The signal for growth rate control and stringent sensitivity in E. coli is not restricted to a particular sequence motif within the promoter region

The E. coli anti-sigma factor Rsd: studies on the specificity and regulation of its expression

Background

Among the seven different sigma factors in E. coli σ⁷⁰ has the highest concentration and affinity for the core RNA polymerase. The E. coli protein Rsd is regarded as an anti-sigma factor, inhibiting σ⁷⁰-dependent transcription at the onset of stationary growth. Although binding of Rsd to σ⁷⁰ has been shown and numerous structural studies on Rsd have been performed the detailed mechanism of action is still unknown.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We have performed studies to unravel the function and regulation of Rsd expression in vitro and in vivo. Cross-linking and affinity binding revealed that Rsd is able to interact with σ⁷⁰, with the core enzyme of RNA polymerase and is able to form dimers in solution. Unexpectedly, we find that Rsd does also interact with σ³⁸, the stationary phase-specific sigma factor. This interaction was further corroborated by gel retardation and footprinting studies with different promoter fragments and σ³⁸- or σ⁷⁰-containing RNA polymerase in presence of Rsd. Under competitive in vitro transcription conditions, in presence of both sigma factors, a selective inhibition of σ⁷⁰-dependent transcription was prevailing, however. Analysis of rsd expression revealed that the nucleoid-associated proteins H-NS and FIS, StpA and LRP bind to the regulatory region of the rsd promoters. Furthermore, the major promoter P2 was shown to be down-regulated in vivo by RpoS, the stationary phase-specific sigma factor and the transcription factor DksA, while induction of the stringent control enhanced rsd promoter activity. Most notably, the dam-dependent methylation of a cluster of GATC sites turned out to be important for efficient rsd transcription.

Conclusions/Significance

The results contribute to a better understanding of the intricate mechanism of Rsd-mediated sigma factor specificity changes during stationary phase.

Cold-shock-induced de novo transcription and translation of infA and role of IF1 during cold adaptation

Escherichia coli infA is transcribed from two promoters, P1 and P2, into a longer and a shorter mRNA encoding translation initiation factor IF1. Although P1 is intrinsically stronger than P2, the shorter half-life of its transcripts causes the steady-state level of the P2 transcript to be substantially higher than that of P1 during growth at 37 degrees C. After cold-shock, de novo transcription and translation of infA contribute to the transient increase of the IF1/ribosomes ratio, which is partially responsible for translational bias consisting in the preferential translation of cold-shock mRNAs in the cold. Cold-stress induction of infA expression is mainly due to the high activity of P1 at low temperature, which is further increased by transcriptional stimulation by CspA and by an increased transcript stability. Furthermore, the longer infA mRNA originating from P1 is preferentially translated at low temperature by the translational machinery of cold-shocked cells. The increased level of IF1 during cold adaptation is essential for overcoming the higher stability of the 70S monomers at low temperature and for providing a sufficient pool of dissociated 30S subunits capable of initiating translation.

Promoter prediction in the rhizobia

The ability to recognize and predict non-σ54promoters in the alphaproteobacteria is not well developed. In this study, 25 experimentally verifiedSinorhizobium melilotipromoter sequences were compiled and used to predict the location of other related promoters in theS. melilotigenome. Fourteen candidate predictions were targeted for verification and of these at least 12 proved to be genuine promoters. As a result, the experimental identification of 12 novel promoters linked to genesrpoD,topA,rpmJ,trpS,ropB1,metC,rpsT,secE,trkHand three tRNA genes is reported. In all, 99 predicted and verified promoters are reported, including those linked with 13 tRNA genes, eight ribosomal protein genes and a number of other physiologically important or essential genes. On the basis of sequence conservation and a mutational analysis of promoter activity, the −35 and −10 consensus for these promoters is 5-CTTGAC-N17-CTATAT. This promoter structure, which seems to be widely conserved amongst several other genera in the alphaproteobacteria, shares significant similarity with, but is skewed by a 1 nt step from, the canonicalEscherichia coliσ70promoter. Perhaps this difference is responsible for the observation thatS. melilotipromoters are often poorly expressed inE. coli. In this regard, expression data from plasmid-bornegfp-reporter fusions to eight of theS. melilotipromoters verified in this work revealed that while these promoters were very active inS. melilotiandAgrobacterium tumefaciensonly very low, near-background activity was detected inE. coli.

