Presence of a limited number of essential nucleotides in the promoter region of mouse ribosomal RNA gene

DNA binding preferences of S. cerevisiae RNA polymerase I Core Factor reveal a preference for the GC-minor groove and a conserved binding mechanism

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Core Factor (CF) is a key evolutionarily conserved transcription initiation factor that helps recruit RNA polymerase I (Pol I) to the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) promoter. Upregulated Pol I transcription has been linked to many cancers, and targeting Pol I is an attractive and emerging anti-cancer strategy. Using yeast as a model system, we characterized how CF binds to the Pol I promoter by electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA). Synthetic DNA competitors along with anti-tumor drugs and nucleic acid stains that act as DNA groove blockers were used to discover the binding preference of yeast CF. Our results show that CF employs a unique binding mechanism where it prefers the GC-rich minor groove within the rDNA promoter. In addition, we show that yeast CF is able to bind to the human rDNA promoter sequence that is divergent in DNA sequence and demonstrate CF sensitivity to the human specific Pol I inhibitor, CX-5461. Finally, we show that the human Core Promoter Element (CPE) can functionally replace the yeast Core Element (CE) in vivo when aligned by conserved DNA structural features rather than DNA sequence. Together, these findings suggest that the yeast CF and the human ortholog Selectivity Factor 1 (SL1) use an evolutionarily conserved, structure-based mechanism to target DNA. Their shared mechanism may offer a new avenue in using yeast to explore current and future Pol I anti-cancer compounds.

Reconstitution of human rRNA gene transcription in mouse cells by a complete SL1 complex

An important characteristic of the transcription of a ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA) mediated by DNA-dependent RNA polymerase (Pol) I is its stringent species specificity. SL1/TIF-IB is a key complex for species specificity, but its functional complex has not been reconstituted. Here, we established a novel and highly sensitive monitoring system for Pol I transcription to reconstitute the SL1 activity in which a transcript harboring a reporter gene synthesized by Pol I is amplified and converted into translatable mRNA by the influenza virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. Using this monitoring system, we reconstituted Pol I transcription from the human rDNA promoter in mouse cells by expressing four human TATA-binding protein (TBP)-associated factors (TAFIs) in the SL1 complex. The reconstituted SL1 also re-activated human rDNA transcription in mouse A9 cells carrying an inactive human chromosome 21 that contains the rDNA cluster. Chimeric SL1 complexes containing human and mouse TAFIs could be formed, but these complexes were inactive for human rDNA transcription. We conclude that four human TAFIs are necessary and sufficient to overcome the barrier of species specificity for human rDNA transcription in mouse cells.

Identification of a novel 70 kDa protein that binds to the core promoter element and is essential for ribosomal DNA transcription

Mammalian ribosomal RNA genes (rDNA) are transcribed by RNA polymerase I and at least two auxiliary factors, UBF and SL1/TFID/TIF-IB. It has also been reported that an additional factor(s) is required to reconstitute efficient initiation of rDNA transcription in vitro, depending upon the procedures of chromatographic separation. In an attempt to elucidate the molecular identity of such yet uncertain activities, we have developed agarose gel shift and UV cross-linking assays to detect proteins directly bound to the core promoter region of murine rDNA. With these techniques, we identified a 70 kDa protein (p70) in the flow-through fraction of a phosphocellulose column (TFIA-fraction). Interestingly, the binding of p70 to the rDNA core promoter was observed only in the presence of the SL1-containing fraction. The probable human orthologue of p70 was also detected in HeLa cells. Consistent with the observation that p70 bound to the core promoter only in the presence of the TFIA- and SL1-fractions, alteration of DNase I footprint pattern over the core promoter element was demonstrated by cooperative action of the TFIA- and SL1-fractions. A reconstituted in vitro transcription assay with further purified p70 indicated that p70 was required for accurate initiation of rDNA transcription. These results indicate that the p70 identified recently by the current DNA-binding experiments represents a novel transcription factor in rDNA transcription.

Single-stranded DNA-protein binding in the procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) promoter of Trypanosoma brucei

We performed gel retardation analyses of DNA-protein interactions using DNA from the procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) promoter of the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma brucei. The PARP genes of Trypanosoma brucei are transcribed in an alpha-amanitin resistant manner, and it has been proposed that RNA polymerase I, rather than RNA polymerase II, transcribes the PARP genes. Double-stranded restriction fragments containing the essential PARP-promoter regions bound only sequence-nonspecific nuclear factors, even though protein factors that bind specifically to double-stranded DNA from the snRNA U2 promoter were present in the extracts. In contrast, single-stranded DNA-binding proteins bound with high affinity, nucleotide-sequence and strand-specificity to the -69/-55 element and the coding and non-coding strands of the -37/-11 element.

