Promotion of double-strand break repair by human nuclear extracts preferentially involves recombination with intact homologous DNA

Cell-free recombination of immunoglobulin switch-region DNA with nuclear extracts

We have developed an in vitro recombination system employing cell-free nuclear extracts from human B lymphocytes capable of detecting the recombination between human mu switch (Smu) and Sepsilon sequences in a model plasmid. Nuclear extracts from CD40-stimulated B lymphocytes gave a higher frequency of recombination in the assay than the unstimulated B cells. Recombination between Smu and Sepsilon was mediated by the nuclear extracts as the recombinational products could be amplified prior to bacterial transformation. Characterization of the recombination products demonstrated that the recombination process had the characteristics of immunoglobulin (Ig) isotype switching, as it was (i) switch-region-sequence specific, (ii) nonhomologous recombination, and (iii) enhanced by CD40 stimulation. Transcription through the S region DNA was not required for recombination in the system. These results demonstrate that Ig switch-region DNA recombination can be accomplished in vitro by cell-free nuclear extracts. This in vitro system for Ig switch-region DNA recombination using cell-free nuclear extracts will permit the dissection of the events involved in IgE class switch recombination, a critical event in the development of allergic diseases.

Human POMp75 is identified as the pro-oncoprotein TLS/FUS: both POMp75 and POMp100 DNA homologous pairing activities are associated to cell proliferation

We have previously developed an assay to measure DNA homologous pairing activities in crude extracts: The POM blot. In mammalian nuclear extracts, we detected two major DNA homologous pairing activities: POMp100 and POMp75. Here, we present the purification and identification of POMp75 as the pro-oncoprotein TLS/FUS. Because of the pro-oncogene status of TLS/FUS, we studied in addition, the relationships between cell proliferation and POM activities. We show that transformation of human fibroblasts by SV40 large T antigen results in a strong increase of both POMpl00 and TLS/POMp75 activities. Although detectable levels of both POMp100 and TLS/POMp75 are observed in non-immortalized fibroblasts or lymphocytes, fibroblasts at mid confluence or lymphocytes stimulated by phytohaemaglutinin, show higher levels of POM activities. Moreover, induction of differentiation of mouse F9 line by retinoic acid leads to the inhibition of both POMp100 and TLS/POMp75 activities. Comparison of POM activity of TLS/FUS with the amount of TLS protein detected by Western blot, suggests that the POM activity could be regulated by post-translation modification. Taken together, these results indicate that POMp100 and TLS/POMp75 activities are present in normal cells but are connected to cell proliferation. Possible relationship between cell proliferation, response to DNA damage and DNA homologous pairing activity of the pro-oncoprotein TLS/FUS are discussed.

The role of homologous recombination processes in the repair of severe forms of DNA damage in mammalian cells

The role of homologous recombination processes in the repair of severe forms of DNA damage is reviewed, with particular attention to the functions of members of the recA/RAD51 family of genes. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, several of the gene products involved in homologous recombination repair (HRR) have been studied in detail, and a picture is beginning to emerge of the repair mechanism for DNA double-strand breaks. Knowledge is fragmentary for other eukaryotic organisms and for other types of DNA damage. In mammalian cells, while it has been known for some years that HRR occurs, the relative importance of the process in repairing DNA damage is unknown and very few of the gene products involved have been identified. Very recently, a number of RAD51-like genes have been identified in mammals, either through cloning genes complementing cell lines sensitive to DNA-damaging agents (XRCC2, XRCC3), or through homology searches (RAD51L1, RAD51L2, RAD51L3). As yet the role of these genes and their possible functions are speculative, although the combination of sequence conservation and gene expression patterns suggest that they function in HRR pathways.