Structural basis for transcription regulation by alarmone ppGpp

Guanosine-tetraphosphate (ppGpp) is a major regulator of stringent control, an adaptive response of bacteria to amino acid starvation. The 2.7 A resolution structure of the Thermus thermophilus RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzyme in complex with ppGpp reveals that ppGpp binds to the same site near the active center in both independent RNAP molecules in the crystal but in strikingly distinct orientations. Binding is symmetrical with respect to the two diphosphates of ppGpp and is relaxed with respect to the orientation of the nucleotide base. Different modes of ppGpp binding are coupled with asymmetry of the active site configurations. The results suggest that base pairing of ppGpp with cytosines in the nontemplate DNA strand might be an essential component of transcription control by ppGpp. We present experimental evidence highlighting the importance of base-specific contacts between ppGpp and specific cytosine residues during both transcription initiation and elongation.

Essential steps in the ppGpp-dependent regulation of bacterial ribosomal RNA promoters can be explained by substrate competition

Transcription of stable RNA genes is known to be dramatically reduced in the presence of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), the mediator of the stringent response. Using in vitro transcription systems with ribosomal RNA P1 promoters, we have analyzed which step of the initiation cycle is inhibited by the effector ppGpp. We show that formation of the ternary transcription initiation complex consisting of RNA polymerase holoenzyme, the promoter DNA, and the first initiating nucleotide triphosphate is the major step at which ppGpp exerts its regulation. Neither primary binding of RNA polymerase to the promoter nor isomerization to the open binary complexes or the subsequent promoter clearance steps contributes notably to the observed inhibition. The effect of ppGpp-dependent inhibition in the formation of the ternary transcription initiation complex could be mimicked by nucleotide derivatives known to bind to the RNA polymerase active center. Using these model compounds, almost identical inhibition characteristics were observed as seen with ppGpp. The results support the previously published model, which suggests that ppGpp-dependent inhibition is based on competition between the inhibitor molecules and NTP substrates for access to the active center of RNA polymerase.

Identification of a novel mycobacterial transcriptional regulator and its involvement in growth rate dependence and stringent control

A novel transcriptional regulator has been identified in the 400-bp upstream region of the guaA gene of Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv that promotes the expression of lacZ gene in Mycobacterium smegmatis mc(2)155 and M. tuberculosis H37Rv but not in Escherichia coli DH5alpha. PCR-mediated deletion mutagenesis and cloning identified a 120-bp fragment upstream from the guaA gene to be the actual regulator. Primer extension analysis mapped the transcription start site to be the first 'G' residue of the translation start codon GTG of the guaA gene. Electrophoretic mobility shift assay showed strong binding of M. smegmatis RNA polymerase holoenzyme to the 400-bp fragment that expresses lacZ in mycobacterial species and a weak binding to the 280-bp fragment that expresses only in E. coli DH5alpha. Both promoter recombinants revealed varied response in the presence of purine nucleotides and exhibited down-regulation when subjected to amino acid starvation.

Transcriptional pausing of RNA polymerase in the presence of guanosine tetraphosphate depends on the promoter and gene sequence

We have studied the response of the effector molecule guanosine 3',5'-bisdiphosphate (ppGpp) on RNA polymerase pausing during in vitro transcription elongation. Pausing was followed during single round extension of stalled ternary complexes excluding possible ppGpp effects on initiation. The ppGpp dependences of early pausing sites within different transcription systems controlled by promoters with known response to enhanced ppGpp levels in vivo were quantitatively characterized. Transcription of stable RNAs and mRNA genes were analyzed. In addition, the in vitro pausing behavior of two promoter variants directing the same sequence but differing in their in vivo ppGpp sensitivity were compared. In the presence of ppGpp we noted a slight general enhancement of specific pauses in all transcription systems. However, genes known to be under stringent or growth rate control in vivo revealed a notably stronger pausing enhancement. The sites of pausing are not changed by the presence of ppGpp but appear to be sequence-specific. The effect of ppGpp on the extent of pausing depends on the particular promoter and closely adjacent sequences that the RNA polymerase has passed during initiation. Pausing enhancement requires the presence of ppGpp during elongation but not during initiation. The results underline the importance of pausing for transcription regulation and offer a plausible explanation for inhibition of stable RNA expression under conditions of elevated concentrations of ppGpp.