The promoter for the procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) genes of Trypanosoma brucei shares features with RNA polymerase I promoters

All eukaryotic protein-coding genes are believed to be transcribed by RNA polymerase (Pol) II. An exception may exist in the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma brucei, in which the genes encoding the variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) and procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) are transcribed by an RNA polymerase that is resistant to the Pol II inhibitor alpha-amanitin. The PARP and VSG genes were proposed to be transcribed by Pol I (C. Shea, M. G.-S. Lee, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, Cell 50:603-612, 1987; G. Rudenko, M. G.-S. Lee, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, Nucleic Acids Res. 20:303-306, 1992), a suggestion that has been substantiated by the finding that trypanosomes can transcribe protein-coding genes by Pol I (G. Rudenko, H.-M. Chung, V. P. Pham, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, EMBO J. 10:3387-3397, 1991). We analyzed the sequence elements of the PARP promoter by linker scanning mutagenesis and compared the PARP promoter with Pol I, Pol II, and Pol III promoters. The PARP promoter appeared to be of limited complexity and contained at least two critical regions. The first was located adjacent to the transcription initiation site (nucleotides [nt] -69 to +12) and contained three discrete domains in which linker scanning mutants affected the transcriptional efficiency: at nt -69 to -56, -37 to -11, and -11 to +12. The second region was located between nt -140 and -131, and a third region may be located between nt -228 and -205. The nucleotide sequences of these elements, and their relative positioning with respect to the transcription initiation site did not resemble those of either Pol II or Pol III promoter elements, but rather reflected the organization of Pol I promoters in (i) similarity in the positioning of essential domains in the PARP promoter and Pol I promoter, (ii) strong sequence homology between the PARP core promoter element (nt -37 to -11) and identically positioned nucleotide sequences in the trypanosome rRNA and VSG gene promoters, and (iii) moderate effects on promoter activity of mutations around the transcription initiation site.

The promoter for the procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) genes of Trypanosoma brucei shares features with RNA polymerase I promoters

All eukaryotic protein-coding genes are believed to be transcribed by RNA polymerase (Pol) II. An exception may exist in the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma brucei, in which the genes encoding the variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) and procyclic acidic repetitive protein (PARP) are transcribed by an RNA polymerase that is resistant to the Pol II inhibitor alpha-amanitin. The PARP and VSG genes were proposed to be transcribed by Pol I (C. Shea, M. G.-S. Lee, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, Cell 50:603-612, 1987; G. Rudenko, M. G.-S. Lee, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, Nucleic Acids Res. 20:303-306, 1992), a suggestion that has been substantiated by the finding that trypanosomes can transcribe protein-coding genes by Pol I (G. Rudenko, H.-M. Chung, V. P. Pham, and L. H. T. Van der Ploeg, EMBO J. 10:3387-3397, 1991). We analyzed the sequence elements of the PARP promoter by linker scanning mutagenesis and compared the PARP promoter with Pol I, Pol II, and Pol III promoters. The PARP promoter appeared to be of limited complexity and contained at least two critical regions. The first was located adjacent to the transcription initiation site (nucleotides [nt] -69 to +12) and contained three discrete domains in which linker scanning mutants affected the transcriptional efficiency: at nt -69 to -56, -37 to -11, and -11 to +12. The second region was located between nt -140 and -131, and a third region may be located between nt -228 and -205. The nucleotide sequences of these elements, and their relative positioning with respect to the transcription initiation site did not resemble those of either Pol II or Pol III promoter elements, but rather reflected the organization of Pol I promoters in (i) similarity in the positioning of essential domains in the PARP promoter and Pol I promoter, (ii) strong sequence homology between the PARP core promoter element (nt -37 to -11) and identically positioned nucleotide sequences in the trypanosome rRNA and VSG gene promoters, and (iii) moderate effects on promoter activity of mutations around the transcription initiation site.

Cloning and structural analysis of cDNA and the gene for mouse transcription factor UBF

The gene and protein structure of the mouse UBF (mUBF), a transcription factor for mouse ribosomal RNA gene, have been determined by cDNA and genomic clones. The unique mUBF gene consists of 21 exons spanning over 13 kb. Two mRNAs coding for mUBF1 and mUBF2 having 765 a.a. and 728 a.a., respectively, are produced by an alternative splicing of exon 8. It specifies 37 amino acids constituting a part of the regions homologous to high mobility group proteins (HMG box 2). A human UBF (hUBF) cDNA obtained by polymerase chain reaction also indicates the presence of two kinds of mRNAs, the shorter form lacking the same region as mUBF2. Comparison of the cDNAs from hUBF and mUBF revealed an unusual conservation of nucleotide sequence in the 3'-terminal non-coding region. We examined the relative amounts of expression of mUBF1 and mUBF2. The eight tissues studied contained both molecular species, although mUBF2 was the predominant form of UBF. The mRNA of mUBF1 was expressed one half of the mUBF2 in quiescent mouse fibroblasts but reached the same amount in growing state.

Identification of two forms of the RNA polymerase I transcription factor UBF

The structure of the rat homologue of the RNA polymerase I transcription factor UBF was investigated. The sequence of the protein was deduced from the sequence of overlapping cDNAs isolated from a cDNA library and from clones of the products generated by the polymerase chain reaction from random-primed, first-strand cDNA. The sequences of these clones indicated that there were two mRNAs for UBF and that the encoded proteins were similar but not identical. One form of rat UBF was essentially identical to human UBF. The second class of UBF mRNA contained an in-frame "deletion" in the coding region that results in the deletion of 37 amino acids from the predicted protein sequence. This deletion reduces the predicted molecular size of the encoded form of UBF by approximately 4400 from 89.4 kDa to 85 kDa and significantly alters the structure of one of the four HMG-1 homology regions (HMG box-2) in that form of UBF. Evidence for the existence of two mRNAs in rat cells was confirmed by a probe protection assay, and we provide evidence that other vertebrate cells contain these same two forms of UBF mRNA. These results are consistent with the observation that UBF purified from four different vertebrates migrates as two bands upon SDS/PAGE. It has been hypothesized that the HMG motifs are the DNA-binding domains of UBF. Altering one of these "boxes," as in the second form of UBF, may alter the functional characteristics of the transcription factor. Thus, the existence of different forms of UBF may have important ramifications for transcription by RNA polymerase I.

