatory chlamydial testing was performed by isolating the organism from a urethral swab. On these premises, the number of true-positive men was 26 (9.3% of all men studied). The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value for MicroTrak EIA were 85%, 98%, 85%, and 98%, respectively. IDEIA III was less sensitive than MicroTrak EIA (42% vs 85%). In conclusion, the diagnosis of asymptomatic chlamydial infections in men can be established with reasonable accuracy by the detection of Chlamydia antigens in urine samples using MicroTrak EIA.

Accuracy of two enzyme immunoassays and cell culture in the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in low and high risk populations in Senegal

Two enzyme immunoassays (EIAs), Chlamydiazyme (CZ; Abbott Laboratories) and Pathfinder (PF; Kallestadt), were compared with a cell culture technique in the detection of cervical Chlamydia trachomatis infection in 670 women in urban settings in Senegal (377 pregnant women and 293 prostitutes). Positive CZ and positive PF specimens were tested a second time using a monoclonal antibody blocking technique. True positive specimens were defined as those positive on culture or positive on EIA with confirmation of the result after blocking. Using this definition, the prevalence of genital chlamydial infection was 14.6% and 14.3% in pregnant women and prostitutes respectively. An important difference between the two populations was that the pregnant women were younger than the prostitutes, which might explain the fact that the prevalence of infection among the pregnant women was as high as that among the prostitutes, although the age-adjusted prevalence was higher among prostitutes than among pregnant women. The chlamydial detection rates of cell culture, CZ and PF were 62% (26/42), 69% (29/42) and 86% (36/42) respectively in prostitutes and 76% (42/55), 40% (22/55) and 53% (29/55) respectively in pregnant women. Agreement between the tests was 89%, 85% and 88% for culture/CZ, culture/PF and CZ/PF respectively. However, when data were adjusted for chance agreement, kappa coefficients were 0.40 for culture/CZ, 0.34 for culture/PF and 0.48 for CZ/PF. These results indicate that the accuracy of the EIAs and cell culture may vary greatly in different populations: both EIAs showed a distinctly higher detection rate than culture in prostitutes and a significantly lower detection rate in pregnant women.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Diagnostic judgments of nurse practitioners providing primary gynecologic care: a quantitative analysis

OBJECTIVES

To determine the accuracy of experienced nurse practitioners' judgments of the probability of chlamydial infection of the cervix, to identify the clinical factors ("cues") related to the judgments, and to discern likely sources of judgment error.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study with prospective data collection.

SETTING

Urban hospital-based clinic.

PATIENTS

492 nonpregnant women receiving primary gynecologic care.

INTERVENTIONS

Four nurse practitioners recorded clinical data, tested women for chlamydial infection, and judged the probability of chlamydial infection using six categories: less than 1%, 1-4%, 5-9%, 10-24%, 25-50%, and greater than 50%.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Chlamydial infection was detected by immunofluorescent assay in 31 (6%) of the 492 women. Although the median probability judgment was 5-9%, judgments were only weakly related (p = 0.08) to actual rates of infection. In a multivariate analysis, eight clinical cues were independently (p less than 0.05) related to nurse practitioners' probability judgments: age less than 20 years; past chlamydial or gonococcal infection; new sex partner; partner with suspected genital infection; genito-urinary symptoms; cervicitis, purulent vaginal discharge; and malodorous vaginal discharge. A linear model based on the eight cues, weighted according to their regression coefficients, predicted chlamydial infection more accurately than did the nurse practitioners' actual judgments (ROC curve areas 0.69 vs. 0.58, respectively; p less than 0.05). However, only two of the eight cues (age less than 20 years and purulent vaginal discharge) were actually related to chlamydial infection in a second multivariate model; this model bad accuracy similar to that of an empirically derived prediction rule (ROC curve areas 0.77 and 0.80, p = 0.27).

CONCLUSIONS

Nurse practitioners were often inaccurate in their diagnostic judgments. Our analyses suggest that this inaccuracy stemmed from both the inconsistent use of clinical cues and the use of cues that were not related to chlamydial infection. Therefore, interventions such as algorithms that promote consistency and accuracy in diagnostic use of relevant cues would be likely to improve their diagnostic judgments.