Factor for inversion stimulation-dependent growth rate regulation of serine and threonine tRNA species

We have previously shown that the accumulation of 20 tRNA species in Escherichia coli is individually regulated as a function of cellular growth rate. We have also reported that the growth rate regulation of some but not all tRNA species is dependent on the activity of the factor for inversion stimulation (FIS). In present work, we studied the growth rate regulation of the serine- and threonine-accepting tRNA families. We show that the levels of tRNA(3Thr), tRNA(3Ser), tRNA(2Thr), tRNA(3Thr), and tRNA(4Thr) are reduced in fis cells as the growth rate increases. The accumulation of these tRNA species is reduced 2-5-fold at the fastest bacterial growth rate. The strongest effect is observed for the two minor tRNA species; tRNA(2Ser) and tRNA(2Thr). In contrast, we find that the accumulation of tRNA(1Ser), tRNA(5Ser), and tRNA(1Thr) is similar in wild type and fis bacteria. The data presented provide further evidence for the suggestion that FIS is a stimulating factor that is involved, directly or indirectly, in the high expression level of some tRNA genes at fast bacterial growth rates.

Escherichia coli tyrT gene transcription is sensitive to DNA supercoiling in its native chromosomal context: effect of DNA topoisomerase IV overexpression on tyrT promoter function

We have investigated the in vivo DNA supercoiling sensitivity of the Escherichia coli tRNA(1tyr) gene (tyrT) promoter in its normal chromosomal location. Here, the native tyrT promoter is found to be exquisitely sensitive to mutations and to drugs which alter the level of DNA supercoiling. We show that the response of the tyrT promoter to supercoiling is qualitatively similar to that of a known supercoiling-sensitive tRNA gene promoter, hisR. Specifically, treatments which increase in vivo DNA supercoiling levels enhance transcription of these tRNA genes. Particularly striking is the strong enhancement of expression from both promoters by a transposon insertion mutation in the topA gene encoding DNA toposisomerase I. This phenotypic effect can be complemented by providing active topoisomerase I in trans from a recombinant plasmid. Interestingly, it can also be complemented by overexpression of the genes encoding the subunits of DNA topoisomerase IV. We believe that this is the first demonstration that DNA topoisomerase IV can influence gene expression and it suggests that DNA topoisomerase I is partially redundant, at least in E. coli.

Identification of cis-acting regulatory regions upstream of the rRNA operons of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The promoter region(s) for the rRNA operons of Rhodobacter sphaeroides was identified. By utilizing both in vivo and in vitro techniques, the transcriptional start sites of all three operons were identified. Upstream of the transcriptional start, -10 and -35 promoter regions that bear little similarity to typical Escherichia coli promoter sequences were identified. In addition to the promoter sequences, probable Fis protein-binding sites were identified upstream of all three rRNA operons. Transcriptional fusions of the promoter regions from rrnA and rrnB were constructed by utilizing the reporter molecule encoded by xylE and analyzed under various growth conditions, in both a wild-type background and an rrnBC mutant background. Production of the xylE gene product (catechol 2,3-dioxygenase) was always greatest under photosynthetic growth conditions. However, the upstream region of rrnB, when fused with xylE, produced significantly more catechol 2,3-dioxygenase than did analogous regions of rrnA, suggesting that the promoters of the rrn operons differ in strength. These results were further confirmed by the study of mutant strains altered for the rrn operons either singly or in combination. Little or no expression of the xylE gene was manifest in E. coli when directed by rDNA sequences derived from R. sphaeroides.