Structure of the core promoter of human and mouse ribosomal RNA gene. Asymmetry of species-specific transcription

In vitro transcription of the ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA) shows a remarkable species specificity such that human and mouse rDNA cannot use heterologous extracts of each other. The region that is responsible for this specificity has been studied using human-mouse chimeric genes and characteristic structures of both core promoters are presented. When the mouse sequence is substituted by the corresponding human sequence from upstream, the promoter activity in the mouse extract begins to decline at nucleotide -32 or -30, decreasing gradually and is lost completely at -19. A similar gradual decrease was noted for the 3' side substitution, which started at nucleotide -14 and was completed when up to the nucleotide -22 mouse position was replaced by the corresponding sequence from human. Thus, in the mouse rDNA core promoter, the sequence that is involved in species specificity resides only in a stretch encompassing the non-conserved region between the distal conserved sequence (DCS) and the proximal conserved sequence (PCS), plus two altered nucleotides in the PCS. When human rDNA is transcribed with human cell extract, the mouse sequence cannot substitute for the human sequence within the region from nucleotide -43 to +17 without affecting promoter activity significantly. This asymmetry of species specificity is due to the presence of nucleotides -43, +1 and +17, which are sensitive to change in only the human core promoter. The difference in the 5' border is ascribed to the species specificity of a transcription factor TFID, which recognizes this region. But the large difference of the 3' border is apparently due to another factor, possibly RNA polymerase I itself, because this region is not recognized by TFID in either human or mouse. Mammalian rDNA core promoter appears to consist of a tandem mosaic in which three evolutionarily conserved sequences alternate with non-conserved sequences having certain functionally important nucleotides. Not only non-conserved sequences and non-conserved nucleotides in conserved sequences, but also the spacings between the three conserved regions, play a crucial role in species specificity.

News from the nucleolus: rRNA gene expression

Although the typical, actively growing eukaryotic cell contains over 10,000 different transcripts, half of its RNA synthetic capacity is devoted to the production of a single kind of RNA. This is the pre-ribosomal RNA, which is synthesized in a special compartment of the nucleus, the nucleolus, and is the exclusive product of transcription by RNA polymerase I. In vivo and in vitro approaches have revealed the major features of rRNA gene transcription and of the subsequent processing of the primary transcript.

Mouse U14 snRNA is encoded in an intron of the mouse cognate hsc70 heat shock gene

Mouse U14 snRNA (previously designated mouse 4.5S hybRNA) is an evolutionarily conserved eukaryotic low molecular weight RNA capable of intermolecular hybridization with both homologous and heterologous 18S rRNA (1). A single genomic fragment of mouse DNA containing the U14 snRNA gene(s) has been isolated from a Charon 4A lambda phage mouse genomic library and sequenced. Results have surprisingly revealed the presence of three U14 snRNA-homologous regions positioned within introns 5, 6, and 8 of the mouse cognate hsc70 heat shock gene. Comparative analysis with the previously reported rat and human cognate hsc70 genes revealed a similar positioning of U14 snRNA-homologous sequences within introns 5, 6 and 8 of the respective rat and human genes. The U14 sequences contained in all three introns of all three organisms are highly homologous to each other and well conserved with respect to the diverging intron sequences flanking each U14-homologous sequence. Comparison of the mouse U14 snRNA sequence with the U14 DNA sequences contained in the three mouse hsc70 introns indicates that intron 5 is utilized for U14 snRNA synthesis in normally growing mouse ascites cells. Analysis of the determined mouse, rat, and human U14-homologous sequences and the upstream and downstream flanking regions did not reveal the presence of any previously defined RNA polymerase I, II, or III binding sites. This suggests that either higher eukaryotic U14 snRNA is transcribed from a unique transcriptional promoter sequence, or alternatively, is generated by intron processing of the hsc70 pre-mRNA transcript.

Characterization of factors that direct transcription of rat ribosomal DNA

The protein components that direct and activate accurate transcription by rat RNA polymerase I were studied in extracts of Novikoff hepatoma ascites cells. A minimum of at least two components, besides RNA polymerase I, that are necessary for efficient utilization of templates were identified. The first factor, rat SL-1, is required for species-specific recognition of the rat RNA polymerase I promoter and may be sufficient to direct transcription by pure RNA polymerase I. Rat SL-1 directed the transcription of templates deleted to -31, the 5' boundary of the core promoter element (+1 being the transcription initiation site). The second factor, rUBF, increased the efficiency of template utilization. Transcription of deletion mutants indicated that the 5' boundary of the domain required for rUBF lay between -137 and -127. Experiments using block substitution mutants confirmed and extended these observations. Transcription experiments using those mutants demonstrated that two regions within the upstream promoter element were required for optimal levels of transcription in vitro. The first region was centered on nucleotides -129 and -124. The 5' boundary of the second domain mapped to between nucleotides -106 and -101. DNase footprint experiments using highly purified rUBF indicated that rUBF bound between -130 and -50. However, mutation of nucleotides -129 and -124 did not affect the rUBF footprint. These results indicate that basal levels of transcription by RNA polymerase I may require only SL-1 and the core promoter element. However, higher transcription levels are mediated by additional interactions of rUBF, and possibly SL-1, bound to distal promoter elements.