Laboratory techniques for the diagnosis of chlamydial infections

Yolk-sac inoculation of embryonated eggs was superseded 25 years ago by the use of cell cultures (often McCoy) for the isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis. Centrifugation of specimens onto the cell monolayers was shown to increase sensitivity, but little of late has further improved sensitivity which is at least ten-fold greater than that of eggs. However, culture is slow and labour intensive so that non-cultural techniques without these drawbacks have come to dominate. Direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) tests are rapid and have sensitivities that range from 70% to 100% for men and 68% to 100% for women, and specificities that range from 87% to 99% for men and 82% to 100% for women; if the tests are read by competent observers the values are at the top end of the ranges. The detection rate may be enhanced even further by relatively low-speed centrifugation of specimens before staining. Skilled reading is not a feature of enzyme immunoassays (EIAs) which according to the literature have sensitivities that range from 62% to 97% for men and 64% to 100% for women, and specificities that range from 92% to 100% for men and 89% to 100% for women. However, comparison against poor reference tests is responsible for most of the higher values and the clinician should not be misled into believing that EIAs have excellent sensitivity; the lower values in the ranges are closer to reality. Furthermore, EIAs that are being designed for use by general practitioners should be regarded with the greatest caution since lack of sensitivity means that chlamydia-positive patients will go undetected. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is not bedevilled by insensitivity but it is no more sensitive than the most sensitive cell culture or DFA tests. PCR is unsuitable for routine diagnosis but has a place as a research tool. For men, examination of "first-catch" urine samples by the best of the non-cultural procedures provides an acceptable non-invasive approach to diagnosis; for women, the value of examining urine may be less, but needs to be thoroughly tested. However, there is little doubt that a Cytobrush used to obtain cervical specimens holds no practical advantage over a swab. Serological tests are reliant on the provision of paired sera for making a diagnosis; high antibody titres in single sera may be suggestive of an aetiological association in deep-seated chlamydial infections (epididymitis, arthritis, salpingitis, etc), but unequivocal interpretation is unusual, particularly in an individual case, since the distinction between a current and past infection is problematical.

Correlation of the percent of positive Chlamydia trachomatis direct fluorescent antibody detection tests with the adequacy of specimen collection

Chlamydia trachomatis is an obligate, intracellular parasite infecting the columnar and transitional cells lining the endocervix, uterus, fallopian tubes, rectum, urethra, and epididymis. We determined if the percent of specimens positive for C. trachomatis in the Microtrak Direct Specimen Test depended on the quality of specimens obtained. Female genital slides (649) were evaluated by the direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) test for the presence and numbers of (a) C. trachomatis elementary bodies and (b) columnar, transitional and squamous epithelial cells, and polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMNs). Only 138 (21.3%) of the 649 slides were considered to be adequately taken, that is, containing columnar/transitional cells either alone or in conjunction with squamous cells and/or PMNs. Of the 138 adequate slides, 10 (7.2%) were C. trachomatis positive. However, 511 (78.7%) of the 649 slides were judged inadequate; 395 contained only squamous cells and/or PMNs, 19 were too thick to determine cell types, 46 contained only cell debris, and 51 contained neither cells nor debris. Only four (0.78%) of 511 were C. trachomatis positive. Thus adequate specimens containing columnar/transitional cells for C. trachomatis detection had a tenfold increase in the percent of positive results compared to inadequately collected specimens. By using the DFA test, one has the advantage of determining the adequacy of the specimens obtained as well as the presence of chlamydiae.

Epidemiological aspects of chlamydial infections and tubal abnormalities in infertile couples

Demographic and behavioural data on parameters of previous sexual behaviour were collected of both partners of 184 couples visiting the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology because of infertility. They were also screened for urogenital infection with Chlamydia trachomatis. Of 131 (71.2%) women, a diagnosis was established by hysterosalpingography and/or laparoscopy about the condition of their fallopian tubes. An unmarried status correlated significantly with a history of sexually transmitted disease, and with past promiscuity of male and female partner. Abnormalities of the fallopian tubes were significantly related to an unmarried status, a history of pelvic inflammatory disease, and past promiscuity. Male promiscuity was not shown to correlate with tubal abnormalities in the female partner. In only three couples, the partners reported to have had a sexual relationship with a partner other than the current one over the past year. The percentage of Chlamydia trachomatis-positive women of 1.8 and men of 3.0 in our study agrees with this low recent promiscuity. Chlamydia trachomatis was shown to be able to maintain itself for at least 4 years within a couple. The results are commented on.

