Different nucleosome spacing in transcribed and non-transcribed regions of the ribosomal RNA gene in Tetrahymena thermophila

Chromatin states at ribosomal DNA loci

Eukaryotic transcription of ribosomal RNAs (rRNAs) by RNA polymerase I can account for more than half of the total cellular transcripts depending on organism and growth condition. To support this level of expression, eukaryotic rRNA genes are present in multiple copies. Interestingly, these genes co-exist in different chromatin states that may differ significantly in their nucleosome content and generally correlate well with transcriptional activity. Here we review how these chromatin states have been discovered and characterized focusing particularly on their structural protein components. The establishment and maintenance of rRNA gene chromatin states and their impact on rRNA synthesis are discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Transcription by Odd Pols.

Nucleosome positioning in human HOX gene clusters

The distribution of nucleosomes along the genome is a significant aspect of chromatin structure and is thought to influence gene regulation through modulation of DNA accessibility. However, properties of nucleosome organization remain poorly understood, particularly in mammalian genomes. Toward this goal we used tiled microarrays to identify stable nucleosome positions along the HOX gene clusters in human cell lines. We show that nucleosome positions exhibit sequence properties and long-range organization that are different from those characterized in other organisms. Despite overall variability of internucleosome distances, specific loci contain regular nucleosomal arrays with 195-bp periodicity. Moreover, such arrays tend to occur preferentially toward the 3' ends of genes. Through comparison of different cell lines, we find that active transcription is correlated with increased positioning of nucleosomes, suggesting an unexpected role for transcription in the establishment of well-positioned nucleosomes.

Diverse regulation of SNF2h chromatin remodeling by noncatalytic subunits

SNF2h-based ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling complexes diverge in composition, nuclear localization, and biological function. Such differences have led to the hypothesis that SNF2h complexes differ mechanistically. One proposal is that the complexes have different functional interactions with the naked DNA adjacent to the nucleosome. We have used a series of templates with defined nucleosomal position and differing amounts and placement of adjacent DNA to compare the relative activities of SNF2h and SNF2h complexes. The complexes hACF, CHRAC, WICH, and RSF all displayed differences in functional interactions with these templates, which we attribute to the differences in the noncatalytic subunit. We suggest that the ability to sense adjacent DNA is a general property of the binding partners of SNF2h and that each partner provides distinct regulation that contributes to distinct cellular function.

Structural organization of the hepatitis B virus minichromosome

The replicative intermediate of hepatitis B virus (HBV), the covalently closed, circular DNA, is organized into minichromosomes in the nucleus of the infected cell by histone and non-histone proteins. In this study we investigated the architecture of the HBV minichromosome in more detail. In contrast to cellular chromatin the nucleosomal spacing of the HBV minichromosome has been shown to be unusually reduced by approximately 10 %. A potential candidate responsible for an alteration in the chromatin structure of the HBV minichromosome is the HBV core protein. The HBV core protein has been implicated in the nuclear targeting process of the viral genome. The association of the HBV core protein with nuclear HBV replicative intermediates could strengthen this role. Our findings, confirmed by in vivo and in vitro experiments indicate that HBV core protein is a component of the HBV minichromosome, binds preferentially to HBV double-stranded DNA, and its binding results in a reduction of the nucleosomal spacing of the HBV nucleoprotein complexes by 10 %. From this model of the HBV minichromosome we propose that the HBV core protein may have an impact on the nuclear targeting of the HBV genome and be involved in viral transcription by regulating the nucleosomal arrangement of the HBV regulatory elements, probably in a positive manner.