Structural analysis of the short length ribosomal DNA variant from Pisum sativum L. cv. Alaska

The genomic clone, RRNpss1, representing the short ribosomal DNA length variant in Pisum sativum L. cv. Alaska, has been isolated and the 2859 bp intergenic spacer, along with the 25S rRNA 3' border and 18S rRNA 5' border, has been sequenced. The intergenic spacer contains nine tandem repeats, approximately 180 bp in length, which show greater than 80% sequence homology to each other. The RNA polymerase I transcription start site and a processing site, located 776 bp and 536 bp upstream of the 5' end of 18S rRNA, respectively, have been determined using S1 analysis. The region surrounding the +1 site shows strong homology between the positions -6 to +10 to the rDNA sites of initiation in radish, maize, and wheat. The sequence CATGCAAA is located 19 bp upstream of the site of initiation, and appears once within each subrepeat and twice more between the end of the subrepeat array and the site of initiation. A previously characterized HpaII site which shows developmental regulation of methylation is located 31 bp downstream of the site of initiation. Using RFLP linkage analysis, the short rDNA length variant of cv. Alaska is assigned to Chromosome 4 where it is genetically independent of the long rDNA length variant which is putatively assigned to Chromosome 7.

Characterization of factors that direct transcription of rat ribosomal DNA

The protein components that direct and activate accurate transcription by rat RNA polymerase I were studied in extracts of Novikoff hepatoma ascites cells. A minimum of at least two components, besides RNA polymerase I, that are necessary for efficient utilization of templates were identified. The first factor, rat SL-1, is required for species-specific recognition of the rat RNA polymerase I promoter and may be sufficient to direct transcription by pure RNA polymerase I. Rat SL-1 directed the transcription of templates deleted to -31, the 5' boundary of the core promoter element (+1 being the transcription initiation site). The second factor, rUBF, increased the efficiency of template utilization. Transcription of deletion mutants indicated that the 5' boundary of the domain required for rUBF lay between -137 and -127. Experiments using block substitution mutants confirmed and extended these observations. Transcription experiments using those mutants demonstrated that two regions within the upstream promoter element were required for optimal levels of transcription in vitro. The first region was centered on nucleotides -129 and -124. The 5' boundary of the second domain mapped to between nucleotides -106 and -101. DNase footprint experiments using highly purified rUBF indicated that rUBF bound between -130 and -50. However, mutation of nucleotides -129 and -124 did not affect the rUBF footprint. These results indicate that basal levels of transcription by RNA polymerase I may require only SL-1 and the core promoter element. However, higher transcription levels are mediated by additional interactions of rUBF, and possibly SL-1, bound to distal promoter elements.

Interaction of RNA polymerase I transcription factors with a promoter in the nontranscribed spacer of rat ribosomal DNA

The spacer promoter of the rat rDNA repeat consists of two functional domains: a core (proximal) element that is sufficient for transcription in vitro, and an upstream (distal) promoter element that increases the efficiency of transcription. Two of the transcription factors that interact with the 45S promoter also interact with the spacer promoter. Rat SL-1, is required for transcription of the spacer promoter by heterologous extracts, e.g. human, and rat SF-1 is required for efficient transcription in vitro. Order-of-addition experiments demonstrated that the preinitiation complex formed by these factors on the spacer promoter is not as stable as the complex formed on the 45S promoter. DNase 1 footprinting experiments demonstrated binding sites for rat SL-1 and SF-1 on the distal element of the spacer promoter. The topology of the domains of the spacer promoter may explain both the reduced stability of the preinitiation complex formed on that promoter and the lower efficiency of transcription of that promoter when compared to the 45S promoter.

Point mutation analysis of the Xenopus laevis RNA polymerase I core promoter

The core region of the Xenopus laevis pre-ribosomal RNA promoter was subjected to point mutation analysis. A total of 27 point mutants within a 78 base pair region from -64 to +14, (relative to the start of transcription at +1), were assayed by oocyte microinjection. The results locate the 3' boundary of the core promoter at +4 and the 5' boundary at between -33 and -39 and suggest that this region of the Xenopus promoter is generally similar in organisation to mammalian core promoters. In particular, the conserved guanidine nucleotides at -7 and -16 are clearly essential for promoter function. The data suggest that interactions between the transcription machinery and the promoter occur in four distinct regions around +2 to +4, -7, -17 to -20 and -28 to -33. This particular periodicity of functionally important nucleotides is consistent with a model in which all protein-DNA interactions take place from predominantly one side of the DNA helix.