Accuracy of Chlamydia trachomatis antigen detection methods in a low-prevalence population in a primary care setting

We compared a direct fluorescent-antibody stain (DFA) and an enzyme immunoassay (EIA) with a standard cell culture technique for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis infection in women in an urban family practice setting. We also evaluated a DFA sample in a commercial laboratory to determine the interlaboratory reliability of this test. There were 268 women in the study; the EIA provided a higher sensitivity (83 versus 50%) and a higher positive predictive value (83 versus 69%) than the DFA test and comparably high specificity (99 versus 98%). Concordance between the two laboratories on the DFA test was not high when data were adjusted for chance agreement (kappa coefficient = 0.64). DFA validity was optimal with an elementary body cutoff of greater than 5, while EIA validity was optimal at the recommended cutoff of 0.1 optical density unit. None of 11 women with negative cultures after treatment had false-positive antigen tests. False-negative results with both tests were associated with low culture inclusion counts but were not strongly associated with the presence or absence of symptoms, menses, pregnancy, or recent antibiotic use. False-positive results with EIA were seen only for three women who had a chief complaint of vaginal discharge. Although the positive predictive value of DFA could be increased in high-prevalence subpopulations, EIA was still more valid in two such groups: teenagers and prenatal patients. These results indicate that EIA might be preferable for low- or moderate-prevalence populations in primary care settings and that a falloff in DFA sensitivity could be explained by lower infection burdens in low-prevalence groups.

A new diagnostic index for predicting cervical infection with either Chlamydia trachomatis or Neisseria gonorrhoeae

OBJECTIVE

To develop and test a diagnostic index for estimating the probability of cervical infection with either Chlamydia trachomatis or Neisseria gonorrhoeae.

DESIGN

Prospective, cross-sectional study in two phases: 1) to develop a diagnostic index based on independent predictors of cervical infection; 2) to test the index.

SETTINGS

A hospital-based clinic and a student health service.

PATIENTS

Development phase: 190 nonpregnant women seen in the gynecology clinic; testing phase: 588 women seen in the gynecology clinic (n = 372) or the student health service (n = 216).

INTERVENTIONS

Experienced clinicians recorded historical, physical, and microscopic findings on standard forms and tested women for chlamydial and gonococcal infections.

RESULTS

Three independent predictors of cervical infection were identified and weighted: age (two points if less than 20 years and one point if 20-29 years); a new sex partner or one suspected of having a genital infection (one point); purulent vaginal discharge (one point). In the testing groups, cervical infection was present in none of 62 women with no points, seven of 269 (3%) with one point, 14 of 188 (7%) with two points, and 19 of 69 (28%) with three or four points (p less than 0.001). The index estimated the probability of infection more accurately (p less than 0.01) than did clinicians, performed well in each site, and remained accurate when C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae were considered separately.

CONCLUSION

The diagnostic index accurately estimates the probability of cervical infection with either C. trachomatis or N. gonorrhoeae and may be useful in selecting women for definitive diagnostic testing.

Effect of endocervical specimen quality on detection of Chlamydia trachomatis and on the incidence of false-positive results with the Chlamydiazyme method

Duplicate endocervical swabs were collected from 1,675 patients to assess the effects of variations in specimen quality on Chlamydiazyme (Abbott Laboratories) detection of Chlamydia trachomatis and the incidence of false-positive results. One swab (at random) from each patient was tested for C. trachomatis antigen by using the standard Chlamydiazyme procedure. A 200-microliter volume of 0.9% saline was added to the other swab from each patient. After vortexing, 20 microliters was smeared on a slide for Papanicolaou (Pap) staining and the remaining specimen was then tested with the Chlamydiazyme assay. The Chlamydiazyme result was positive for 170 (10.1%) and 165 (9.8%) of the stained and unstained duplicate specimens, respectively (no significant difference). Pap stains on smears from 1,536 (91.7%) of the patients were analyzed, and endocervical and/or metaplastic (E-M) cells were detected in 789 (51.4%) smears. Of these 1,536 stained and analyzed specimens, 150 (9.8%) were Chlamydiazyme positive but only 132 (88.0%) of the positive results were confirmed by repeating the test and using a monoclonal blocking antibody (Abbott). Confirmed Chlamydiazyme-positive results were obtained from only 34 (4.6%) of 747 specimens lacking E-M cells but from 98 (12.4%) of 789 specimens containing the cells (P less than 0.001). Of the 150 initially Chlamydiazyme-positive results obtained with Pap-stained, analyzed specimens, 12 (26.1%) of 46 were falsely positive from specimens lacking E-M cells but only 6 (5.8%) of 104 were falsely positive from specimens containing E-M cells (P less than 0.01). C. trachomatis antigen was detected significantly more frequently and false-positive results were significantly less common from specimens in which E-M cells were detected.