Introns of the chicken ovalbumin gene promote nucleosome alignment in vitro

A defined in vitro chromatin assembly system was used to examine the nucleosome alignment induced by histone H5 throughout a 12 kilobase pair chicken genomic DNA fragment containing the ovalbumin gene. In contrast with total fragmented chicken DNA and several anonymous cloned fragments, much of the gene permitted histone H5 to space nucleosomes at physiological intervals in an extended array. Nucleosomes at the 3'-end of the gene and on approximately 4 kilobase pairs of 5'-flanking ovalbumin sequence did not become aligned to appreciable extents. Analysis of cloned 2-3 kilobase pair subfragments suggested that a strong nucleosome alignment signal, specifying a 196 +/- 5 base pair repeat exists in intron E. A second discrete region of the gene, which mapped approximately to intron A, exhibited nucleosome alignment with a spacing periodicity of about 200 base pairs. The ovalbumin cDNA did not permit nucleosome alignment. These findings suggest that some of the introns contain signals that direct nucleosome alignment over the ovalbumin gene in a way conducive to its regulation.

ATP dependent histone phosphorylation and nucleosome assembly in a human cell free extract

Physiologically spaced nucleosome formation in HeLa cell extracts is ATP dependent. ATP hydrolysis is required for chromatin assembly on both linear and covalently closed circular DNA. The link between the phosphorylation state of histones and nucleosome formation has been examined and we demonstrate that in the absence of histone phosphorylation no stable and regularly spaced nucleosomes are formed. Phosphorylated H3 stabilizes the nucleosome core; while phosphorylation of histone H2a is necessary to increase the linker length between nucleosomes from 0 to approximately 45 bp. Histone H1 alone, whether phosphorylated or unphosphorylated, does not increase the nucleosome repeat length in the absence of core histone phosphorylation. Phosphorylations of H1 and H3 correlate with condensation of chromatin. Maximum ATP hydrolysis which is necessary to increase the periodicity of nucleosomes from approximately 150 to approximately 185 bp, not only inhibits H1 and H3 phosphorylation but facilitates their dephosphorylation.

Introduction of extra telomeric DNA sequences into Saccharomyces cerevisiae results in telomere elongation

The termini of Saccharomyces cerevisiae chromosomes consist of tracts of C1-3A (one to three cytosine and one adenine residue) sequences of approximately 450 base pairs in length. To gain insights into trans-acting factors at telomeres, high-copy-number linear and circular plasmids containing tracts of C1-3A sequences were introduced into S. cerevisiae. We devised a novel system to distinguish by color colonies that maintained the vector at 1 to 5, 20 to 50, and 100 to 400 copies per cell and used it to change the amount of telomeric DNA sequences per cell. An increase in the number of C1-3A sequences caused an increase in the length of telomeric C1-3A repeats that was proportional to plasmid copy number. Our data suggest that telomere growth is inhibited by a limiting factor(s) that specifically recognizes C1-3A sequences and that this factor can be effectively competed for by long tracts of C1-3A sequences at telomeres or on circular plasmids. Telomeres without this factor are exposed to processes that serve to lengthen chromosome ends.

Introduction of extra telomeric DNA sequences into Saccharomyces cerevisiae results in telomere elongation

The termini of Saccharomyces cerevisiae chromosomes consist of tracts of C1-3A (one to three cytosine and one adenine residue) sequences of approximately 450 base pairs in length. To gain insights into trans-acting factors at telomeres, high-copy-number linear and circular plasmids containing tracts of C1-3A sequences were introduced into S. cerevisiae. We devised a novel system to distinguish by color colonies that maintained the vector at 1 to 5, 20 to 50, and 100 to 400 copies per cell and used it to change the amount of telomeric DNA sequences per cell. An increase in the number of C1-3A sequences caused an increase in the length of telomeric C1-3A repeats that was proportional to plasmid copy number. Our data suggest that telomere growth is inhibited by a limiting factor(s) that specifically recognizes C1-3A sequences and that this factor can be effectively competed for by long tracts of C1-3A sequences at telomeres or on circular plasmids. Telomeres without this factor are exposed to processes that serve to lengthen chromosome ends.