In vivo regulatory responses of four Escherichia coli operons which encode leucyl-tRNAs

Four Escherichia coli operons, the leuV operon which encodes tRNA(1Leu), the leuX operon which encodes tRNA(6Leu), the metT operon which encodes tRNA(3Leu), and the argT operon which encodes tRNA(1Leu), were examined for the stringent response induced by serine hydroxamate and for growth rate-dependent regulation. In nuclease protection assays, the leuV operon displayed the stringent response in response to leucine starvation, analog inhibition, and growth of a temperature-sensitive leucyl-tRNA synthetase mutant at nonpermissive temperatures. The leuV operon also exhibited the stringent response in multicopy plasmids. The promoters of all four leucyl operons were fused to the gene for beta-galactosidase and inserted into the chromosome by using bacteriophage lambda. All except the leuX promoter displayed growth rate-dependent regulation, consistent with the recent report that the concentration of tRNA(6Leu) actually decreases as growth rate increases. The leuV promoter fused to the beta-galactosidase gene showed a decrease in efficiency in the presence of extrachromosomal copies of rRNA genes. All chromosomal tRNA genes examined showed decreased transcriptional activity following a stringent response, but the leuX gene responded to a lesser extent (3-fold versus 10-fold or more) than the others. Primer extension analysis of this promoter showed little if any response to serine hydroxamate treatment, suggesting that multiple levels of control may exist or that promoter context effects are important in regulation.

Mutagenesis and functional analysis of the Escherichia coli tRNA(1Leu) promoter

The leuV promoter which produces tRNA(1Leu) in Escherichia coli has been extensively mutagenized in order to determine the effects of altered sequences on promoter efficiency (strength) and on growth-rate-dependent regulation (GDR). Each mutant promoter was ligated with a beta-galactosidase reporter gene into the chromosome of a host cell by phage lambda lysogenization. Reporter gene activities were measured for cells growing in selected media at various growth rates. Sequences which flank the -10 consensus region, when altered, caused remarkable up-promoter effects, increasing efficiency in some cases almost 10-fold. One up mutation which had five successive T residues in the 'discriminator' region completely abolished GDR, whereas several mutations with single base changes in the discriminator had little or no effect on GDR. Another mutation which changed one base in the -35 region to bring it to consensus increased promoter strength 18-fold and sharply reduced GDR. Chimaeric promoters in which segments of leuV were replaced by segments of the his operon showed that only when the discriminator of leuV is replaced by the his discriminator was GDR-disturbed. All upstream sequences which were replaced by his sequences had little effect on GDR. Overall, there appeared to be little correlation between promoter efficiency and GDR.

Analysis of sequence elements important for the synthesis and control of ribosomal RNA in E coli

The regulation of the synthesis of ribosomal RNA is a key problem for the understanding of bacterial growth. Many different regulatory mechanisms involving cis and trans acting components participate in a concerted way to achieve the very efficient, flexible and coordinated production of this class of molecules. We have studied three different sequence regions within a ribosomal RNA transcription unit which are believed to control different stages of ribosomal RNA expression. In the first part of the study the function of AT-rich sequences upstream of the -35 hexamer of rRNA promoter P1 in the activation of rRNA transcription was analyzed. We confirm that a sequence dependent bend upstream of P1 is responsible for the high promoter activity. Experiments employing linker scanning mutations demonstrated that the distance as well as the angular orientation of the bent DNA is crucial for the degree of activation. In addition, the effect of the trans activating protein Fis on the transcription initiation of promoter P1 was investigated. We can show, using the abortive initiation assay, that the predominant effect of Fis is due to an increase in the affinity of RNA polymerase for the promoter (binding constant KB) while the isomerisation rate (kf) from a closed to an open RNA polymerase promoter complex is not altered significantly. We also describe the characterization of sequence determinants important for stringent regulation and growth rate control. Evidence is provided that the discriminator motif GCGC is a necessary but not sufficient element for both types of control. Furthermore we show that not simply a particular DNA primary structure but the higher order conformation of the complete promoter region is recognized and triggers the two regulatory mechanisms, both of which are apparently mediated by the effector molecule guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp). Finally, we have carried out a systematic mutational analysis of the rrnB leader region preceding the structural gene for 16S RNA. We could demonstrate that highly conserved sequence elements within the rrnB leader, which were believed to be involved in transcription antitermination have post-transcriptional functions. We present evidence that these sequence elements direct the biogenesis of active ribosomal particles.