Inhibition of DNA polymerase alpha by aphidicolin derivatives

Aphidicolin: Its Chemistry and Biosynthesis

1. Introduction

2. Naturally occurring aphidicolanes

3. The chemistry of aphidicolin

4. Synthesis

5. Biosynthesis

6. References

The occurrence and structure of the biologically active tetracyclic diterpenoid aphidicolin and related aphidicolane natural products, together with their chemistry, their molecular rearrangements and their biosynthesis, are reviewed.

Structural basis for inhibition of DNA replication by aphidicolin

Natural tetracyclic diterpenoid aphidicolin is a potent and specific inhibitor of B-family DNA polymerases, haltering replication and possessing a strong antimitotic activity in human cancer cell lines. Clinical trials revealed limitations of aphidicolin as an antitumor drug because of its low solubility and fast clearance from human plasma. The absence of structural information hampered the improvement of aphidicolin-like inhibitors: more than 50 modifications have been generated so far, but all have lost the inhibitory and antitumor properties. Here we report the crystal structure of the catalytic core of human DNA polymerase α (Pol α) in the ternary complex with an RNA-primed DNA template and aphidicolin. The inhibitor blocks binding of dCTP by docking at the Pol α active site and by rotating the template guanine. The structure provides a plausible mechanism for the selectivity of aphidicolin incorporation opposite template guanine and explains why previous modifications of aphidicolin failed to improve its affinity for Pol α. With new structural information, aphidicolin becomes an attractive lead compound for the design of novel derivatives with enhanced inhibitory properties for B-family DNA polymerases.

FANCM regulates DNA chain elongation and is stabilized by S-phase checkpoint signalling

FANCM binds and remodels replication fork structures in vitro. We report that in vivo, FANCM controls DNA chain elongation in an ATPase-dependent manner. In the presence of replication inhibitors that do not damage DNA, FANCM counteracts fork movement, possibly by remodelling fork structures. Conversely, through damaged DNA, FANCM promotes replication and recovers stalled forks. Hence, the impact of FANCM on fork progression depends on the underlying hindrance. We further report that signalling through the checkpoint effector kinase Chk1 prevents FANCM from degradation by the proteasome after exposure to DNA damage. FANCM also acts in a feedback loop to stabilize Chk1. We propose that FANCM is a ringmaster in the response to replication stress by physically altering replication fork structures and by providing a tight link to S-phase checkpoint signalling.

Targeting human DNA polymerase alpha for the inhibition of keratinocyte proliferation. Part 1. Homology model, active site architecture and ligand binding

In order to understand the binding modes of human DNA polymerase alpha (pol alpha) inhibitors on a molecular level, a 3D homology model of the active site of the enzyme was proposed based on the application of molecular modelling methods and molecular dynamic simulations using available crystal coordinates of pol alpha relatives. Docking results for a series of known nucleotide analogue inhibitors were consistent with reported experimental binding data and offered the possibility to elucidate structure-activity relationships via investigations of active site-inhibitor interactions. Furthermore, the study could explain, at least partially, the inhibitory effect of aphidicolin on pol alpha. In molecular dynamics simulations, aphidicolin occupied the catalytic centre, but acted in a not truly competitive manner with respect to nucleotides. It destabilized the replicating "closed" form of the pol alpha and transferred the enzyme into the inactive "open" conformation. This result is consistent with recent experiments on the binding mode of aphidicolin.

Effects of hydroxyurea and aphidicolin on phosphorylation of ataxia telangiectasia mutated on Ser 1981 and histone H2AX on Ser 139 in relation to cell cycle phase and induction of apoptosis

BACKGROUND

DNA replication stress often induces DNA damage. The antitumor drug hydroxyurea (HU), a potent inhibitor of ribonucleotide reductase that halts DNA replication through its effects on cellular deoxynucleotide pools, was shown to damage DNA inducing double-strand breaks (DSBs). Aphidicolin (APH), an inhibitor of alpha-like DNA polymerases, was also reported to cause DNA damage, but the evidence for induction of DSBs by APH is not straightforward. Histone H2AX is phosphorylated on Ser 139 in response to DSBs and one of the protein kinases that phosphorylate H2AX is ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM); activation of ATM is through its phosphorylation of Ser 1981. The present study was undertaken to reveal whether H2AX is phosphorylated in cells exposed to HU or APH and whether its phosphorylation is mediated by ATM.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

HL-60 cells were treated in cultures with 0.1-5.0 mM HU or 1-4 muM APH for up to 5 h. Activation of ATM and H2AX phosphorylation was detected immunocytochemically using Ab specific to Ser1981-ATM or Ser 139-H2AX epitopes, respectively, concurrent with measurement of cellular DNA content.