Generation of different nucleosome spacing periodicities in vitro. Possible origin of cell type specificity

We have been able to generate ordered nucleosome arrays that span the physiological range of spacing periodicities, using an in vitro system. Our system (a refinement of the procedure previously developed) uses the synthetic polynucleotide poly[d(A-T)], poly[d(A-T)], core histones, purified H1, and polyglutamic acid, a factor that increases nucleohistone solubility and greatly promotes the formation of ordered nucleosome arrays. This system has three useful features, not found in other chromatin assembly systems. First, it allowed us to examine histones from three different cell types/species (sea urchin sperm, chicken erythrocyte, and HeLa) as homologous or heterologous combinations of core and H1 histones. Second, it allowed us to control the average packing density (core histone to polynucleotide weight ratio) of nucleosomes on the polynucleotide; histone H1 is added in a second distinct step in the procedure to induce nucleosome alignment. Third, it permitted us to study nucleosome array formation in the absence of DNA base sequence effects. We show that the value of the spacing periodicity is controlled by the value of the initial average nucleosome packing density. The full range of physiological periodicities appears to be accessible to arrays generated using chicken erythrocyte (or HeLa) core histones in combination with chicken H5. However, chromatin-like structures cannot be assembled for some nucleosome packing densities in reactions involving some histone types, thus limiting the range of periodicities that can be achieved. For example, H1 histone types differ significantly in their ability to recruit disordered nucleosomes into ordered arrays at low packing densities. Sea urchin sperm H1 is more efficient than chicken H5, which is more efficient than H1 from HeLa or chicken erythrocyte. Sea urchin sperm core histones are more efficient in this respect than the other core histone types used. These findings suggest how different repeat lengths arise in different cell types and species, and provide new insights into the problems of nucleosome linker heterogeneity and how different types of chromatin structures could be generated in the same cell.

Mapping protein-DNA interactions in vivo with formaldehyde: evidence that histone H4 is retained on a highly transcribed gene

We have used formaldehyde-mediated protein-DNA crosslinking within intact cells to examine the in vivo chromatin structure of the D. melanogaster heat shock protein 70 (hsp70) genes. In agreement with previous in vitro studies, we find that the heat shock-mediated transcriptional induction of the hsp70 genes perturbs their chromatin structure, resulting in fewer protein-DNA contacts crosslinkable in vivo by formaldehyde. However, contrary to earlier in vitro evidence that histones may be absent from actively transcribed genes, we show directly, by immunoprecipitation of in vivo-crosslinked chromatin fragments, that at least histone H4 remains bound to hsp70 DNA in vivo, irrespective of its rate of transcription. The formaldehyde-based in vivo mapping techniques described in this work are generally applicable, and can be used both to probe protein-DNA interactions within specific genes and to determine the genomic location of specific chromosomal proteins.

Telomeric DNA-protein interactions of Oxytricha macronuclear DNA

Telomeres of Oxytricha macronuclear chromatin exist as discrete nonnucleosomal DNA-protein complexes, each of which encompasses the terminal 100-150 bp of a macronuclear DNA molecule. We have used chemical and nuclease footprinting to examine the internal structure of these telomeric complexes. Remarkably salt-stable DNA-protein interactions result in methylation-protection of specific guanine residues in the 3'-terminal T4G4T4G4 tail. The methylation pattern seen in vivo and in isolated macronuclei is reconstituted in vitro when purified 55-kD and 43-kD telomere proteins are added to purified macronuclear DNA. Very different interactions are observed between protein and DNA within the region approximately 45-135 bp from the 5' terminus. The DNase I cleavage pattern indicates that this DNA lies on the outside surface of protein but is not part of a nucleosome. Our data suggest that the telomeric complexes have two structural domains characterized by their dissimilar DNA-protein interactions. We propose that functionally equivalent telomeres from other organisms could be accommodated in a similar telomeric chromatin structure.

