Impact of pretreatment low-abundance HIV-1 drug-resistant variants on virological failure among HIV-1/TB-co-infected individuals

The association between HIV pretreatment drug resistance and virological outcomes in children and adults in sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic review and meta-analysis

INTRODUCTION

Pretreatment drug resistance (PDR) could occur in antiretroviral treatment (ART) naïve individuals, those previously exposed to ART, or individuals re-initiating ARV after a long period of interruption. Few studies have shown its association with virological outcomes, although inconsistent. The objective of this review was to provide a synthesis of the association between PDR and virological outcomes (virological failure or suppression).

METHODS

This report is presented following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The method was subdivided into three main phases: record identification, screening, and report inclusion. Record identification consisted of an initial search with search term "HIV pretreatment drug resistance". Another search was done using terms "Pretreatment drug resistance OR pre-treatment drug resistance OR Pretreatment drug resist* OR pre-treatment drug resist* OR pretreatment antiretroviral resistance OR pretreatment medic* OR pretreatment medic* resist*" and a list of all the countries in sub-Saharan Africa. After the electronic search, studies were screened from full list based on their title and abstract and then full articles retrieved and studies were assessed based on set criteria. Inclusion criteria involved observational studies that report the association between PDR and virological failure. Data from trials that reported the association were also included. Published articles like modelling studies and reviews, and studies with data that had been previously included in the review were excluded. The Mantel Haenszel method with odds ratios was used for synthesis (meta-analyses) with the weights of each study which depends on the number of events and totals.

RESULTS

A total of 733 records(studies) were obtained from all database search of which 74 reported on PDR, virological outcomes in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). Out of the 74 articles, 11 were excluded and 26 did not explicitly report data needed, and 5 did not meet the inclusion criteria. Of the remaining 32 studies, 19 studies that had complete data on the number of participants with PDR and no PDR according to virological failure (VF) were included in the metanalyses. The pooled results from eleven (13) of these studies showed those with PDR had higher odds of virological failure compared to those without PDR OR 3.64[95% CI 2.93, 4.52]. The result was similar when stratified in adults and in children. In six (6) studies that had Virological suppression (VS) as outcome, there was a reduction in the odds of VS in those with PDR compared to those without PDR, OR 0.42 (95% CI 0.30, 0.58).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, this systematic review indicates that PDR increases the risk of virological failure in sub-Saharan Africa. The risk could be reduced by PDR monitoring for NNRTIs and INSTIs.

Impact of pretreatment low-abundance HIV-1 drug resistance on virological failure after 1 year of antiretroviral therapy in China

OBJECTIVES

To assess the impact of pretreatment low-abundance HIV drug-resistant variants (LA-DRVs) on virological outcomes among ART-naive HIV-1-infected Chinese people who initiated ART.

METHODS

A nested case-control study was conducted among HIV-1-infected individuals who had pretreatment drug resistance (PDR) genotypic results. Cases were defined as individuals with virological failure (HIV-1 RNA viral load ≥1000 copies/mL) after 1 year of ART, and controls were individuals from the same cohort whose viral load was less than 1000 copies/mL. Next-generation sequencing was used to identify low-abundance PDR mutations at detection thresholds of 10%, 2% and 1%. The mutant load was calculated by multiplying the abundance of HIV-1 drug-resistant variants by the pretreatment viral load. The impact of pretreatment low-abundance mutations on virological failure was estimated in logistic regression models.

RESULTS

Participants (43 cases and 100 controls) were included in this study for the analysis. The proportion of participants with PDR was higher in cases than in controls at different detection thresholds (44.2% versus 22.0%, P = 0.007 at 10% threshold; 58.1% versus 31.0%, P = 0.002 at 2% threshold; 90.7% versus 69.0%, P = 0.006 at 1% threshold). Compared with participants without PDR, participants with ≥10% detectable PDR mutations were associated with an increased risk of virological failure (adjusted OR 8.0, 95% CI 2.4-26.3, P = 0.001). Besides this, individuals with pretreatment LA-DRVs (2%-9% abundance range) had 5-fold higher odds of virological failure (adjusted OR 5.0, 95% CI 1.3-19.6, P = 0.021). Furthermore, LA-DRVs at 2%-9% abundance resistant to NRTIs and mutants with abundance of ≥10% resistant to NNRTIs had a 4-fold and 8-fold risk of experiencing virological failure, respectively. It was also found that a mutant load of more than 1000 copies/mL was predictive of virological failure (adjusted OR 7.2, 95% CI 2.5-21.1, P = 0.0003).