RESULTS

While exposure of cells to HU led to H2AX phosphorylation selectively during S phase and the cells progressing through the early portion of S (DI = 1.1-1.4) were more affected than late-S phase (DI = 1.6-1.9) cells, ATM was not activated by HU. In fact, the level of constitutive ("programmed") ATM phosphorylation was distinctly suppressed, in all phases of the cell cycle, at 0.1-5.0 mM HU. Cells' exposure to APH also resulted in H2AX phosphorylation at Ser139 with no evidence of ATM activation, and as in the case of HU, the early-S cells were more affected than the late-S phase cells. The rise in frequency of apoptotic cells became apparent after 2 h of exposure to HU or APH, and all apoptotic cells had markedly elevated levels of both H2AX-Ser139 and ATM-Ser1981 phosphorylation.

CONCLUSIONS

The lack of correlation between H2AX phosphorylation and ATM activation indicates that protein kinase(s) other than ATM (ATR and/or DNA-dependent protein kinase) are activated by DSBs induced by replication stress. Interestingly, HU inhibits the constitutive ("programmed") level of ATM phosphorylation in untreated cells. However, DNA fragmentation during apoptosis activates ATM and dramatically increases level of H2AX phosphorylation.

Histone H1b phosphorylation is dependent upon ongoing transcription and replication in normal and ras-transformed mouse fibroblasts

We have previously shown that mouse phosphorylated histone H1b (pH1b) was localized near nuclear sites that contained splicing factors. This observation suggested to us that pH1b was associated with transcribing chromatin. Here we investigated the relationship between phosphorylation of H1b and transcription. We demonstrate that treatment of normal or ras-transformed mouse fibroblasts with the transcription inhibitor actinomycin D for 70 min results in a dramatic decrease in the level of pH1b. Similar results were observed when transcription was inhibited by 5, 6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofuranosylbenzimidazole (DRB). When DRB was removed, the level of pH1b was restored after 2 h. Treatment of the cells with aphidicolin, a potent inhibitor of replication, resulted in a marked decrease in the level of pH1b after 30 min. This is the first report showing a dependence of histone modification upon ongoing transcription and replication. Inhibition of transcription or replication may hinder accessibility of H1b to the H1 kinase, supporting the idea that pH1b is associated with transcribing chromatin. Phosphorylation of H1b may be required to maintain a more decondensed chromatin structure to facilitate transcription and replication processes.

Analysis of inhibitors of bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase

Bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase was inhibited by butylphenyl nucleotides, aphidicolin and pyrophosphate analogs, but with lower sensitivities than other members of the B family DNA polymerases. The nucleotides N2-(p-n-butylphenyl)dGTP (BuPdGTP) and 2-(p-n-butylanilino)dATP (BuAdATP) inhibited T4 DNA polymerase with competitive Ki values of 0.82 and 0.54 microM with respect to dGTP and dATP, respectively. The same compounds were more potent inhibitors in truncated assays lacking the competitor dNTP, displaying apparent Ki values of 0.001 and 0.0016 microM, respectively. BuPdGTP was a substrate for T4 DNA polymerase, and the resulting 3'-BuPdG-primer:template was bound strongly by the enzyme. Each of the non-substrate derivatives, BuPdGDP and BuPdGMPCH2PP, inhibited T4 DNA polymerase with similar potencies in both the truncated and variable competitor assays. These results indicate that BuPdGTP inhibits T4 DNA polymerase by distinct mechanisms depending upon the assay conditions. Reversible competitive inhibition predominates in the presence of dGTP, and incorporation in the absence of dGTP leads to potent inhibition by the modified primer:template. The implications of these findings for the use of these inhibitors in the study of B family DNA polymerases is discussed.

Bacteriophage T4 and human type I DNA ligases relax DNA under joining conditions

Both bacteriophage T4 and human type I DNA ligases in the presence of a mixture of ATP, AMP and PPi altered the topological properties of a supercoiled substrate by a step-wise reaction eventually leading to a population of fully relaxed, covalently closed products. In the presence of only AMP and PPi DNA products containing nicks with 3'OH/5'P termini accumulated in the presence of bacteriophage T4 DNA ligase, suggesting reversal of the entire joining reaction, but not in the presence of human DNA ligase I. Both DNA ligases became deoxyadenylylated in the presence of dATP, but the joining reaction did not proceed to completion. However, with both enzymes the full relaxing reaction took place in the presence of dAMP alone and in the presence of a mixture of dATP, dAMP and PPi. In no case could the joining reaction be reversed by dAMP and PPi. Related experiments with modified derivatives of deoxyribonucleoside 5'-triphosphates and PPi gave results in accord with these observations. The AMP dependent DNA relaxation catalysed by DNA ligases was insensitive to the presence of exonuclease III. These results indicate that controlled relaxation of the substrate by both DNA ligases occurs as a separate reaction rather than by simple reversal of the joining reaction. These findings support the hypothesis that in vivo the DNA topoisomerising ligases relax their substrate at the replication fork both during and separately from ligation of a pre-existing nick.