The telomeres of Tetrahymena ribosomal DNA are not sufficient for stabilizing linear DNA in Xenopus oocytes

Restriction fragments that include the telomeres of ribosomal DNA from Tetrahymena thermophila (TtrDNA) were ligated to the ends of linearized simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA. The linear SV40 DNA with TtrDNA ends, circular SV40 DNA, linear SV40 DNA, and intact TtrDNA were injected into the nuclei of Xenopus laevis oocytes and assayed for stability. The intact linear 21-kb TtrDNA and circular SV40 DNA were maintained stably for at least 72 h after injection while the linearized SV40 DNA, either with or without telomeric ends, was degraded rapidly. Limited digestion with micrococcal nuclease revealed that neither the intact TtrDNA nor the SV40 DNA with telomeric ends reconstituted into chromatin containing regularly spaced nucleosomes. Another linearized plasmid DNA (pBamC), 14 kb in length, also was not stable in Xenopus oocytes with or without the addition of TtrDNA telomeres. Therefore, TtrDNA telomeres by themselves are not sufficient for stabilization of linear DNA in Xenopus oocytes. Rather, linear TtrDNA is maintained stably because of additional sequence or structural information encoded within the molecule.

Simian virus 40 protein VP1 is involved in spacing nucleosomes in minichromosomes

We have investigated the average nucleosome spacing in the chromatin from several simian virus 40 virion assembly mutants temperature-sensitive in the major capsid protein VP1. Viral assembly intermediates that accumulate in cells infected with mutants that block virion assembly at the propagation step (tsB) have an average nucleosome repeat length similar to that of wild-type SV40 chromatin, approximately 198(+/- 4) base-pairs. This repeat length is longer than that of the host (BSC-40) cellular chromatin, which has a value of 187(+/- 4) base-pairs. In contrast, SV40 chromatin from cells infected with virus containing a mutation that blocks virion assembly at the initiation step (tsC) has a significantly shorter average repeat length of 177(+/- 4) base-pairs. At the permissive temperature (33 degrees C), tsC chromatin has a nucleosome spacing periodicity essentially the same as that of wild-type SV40 chromatin. In addition to possessing a chromatin structure with nucleosomes that are, on the average, closer together, tsC chromatin contains a nuclease-hypersensitive or open region in nearly all molecules, but apparently the same number of nucleosomes. These findings suggest that nucleosomes are deposited initially on newly replicated SV40 chromatin in such a way as to leave the DNA region containing the origin of replication and transcription enhancers uncovered. Subsequent interaction with capsid proteins appears to increase the average nucleosome spacing and consequently to cover the open region for encapsidation.

Histones and their modifications

Histones constitute the protein core around which DNA is coiled to form the basic structural unit of the chromosome known as the nucleosome. Because of the large amount of new histone needed during chromosome replication, the synthesis of histone and DNA is regulated in a complex manner. During RNA transcription and DNA replication, the basic nucleosomal structure as well as interactions between nucleosomes must be greatly altered to allow access to the appropriate enzymes and factors. The presence of extensive and varied post-translational modifications to the otherwise highly conserved histone primary sequences provides obvious opportunities for such structural alterations, but despite concentrated and sustained effort, causal connections between histone modifications and nucleosomal functions are not yet elucidated.

Preferential DNase I sensitivity of insert-free ribosomal RNA repeats of Drosophila melanogaster

The five predominant types of rDNA repeats in D. melanogaster were analyzed with respect to their DNase I sensitivity. Only the insert-free repeats showed a generalized DNase I sensitivity pattern whereas the major type I, both minor type I and type II repeats were not as extensively degraded by the nuclease. For XX and XY embryonic nuclei, where there is rapid cell division, the majority of the In- repeats were DNase I sensitive. This indicated that these In- repeats have the potential to be transcribed during this developmental stage. When compared to the In- repeats, the chromatin configuration of the In+ repeats is indicative of a higher order of chromatin folding. The paucity of In+ primary gene transcripts observed in vivo could result from In+ repeats being packaged into a more condensed form of chromatin.