An RNA polymerase I promoter located in the CHO and mouse ribosomal DNA spacers: functional analysis and factor and sequence requirements

We report results of experiments in which we demonstrated the existence of a polymerase I promoter within the ribosomal DNA spacer upstream from the rRNA initiation site in Chinese hamsters and mice. Transcription of the CHO spacer promoter was achieved by the same protein factors, C and D, that catalyzed transcription of the gene promoter, and these factors bound stably to the CHO spacer promoter in a preinitiation complex, just as they did to the gene promoter. In contrast to the CHO spacer promoter, which was transcribed in vitro nearly as efficiently as the gene promoter, the mouse spacer promoter was far less active; this low activity was attributable to the fact that the mouse spacer promoter bound factor D inefficiently. It is striking that the active CHO spacer promoter violated the otherwise universal rule that metazoan RNA polymerase I promoters all have a G residue at position -16. Sequence comparisons also revealed a great similarity between the CHO and mouse spacer promoter regions, yet there was much less similarity between the flanking sequences. There was also only limited homology between the spacer and gene promoter regions, but despite this the two kinds of initiation regions were organized similarly, both consisting of an essential core promoter domain and a stimulatory domain that extended upstream to approximately residue -135. Evolutionary considerations argue strongly that the presence of ribosomal DNA spacer promoters offers a significant selective advantage.

Structural determinant of the species-specific transcription of the mouse rRNA gene promoter

Mammalian ribosomal DNA (rDNA) transcription has a certain species specificity such that, both in vivo and in vitro, human rDNA cannot be transcribed by mouse machinery and vice versa. This is due to a species-dependent transcription factor, TFID (Y. Mishima, I. Financsek, R. Kominami, and M. Muramatsu, Nucleic Acids Res. 10:6659-6670, 1982). On the basis of the information obtained from 5' and 3' substitution mutants, we prepared a chimeric gene in which the mouse sequence from positions -32 to -14 was inserted into the corresponding location of the human rDNA promoter. The chimeric gene could be transcribed by mouse extracts nearly as efficiently as the wild-type mouse promoter. The chimeric gene could also sequester transcription factor TFID at an efficiency similar to that for the mouse promoter. Partially purified mouse TFID that could not protect the human rDNA promoter against DNase I produced a clear footprint on this chimeric gene that was similar to that on mouse rDNA promoter. The basic structure of the mouse rDNA core promoter is discussed in relation to the interaction with TFID.

An RNA polymerase I promoter located in the CHO and mouse ribosomal DNA spacers: functional analysis and factor and sequence requirements

We report results of experiments in which we demonstrated the existence of a polymerase I promoter within the ribosomal DNA spacer upstream from the rRNA initiation site in Chinese hamsters and mice. Transcription of the CHO spacer promoter was achieved by the same protein factors, C and D, that catalyzed transcription of the gene promoter, and these factors bound stably to the CHO spacer promoter in a preinitiation complex, just as they did to the gene promoter. In contrast to the CHO spacer promoter, which was transcribed in vitro nearly as efficiently as the gene promoter, the mouse spacer promoter was far less active; this low activity was attributable to the fact that the mouse spacer promoter bound factor D inefficiently. It is striking that the active CHO spacer promoter violated the otherwise universal rule that metazoan RNA polymerase I promoters all have a G residue at position -16. Sequence comparisons also revealed a great similarity between the CHO and mouse spacer promoter regions, yet there was much less similarity between the flanking sequences. There was also only limited homology between the spacer and gene promoter regions, but despite this the two kinds of initiation regions were organized similarly, both consisting of an essential core promoter domain and a stimulatory domain that extended upstream to approximately residue -135. Evolutionary considerations argue strongly that the presence of ribosomal DNA spacer promoters offers a significant selective advantage.

Structural determinant of the species-specific transcription of the mouse rRNA gene promoter

Mammalian ribosomal DNA (rDNA) transcription has a certain species specificity such that, both in vivo and in vitro, human rDNA cannot be transcribed by mouse machinery and vice versa. This is due to a species-dependent transcription factor, TFID (Y. Mishima, I. Financsek, R. Kominami, and M. Muramatsu, Nucleic Acids Res. 10:6659-6670, 1982). On the basis of the information obtained from 5' and 3' substitution mutants, we prepared a chimeric gene in which the mouse sequence from positions -32 to -14 was inserted into the corresponding location of the human rDNA promoter. The chimeric gene could be transcribed by mouse extracts nearly as efficiently as the wild-type mouse promoter. The chimeric gene could also sequester transcription factor TFID at an efficiency similar to that for the mouse promoter. Partially purified mouse TFID that could not protect the human rDNA promoter against DNase I produced a clear footprint on this chimeric gene that was similar to that on mouse rDNA promoter. The basic structure of the mouse rDNA core promoter is discussed in relation to the interaction with TFID.

Effects of single-base substitutions within the Acanthamoeba castellanii rRNA promoter on transcription and on binding of transcription initiation factor and RNA polymerase I

Single-point mutations were introduced into the promoter region of the Acanthamoeba castellanii rRNA gene by chemical mutagen treatment of a single-stranded clone in vitro, followed by reverse transcription and cloning of the altered fragment. The promoter mutants were tested for transcription initiation factor (TIF) binding by a template commitment assay plus DNase I footprinting and for transcription by an in vitro runoff assay. Point mutations within the previously identified TIF interaction region (between -20 and -47, motifs A and B) indicated that TIF interacts most strongly with a sequence centered at -29 and less tightly with sequences upstream and downstream. Some alterations of the base sequence closer to the transcription start site (and outside the TIF-protected site) also significantly decreased specific RNA synthesis in vitro. These were within the region which is protected from DNase I digestion by polymerase I, but these mutations did not detectably affect the binding of polymerase to the promoter.