Construction of a vector containing a site-specific DNA double-strand break with 3'-phosphoglycolate termini and analysis of the products of end-joining in CV-1 cells

Previous studies have shown that linearized SV40-based shuttle vectors transfected into mammalian cells are efficiently recircularized by an error-prone end-joining pathway. To determine whether and with what specificity free radical-mediated double-strand breaks are rejoined by this pathway, a structural mimic of such a break was introduced at a specific site in an SV40-based shuttle vector, by ligating purified 3'-phosphoglycolate-terminated oligonucleotides into 3' recessed ends generated in the linearized vector. These terminally blocked linear vectors were efficiently repaired and replicated when transfected into simian CV-1 cells. Sequencing across the repair joints in progeny plasmid indicated that, for a blunt-ended vector, the most frequent mechanism of rejoining was splicing at a terminal 4-base homology; however, a significant fraction of the joints retained all bases from both ends of the break, consistent with a mechanism involving simple 3'-phosphoglycolate removal, followed by blunt-end ligation. For the analogous 3'-hydroxyl terminated break, the fraction of simple blunt-end ligations was considerably higher. For a phosphoglycolate-terminated vector with cohesive ends the most frequent repair mechanism was simple ligation of the annealed cohesive ends, presumably preceded by phosphoglycolate removal. For all these substrates, the remaining repair joints showed small or large deletions from one or both of the ends, usually with apparent annealing at short (1-4-base) homologies. The results suggest that while breaks with 3'-phosphoglycolates can be repaired, these blocked termini represent a significant barrier to DNA end-joining, and can significantly alter its specificity. The presence of cohesive ends appears to improve markedly the fidelity of rejoining for terminally blocked double-strand breaks.

End-joining of free radical-mediated DNA double-strand breaks in vitro is blocked by the kinase inhibitor wortmannin at a step preceding removal of damaged 3' termini

Both mammalian cells and Xenopus eggs possess activities for the joining of nonhomologous DNA ends, and such activities may play a major role in double-strand break repair. In order to dissect the biochemical processing of breaks with oxidatively modified ends, vectors containing various site-specific double-strand breaks with 3'-phosphoglycolate termini were constructed and treated with Xenopus egg extracts. These vectors were rejoined by the extracts at rates 30-100 times slower than comparable 3'-hydroxyl vectors. Vectors with blunt or cohesive 3'-phosphoglycolate ends yielded single repair products corresponding to simple phosphoglycolate removal followed by ligation, while a vector with mismatched ends was also rejoined but yielded a mixture of products. Addition of the kinase inhibitors wortmannin and dimethylaminopurine not only blocked rejoining, but also suppressed phosphoglycolate removal, implying an early, essential, kinase-dependent restriction point in the pathway. The results suggest that double-strand breaks with oxidatively modified ends are repaired in Xenopus eggs by a highly conservative and stringently regulated end-joining pathway, in which all biochemical processing of the breaks is contingent on both end alignment and a specific phosphorylation event. Several lines of indirect evidence suggest DNA-dependent protein kinase as a likely candidate for effecting this phosphorylation.

Structural effect of donor DNA on the initiation of recombination for double strand break repair in human nuclear extracts

The effect of the structure of donor DNA molecules on the initiation of recombination for double strand break repair in human nuclear extracts, was investigated here. A unique double strand break was introduced into M13 duplex derivatives by digestion with restriction enzymes. After coincubation of the cleaved DNA in human nuclear extracts, with a plasmid containing M13 sequences spanning the break, double strand break repair was estimated by the plating efficiency in JM109 (RecA1) bacteria. We first confirm that a short heterologous insert (8bp) close to the break on the recipient cleaved M13 DNA inhibits recombination with circular as well as with linear donor molecules. The results indicate that, with these substrates, recombination is initiated at the level of the break, requires uninterrupted homology on both sides of the break, and is associated with a decreasing gradient of gene conversion. When the heterologous insertion is located on the plasmid donor DNA, similar results are obtained with a circular donor DNA. In contrast, with a linear donor molecule, bearing the insert, homology requirements, in the region of the break in M13 DNA, are abolished. This last result suggests that recombination could be initiated at the extremities of the linear donor DNA.