A model chromatin assembly system. Factors affecting nucleosome spacing

Poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)], when reconstituted with chicken erythrocyte core histones and subsequently incubated with sufficient histone H5 in a solution containing polyglutamic acid, forms structures resembling chromatin. H5 induces nucleosome alignment in about two hours at physiological ionic strength and 37 degrees C. The nucleosome spacing and apparent linker heterogeneity in the assembled nucleoprotein are very similar to those in chicken erythrocyte chromatin. Also, condensed chromatin-like fibers on the polynucleotide can be visualized. The binding of one mole of H5 per mole of core octamer is necessary to generate the physiological nucleosome spacing, which remains constant with the addition of more H5. The nucleosome repeat length is not a function of the core histone to poly[d(A-T)] ratio for values lower than the physiological ratio. With increasing ratios, in excess of the physiological value, nucleosome spacing first becomes non-uniform, and then takes on the close packing limit of approximately 165 base-pairs. In addition to eliminating possible base sequence effects on nucleosome positioning, poly[d(A-T)] allows nucleosomes to slide more readily than does DNA, thereby facilitating alignment. Evidence is presented that polyglutamic acid facilitates the nucleosome spacing activity of histone H5, primarily by keeping the nucleoprotein soluble. This model system should be useful for understanding how different repeat lengths arise in chromatin.

Transcriptionally active chromatin

Eukaryotic chromatin has a dynamic, complex hierarchical structure. Active gene transcription takes place on only a small proportion of it at a time. While many workers have tried to characterize active chromatin, we are still far from understanding all the biochemical, morphological and compositional features that distinguish it from inactive nuclear material. Active genes are apparently packaged in an altered nucleosome structure and are associated with domains of chromatin that are less condensed or more open than inactive domains. Active genes are more sensitive to nuclease digestions and probably contain specific nonhistone proteins which may establish and/or maintain the active state. Variant or modified histones as well as altered configurations or modifications of the DNA itself may likewise be involved. Practically nothing is known about the mechanisms that control these nuclear characteristics. However, controlled accessibility to regions of chromatin and specific sequences of DNA may be one of the primary regulatory mechanisms by which higher cells establish potentially active chromatin domains. Another control mechanism may be compartmentalization of active chromatin to certain regions within the nucleus, perhaps to the nuclear matrix. Topological constraints and DNA supercoiling may influence the active regions of chromatin and be involved in eukaryotic genomic functions. Further, the chromatin structure of various DNA regulatory sequences, such as promoters, terminators and enhancers, appears to partially regulate transcriptional activity.

Chromatin structure of the molecular ends of Oxytricha macronuclear DNA: phased nucleosomes and a telomeric complex

Oxytricha macronuclear DNA exists as approximately 24 X 10(6) gene-sized molecules terminating with a C4A4 repeat. DNA-protein interactions at the ends of bulk macronuclear molecules were probed with micrococcal nuclease and methidiumpropyl-EDTA X Fe(II) (MPE X Fe[II]). The ends were indirectly labeled by hybridizing with (C4A4)2. Alternatively, a novel method using MPE X FE(II) as a probe and directly labeling the 3' ends with terminal transferase was implemented. A terminal complex involving approximately 100 bp with nucleosomes phased inward from the complex was found to be characteristic of most or all of the ends. Analysis of two specific genes confirmed the pattern and showed that the special structure was on both ends of each molecule. We conclude that a DNA-protein complex involving 100 bp and terminating with the C4A4 repeat can be sufficient to provide the fundamental functions of telomeres, allowing linear DNA replication and conferring stability of linear DNA.

A protein binds to a satellite DNA repeat at three specific sites that would be brought into mutual proximity by DNA folding in the nucleosome

Using a generally applicable assay for specific DNA-binding proteins in crude extracts, we have detected and purified an HMG-like nuclear protein from African green monkey cells that preferentially binds to the 172 bp repeat of alpha-satellite DNA (alpha-DNA). DNAase I footprinting with the purified protein detects three specific binding sites (I-III) per alpha-DNA repeat. Site II is 145 bp (one core nucleosome length) from site III on the adjacent alpha-DNA repeat, while site I lies midway between sites II and III. In the alpha-nucleosome phasing frame corresponding with this arrangement, sites I-III would be brought into mutual proximity by DNA folding in the nucleosome. This phasing frame is identical with the preferred frame detected previously in isolated chromatin. Our results suggest that this new and abundant protein recognizes a family of short, related nucleotide sequences found not only in alpha-DNA but also throughout the genome, and that functions of this protein are mediated through its nucleosome-positioning activity. Such nucleosome-positioning proteins may underlie the sequence specificity of both nucleosome arrangements and higher order chromatin structures.