Aphidicolin selectively kills neuroblastoma cells in vitro

Aphidicolin is a tetracyclic diterpene antibiotic which is known to inhibit the growth of eucaryotic cells by reversible binding to DNA polymerase alpha without significant effect on cell viability in most common human cell lines. We observed that aphidicolin at a concentration of 5 x 10(-7) M kills all cells of four human neuroblastoma cell lines. In contrast, viability of normal human embryonal cells and of human continuous cell lines including HeLa, H9, A549 and Caco-2 was influenced only moderately by aphidicolin. In addition, neuroblastoma cells were killed after treatment with 5 x 10(-7) M aphidicolin in cocultures with normal embryonal cells which continued to proliferate after removal of aphidicolin. These results show that aphidicolin provides an agent which selectively kills neuroblastoma cells in vitro.

Terminal differentiation of human erythroleukemia cell line K562 induced by aphidicolin

To analyze the relationship between differentiation and DNA replication, the effect of aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor for DNA polymerase alpha, was measured with respect to erythroid differentiation and activities of DNA polymerases alpha, beta, and gamma. Five micromolar aphidicolin completely blocked the growth of K562 cells and caused 80% of cells to become hemoglobin positive after 5 days exposure. The cessation of K562 cell growth induced by aphidicolin was irreversible, whereas the inhibition of HeLa cell growth was completely reversible. The enzyme activity of DNA polymerase alpha of K562 cells showed a 50-110% increase with aphidicolin treatment as compared to control K562 cells; activities of DNA polymerases beta and gamma were not affected. These features sharply contrasted with the erythroid induction of the same cells by hemin, where cell growth was not suppressed and DNA polymerase alpha was not increased but rather decreased. The enzyme activity of DNA polymerase alpha remained high even after removal of aphidicolin from the culture medium. These results suggest that treatment with aphidicolin might induce an accumulation of protein factors for replication and/or differentiation, causing rapid cell differentiation of cells without cell division.

Deoxyribonucleotide analogs as inhibitors and substrates of DNA polymerases

Inhibitory and substrate properties of analogs of deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates toward DNA polymerases are reviewed. A general introduction is followed by a description of DNA polymerases and the reaction that they catalyze, and sites at which substrate analogs may inhibit them. Effects of modifications in the major family of compounds, nucleotide derivatives, at the base, sugar and triphosphate portions of the molecule, are summarized with respect to retention of substrate properties and generation of inhibitory properties. Structure-activity relationships and the basis of selectivity in the second family of compounds, deoxyribonucleotide mimics, are also presented. Conclusions are drawn regarding the structural basis of inhibitor selectivity and mechanism, relationship between in vitro and in vivo effects of inhibitors, and the promise of inhibitors as probes for study of active sites of DNA polymerases.

Structure-activity relationships for the inhibition of DNA polymerase alpha by aphidicolin derivatives

Aphidicolin and 17 derivatives that have been structurally modified in the A- and D-rings were assessed for their ability to inhibit DNA polymerase alpha. No derivative surpassed the activity of aphidicolin; derivatives with structural alterations in the A-ring exhibited significantly greater loss of activity relative to derivatives with structural alterations in the D-ring. The conclusions of these studies indicate a critical role for the C-18 function in the interaction of aphidicolin with polymerase alpha. Molecular modelling studies could not identify structural features of the aphidicolin-dCTP "overlap" that is unique to dCTP, relative to the remaining dNTPs, and that is consistent with the extant structure-activity data.

Effect of pisiferic acid and its derivatives on cytotoxicity macromolecular synthesis and DNA polymerase alpha of HeLa cells

1. Seventy-seven derivatives of pisiferic acid (2), an antimicrobial diterpenoid, were tested for cytotoxicity against HeLa cells and 9 derivatives were found to show cytotoxicity at less than 2 micrograms/ml dose (IC50). 2. Hydrophobicity was revealed to be an important factor for cytotoxicity of the derivatives. 3. Compound 2 inhibited predominantly DNA synthesis in HeLa cells as compared with RNA and protein synthesis. 4. No direct interaction between 2 and nucleic acid bases was indicated by a u.v. spectral method. 5. Several of the pisiferic acid species showed inhibitory action on HeLa DNA polymerase alpha, and the inhibitory activity was about 1/20 of aphidicolin.