Evaluation of a nonisotopic probe for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in endocervical specimens

A nonisotopic probe (Gen-Probe PACE; Gen-Probe, Inc., San Diego, Calif.) for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in endocervical specimens was evaluated in 344 women attending a dysplasia clinic or an obstetrics clinic and 158 women who visited an emergency room. For each patient, the probe, a tissue cell culture, and a direct immunofluorescent-antibody test (DFA; MicroTrak; Syva Co., Palo Alto, Calif.) were used. C. trachomatis was detected in 54 specimens by at least one method. Forty-four, 44, and 37 specimens were positive by culture, probe, and DFA, respectively, and 31 were positive by all three methods. Considering culture-positive plus both probe- and DFA-positive results as the "gold standard," we determined the overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the probe to be 80, 98, 82, and 98%, respectively. These values were 94, 98, 84, and 99%, respectively, in emergency room patients and 71, 98, 80, and 97%, respectively, in clinic patients. The sensitivities, specificities, and negative predictive values of the DFA and probe were comparable. The positive predictive values of the DFA in all patients and in emergency room and clinic patients were 97, 100, and 95%, respectively. Given the number of probe-positive results that were not confirmed by culture, we do not recommend using the Gen-Probe PACE to screen for C. trachomatis in women with a low to moderate risk for infection.

Molecular techniques for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis

A DNA probe assay (PACE; Gen-Probe, San Diego, Calif.) was compared with a culture reference method for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis. Using stock isolates of each of the 15 serovars (A to K, Ba, L1, L2, and L3) of C. trachomatis, the lower limit of sensitivity for the DNA probe ranged between 1,086 inclusion-forming units (IFU) for serovar E (Bour) to 2,930 IFU for serovar L1 (440), with the only exception being serovar C (TW-3), with which 99 IFU was detected. There was no cross-reactivity with Chlamydia psittaci (Texas turkey) and Chlamydia pneumoniae (TWAR-183). Bacterial and fungal isolates representing 14 species of normal vaginal flora as well as Neisseria gonorrhoeae gave negative results with the DNA probe when tested at a level of 1.5 X 10(7) CFU/ml. In addition, the DNA probe, a direct fluorescent-antibody stain (DFA) (MicroTrak; Syva Corp., Palo Alto, Calif.), and an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Chlamydiazyme; Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, Ill.) were compared with culture for the detection of C. trachomatis, using 196 clinical cervical samples. Of the 196 samples, 20 (10%) were culture positive. Of the 176 culture-negative samples, 1 was not evaluated by DNA probe and 4, because of a lack of cellular material, were not evaluated by DFA. The sensitivities of the DNA probe, DFA, and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay were 60, 75, and 85%, respectively, and specificities were 95, 99, and 97%, respectively. Of the false-positive direct results, there was only one specimen with which more than one direct method was positive, and with this specimen all three direct methods were positive. The majority of false-negative results by the direct methods were from specimens which by the culture method gave <100 IFU per culture.

Detection of Chlamydia trachomatis, Mycoplasma hominis and Ureaplasma urealyticum in pregnant Dutch women

A prospective study was performed to determine the prevalence of endocervical infection by Chlamydia trachomatis and vaginal colonization by Mycoplasma hominis and Ureaplasma urealyticum in pregnant women seeking routine obstetrical care in two clinics in the southern part of the Netherlands. C. trachomatis was detected using the direct immunofluorescence staining technique. For the genital mycoplasmata, generally accepted culture methods were used. Evaluable samples were obtained from 691 of 770 women in the first trimester of pregnancy. C. trachomatis was detected in 2.3%, M. hominis in 5.2% and U. urealyticum in 23.9% of the women. The isolation percentages of C. trachomatis and U. urealyticum were almost equally distributed in the different age groups. The prevalence of all three micro-organisms did not seem to be related to parity. Smoking and alcohol consumption seemed to influence the isolation rate of M. hominis and U. urealyticum.