Effects of single-base substitutions within the Acanthamoeba castellanii rRNA promoter on transcription and on binding of transcription initiation factor and RNA polymerase I

Single-point mutations were introduced into the promoter region of the Acanthamoeba castellanii rRNA gene by chemical mutagen treatment of a single-stranded clone in vitro, followed by reverse transcription and cloning of the altered fragment. The promoter mutants were tested for transcription initiation factor (TIF) binding by a template commitment assay plus DNase I footprinting and for transcription by an in vitro runoff assay. Point mutations within the previously identified TIF interaction region (between -20 and -47, motifs A and B) indicated that TIF interacts most strongly with a sequence centered at -29 and less tightly with sequences upstream and downstream. Some alterations of the base sequence closer to the transcription start site (and outside the TIF-protected site) also significantly decreased specific RNA synthesis in vitro. These were within the region which is protected from DNase I digestion by polymerase I, but these mutations did not detectably affect the binding of polymerase to the promoter.

Analysis of clustered point mutations in the human ribosomal RNA gene promoter by transient expression in vivo

We have mapped the cis regulatory elements required in vivo for initiation at the human rRNA promoter by RNA polymerase I. Transient expression in COS-7 cells was used to evaluate the transcription phenotype of clustered base substitution mutations in the human rRNA promoter. The promoter consists of two major elements: a large upstream region, composed of several domains, that lies between nucleotides -234 and -107 relative to the transcription initiation site and affects transcription up to 100-fold and a core element that lies between nucleotides -45 and +20 and affects transcription up to 1000-fold. The upstream region is able to retain partial function when positioned within 100-160 nucleotides of the transcription initiation site, but it cannot stimulate transcription from distances of greater than or equal to 600 nucleotides. In addition, we demonstrate, using mouse-human hybrid rRNA promoters, that the sequences responsible for human species-specific transcription in vivo appear to reside in both the core and upstream elements, and sequences from the mouse rRNA promoter cannot be substituted for them.

Additional RNA polymerase I initiation site within the nontranscribed spacer region of the rat rRNA gene

We identified and characterized an additional promoter within the nontranscribed spacer (NTS) of the rat ribosomal gene repeat that is capable of supporting initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase I in vitro. Within this promoter there is a sequence of 13 nucleotides which is 100% homologous to nucleotides -18 to -6 (+1 being the first nucleotide of 45S rRNA) of the major promoter of 45S pre-rRNA and is located between nucleotides -731 and -719. To identify the exact location of the upstream initiation site, the RNA synthesized in vitro from this new promoter was gel isolated and subjected to fingerprint analysis, Southern hybridization, and reverse transcriptase elongation. Based on these analyses, the in vitro-synthesized RNA initiates with an A at nucleotide -713. When compared individually, the upstream promoter was transcribed ninefold less efficiently than the major promoter. When templates which contain both promoters on the same piece of DNA were transcribed, the major promoter was at least 50-fold more efficient.

Sequestration analysis for RNA polymerase I transcription factors with various deletion and point mutations reveals different functional regions of the mouse rRNA gene promoter

We compared the ability of various deletion and substitution mutants of the mouse rRNA gene promoter to bind essential factors required for accurate transcription initiation by RNA polymerase I. Different amounts of a competitor template were first incubated with a mouse cell extract containing the whole complement of factors and RNA polymerase I, and then a tester template was added for the second incubation. Transcription was started by adding nucleoside triphosphates (one labeled), and the accurate transcripts were determined on a gel. The results indicated that the ability of 5' deletion mutants to sequester essential factors decreased almost concurrently with the impairment of in vitro transcription activity, whereas when the promoter sequence was removed from the 3' side, the transcription activity decreased earlier and more drastically than the sequestration ability. Similar, though not identical, results were obtained by preincubation with fraction D separated on a phosphocellulose column, indicating that the major factor which was sequestered was TFID, the species-dependent transcription initiation factor that binds first to the promoter in the initiation reaction (H. Kato, M. Nagamine, R. Kominami, and M. Muramatsu, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:3418-3427, 1986). Compilation of the data suggests that a region inside the 5' half of the core promoter (-40 to -1) is essential for the binding of TFID. The 3' half of the promoter (-1 to downstream) is not essential for the binding of TFID but is highly important for an efficient transcription initiation. A strong down-mutant with a one-base substitution at -16 (G to A) had a reduced ability to bind to TFID, whereas a null mutant with a single base substitution at -7 (G to A) showed a binding ability similar to that of the wild-type promoter when tested with whole-cell extract. This null mutant, however, could not sequester the TFID well when incubated with fraction D alone, suggesting that the binding of TFID with this mutant is unstable in the absence of another factor(s) present in cell extract. The factor is not TFIA, which binds after TFID, because the addition of fraction A containing TFIA did not cause TFID to bind to the mutant. The availability of different mutants having lesions at different steps of transcription initiation will provide a powerful tool for the dissection of the initiation reaction of the RNA gene.