CONCLUSIONS

Low-abundance PDR mutations ranging from 2% to 9% of abundance can increase the risk of virological failure. Further studies are warranted to define a clinically relevant threshold of LA-DRVs and the role of NRTI LA-DRVs.

HIV-1 Low-Frequency Variants Identified in Antiretroviral-Naïve Subjects with Virologic Failure after 12 Months of Follow-Up in Panama

Low-frequency mutations associated with drug resistance have been related to virologic failure in subjects with no history of pre-treatment and recent HIV diagnosis. In total, 78 antiretroviral treatment (ART)-naïve subjects with a recent HIV diagnosis were selected and followed by CD4+ T lymphocytes and viral load tests to detect virologic failure. We sequenced the basal samples retrospectively using next-generation sequencing (NGS), looking for low-frequency mutations that had not been detected before using the Sanger sequencing method (SSM) and describing the response to ART. Twenty-two subjects developed virologic failure (VF), and thirteen of them had at least one drug-resistance mutation associated with Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors (RTI) and Protease Inhibitors (PIs) at frequency levels ≤ 1%, not detected previously in their basal genotyping test. No resistance mutations were observed to Integrase Strand Transfer Inhibitors (INSTIs). We identified a possible cause of VF in ART-naïve subjects with low-frequency mutations detected. To our knowledge, this is the first evaluation of pre-existing drug resistance for HIV-1 minority variants carried out on ART-naïve people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) by analyzing the HIV-1 pol gene using NGS in the country.

From Capillary Electrophoresis to Deep Sequencing: An Improved HIV-1 Drug Resistance Assessment Solution Using In Vitro Diagnostic (IVD) Assays and Software

BACKGROUND

Drug-resistance mutations were mostly detected using capillary electrophoresis sequencing, which does not detect minor variants with a frequency below 20%. Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) can now detect additional mutations which can be useful for HIV-1 drug resistance interpretation. The objective of this study was to evaluate the performances of CE-IVD assays for HIV-1 drug-resistance assessment both for target-specific and whole-genome sequencing, using standardized end-to-end solution platforms.

METHODS

A total of 301 clinical samples were prepared, extracted, and amplified for the three HIV-1 genomic targets, Protease (PR), Reverse Transcriptase (RT), and Integrase (INT), using the CE-IVD DeepChek^® Assays; and then 19 clinical samples, using the CE-IVD DeepChek^® HIV Whole Genome Assay, were sequenced on the NGS iSeq100 and MiSeq (Illumina, San Diego, CA, USA). Sequences were compared to those obtained by capillary electrophoresis. Quality control for Molecular Diagnostics (QCMD) samples was added to validate the clinical accuracy of these in vitro diagnostics (IVDs). Nineteen clinical samples were then tested with the same sample collection, handling, and measurement procedure for evaluating the use of NGS for whole-genome HIV-1. Sequencing analyzer outputs were submitted to a downstream CE-IVD standalone software tailored for HIV-1 analysis and interpretation.

RESULTS

The limits of range detection were 1000 to 10⁶ cp/mL for the HIV-1 target-specific sequencing. The median coverage per sample for the three amplicons (PR/RT and INT) was 13,237 reads. High analytical reproducibility and repeatability were evidenced by a positive percent agreement of 100%. Duplicated samples in two distinct NGS runs were 100% homologous. NGS detected all the mutations found by capillary electrophoresis and identified additional resistance variants. A perfect accuracy score with the QCMD panel detection of drug-resistance mutations was obtained.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the first evaluation of the DeepChek^® Assays for targets specific (PR/RT and INT) and whole genome. A cutoff of 3% allowed for a better characterization of the viral population by identifying additional resistance mutations and improving the HIV-1 drug-resistance interpretation. The use of whole-genome sequencing is an additional and complementary tool to detect mutations in newly infected untreated patients and heavily experienced patients, both with higher HIV-1 viral-load profiles, to offer new insight and treatment strategies, especially using the new HIV-1 capsid/maturation inhibitors and to assess the potential clinical impact of mutations in the HIV-1 genome outside of the usual HIV-1 targets (RT/PR and INT).