Comparison of DNA probe, monoclonal antibody enzyme immunoassay, and cell culture for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis

A total of 201 endocervical specimens were obtained from patients with a clinical or epidemiological history suggestive of chlamydial infection. These specimens were tested by DNA probe (Gen-Probe, San Diego, Calif.) and the IDEIA III (Boots-Celltech, Berkshire, United Kingdom) monoclonal antibody enzyme immunoassay and compared with cell culture for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis. Discrepancies between cell culture and antigen detection methods were resolved by direct fluorescent-antibody testing. In a population with a 17.4% prevalence, the sensitivities and specificities of these assays were 82.8 and 99.4%, respectively, for the DNA probe assay and 97.1 and 98.1%, respectively, for the IDEIA III.

Chlamydia trachomatis cervical infection in women seeking routine gynecologic care: criteria for selective testing

PURPOSE

Chlamydia trachomatis infection is one of the most common sexually transmitted diseases. Developing methods to identify patients who are at higher risk would enable clinicians to perform selective testing for C. trachomatis infection, which may reduce morbidity, sequelae, and overall costs. Risk factors for C. trachomatis infection of the cervix in women seen for routine gynecologic care were therefore analyzed.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Extensive clinical data and cervical cultures were obtained from 1,141 women between the ages of 18 and 50. Multivariate techniques were used to develop and prospectively test a model to predict infection.

RESULTS

In the model development series of 530 patients seen in a hospital-based practice, 24 (4.5%) had a positive culture result. In the validation series of 611 patients seen in private practice, 17 (2.8%) had positive culture results. The majority of infected patients (61%) were asymptomatic. For sexually active women 18 to 35 years of age, the optimal predictive model was based on three factors: level of education (high school or less), a sex partner with other partners during the prior three months, and endocervical bleeding induced by the initial swab. In the validation series, the prevalence of infection for women with one or more of these factors was 5.8% (95% confidence interval, 4.0 to 8.6) compared with 0.9% in patients without these factors (p = 0.005).

CONCLUSION

Clinical information can be used in a low-prevalence population to predict a patient's risk for C. trachomatis infection and to select patients for testing.

Laboratory diagnosis of human chlamydial infections

Chlamydia trachomatis is a human pathogen that causes ocular disease (trachoma and inclusion conjunctivitis), genital disease (cervicitis, urethritis, salpingitis, and lymphogranuloma venereum), and respiratory disease (infant pneumonitis). Respiratory chlamydioses also occur with infection by avian strains of C. psittaci or infection by the newly described TWAR agent. Diagnosis of most acute C. trachomatis infections relies on detection of the infecting agent by cell culture, fluorescent antibody, immunoassay, cytopathologic, or nucleic acid hybridization methods. Individual non-culture tests for C. trachomatis are less sensitive and specific than the best chlamydial cell culture system but offer the advantages of reduced technology and simple transport of clinical specimens. Currently available nonculture tests for C. trachomatis perform adequately as screening tests in populations in which the prevalence of infection is greater than 10%. A negative culture or nonculture test for C. trachomatis does not, however, exclude infection. The predictive value of a positive nonculture test may be unsatisfactory when populations of low infection prevalence are tested. Tests that detect antibody responses to chlamydial infection have limited utility in diagnosis of acute chlamydial infection because of the high prevalence of persistent antibody in healthy adults and the cross-reactivity due to infection by the highly prevalent C. trachomatis and TWAR agents. Assays for changes in antibody titer to the chlamydial genus antigen are used for the diagnosis of respiratory chlamydioses. A single serum sample that is negative for chlamydial antibody excludes the diagnosis of lymphogranuloma venereum.

Chlamydia trachomatis infection in a gynaecology clinic population: identification of high-risk groups and the value of contact tracing

Of 1267 women attending a gynaecology clinic, who were screened for the presence of Chlamydia trachomatis, 45 (3.6%) were found to be infected. Infection with C. trachomatis was more common in women who were less than or equal to 25 years of age, unmarried, nulliparous, requesting termination of pregnancy, using oral contraception as opposed to barrier methods, and who had cervical ectopy or cervicitis. Using contact tracing techniques 35% of male sexual partners of women who harboured C. trachomatis were also found to be infected. 86% of these men were symptomless. Asymptomatic chlamydial infection is common in men as well as women. Selective screening to identify women at risk of infection and the use of contact tracing to identify symptomless men with chlamydial infection are shown to be of value.

Detecting Chlamydia trachomatis by direct immunofluorescence using a Cytobrush sampling technique

We compared two different methods of collecting endocervical samples for examination by direct immunofluorescence for Chlamydia trachomatis. A cervical Cytobrush gave better results than a dacron swab. Further studies should be performed to assess the value of alternative sampling methods to detect this organism.