Comparison of the active and inactive chromatin structures of genes transcribed by RNA polymerases I and II

The coding sequences of the yeast 35S rDNA gene and of the yeast galactokinase gene both show clear staphylococcal nuclease nucleosome profiles under conditions in which the gene is inactive (galactokinase) or less active (rDNA). Under conditions of more active expression, the galactokinase gene shows marked smearing in the digestion profiles. The rDNA gene shows a qualitatively similar change in digestion patterns. There is a typical nucleosomal DNase I ladder on the coding sequences of both genes, regardless of the state of activity. In contrast to the coding sequences, the rDNA upstream region chromatin shows a nonnucleosomal profile. The nonnucleosomal character is more pronounced when the gene is more active. On the galactokinase upstream region chromatin, there is a nucleosomal structure, with some minor modifications, when the gene is inactive and a clear nonnucleosomal structure when the gene is expressed.

Chromatin structure at the replication origins and transcription-initiation regions of the ribosomal RNA genes of Tetrahymena

The chromatin structure of regulatory regions of the extrachromosomal rRNA genes of Tetrahymena thermophila was probed by nuclease treatment of isolated nuclei. The chromatin near the origins of replication contains hypersensitive sites for micrococcal nuclease, DNAase I, and DNAase II. These sites persist in starved cells, consistent with the origins' being maintained in an altered chromatin structure independent of DNA replication. The region between the two origins of replication is organized into a phased array of seven nucleosomes, the fourth of which is centered at the axis of symmetry of the palindromic rDNA. The entire transcribed region and 150 bp upstream from the initiation site are generally accessible to nucleases; any histone proteins associated with these regions are clearly not in a highly organized nucleosomal array as seen in the central region. Comparison of the chromatin structures of the central spacer of T. thermophila and T. pyriformis rDNA reveals that deletion or insertion of DNA has occurred in increments of 200 bp. This is taken to imply that there are constraints on the evolution of spacer DNA sequences at the level of the nucleosome.

Reversible changes in nucleosome structure and histone H3 accessibility in transcriptionally active and inactive states of rDNA chromatin

The sulfhydryl reagent iodoacetamidofluorescein (IAF) was used to probe the structure of chromatin subunits in transcribed and nontranscribed regions of Physarum rDNA. IAF labels histone H3 -SH groups in the elongated monomeric subunits (A particles) from the transcribed region, but it does not label H3 in the 11S monomers from the nontranscribed central spacer. All H3 reactivity is lost from rDNA chromatin in the inactive spherule stage of Physarum. Restriction cleavage of rDNA chromatin generates fragments from the transcription unit with reactive H3 -SH groups, whereas fragments containing nontranscribed spacer sequences are unreactive. The extended rDNA chromatin contains all four core histones and other prominent proteins. Electron microscopy shows that most of the extended subunits consist of two roughly spherical bodies connected by a 50 bp nucleoprotein bridge.

Nucleosome phasing in Tetrahymena macronuclei

Core-protected DNA can drive only 60% of the Tetrahymena thermophila macronuclear genome into duplexes in hybridization experiments. This core-protected DNA therefore contains only a subset of the genome complexity. We interpret this to mean that a large fraction, if not all, of the genome is phased with respect to nucleosome placement. Among the sequences present in total DNA and absent from core-protected DNA are most of the sequences containing N6-methyladenine (MeAde) residues, consistent with our previous demonstration that most of these residues lie in linker DNA. We show that these results are not due to artifacts resulting from the small size of the DNA driver, nor are they due to any sequence preferences exhibited by staphylococcal (staph) nuclease. This is the first evidence that nucleosome phasing may be a bulk genome characteristic.