Affordable drug resistance genotyping of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase, protease and integrase genes, for resource limited settings

BACKGROUND

As use of dolutegravir (DTG) becomes more common in resource limited settings (RLS), the demand for integrase resistance testing is increasing. Affordable methods for genotyping all relevant HIV-1 pol genes (i.e., protease (PR), reverse transcriptase (RT) and integrase (IN)) are required to guide choice of future antiretroviral therapy (ART). We designed an in-house HIV-1 drug resistance (HIVDR) genotyping method that is affordable and suitable for use in RLS.

METHODS

We obtained remnant plasma samples from CAPRISA 103 study and amplified HIV-1 PR, RT and IN genes, using an innovative PCR assay. We validated the assay using remnant plasma samples from an external quality assessment (EQA) programme. We genotyped samples by Sanger sequencing and assessed HIVDR mutations using the Stanford HIV drug resistance database. We compared drug resistance mutations with previous genotypes and calculated method cost-estimates.

RESULTS

From 96 samples processed, we obtained sequence data for 78 (81%), of which 75 (96%) had a least one HIVDR mutation, with no major-IN mutations observed. Only one sample had an E157Q INSTI-accessory mutation. When compared to previous genotypes, 18/78 (23%) had at least one discordant mutation, but only 2/78 (3%) resulted in different phenotypic predictions that could affect choice of subsequent regimen. All CAPRISA 103 study sequences were HIV-1C as confirmed by phylogenetic analysis. Of the 7 EQA samples, 4 were HIV-1C, 2 were HIV-1D, and 1 was HIV-1A. Genotypic resistance data generated using the IDR method were 100% concordant with EQA panel results. Overall genotyping cost per sample was estimated at ~ US$43-$US49, with a processing time of ~ 2 working days.

CONCLUSIONS

We successfully designed an in-house HIVDR method that is suitable for genotyping HIV-1 PR, RT and IN genes, at an affordable cost and shorter turnaround time. This HIVDR genotyping method accommodates changes in ART regimens and will help to guide HIV-1 treatment decisions in RLS.

High concordance in plasma and CSF HIV-1 drug resistance mutations despite high cases of CSF viral escape in individuals with HIV-associated cryptococcal meningitis in Botswana

OBJECTIVES

We compared the patterns of HIV-1 drug resistance mutations between the CSF and plasma of individuals with HIV-associated cryptococcal meningitis.

METHODS

This is a cross-sectional study of archived CSF and plasma samples collected from ART-exposed participants recruited in the Phase 3 AmBisome Therapy Induction Optimisation randomized controlled trial (ISRCTN72509687) conducted in Botswana between 2018 and 2021. HIV-1 RT and protease genes were genotyped using next-generation sequencing and HIV-1 drug resistance mutations were compared between the CSF and plasma compartments stratified by thresholds of ≥20% and <20%.

RESULTS

Overall, 66.7% (16/24) of participants had at least one HIV-1 drug resistance mutation in the CSF and/or plasma. A total of 15/22 (68.2%) participants had HIV-1 drug resistance mutations at ≥20% threshold in the plasma and of those, 11 (73.3%) had been on ART longer than 6 months. HIV-1 drug resistance mutations were highly concordant between the CSF and plasma at ≥20% threshold despite a substantial number of individuals experiencing CSF viral escape and with only 54.5% with CSF WBC count ≥20 cells/mm3. Minority HIV-1 drug resistance mutations were detected in 20.8% (5/24) of participants. There were no mutations in the CSF that were not detected in the plasma.

CONCLUSIONS

There was high concordance in HIV-1 drug resistance mutations in the CSF and plasma, suggesting intercompartmental mixing and possibly a lack of compartmentalization. Some individuals harboured minority HIV-1 drug resistance mutations, demonstrating the need to employ more sensitive genotyping methods such as next-generation sequencing for the detection of low-abundance mutations.

Low-frequency HIV-1 drug resistance mutations in antiretroviral naïve individuals in Botswana

BACKGROUND

Individuals living with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) who experience virological failure (VF) after combination antiretroviral therapy (cART) initiation may have had low-frequency drug resistance mutations (DRMs) at cART initiation. There are no data on low-frequency DRMs among cART-naïve HIV-positive individuals in Botswana.

METHODS

We evaluated the prevalence of low-frequency DRMs among cART-naïve individuals previously sequenced using Sanger sequencing. The generated pol amplicons were sequenced by next-generation sequencing.