Directional recombination is initiated at a double strand break in human nuclear extracts

The involvement of a double strand break in the initiation of homologous recombination was examined in human nuclear extracts. M13 duplex derivatives, containing inserts in the LacZ' region (producing white plaques), were cleaved by restriction enzymes and coincubated in the extracts with a circular plasmid containing the LacZ' region without insert, and unable to produce plaques. Repair was estimated by the ability to produce plaques after transfection into JM109 (recA1) bacteria. Recombination with the plasmid enhances the number of plaques and also the frequency of M13 producing blue plaques. Heterologous insertions in the region surrounding the break were analyzed for their effects on initiation of recombination. The extent of repair by recombination (number of plaques) was compared with the number of blue plaques among the repaired population. Initiation of recombination is inhibited when heterologous insertions are located at 7bp from the break, on the right side as well as on the left side. A low level of recombination is measurable for 27 bp of homology but the maximum efficiency of recombination occurred with homologies of 165 or 320 bp from the break to the heterologous insertion. At 320 bp, the extent of recombinational repair remained at a plateau level but the frequency of blue plaques progressively decreases. We have also analyzed the effect of different sizes of inserts. With longer inserts, a longer length of homology adjacent to the break is required for optimum recombination. However, the size of the insert does not affect the low level of recombination that occurred with a short homology (27 bp). The results indicate that the process is initiated at or near the break, requires homology on both sides of the break and is followed by an elongation from the double strand break to the distal regions of the DNA. Our data provide some support to the double-strand-break repair model established for meiotic recombination in yeast.

A system for assaying homologous recombination at the endogenous human thymidine kinase gene

A system for assaying human interchromosomal recombination in vitro was developed, using a cell line containing two different mutant thymidine kinase genes (TK) on chromosomes 17. Heteroalleles were generated in the TK+/+ parent B-lymphoblast cell line WIL-2 by repeated exposure to the alkylating nitrogen mustard ICR-191, which preferentially causes +1 or -1 frameshifts. Resulting TK-/- mutants were selected in medium containing the toxic thymidine analog trifluorothymidine. Mutations were characterized by exon-specific polymerase chain reaction amplification and direct sequencing. In two lines, heterozygous frameshifts were located in exons 4 and 7 of the TK gene separated by approximately 8 kilobases. These lines undergo spontaneous reversion to TK+ at a frequency of less than 10(-7), and revertants can be selected in cytidine/hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine medium. The nature and location of these heteroallelic mutations make large deletions, rearrangements, nondisjunction, and reduplication unlikely mechanisms for reversion to TK+. The mode of reversion to TK+ was specifically assessed by DNA sequencing, use of single-strand conformation polymorphisms, and analysis of various restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) linked to the TK gene on chromosome 17. Our data suggest that a proportion of revertants has undergone recombination and gene conversion at the TK locus, with concomitant loss of frameshifts and allele loss at linked RFLPs. Models are presented for the origin of two recombinants.

Kinetics of chromosome lesion repair in synchronized quiescent and proliferating CHO cells

The induction of chromosome aberrations by X-rays was investigated in synchronized quiescent and proliferating CHO-K1 cells. Kinetics of chromosome lesion repair was studied using the method of fractionated irradiation. In both cell types the time-course of repair during fractionation intervals followed first-order kinetics. Comparison with kinetic data reported on DNA double-strand break repair supports the hypothesis that DNA double-strand breaks are the lesions underlying chromosome aberration formation. Quiescent CHO cells showed higher aberration yields than proliferating cells, and chromosome lesion repair was faster in quiescent cells. This correlation can be interpreted in terms of a higher degree of repair synchronism during pairwise lesion interaction. The effect of delayed plating on aberration induction was studied in quiescent cells. The time-course of repair active during the delayed plating interval followed first-order kinetics. The kinetics observed in delayed plating experiments is slower than the repair kinetics observed in fractionation experiments, suggesting the involvement of two different processes.

Intrachromosomal homologous recombination in human cells which differ in nucleotide excision-repair capacity

To examine the mechanism of recombination and the role of DNA repair in this process, we transfected a plasmid carrying duplicated copies of the Herpes simplex virus I thymidine kinase (Htk) gene, each containing an 8 bp XhoI site inserted in a unique site and with the neo coding for geneticin resistance located between them, into tk-deficient human cell lines which differ in their ability to carry out nucleotide excision repair. One parental cell line has a normal level of repair activity; the second has an intermediate level, and the third has virtually no repair activity. Several geneticin-resistant transfectant cell strains from each parental line were isolated and assayed for the ability to undergo productive recombination giving rise to tk+ cells. Approximately 25% of them could do so. Southern blot analysis of these transfectants indicated that the majority contained a single copy, or at most, two copies of the plasmid integrated into the chromosome. Fluctuation analysis tests to determine the rate of spontaneous recombination (events per 10(6) cells per cell generation) in the various cell strains showed that the rates ranged from 0.15 to 4.1. The mean rate for the cell strains derived from the repair-deficient cell line was 3.6; for those derived from the cells with an intermediate rate, it was 0.8; and for those with a normal rate of excision repair, it was 0.9. Southern blot analysis of tk+ recombinants showed that in all cases, one of the Htk genes had become wild-type, i.e., XhoI-resistant. 90% of the recombinants retained the Htk gene duplication, consistent with non-reciprocal transfer of genetic information, i.e., gene conversion. The rest contained a single, wild-type Htk gene, consistent with a single reciprocal exchange within a chromatid or a single unequal exchange between sister chromatids. These cell strains will be useful for investigating the role of DNA damage and repair in homologous recombination.