Regions upstream from the core promoter of the rat ribosomal gene are required for the formation of a stable transcription initiation complex by RNA polymerase I in vitro

The sites required for the formation of a stable transcription initiation complex and for the initiation of transcription of rat rDNA in vitro were examined. A series of 5' deletion mutants of the rat transcription initiation region (-167 through +638) were constructed. These mutants were examined for their ability to support the faithful initiation of transcription in vitro. Mutants which contain less than 31 nucleotides upstream of the initiation site (+1) were unable to support detectable initiation of transcription. In this transcription system a series of deletion mutants from -167 to -31 were transcribed with equal efficiency when assayed individually. On the other hand, when the wild-type and mutant templates were compared in order-of-addition assays, they were found to be unequal. The incubation of an extract with a wild-type template, prior to the addition of nucleotides, precluded transcription of any second template added after the preincubation step. However, the preincubation of extract with mutants of the region upstream of the core promoter, from -122 to -31, did not preclude transcription of a wild-type template added after the preincubation step. Formation of the stable preinitiation complex was found to require the region between and -167.

Additional RNA polymerase I initiation site within the nontranscribed spacer region of the rat rRNA gene

We identified and characterized an additional promoter within the nontranscribed spacer (NTS) of the rat ribosomal gene repeat that is capable of supporting initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase I in vitro. Within this promoter there is a sequence of 13 nucleotides which is 100% homologous to nucleotides -18 to -6 (+1 being the first nucleotide of 45S rRNA) of the major promoter of 45S pre-rRNA and is located between nucleotides -731 and -719. To identify the exact location of the upstream initiation site, the RNA synthesized in vitro from this new promoter was gel isolated and subjected to fingerprint analysis, Southern hybridization, and reverse transcriptase elongation. Based on these analyses, the in vitro-synthesized RNA initiates with an A at nucleotide -713. When compared individually, the upstream promoter was transcribed ninefold less efficiently than the major promoter. When templates which contain both promoters on the same piece of DNA were transcribed, the major promoter was at least 50-fold more efficient.

Sequestration analysis for RNA polymerase I transcription factors with various deletion and point mutations reveals different functional regions of the mouse rRNA gene promoter

We compared the ability of various deletion and substitution mutants of the mouse rRNA gene promoter to bind essential factors required for accurate transcription initiation by RNA polymerase I. Different amounts of a competitor template were first incubated with a mouse cell extract containing the whole complement of factors and RNA polymerase I, and then a tester template was added for the second incubation. Transcription was started by adding nucleoside triphosphates (one labeled), and the accurate transcripts were determined on a gel. The results indicated that the ability of 5' deletion mutants to sequester essential factors decreased almost concurrently with the impairment of in vitro transcription activity, whereas when the promoter sequence was removed from the 3' side, the transcription activity decreased earlier and more drastically than the sequestration ability. Similar, though not identical, results were obtained by preincubation with fraction D separated on a phosphocellulose column, indicating that the major factor which was sequestered was TFID, the species-dependent transcription initiation factor that binds first to the promoter in the initiation reaction (H. Kato, M. Nagamine, R. Kominami, and M. Muramatsu, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:3418-3427, 1986). Compilation of the data suggests that a region inside the 5' half of the core promoter (-40 to -1) is essential for the binding of TFID. The 3' half of the promoter (-1 to downstream) is not essential for the binding of TFID but is highly important for an efficient transcription initiation. A strong down-mutant with a one-base substitution at -16 (G to A) had a reduced ability to bind to TFID, whereas a null mutant with a single base substitution at -7 (G to A) showed a binding ability similar to that of the wild-type promoter when tested with whole-cell extract. This null mutant, however, could not sequester the TFID well when incubated with fraction D alone, suggesting that the binding of TFID with this mutant is unstable in the absence of another factor(s) present in cell extract. The factor is not TFIA, which binds after TFID, because the addition of fraction A containing TFIA did not cause TFID to bind to the mutant. The availability of different mutants having lesions at different steps of transcription initiation will provide a powerful tool for the dissection of the initiation reaction of the RNA gene.

Two distinct promoter elements in the human rRNA gene identified by linker scanning mutagenesis

A cell-free RNA polymerase I transcription system was used to evaluate the transcription efficiency of 21 linker scanning mutations that span the human rRNA gene promoter. Our analysis revealed the presence of two major control elements, designated the core and upstream elements, that affect the level of transcription initiation. The core element extends from -45 to +18 relative to the RNA start site, and transcription is severely affected (up to 100-fold) by linker scanning mutations in this region. Linker scanning and deletion mutations in the upstream element, located between nucleotides -156 and -107, cause a three- to fivefold reduction in transcription. Under certain reaction conditions, such as the presence of a high ratio of protein to template or supplementation of the reaction with partially purified protein fractions, sequences upstream of the core element can have an even greater effect (20- to 50-fold) on RNA polymerase I transcription. Primer extension analysis showed that RNA synthesized from all of these mutant templates is initiated at the correct in vivo start site. To examine the functional relationship between the core and the upstream region, mutant promoters were constructed that alter the orientation, distance, or multiplicity of these control elements relative to each other. The upstream control element appears to function in only one orientation, and its position relative to the core is constrained within a fairly narrow region. Moreover, multiple core elements in close proximity to each other have an inhibitory effect on transcription.