RESULTS

We observed low-frequency DRMs (detected at <20% in 33/103 (32%) of the successfully sequenced individuals, of whom four also had mutations detected at >20%. K65R was the most common low-frequency DRM detected in 8 individuals. Eighty-two of the 103 individuals had follow-up viral load data while on cART. Twenty-seven of the 82 individuals harbored low-frequency DRMs. Only 12 of 82 individuals experienced VF. The following low-frequency DRMs were observed in four individuals experiencing VF: K65R, K103N, V108I, and Y188C. No statistically significant difference was observed in the prevalence of low-frequency DRMs between individuals experiencing VF (4/12) and those not experiencing VF (23/70) (P = .97). However, individuals with non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors-associated low-frequency DRMs were 2.68 times more likely to experience VF (odds ratio, 2.68; 95% confidential interval, 0.4-13.9) compared with those without (P = .22).

CONCLUSION

Next-generation sequencing was able to detect low-frequency DRMs in this cohort in Botswana, but these DRMs did not contribute significantly to VF.

HIV-1 Drug Resistance Assay Using Ion Torrent Next Generation Sequencing and On-Instrument End-to-End Analysis Software

HIV-1 antiretroviral therapy management requires sequencing the protease, reverse transcriptase, and integrase portions of the HIV-1 pol gene. Most resistance testing is performed with Sanger sequencing, which has limited ability to detect minor variants. Next generation sequencing (NGS) platforms enable variant detection at frequencies as low as 1% allowing for earlier detection of resistance and modification of therapy. Implementation of NGS assays in the clinical laboratory is hindered by complicated assay design, cumbersome wet bench procedures, and the complexity of data analysis and bioinformatics. We developed a complete NGS protocol and companion analysis and reporting pipeline using AmpliSeq multiplex PCR, Ion Torrent S5 XL sequencing, and Stanford's HIVdb resistance algorithm. Implemented as a Torrent Suite software plugin, the pipeline runs automatically after sequencing. An optimum variant frequency threshold of 10% was determined by comparing Sanger sequences of archived samples from ViroSeq testing, resulting in a sensitivity of 98.2% and specificity of 99.0%. The majority (91%) of drug resistance mutations were detected by both Sanger and NGS, with 1.7% only by Sanger and 7.3% only by NGS. Variant calls were highly reproducible and there was no cross-reactivity to VZV, HBV, CMV, EBV, and HCV. The limit of detection was 500 copies/mL. The NGS assay performance was comparable to ViroSeq Sanger sequencing and has several advantages, including a publicly available end-to-end analysis and reporting plugin. The assay provides a straightforward path for implementation of NGS for HIV drug resistance testing in the laboratory setting without additional investment in bioinformatics infrastructure and resources.

Adherence measured using electronic dose monitoring is associated with emergent antiretroviral resistance and poor outcomes in patients co-infected with HIV/AIDS and multidrug-resistant tuberculosis

BACKGROUND

Medication adherence is known to challenge treatment of HIV/AIDS and multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB). We hypothesized that electronic dose adherence monitoring (EDM) would identify an ART adherence threshold for emergent ART resistance and predict treatment outcomes in patients with MDR-TB and HIV on ART and bedaquiline-containing TB regimens.

METHODS

A prospective cohort of adults with MDR-TB and HIV, on ART and initiating MDR-TB treatment with bedaquiline, were enrolled at a public TB referral hospital in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa (PRAXIS Study, Clinicaltrials.gov NCT03162107). Participants received separate EDM devices measuring adherence to bedaquiline and ART (nevirapine or lopinavir/ritonavir). Adherence was calculated cumulatively over six months. Participants were followed through completion of MDR-TB treatment. HIV genome sequencing was performed at baseline, 2 and 6 months on samples with HIV RNA ≥1000 copies/mL.

FINDINGS

From November 2016 through February 2018, 198 MDR-TB and HIV co-infected participants were enrolled and followed (median 17.2 months, IQR 12.2 - 19.6). Eleven percent had baseline ART resistance mutations, and 7.5% developed emergent ART resistance at 6 months. ART adherence was independently associated with both emergent ART resistance and mortality. Modeling identified a significant (p<0.001), but linear association between ART adherence and emergent resistance, suggesting a strong association without a specific threshold.

INTERPRETATION

Our findings highlight the need for ART resistance testing, especially in MDR-TB HIV co-infected patients, which is currently not standard of care in resource-limited settings. Despite short follow-up duration, reduced ART adherence was significantly associated with emergent resistance and increased mortality.