Molecular characterization of hprt mutants induced by low- and high-LET radiations in human cells

Southern blotting techniques were employed to examine the spectrum of molecular alterations in DNA induced by internally emitting iodine isotopes and X-rays at and around the hprt locus in a human lymphoblastoid cell line. We analyzed 165 mutant clones using a cDNA probe for the human hprt locus, and 3 anonymous sequence probes for regions of the X chromosome which are linked to hprt. The results were compared with those for 35 spontaneously arising mutant clones. The majority of ionizing radiation-induced mutants showed changes in the normal restriction patterns at the hprt locus, whereas very few alterations were seen at linked markers along the X chromosome. Total hprt coding sequence deletions comprised 30-48% of the changes observed at this locus, while partial deletions and rearrangements comprised 14-54% of the observed changes. In the case of mutants induced by [125I]dUrd, a densely ionizing radiation, the spectrum of alterations was dose-dependent; at low doses it was not significantly different from that seen after sparsely ionizing X-ray exposure, whereas a higher proportion of gene deletions and rearrangements occurred after high doses of this incorporated isotope. Changes were rarely observed in the 3 linked markers examined. Overall, these results indicate that the distribution of mutational events at the hprt locus in irradiated human cells may not only be LET-dependent but dose-dependent, and that deletions involving large regions of the X chromosome surrounding the hprt locus are rare events.

A recombination hotspot in the LTR of a mouse retrotransposon identified in an in vitro system

The recombinational frequency between two long terminal repeat elements (LTR-IS) of a mouse retrotransposon was about 13 times higher, compared with that of two control DNA sequences in extracts from mouse testes, but not in extracts from ascites cells. Deletion of a 37 bp region from the LTR-IS element strongly suppresses its recombinational activity. This 37 bp region encompasses an area of potentially single-stranded DNA and interacts with at least two nuclear proteins. One of them binds sequence-specifically to single-stranded DNA and is present in both types of extracts. Another protein(s) binds to dsDNA at the motif TGGAAATCCCC and is absent in extracts from testes. Our results suggest that a cis-acting DNA sequence within the 504 bp LTR-IS element is responsible for its high recombinational activity in vitro, and they further support the previous suggestion that the LTR-IS elements are meiotic recombinational hotspots in vivo.

Analysis of recombination in mammalian cells using SV40 and SV40-derived vectors

Viruses and viral vectors have played a crucial role in our understanding of the pathways of homologous and non-homologous recombination in mitotically dividing mammalian cells. In particular, they have allowed the confirmation of the preponderance of non-homologous over homologous recombination events and led to schemes for the selection and isolation of homologous recombination products. These studies have allowed an examination of the properties of reciprocal and non-reciprocal homologous recombination events extrachromosomally, in the chromosome and between plasmids and chromosomes. They suggest that it is feasible now to direct DNA segments to predetermined chromosomal locations by homologous recombination.

Molecular analysis of homologous recombination catalysed by human nuclear extract: fidelity and DNase protection

We present a molecular analysis of DNA's resulting from homologous recombination, between two duplex molecules, and catalysed by human nuclear extracts. Sequence analysis of 20 recombined clones (400 nucleotides per clone), in a genetically silent sequence surrounding the recombination initiation or termination site, shows no modification compared to the parental sequence. Transient protection of the DNA's against DNase treatment was brought about by the nuclear extract. This protection was found to be strickly confined to the homologous sequences potentially implicated in recombination.