The core promoter of mouse rDNA consists of two functionally distinct domains

We have determined the sequences constituting the minimal promoter of mouse rDNA. A very small region immediately upstream of the transcription start site (from -1 to -39) is sufficient to direct correct transcription initiation. Sequences immediately downstream of the transcription start site (+1 to +11) increase the efficiency of transcription initiation. Point mutations within the core promoter have been generated and assayed for their effects on template activity and on interaction with the pol I specific transcription factor TIF-IB. The core promoter element appears to consist of two functionally different domains. The distal sequence motif from position -22 to -16 is recognized by factor TIF-IB. Mutations within this region lead to similar changes of both template activity and binding of TIF-IB. Two point mutations within the proximal sequence motif from -15 to -1 do not affect TIF-IB binding although they severely impair transcription initiation. It is suggested, that this proximal region plays a role in the assembly of functional transcription initiation complexes rather than in the primary binding of TIF-IB.

A purified transcription factor (TIF-IB) binds to essential sequences of the mouse rDNA promoter

A transcription factor that is specific for mouse rDNA has been partially purified from Ehrlich ascites cells. This factor [designated transcription initiation factor (TIF)-IB] is required for accurate in vitro synthesis of mouse rRNA in addition to RNA polymerase I and another regulatory factor, TIF-IA. TIF-IB activity is present in extracts both from growing and nongrowing cells in comparable amounts. Prebinding competition experiments with wild-type and mutant templates suggest that TIF-IB interacts with the core control element of the rDNA promoter, which is located immediately upstream of the initiation site. The specific binding of TIF-IB to the RNA polymerase I promoter is demonstrated by exonuclease III protection experiments. The 3' border of the sequences protected by TIF-IB is shown to be on the coding strand at position -21 and on the noncoding strand at position -7. The results suggest that direct binding of TIF-IB to sequences in the core promoter element is the mechanism by which this factor imparts promoter selectivity to RNA polymerase I.

Characterization of the region around the start point of transcription of ribosomal RNA in the Chinese hamster

The initiation site for ribosomal RNA transcription in the Chinese hamster was identified and the sequence around and upstream determined. The start point region shows considerable homology with comparable regions in the mouse and rat. In the Chinese hamster, the region between bp -700 and -200 consists of imperfect repeats approximately 120-130 bp in length which are flanked by T-rich regions. The region within each repeat which is homologous with an adjacent repeat decreases in length as the start point is approached. The final promoter-proximal repeat preserves only an 11-bp region of the promoter-distal repeats. This short sequence, termed the repeat core, appears with a periodicity of about 120-130 bp in the Chinese hamster, and is conserved in both mouse and rat. In humans, a short repeated sequence occupies similar positions, suggesting that while complete 120-130-bp repeats are not a feature of all mammalian RNA polymerase I promoter-proximal r X DNA spacers, a short sequence repeating with approximate 120-130-bp periodicity may be such a feature.

Two distinct promoter elements in the human rRNA gene identified by linker scanning mutagenesis

A cell-free RNA polymerase I transcription system was used to evaluate the transcription efficiency of 21 linker scanning mutations that span the human rRNA gene promoter. Our analysis revealed the presence of two major control elements, designated the core and upstream elements, that affect the level of transcription initiation. The core element extends from -45 to +18 relative to the RNA start site, and transcription is severely affected (up to 100-fold) by linker scanning mutations in this region. Linker scanning and deletion mutations in the upstream element, located between nucleotides -156 and -107, cause a three- to fivefold reduction in transcription. Under certain reaction conditions, such as the presence of a high ratio of protein to template or supplementation of the reaction with partially purified protein fractions, sequences upstream of the core element can have an even greater effect (20- to 50-fold) on RNA polymerase I transcription. Primer extension analysis showed that RNA synthesized from all of these mutant templates is initiated at the correct in vivo start site. To examine the functional relationship between the core and the upstream region, mutant promoters were constructed that alter the orientation, distance, or multiplicity of these control elements relative to each other. The upstream control element appears to function in only one orientation, and its position relative to the core is constrained within a fairly narrow region. Moreover, multiple core elements in close proximity to each other have an inhibitory effect on transcription.

Faithful initiation of the in vitro transcription of a cloned rDNA from Tetrahymena pyriformis

A cloned rDNA fragment containing the transcriptional start point of Tetrahymena pyriformis was transcribed in vitro with a crude extract from homologous Tetrahymena cells. When a KpnI-HindIII fragment from the cloned rDNA plasmid was used as the template, the runoff transcription gave rise to two major RNA products about 490 and 460 nucleotides (nt) in length. An RNA of about 490 nt long was found to correspond to the expected transcript starting from the in vivo start point determined at our laboratory [Saiga et al., Nucl. Acids Res. 10 (1982) 4223-4235]. Precise size determination was performed using an RNA size marker prepared by hybridizing the template DNA with in vitro-capped 35S pre-rRNA followed by treatment with single-strand specific P1 nuclease. The size of the runoff transcript changed as predicted, according to downstream truncation points. The effects of alpha-amanitin and actinomycin D showed the transcription to be dependent on the added template DNA and to be catalyzed by form-I RNA polymerase. Possible reasons for the discrepancy between our determination of the size of the transcription product and that of Sutiphong et al. [Biochemistry 23 (1984) 6319-6326] are discussed.